This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Humanities Vs. Sciences Essay

1711 words - 7 pages

“SCIENCE HAS BOMBS, and humanities have Britney Spears” (Kershner as cited in Purvis, 2004). This amusing comment, made during a professorial debate concerning which discipline was superior, epitomises the divide that exists between the humanities and sciences. Although the debate has its roots in the Industrial Revolution, in more recent times it was signalled by Snow’s (1959; 1964) discussion outlining the dysfunctional gulf that exists between the cultures. Essentially Snow was critical of the breakdown of communication and understanding between the worlds of the humanities and sciences and blamed this for many of society’s unresolved problems. He was particularly critical of the literary intellectuals: “This loss is leading us to interpret the past wrongly, to misjudge the present, and to deny our hopes of the future. It is making it difficult or impossible for us to take good action.” (Snow, 1964, p.60) In the years that followed there has been considerable discussion and debate about the issue and consequent discussions about the value of the sciences and humanities for society’s wellbeing. For example, Leavis (Leavis & Yudkin, 1963) criticised the notion of a chasm and, in a vitriolic manner, suggested that Snow was simply a public relations ‘stooge’ for the sciences. The argument was deepened by a pseudoscientific hoax paper published in a post-modern cultural studies journal by Sokal (1996a, 1996b), a mathematical physicist, who demonstrated that there was an acceptance of a lack of rigour in published humanities work. There was a furore over this hoax and counter arguments and rebuttals engaged many academics in a bitter dispute, but unsurprisingly an examination of this literature reveals that the protagonists talked past each other. Essentially, the humanities’ position (e.g., Anderson, 2002) in the Snow-Leavis debate has been unrepentant and it has continued to claim the importance of the human condition in the scientific technological world. In a very practical manner, the Third Culture Movement (e.g., Brockman, 1995) has endeavoured to reconcile differences by providing an opportunity for scientists and the literati to integrate ideas from both paradigms in their writings and thinking. Some intellectuals (e.g., Lee & Wallerstein, 2004), in recognising the need for both cultures, have attempted to reconcile the differences in a theoretical sense.
Unification through Division
In university education, the divide remains alive with the autonomous science and humanities departments producing specialist graduates and the academics of each guarding the boundaries of their domains, strengthened by the distinction between the constructivist and scientific paradigms. However, this demarcation masks the real purpose of what a university education is all about today. University education is more than discipline-based, compartmentalised knowledge, attitudes and outcomes – it should reflect the needs of stakeholders (students, business,...

Find Another Essay On Humanities vs. Sciences

Gender Today in Make Believe Play

799 words - 4 pages women are supposed to have feminine traits, such as being emotional, sensitive, nurturing, and weak. In many masculinity and femininity studies it is said that males are generally masculine and women are generally feminine, and both men and women are supposed to have a gender role. A gender role is a “theoretical construct in the social sciences and humanities that refers to a set of social and behavioral norms that are widely considered to be

Division Between Ancient and Modern Science

2575 words - 10 pages . "Once alchemy came out of the closet and alchemists openly communicated their discoveries to other alchemists, the stage was set for the tremendous advances we have come to expect from the natural sciences" (Coudert 211). Philosophical Approaches: ancient magic vs. modern logic Secondly, the dawn of rationalism contributed further to the rift between ancient and modern science. Early science was rooted in mysticism and magic. "Alchemists were

Strategic analysis

2155 words - 9 pages mental human studies. These contrasts are so various it would be impossible notice, yet incorporate the much more extensive thickness and discontinuity (there is nothing approaching an overwhelming hypothesis on the other hand system). Inside mental human sciences, the field of cognitive humanities, (Quinn, 2005) centers particularly on deciding the interior perspectives of the people and assemblies being examined.Images are words, motions

Shalamov and Solzhenitsyn

1320 words - 5 pages Paper 2. Compare/Contrast PaperIndividuals vs. Totalitarian State: Tragic Destiny of Human-Beings in Solzhenitsyn's and Shalmov's Stories(Topic: Solzhenitsyn and Shalamov on the experience of the camps)Written by: Bekzhan ZhamikeyevYear of Study: 1st year SHSS studentCourse Name: Introduction to Critical Issues in the Humanities and Social Sciences Nazarbayev University, SHSSIndividuals vs. Totalitarian State: Tragic Destiny of Human-Beings in

The Case for Principle-Based Accounting

1011 words - 4 pages March 2014 Kariuki, G & Jagongo, A. (2013) Institutional investors’ perceptions on quality of financial reporting in Kenya. International Journal for Humanities and Social Sciences. Vol. 3 No. 21. Accessed from http://www.ijhssnet.com/journals/Vol_3_No_21_[Special_Issue_December_2013]/14.pdf on 29 March 2014 Nisbett, A. & Sheikh, A. (2007) Accounting Scandals, Does “Rules vs. Principles” matter? Tennessee CPA Journal November 2007. Accessed from

