Human Rights Approach To Development Essay

1846 words - 7 pages

The meaning of ‘development’ changes according to what society needs to achieve a better life at any one time (Crocker 1992, p. 585). Exactly how we approach development varies according to our conception of justice in light of this goal. This paper examines three approaches to development: the Rights Based approach, the Basic Needs approach and the Capability approach. Concluding: that as far as fairness goes, the Rights Based approach is the most agreeable of the three, but even so, is not without fault.

The Rights Based approach is based on the concept of Human Rights, which aim to create freedom, justice and peace in the world (United Nations 2014, ‘The Universal Declaration of Human Rights’, para. 1). This approach views development in terms of building the capacity of individuals and Nation States to realize and claim their rights from duty-bearers and to perform their obligation to respect, protect and fulfill those rights claimed (Joussan 2003 p. 15; OHCHR 1996-2012, ‘What are Human Rights?’ para. 9). The nature and extent of such rights have been determined through a process of negotiation and agreement between differing member states from around the globe (United Nations 2014, ‘History Of The Document’, para. 1-7) and have been codified in the following documents: The United Nations Charter (1945), The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966), The International Covenant Economic, Social and Cultural Rights(1966) and The Declaration on the Right to Development (1986). The Charter and Declaration do not have legal force serving more as a vision for member states to strive towards. But those Covenants agreed to and signed by the various member states are legally binding (Australian Human Rights Commission 2014, ‘Human Rights Explained: Fact Sheet 5: The International Bill of Human Rights’ para. 2-3).

One of the charges against the instrumentalisation of Human Rights is that they could be used to oppress, rather than emancipate (Kabasakal Arat 2008 p. 926, 931). While, such a charge can be dismissed in light of the voluntary process by which Human Rights are negotiated, accepted and agreed to, the charge is not totally unfounded. For with the acceptance of rights comes the responsibility to respect equally the rights of others, regardless of their differing attitudes and beliefs (Joussan 2003 p. 15; OHCHR 1996-2012 ‘What are Human Rights?’ para. 9). This can be an issue for those who are educated and well informed, or simply fundamentalist in their belief about what constitutes right and wrong and how things should be. In such cases, when the attitudes and beliefs of others contradicted our own, the obligation to accept the equal rights of all could seem oppressive and even against social progress.

More importantly, the real concern with regards to the Rights Based approach being a tool of oppression is due to the obligation of the Nation State to protect said rights...

Find Another Essay On Human Rights Approach to Development

Why can't one approach to psychology describe all human behaviour?

2505 words - 10 pages Why can't one approach in psychology explain all human behaviour?The aim of this essay is to define why one approach to psychology cannot explain the whole concept of all human behaviour. Five theorists have been chosen, each one has a differing view to psychology. This is to give a varied insight into the different approaches used to define all human behaviour. There are many different approaches within psychology, and all use individual

Women to Lead the Human Rights Revolution

2309 words - 9 pages constituencies in the world today playing a crucial historic role as social justice movements on major global issues. These are: women, the human rights professionals, and the development workers; and all concerned with bettering the human condition.However, the great tragedy is that these various groups are not working together as full partners in order to achieve without compromise the integration of gender, human rights and development challenges, as their

The United Nations and Human Rights: Has the United Nations failed in its determination to support and advocate for human rights?

3896 words - 16 pages that these methods be analyzed in their approach, impact, and effectiveness at shedding light on human rights violations, thus improving the status of human rights, and protecting the rights and fundamental freedoms from any further attack. This, in turn, helps to advance the freedoms of all persons, generating improvements in the overall quality of life that each person may receive as a result from having these international rights and freedoms

Article Review: “On Human Rights Day, stop the blank check to Israel”

1077 words - 5 pages attacked by Israel’s armies. This is due largely in part to desires by the Israeli government to have Palestinian citizens comply with their laws which are violating the Palestinian’s human rights, rights that every single human deserves. Stinemetz reasons that the Israeli’s are understandably letting fear of brutal treatment of European Jewish people influence their laws but, that they have also gone too far in trying to protect themselves

Define the four main approaches to staffing within International Human Resource Management.What are the advantages and disadvantages of each approach to international management.

