Human Rights Violations In The War On Terrorism

1027 words - 4 pages

Following the September 11th terrorist attacks in which at least 3,000 people were killed, the United States has pursued policies that violate human rights in order to wage the war on terrorism. These policies include the adoption of new security measures, the poor treatment of captured fighters at Guantanamo Bay Naval Base in Cuba, and the willingness of the Bush administration to overlook human rights violations in other countries in return for their support in the war on terrorism.

When the enemy is faceless, as it is in the United States' fight against terror, there is a tendency to violate human rights in order to identify the perpetrators and anticipate further atrocities. Violations include detaining suspects without sufficient evidence or cause, denial of access to lawyer, and unfair trials. In addition to these violations, the United States has passed legislation that allows for the indefinite detention of non-US nationals facing deportation on national security grounds. This is currently the case with Mazen Al-Najjar, a Muslim academic who came to the United States in 1981 as student and later became a university professor. In 1997, Al-Najjar was detained for three years after government lawyers claimed that he had raised funds for a terrorist organization. A judge later ruled that there were insufficient reasons for concluding that he posed a threat to national security and he was released. However, he was placed back into custody in November 2001 when immigration agents claimed that he "had established ties to terrorist organizations." According to Amnesty International, no new evidence was presented to support this claim and he is currently being held in solitary confinement for twenty-three hours a day in a maximum security prison on the basis of allegations of involvement in terrorism ( From a democratic standpoint, these actions cannot be considered just or moral.

In addition to new security legislation, the United States also defies human rights standards through the treatment and legal status given to the Taliban and Al-Qaeda prisoners being held at Guantanamo Bay Naval Base in Cuba. According to the Geneva Convention (1949), in which the United States is a party, a captured fighter is considered a prisoner of war if they are members of an adversary state's armed forces or are part of an identifiable military group that abides by the laws of war. Since most members of Al- Qaeda did not wear insignia or abide by the laws of war, they would probably not qualify as prisoners of war. However, Taliban soldiers comprised the armed forces of Afghanistan and should be entitled to POW status (

While the Bush administration decided that the Geneva Convention will apply to Taliban prisoners, it said that none of the detainees will be legally treated as prisoners of war, meaning there will be no effective change in their treatment or status. John Godfrey, a Toronto Liberal MP,...

Find Another Essay On Human Rights Violations in the War on Terrorism

Human Rights, War and Terrorism Essay

1834 words - 7 pages Human Rights, War and Terrorism After every war come the peace talks; after millions of people had been killed. After the terrorist attacks comes the investigation, reason, or counter-terrorism; after lives had been wasted. There is time for the nations of the world to come together to understand one another in order to avoid war and terrorism and that time is now. War is as old as man. It is a reign of terror when

Violations of Human Rights in the Arab-Israeli Conflict

2096 words - 8 pages check for the enemy, bombs, or explosives. All human rights violations stemming from the Arab-Israeli conflict are not limited to just the Israelis, as the Palestinians have violated many articles of the Geneva Convention. The problem arises in Israel’s response to the Palestinian violations, when they resort to military actions that also are considered war crimes. The cycle seems to go on and on, as one side attacks the other in violation of the

Human Rights Violations

939 words - 4 pages San Francisco Chronicle gave information on the rights violations in China. It also stated how students felt it was worth sacrificing their lives for the sake of progress and democracy in China. The Chinese government has since made very little changes in the amount of freedom it allows. [Document 5]      Human rights abuses have continued in the post-World War II era. These violations have occurred in South Africa

Human Rights Violations

1137 words - 5 pages Human Rights Violations Throughout the history of humankind, man has always been hateful and prejudice towards a race or religion different from his or her own. In the early twentieth century itself, we faced atrocities such as the Armenian Massacre, the rape of Nanking and many more. One such crime against the human race that can overthrow all of them is, the Nazi Holocaust led by Adolf Hitler. After World War I, Germany was in a

Troubled Government in Yemen: Human Rights Violations

1945 words - 8 pages violations are rights that have been violated by people or the government. In the United States we do not have to worry about much of these human rights violations. For other countries they are not as lucky. In poor countries they have a lot to worry about. Yemen is a country on the other side of the globe by Saudi Arabia. In 1990 the Yemen republic was established and has a population of 19.8 million (“State Department Issues Background…”). For

What relationships do you see between human rights and the "war on terrorism"?

