Human Rights: Humanitarian Intervention And Its Controversies Philosophy Essay

994 words - 4 pages

Human Rights
Humanitarian Intervention
October 1 2017
Humanitarian intervention has been a complex and challenging issue in the realm of international human rights policies. Basic rights such as life, liberty and autonomy along with many others are constantly being violated in a vast majority of countries in the world. Humanitarian intervention, devoid of national interest and use of extreme military force can help nations with humanitarian crises resolve conflict and restore political, economic, cultural and social stability. While interventions by India in Pakistan, Vietnam in Cambodia and Tanzania in Uganda are considered successful humanitarian interventions, Somalia and Rwanda were not. Some of the successes and failures of these interventions are a result of disagreements in International policies among nations and states, national (self) interest, and lack of reinforcement.
The Indian Invasion of Pakistan in 1971 is one of the first military interventions that successfully restored stability in Eastern Pakistan. “According to the Indian government, this military intervention was carried out in response to the massive slaughter, taking place in what was then East Pakistan, that had caused millions of Pakistani refugees to flee to India” (Poe et al.,169). However, considering India’s and Pakistan’s history of violent conflicts, it was uncertain whether India was intervening for humanitarian reasons or to weaken their enemies in that area, or even both. Furthermore, “The UN General Assembly overwhelmingly disapproved of India’s intervention, although this has no bearing on whether the intervention was ‘humanitarian’ or not” (169). This event highlights two of the biggest roadblocks in International policy: reinforcement and accountability. Regardless of India’s accomplishments in establishing order in Eastern Pakistan, they went against many International agreements and conducts including those of the UN and did not face any consequences as there wasn’t anyone there to enforce them in the first place. “The greatest and gravest weakness in the entire realm of human rights concerns the lack of effective enforcement and protection of those rights” Poe et al assert as they elaborate on a complex issue in International policy that has many gray areas concerning how interventions are conducted, the countries conducting them and a debate as to who is entitled to reinforce these policies. The Rwandan genocide was a prime example of non-humanitarian intervention. Regardless of the slaughter of millions, and the displacement of thousands, there was little to no aid from the International community. After the murder of ten Belgian UN peacekeeping troops, the Security Council of the UN “voted to decrease the size of the peacekeeping force that had been in the country from 2,500 to 270” (174). With the U.N’s withdrawal of peacekeeping troops, there were no countries in the West that were willing to intervene. After the failed...

Find Another Essay On Human Rights: Humanitarian intervention and its controversies - Philosophy - Essay

Corruption and its impact on the full enjoyment of human rights, in particular economic, social and cultural rights

4308 words - 17 pages doors to foreign investment and long term growth, invariably impacting negatively on the enjoyment of human rights by the citizens of the affected country or countries.II. CORRUPTION: ITS FORMS AND CAUSESA. Forms of corruptionIt is possible to identify few interrelated forms of corrupt practices in many countries, though they may vary in intensity, depending on the country as well as during certain phases of national life such as military

The United Nations and Human Rights: Has the United Nations failed in its determination to support and advocate for human rights?

3896 words - 16 pages I. Introduction The supporting and advocating on behalf of human rights has been one of the primary principles of the United Nations. Since its founding in 1945, the United Nations has worked to preserve the basic human rights and fundamental freedoms it believes to be deserved of by every man, woman, and child on the planet. Throughout the near seventy years of the United Nations’ existence, it has been challenged with an array of questions

Evaluate how well Australia has adopted its obligations under its ratifications of international human rights principles

711 words - 3 pages Generally, Australia's ratification of its international human rights obligations has been QUITE good. We have free elections, an independent judiciary, the Executive which is bound the law. Our liberties are legally protected, we have enough to eat and drink, receive secondary education, have access to health care and services, are properly housed, we aren't HARASSED by the State for holding different views to it, we have FREEDOM of movement

Is the West Imposing Its Values on Developing Nations through the Universal Declaration of Human Rights

2425 words - 10 pages for Human Rights Studies in 2006 expressed that “many Arabs perceive internationally recognized human rights as a western import and thus unsuitable for [their] societies” (quoted by Bahey El Din Hassan; IRIN, 2006). The concept of universal norms is one considered by western states, and so this idea of human rights is far from applicable in many other cultures. This essay will argue that although the concept of universal human rights would be

Demonstrate an understanding of human rights legislation and reflect on its implication for people with a learning disability. this reflection looks at personal relationships