1236 words - 5 pages Human Resource Management. The term IHRM refers to the development and deployment of human resource capabilities within an international framework. Companies have several techniques at their disposal when faced with staffing decisions.The first approach is called ethnocentric. It is based on the occupation of a key position by employees from headquarters (i.e. expatriates or parent country nationals PCN). It is assumed that subsidiaries can be

Why education is key to improving Human Development around the world

924 words - 4 pages What is Human Wellbeing:Human wellbeing is the ability of people to access the things they need and want in order to live happy and content lives. Geographers can measure this on many different scales by collecting and analysing data on the population of a specific area, as well as the geographical data of the area itself. This is called the Human Development Index (HDI). The world currently faces a huge inequality in the distribution of wealth

Human Development: Basic Trust vs. Basic Mistrust (Birth to 18 Months)

2274 words - 9 pages Stage 1: Basic Trust vs. Basic Mistrust (Birth to 18 Months) In stage one of Erickson’s theory, the first eighteen months of life is centered on the development of trust (Zaslow & Kirst-Ashman, 2007); that is, the infant must learn to trust and depend on others for food and care. According to Erikson (1985), the most important event of this stage is feeding. The infant will either develop trust if her caregiver’s presence and feedings are

This essay talks about how to start you own club having to do with amnesty international, the human rights organization.

1111 words - 4 pages The Amnesty MissionAmnesty International is a globally acclaimed organization that helps to protect the basic human rights of people all over the world through campaigns, donations, and volunteer work. Amnesty international is a self-governed organization that neither supports nor opposes any one political policy or political leader. Rather it strives to maintain a vision of rights as written in the Universal Declaration for Human Rights

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Rights of Man and the Citizen compared to The U.S. Constitution and the Declaration of Independence.

794 words - 3 pages Two early American documents, the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence have, over the past 200 years, influenced a great number of democratic ideas and institutions. The Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights share many obvious similarities to both the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution.The Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen was written by the Marquis

The Extent to Which the Human Rights Act of 1998 Strengthened the Rule of Law in the U.K. Constitution

3695 words - 15 pages make the difficult decisions caused by competing legal considerations than the courts themselves, adds weight to this position. Yet an alternative approach does exist. As put by Lord Woolf:[29] (there was a) very sophisticated approach adopted by the legislator when making the European Convention on Human Rights part of our domestic law assisted. The legislator, instead of giving the United Kingdom courts power to

Deontological ethics is too rigid in its emphasis on duties, utilitarian ethics too keen to override basic human rights.

1047 words - 4 pages meansdepriving people of basic human rights for example. However does this mean thatdeontological ethics is too rigid in its emphasis on duties and that utilitarian ethics istoo keen to override basic human rights?According to a deontologist ones actions must be determined by a set of dutiesregardless of whether the long term consequences are good or bad. A deontologistbelieves in human morals and that every human has certain rights and these morals

Similar Essays

Human Rights Vs. Global Partnership For Development. Armenia's Perspective

1367 words - 5 pages the subjects and objects of all those changes. That is why human rights, have played a prominent role in international development cooperation since the early 1990s. United Nations (UN) global conferences-from Rio in 1992 to Rome in 1996-have highlighted the crucial links between the three key goals of the UN Charter: peace, development and human rights. A great importance has been given to the linking development and human rights. The 1986 UN

The Origin, Development And Significance Of Human Rights

9689 words - 39 pages welfare movements that have taken place since. In large part, it is a response to the abuses of capitalist development and its underlying and essentially uncritical conception of individual liberty, which tolerated, and even legitimized, the exploitation of working classes and colonial peoples. Historically, it is a counterpoint to the first generation of civil and political rights, conceiving of human rights more in positive terms ("rights to

Piaget's Approach To Children's Intellectual Development

1318 words - 5 pages Piaget's Approach to Children's Intellectual Development The work of Piaget provided the foundation for developmental psychology. He concentrated on the development of cognitive abilities, leaving much scope for later research. Before exploring how Piaget's approach has been extended it might be helpful to outline his theory. Piaget's theory is constructivist; it shows how knowledge is actively constructed by the

Millenium Development Goals: A Successful Approach To Development

1968 words - 8 pages specialization. Capitalists control the market and economic policies are shaped by their interest. Therefore, some interference from the state is required to assure human rights and balanced growth. Modernization theory is a worldwide social movement; it has been the key policy to enhance development globally. In a nutshell, modernization is a process of transforming ‘traditional’ society into ‘modern’ society. A modernized society would mean