1174 words - 5 pages . We are only making matters worse.Another example of human rights violations taking place because of the "war on terrorism" is the torture that has been induced upon many prisoners of war at the Guantanamo Bay Naval Station in Cuba by the U.S. military. Under international law torture is one of the most serious violations of human rights. It is considered unacceptable anywhere under any circumstances. It is one of the rights that can never be

North Korean Human Rights Violations

1260 words - 5 pages people to provide food and other aid fall on deaf ears. The government did not work with the UN special rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the North Korea and disallowed access to special rapporteur, Marzuki Darusman (Human Rights Watch). To make matters worse, North Korean United Nations representatives often cloud conversation by pointing out violations committed by concerned nations instead of listening to suggestions. Whether it is

Columbia’s Growing Human Rights Violations

1680 words - 7 pages testimonies by actual members of the FARC and various paramilitary groups concerning their daily activities and ways they murdered and annihilated the rural population of Colombians who were in the middle of the conflict. She provided extensive data relating to the amount of human rights violations as well as accurate percentages of the groups committing these crimes. She is currently a Senior Research Fellow at the Institute on Violence and Survival

Human Rights Violations Against Children

3724 words - 15 pages at 18. The term "juvenile" also appears on human rights texts although it is not exactly interchangeable; it usually refers to those who are able to be charged and tried in the juvenile justice system. Concepts that help define childhood, such as maturity and the age of criminal responsibility, rely largely on social and cultural factors. In some societies, childhood is a condition fixed by the condition of the child within the community rather

Illegal immigration-human rights violations

5452 words - 22 pages made difficult. Most importantly, if 7 Frey, Keith_2012 Monday, December 19, 2011 12:51:24 PM CT 70:cd:60:86:2f:be there is some bureaucratic procedure that will delay/deny treatment to a detainee . . . you can be assured that DIHS will do it (qtd. in "In Custody, in Pain" 7). Although all the aforementioned human rights violations have been nonphysical, there have been many cases of sexual and physical abuse by guards and fellow detainees

International Adoption and Human Rights Violations

1157 words - 5 pages enquiring about adopting a child from Haiti. A selfless act like adoption turned into a controversy over human rights and caused many to voice concerns about adopting internationally. A child’s most basic human right is to grow up in a safe nurturing family, and laws had to be put in place to protect these rights. America’s laws vary by state. The laws that govern adoption in general protect all the parties involved focusing on what is the best

Similar Essays

Human Rights Violations In Syria Essay

1530 words - 6 pages here soon. The Syrians do not feel safe at all, because the Syrian government is taking away all of their rights. Some people think it is okay for the Syrian government to do this but it is not okay in any way to do that. So when someone says there are not human rights violations going on in Syria you can tell the violations that are listed and many more are being violated. One of the surrounding countries should go in and help them out with

Human Rights Violations In Tibet Essay

1394 words - 6 pages , including some truly perverted, evil,cruel, depraved, malicious, degenerate, malignant tortures. Furthermore, according to the Targeted News Service, Amnesty International said that “The continued lock-down in Tibet has made independent verification of reports difficult and raised fears that reports of human rights violations that reach the outside world represent just a fraction of the whole.” Meaning that, considering the thousands of reported

Human Rights Violations In Haiti Essay

1311 words - 5 pages longer one, petty crimes such as pickpocketing tourists and purse-snatching are not closely as common as the rate of said crimes in neighboring country, Dominican Republic for example. But the crimes and human rights violations are still in great effect and the country is in dire need of a mas-Reformation. The religious influence in Haiti does not and cannot play a big factor in Haiti the way things are because there is not enough order as yet. But

Focusing On Liberian Human Rights Violations

1441 words - 6 pages helping their citizens respect human rights. Yet "both government and rebel forces have carried out executions, beatings, and torture of citizens. Civilians have been raped and forced into labor. Large numbers of children have been involved in the Civil War as child soldiers." (Payne). There are many possible ways to get the Liberian government to smarten up and start respecting human rights. Unless the violations end, Liberia could be denied any