This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Hunting And Gathering Vs. Agriculture Essay

735 words - 3 pages

From the early prehistoric society until now, we often heard the word “adaptation”, which means the process of changing something or changing our behavior to deal with new situations. The ways people adjust their natural environment varies according to time, place, and tribe. Foraging is common way of adaptation that people uses for most of human history; however because of the population pressure, some people adopt agriculture to fulfill their need. This essay, will discuss the positive and negative aspects of life in hunting and gathering societies compared to the agricultural societies based on Martin Harris’ article “Murders in Eden” and Jared Diamond’s article “The Worst Mistake in the History of Human Race.”

Hunting and gathering is the longest-lasting lifestyle for most of human history. In addition to their way of life, hunter-gatherers are often regarded as “nasty, brutish, and short” (Diamond 114). Progressivists also suggested our hunter-gatherer ancestors adopt agriculture because of “its efficient way to get more food for less work”(Diamond 114). However, as archaeologists observe in some aspects of their lives, hunter-gatherers societies are not necessarily “nasty, brutish, and short.” Some issues that we need to compare between hunting and gathering and agricultural societies include workloads, nutrition, production, starvation, infanticide, health and disease, and differences in wealth.

From the work loads, it shows that in the barren environment of the Kalahari dessert, the present day Bushmen need only 12 to 19 hours per week to obtaining a diet rich in protein and a high nutritional standard, while their farmer neighbors, the Hadza nomads of Tanzania, need 14 hours per week and get less protein. It also takes more additional hours of food preparation to make it is suitable for consumption. It appears that hunter-gatherers have more leisure time than farmers. On the other hand, an agricultural system absorbs more labor and increased workload per capita.

Based on the output of production, agriculture is perceived as an advance because farmers can produce more food within a smaller area than they could possibly obtain as hunter-gatherers. Harris says that this situation happened since farmers control “the rate of plant reproduction” (Harris 219), which means that immediate adverse consequences could be prevented with the intensification...

Find Another Essay On Hunting and Gathering vs. Agriculture

A Short History of the World J. M. Roberts

1012 words - 4 pages In A Short History of the World J. M. Roberts argues, “The Coming of Agriculture changed life so much and so deeply that nothing since would have been possible without it” (Roberts 1993, 22). Prior to the emergence of agriculture, and "for most of human history, people lived in relatively small groups, gathering, fishing, and hunting what they needed from their immediate environments" (Goucher and Walton 2013, 36). Because of the unpredictable

Man's Transition to Agriculture Essay

1534 words - 6 pages misleading in that there was no sudden transformation to agriculture. Learning the new agricultural methods was difficult and many people combined a bit of agriculture with reliance on the older system of hunting and gathering. The idea of revolution is appropriate in demonstrating the magnitude of change involved. Early agriculture could support more people per square mile than hunting. Agriculture requires more work at least of men than hunting. As

The Human Mind

994 words - 4 pages Twenty thousand years ago the Ice Age was ending, and the Long Summer began. This period in time was the start of many changes that became known as the Neolithic. The Neolithic was a period during which humans started to abandon hunting and gathering. Instead, large scale agriculture was established. The development of agriculture led to technological advances. These big changes raised questions. What caused human beings to focus on agriculture

Agriculture In More and Less Developed Countries

2105 words - 8 pages the food they needed for survival through hunting for animals, fishing or gathering plants. People from northern Asia are thought to have migrated to this continent about 20,000 years ago. By hunting and following heards of animals, they crossed the Bering land bridge that once connected Asia to Alaska. Bison were critical to the life of the early inhabitants of the Great Plains. Bison provided people with food, skins for clothing and shelter

Pre-Agricultural Human Environmental Impact

807 words - 3 pages early hominids sustained themselves through the oldest and simplest human mode of production, hunting and gathering. They mainly "gathered nuts, seeds and plants, which they would have supplemented by scavenging dead animals killed by other predators and perhaps the hunting of a few small mammals."3 A wide variety of food was available and provided a sufficiently nutritional diet. This form of economy was often far from meager and likely represents

Discuss the negative and positive aspects of the development of agriculture. Was it, or was it not the worst mistake in the history of the human race?

