This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Hume’s Reasons For Rejecting Miracles Essay

1250 words - 5 pages

Hume’s Reasons for Rejecting Miracles

One of the main philosophers in the debate about miracles is David
Hume. I will start this essay with a basic summary of Hume’s argument.

Hume’s argument is not that miracles cannot happen, but that, given
the amount of evidence that has established and confirmed a law of
nature, there can never be sufficient evidence to prove that a law of
nature has been violated. He believes that miracles have no rational

Hume was an empiricist, in other words, he believed that all knowledge
is based on evidence that we gain through our senses. He argues that
if a miracle goes against a law of nature, then it represents a single
piece of evidence that goes against all the rest. So, for example, if
we let go of a heavy object, it falls to the ground. That observation,
repeated many times, confirms our understanding of the law of gravity.
If then, an account is heard of the heavy object floating upwards of
its own accord, you can ask yourself, which is the more likely: that
the report is mistaken or that it actually happened.

However, Hume talks of laws of nature as if set in stone implying that
Natural Law can never be shown to be false. The possibility for laws
of nature to be false must be left open.

Hume claims that, if we balance on one hand the improbability of
miracles occurring and on the other hand the evidence that they have
occurred, we will always come to the conclusion that it is more likely
that natural laws occurred rather than miracles.

On the other hand, Hume was working with Newton’s understanding of
Natural Laws being fixed whereas the modern understanding is that of
the chaos theory. The chaos theory teaches us that the movement of
particles is random and therefore exceptions to natural laws are

Hume argues that a miracle is a breach of a law of nature. As I said
earlier, he believes that the belief in miracles is not rational. He
maintains that if you were a rational human being, you would not
believe in miracles. Hume states that we have a uniform past evidence
for laws of nature. For example, when people walk on water, they sink
and when someone dies, they do not rise from the dead.

However, Hume only deals with reports of miracles and doesn’t look at
them from first hand experience.

Hume furthers his argument by saying that the reports of witnesses are
unreliable and untrustworthy. He makes the point that people who are
claiming a miracle has happened should have a reputation to lose and
absolutely nothing to gain.

Hume advances on this argument to say that reports of miracles
generally come from ignorant and barbarous people. He states that
humans love the fantastic. People love the idea of something unlikely
happening since wonder and excitement are enjoyable emotions.


Find Another Essay On Hume’s Reasons for Rejecting Miracles

Of Miracles by David Hume Essay

975 words - 4 pages or not miracles exist, but whether we should believe in them or not. Hume discusses, in ?Of Miracles,? many reasons why we should not believe in such miracles for various reasons. However I have made a counter argument of Hume?s in saying that we must believe in miracles and if we do not have any faith that they are true then society would fail and not develop. Miracles are something that exist and are something that we have to believe in.

David Hume and Karl Marx’s Critiques of Religion

1287 words - 5 pages Where does religion come from? Many have tried to answer this question, only leaving us with more questions than answers. This essay will focus on two philosophers David Hume and Karl Marx both has strong critiques on the existence of God. Both going against the design argument, the design argument is the argument for the existence of God or single creator; however, with Hume’s empiricist and Marx's atheist they both attack the design argument

The Characteristics of God

2646 words - 11 pages , Hume leads to reader to “reflect on and pursue the consequences of allowing this objection”. (EHU 11.31) Hume’s final position then, is that while objecting premise three of his argument invalidates his argument, for the same reasons, the Objection must be applied to the given teleological argument. The result of this is that we may not reduce the existential conclusion of the teleological argument that nature has a creator to the point in which

David Hume on the Existence of Miracles

1866 words - 8 pages more likely a misinterpretation of what they actually saw. “That no tesitimony is sufficient”,( (Hume, 1777, E10.13) is what Hume believes to be true, accept what is most likely or probable have occurred and that is what you should in fact believe. Under this assumption, therefore, it would never be reasonable to believe that a miracle, or violation of the laws of nature has actually occurred. Hume’s argument for not believing in miracles can

Of Conspiracy Theories

1224 words - 5 pages . If one can be skeptical about the most rigid means of gathering evidence that has accumulated said evidence over the course of centuries, one can be skeptical about just about anything. Now that there are grounds for identifying what characteristics a bad explanation has, Keeley suggests that conspiracy theories are useful because they force us to distinguish good explanations from bad ones. Keeley contrasts conspiracy theories with Hume’s