1765 words - 7 pages UK Citizens now have certain basic human rights which government and public authorities are legally obliged to respect. These became law as part of the Human Rights Act 1998. This Act 1998 gives legal effect in the UK to 16 of the fundamental rights and freedoms contained in the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). These rights not only affect matters of life and death like freedom from torture and killing but also affect your rights in

'Universal Human Rights are a fiction devised by the West in order to legitimise intervention in other areas of the World.' Discuss

3182 words - 13 pages hurriedly trying to bolster its position as a useful organisation on the world stage after feeling redundant at the removal of the Cold War threat. Although both cases are clear examples of the contravention of human rights the decisions made by the powers of the world to intervene and not intervene has placed much doubt over Western motives in humanitarian intervention. A typical argument proposed is that Westerners care little for what goes on in

Humanitarian Intervention and the UN and NATO

2303 words - 9 pages a way to unite countries by making stronger alliances and helping to support and protect each other. Humanitarian intervention has been known for both positive and negative effects and definitely has its pros and cons. The strategic efforts of humanitarian intervention are inoperative because the efforts are not heartfelt but are only done to keep their own citizens from becoming obstreperous. The whole purpose of the UN is to have a strong

Deontological ethics is too rigid in its emphasis on duties, utilitarian ethics too keen to override basic human rights

1047 words - 4 pages meansdepriving people of basic human rights for example. However does this mean thatdeontological ethics is too rigid in its emphasis on duties and that utilitarian ethics istoo keen to override basic human rights?According to a deontologist ones actions must be determined by a set of dutiesregardless of whether the long term consequences are good or bad. A deontologistbelieves in human morals and that every human has certain rights and these morals

NGOs and its humanitarian aid

2023 words - 9 pages the grass root problem. Some NGOs even conducted their own research in various field to identify the problems and find its solution. NGOs also serve as a tool to see whether the implementation of the public policies is a success or failure. Some are more keen in the human rights which they are not afraid to interfere in other country that they feel have fail to recognize the people human right. They have been recognize in the international level

History of Capital Punishment in America and its Controversies

1119 words - 5 pages The history of the capital punishment has been around since the beginning of the world we live in today. As the years have come and gone the use of capital punishment has been passed down throughout the generations of countries. One of the first uses of capital punishment dated back to the Old Testament. During biblical times God punished the world for its sins by causing a flood to destroy mankind. Many ancient cultures followed by deciding

Globalization and its advantages and disadvantages - Philosophy 101 - Essay

534 words - 3 pages developing countries. In poorer countries, globalization utilizes foreign capital and technology to help the counties develop economically and encourages prosperity. When there is prosperity in these countries, democracy is improved along with human rights. Sharing technological advances can help developing countries progress, and are granted free trade agreements. Through trading and creating networks with different countries, globalization promotes

Similar Essays

Controversies And Human Rights Essay

1733 words - 7 pages represent. To sum it up in lemans term we as humans have inalienable rights that cannot be taken away and that have to be respected. These rights give us the freedom to be whatever culture we what and so on. As long as we obey by the law and don’t put ourselves or anyone in harm’s way, we can pretty much do anything. I have two cultural practice controversies that a lot of people have conflicts with. They say that they break the human rights and

International Human Rights And Humanitarian Law

1077 words - 5 pages Introduction While there exist distinct points of difference, principles of international human rights laws and international humanitarian law overlap on multiple occasions. It is both interesting and informative to understand the differences and similarities in these principles between the two. Differences include underlying intention behind formulation, range of application and effect on different parties while similari underlying enactment

Humanitarian Intervention: Questioning Of Its Legality

2001 words - 9 pages War is a paradox. This is because people are killing in order to protect people from being killed. With war, often comes something known as “humanitarian intervention,” which is defined as the threat or use of force against states aimed at preventing or ending defilements of basic human rights, without the permission of the state that force is being directed toward (Holzgreffe & Keohane, 2003). Its main purpose is to relieve human suffering—but

U.S Human Rights Intervention Essay

647 words - 3 pages frivolous complaints to be lodged against the United States as a global power and presence. Lastly, if U.S. intervention in the prevention of human rights is based solely on other American interests, our world today will be a “world of crisis”, so to speak, because such crimes as genocide, crimes against humanity, violations of human rights and humanitarian law would be much more commonplace and no one would do or be able to do anything about it. An