1710 words - 7 pages food are available whatever the weather is like. Early agriculture tended to be even more vulnerable to changes in the weather than hunting and gathering had been.Total dependency on harvest times - to survive, farmers have to gather all their food for at least once, twice or three times a year, rather than gathering year round. They also have to store the produce for the rest of the year, protect it from moisture, pests and thieves, etc. They have

Early Humans and the Environment

915 words - 4 pages , technologies that were either necessary for the continuation of life, or for the improved quality of life, thus changing the environment. Early humans lived by hunting and gathering, affecting their environment only minimally. There was a small human population that supported itself by hunting, gathering, and scavenging until about ten thousand years ago (Ponting 19). Ponting asserts that these early human groups lived in conjunction with the

The Most Important Discovery of All Time, Agriculture

916 words - 4 pages . Agriculture continues to play a big role in our lives today through continuous discovery and new developments to help continue making the world a better place. . Paleolithic people used hunting and gathering techniques to provide their food. Nearly everybody devoted much time to gathering plants for food or to hunting or fishing. They had no time for other actives other than what was necessary to survive. These ancient people were constantly

Native American Lifestyles

774 words - 3 pages , Iroquois, Pueblo, Natchez, and Aztecs (among many others) developed diverse and distinct communities. Some societies favored agriculture, others preferred hunting and gathering; some had egalitarian political systems, others had hierarchical systems; some worshipped nature, others worshipped the sun. Due to the varieties of lifestyles, politics, and religions among the native inhabitants of America, the New World possessed a wide variety of diverse societies.

The Worse Mistake in Human History

1713 words - 7 pages Most people would argue that the transition from hunting and gathering of food to agricultural food production was the best innovation in human history. We are taught to believe that this innovation gave rise to civilization, allowed for more leisure time in which people could then focus on arts and allowed for a higher yielding, more consistent and reliable food source. Despite some of the innovations that sprang from agriculture, upon a

Arch history in it's most descriptive form - UCLA ARCH101 - Research Paper

598 words - 3 pages Almost the entire evolutionary history of genus Homo has taken place within a hunting-and-gathering context. It was only 15,000 years ago that societies of modern humans in different areas of the world began to shift to an agricultural way of life. The transition from hunter–gatherer societies to agricultural societies is one of the most profound and significant events in prehistory. The origins of agriculture can be viewed as a broad phenomenon

Similar Essays

The Triumph Of Food Production Over Hunting And Gathering

1974 words - 8 pages . 2014. Dow, Gregory K., Nancy Olewiler, and Clyde G. Reed. "The Transition to Agriculture: Climate Reversals, Population Density, and Technical Change." Simon Fraser University, Aug. 2005. Web. 19 Mar. 2014. Diamond, Jared. Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Society. New York: W.W. Norton &, 1999. Print. "The Neolithic Revolution and the Birth of Civilization." The Neolithic Revolution and the Birth of Civilization. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Mar. 2014. Locay, Luis. "From Hunting and Gathering to Agriculture." Economic Development and Cultural Change 37.4 (1989): 737. JSTOR. Web. 19 Mar. 2014.

The Discovery And Impact Of Agriculture

659 words - 3 pages The discovery of agriculture has led to many profound changes in society. From its origin during the Neolithic era, to its evolution throughout modern society, agriculture has formed and shaped human society to what it is today. Without agriculture, society would still be a hunting and gathering community. However, because of the uncovering of agriculture, early humans were able to grow crops and domesticate animals. Moreover, farming has

Essay On Agriculture And A Comparison Between It And Hunter Gatherer Societes, As Well Refuting Jared Diamonds Famous Agricultural Essay

645 words - 3 pages As soon as humans began to form permanent settlements, and give up the process of hunting and gathering, agriculture was born. With agriculture came a new means of nutrition and ability to survive to a faltering species. Overpowering hunter-gatherers as dominant individuals, this new group altered the human race to what it is today. Though some tend to disagree with this statement, agriculture was a key and important step in benefiting human

The Neolithic Agrarian Revolution Essay

898 words - 4 pages The Neolithic Agrarian Revolution was the world’s first historically confirmable revolution in agriculture. It was the progression of many human cultures from a lifestyle of hunting and gathering to one of agriculture and settlement, which was supported with a big increasing population. This agriculture involved the domestication of plants and animals, which developed around 9,500 B.C. During this age various types of plants and animals derived