Miracles in the Modern Day

1706 words - 7 pages Miracles seem to be out dated and never happen in our lives. Could the non-existence of miracles be because they are impossible or could it be that we have surrounded our lives with science and technology that we are not aware of the miracles that happen around us? Do we correctly use the term “miracle”? For example the hockey game that the U.S.A. and Soviet Union played in the 1980 Olympic Games is called the “Miracle on Ice”. Yes the U.S.A

Explaining the Term Miracle

2014 words - 8 pages his faith in God. Lourdes is famous as a place of healing miracles; over 6000 miraculous cures have been recorded, although only 64 have been officially recognised. These miracles come about through people having the faith to take the pilgrimage to Lourdes, to show that they believe that God will help. 'Healing miracles do not happen today'. -Do you agree, give reasons for you answer and show that you have

Of Mircacles

805 words - 3 pages belief to the evidence”’; meaning that a wise man will see that Miracles, such as a man rising from the dead, which has never happened before, goes against the laws of nature that have been made by sense experience. This illustrates Hume’s skepticism of his world, and especially religious matters. A more modern day experience would be the telephone game. The game starts by one person forming a phrase and then whispering it into his neighbor’s ear

Commentary of Evil in Hume’s Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, Part X

861 words - 4 pages God is infinitely perfect, which means he has power and wisdom to make the world that non-existence of evil, and he is benevolently want make the world that non-existence of evil, but God is possible have good reasons for allowing evil to exist that, in his mind, outweigh the desirability of the nonexistence of evil. So Philo also offers an answer that we can allow that God's infinite perfection and the evil of his creation can be reconciled in

Negative Impact of God on the Minds of David Hume, Christopher Smart, and William Cowper

1679 words - 7 pages , and never can observe anything but the perception. When my perceptions are removed for any time, as by sound sleep, so long am I insensible of myself, and may truly be said not to exist. (Rossi 2645) Hume believes that existing is a state of mind, not necessarily a state of being. It is not until he is conscious of his perceptions that he believes he truly exists. Hume also wrote on the subject of miracles. Hume’s simple

Viewing Suicide from Kant's and Humes Eyes

1407 words - 6 pages Viewing Suicide from Kant’s and Hume’s eyes According to National Institute of Mental Health, “In 2007, it [suicide] was the tenth leading cause of death in the U.S., accounting for 34,598 deaths.” This statistic shows that even though the numbers compared to the entire population are small, it is rather common for people to deal with suicide around them and it is a major issue among people (NIMH). There are many different mixed emotions and

Similar Essays

David Hume On Miracles Essay

1326 words - 5 pages , derived from our experience over time. If one were to object Hume’s definition of miracles, then it is possible for them to occur. If the definition of a miracle was expanded to represent an occurrence that was just improbable (and no violation of any laws of nature) then the power of Hume’s argument would be diminished. For instance, if a miracle is nothing more than the University of Kentucky winning the National Football Championship (which is

The Existence Of Miracles Essay

1070 words - 4 pages it take second place to the primary fact that a "miracle story" shows that "God directs and intervenes in human history". Through this interpretation of miracles it is a form of confirmation for believers of Gods existence and the fact that He is watching over them. Theistic religions often face a great challenge in the modern world as they must deal with the "rise of modern science" and also acknowledge the

Miracles Essay

1353 words - 5 pages Miracles From the Latin word miraculum meaning “object of wonder” enters the word miracle. Many definitions have been formed for the notion of a miracle but most would agree that it is most commonly an unexplainable extraordinary event, inspiring awe and wonder unto its witnesses. Similar definitions state that it is a

David Hume: On Miracles Essay

1897 words - 8 pages In explaining Hume’s critique of the belief in miracles, we must first understand the definition of a miracle. The Webster Dictionary defines a miracle as: a supernatural event regarded as to define action, one of the acts worked by Christ which revealed his divinity an extremely remarkable achievement or event, an unexpected piece of luck. Therefore, a miracle is based on one’s perception of past experiences, what everyone sees. It is based