Women in Science Careers

2291 words - 9 pages , for example, women are more likely to secure degrees in the humanities, life sciences, and social sciences than in math, computer science, engineering, or the physical sciences; the reverse is true for men” (21). Hill further illustrates that “Another recent poll found that 74 percent of college-bound boys ages 13–17 said that computer science or computing would be a good college major for them compared with 32 percent of their female peers” (21

Metaphor, Sociobiology, and Nature vs. Nurture: The Biological Battle of the Century

2375 words - 10 pages Metaphor, Sociobiology, and Nature vs. Nurture: The Biological Battle of the Century Ladies and Gentlemen! I am proud to present one of the biggest and longest-running biological battles of the century! Tonight we recap the surprising nature vs. nurture fight. The following pages will explain the highlights, but if you want to learn about this war in its entirety, you’ll find the blow-by-blow account available to the public in Connie

The Awakening

1569 words - 6 pages . Critical Essays on American Literature (Ceal) Number: 1: Hall, New York Pagination: 99-128, 1996. xiii, 257.Douglas, Connie Ann Woodruff. "Chopin's Vision: Interrogating Gender Roles of the Creole Female." Dissertation Abstracts International, Section A: The Humanities and Social Sciences 60.6 (1999): 2025.Wright, George. Lecture. History 240. Skyline College, San Bruno. Spring 2009.

Self-esteem and Academic Achievement

2617 words - 11 pages , learning, and behavior disorders: Developmental, biological, and clinical perspectives (pp. 5–22). New York: Cambridge University Press. Dejud, C. (2008). The relationship among ethnic identity, psychological well-being, academic achievement, and intergroup competence of school-age Hispanic/Latino youth. ProQuest Information & Learning Dissertation Abstracts International Section A: Humanities and Social Sciences, 68(11-) Retrieved from

Morals: Nature vs. Nurture

2467 words - 10 pages ://appsychologybhs.wikispaces.com/Development>. Papalia, D. E., S. W. Olds, and R. D. Feldman. Human development. 11. Boston: McGraw-Hill Humanities/Social Sciences/Languages, 2010. Print Rachels, James. "2.1 How Different Cultures Have Different Moral Codes." The Challenge of Cultural Relativism. N.p.. Web. 1 Nov 2012. . Research: Marsh, A., Crowe, S., Yu, H., Gorodetsky, E., Goldman, D., & Blair, R

Eating Disorders and the Media

3346 words - 13 pages . Bibliography: Abstracts ABSTRACT 1: AN: 1998-95017-003 DT: Dissertation-Abstract TI: The role of self-discrepancies in the relationship between media exposure and eating disorders. AU: Harrison, -Kristen SO: Dissertation-Abstracts-International-Section-A: -Humanities-and-Social sciences. 1998 Sep; Vol 59(3-A): 0648 IS: 0419-4209 PY: 1998 UM: AAM9807848 AB: A two-part study was conducted to examine the role of ideal

Similar Essays

What Is Knowledge? Essay

1389 words - 6 pages Knowledge is “the theoretical or practical understanding of a subject” (Oxford Dictionaries). Many scientists and philosophers have studied the way in which knowledge is acquired, and how academic and scientific disciplines make sense of the world (McAllister). Three different categories or groups of sciences which produce knowledge have been established: natural sciences, humanities and social sciences (McAllister). This essay will serve to

Philosophy: The Meaning Of Human Life And Behavior According To Dilthey

2006 words - 8 pages natural sciences and the humanities and social sciences have developed as separate entities, insulated spaces each with their own exclusive focus and methods. While certain disciplines of the natural sciences, such as medicine and biology study conscious human beings, the depth is merely to a physiological level. The human sciences have displayed that it is possible to study the functions of the human mind completely independently to that of what

Scientific Research On Masters Topic Class Research Paper

3606 words - 15 pages cognition in different sciences. 2. Social vs. natural sciences The social sciences or social studies comprise academic disciplines in the arts and humanities concerned with the study of the social life of human groups, and individuals including anthropology, archaeology, communication studies, cultural studies, demography, economics, human geography, history, linguistics, political science, psychology, social work, and sociology. The social sciences

Wild, Wild West And David Lowenthal

649 words - 3 pages aspects of the past are celebrated, others forgotten, as each generation reshapes its legacy in line with the present. Using the arts, the humanities and the social sciences, the author uses sources such as science fiction to examine how we rebel against inherited tradition that has risen to the modern cult of preservation. The Past is a Foreign Country shows that although the past has ceased to be a restriction for inherited power or privilege, as a