This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Husserl’s Conceptions Of Formal Mathematics Essay

3075 words - 12 pages

Husserl’s Conceptions of Formal Mathematics

Edmund Husserl’s conception of mathematics was a unique blend of Platonist and formalist ideas. He believed that mathematics had reached a mixed state combining Platonic and formal elements and that both were important for the pursuit of the sciences, as well as for each other. However, he seemed to believe that only the Platonic aspects had significance for his science of phenomenology. Because of the significance of the distinction between these two types of mathematics, I will always use one of the adjectives “material” or “formal” when discussing any branch of mathematics, unless I specifically mean to include both.

First, I must specify what I mean by each of these terms. By material mathematics, I will mean mathematics as it had traditionally been done before the conceptions of imaginary numbers and non-Euclidean geometry. Thus, any branch of material mathematics seeks to describe how some class of existing things actually behaves. So material geometry seeks to describe how objects lie in space, material number theory seeks to describe how the actual natural numbers are related, and material logic seeks to describe how concepts actually relate to one another. Some of these areas (like material geometry) seek to deal with the physical world, while others (like material logic) deal with abstract objects, so I avoid using the word “Platonic”, which suggests only the latter. By formal mathematics, I will mean mathematics done as is typical in the 20th century, purely axiomatically, without regard to what sorts of objects it might actually describe. Thus, for formal geometry it is irrelevant whether the objects described are physical objects in actual space, or n-tuples of real numbers in Cartesian space. Some areas of mathematics, such as algebra and perhaps topology, seem to exist only in formal and not material guises. This is probably a result of their more recent development.

A significant development brought about by the change from material to formal mathematics is the move from conceptions of “truth” to “correctness”. That is, where material mathematics sees every statement in the field as being “true” or “false”, formal mathematics sees them as being either consequences or negations of consequences of the axioms.1 (Or, as Gödel’s incompleteness theorem showed, neither). This change came about because without a specific class of objects to describe, it is unclear whether a statement can meaningfully be said to be true. In addition, the inaccessible nature of many mathematical objects (or at least, the unreliability of our perceptions of them) makes it difficult to claim certainty, as mathematics likes to do. The circumstance of following from the axioms seems much more of a reliable claim to be able to make.2

In any case, both material and formal mathematics deal with classes of objects rather than particular individuals, and are thus considered “eidetic sciences” by Husserl. As a...

Find Another Essay On Husserl’s Conceptions of Formal Mathematics

Mathematics Essay

1111 words - 4 pages Mathematics In an attempt to express certain basic concepts of mathematics precisely, one should consider a handful of different accepted and developed conceptions. Pythagoras, in the Fifth Century B.C., believed that the ultimate elements of reality were numbers; therefore the explanation for the existence of any object could only be explained in number. Gottlob Frege stated, in an idea referred to as logicism, that mathematics could in

Teaching and Learning 'Rate of Change'' (Slope) in Senior Secondary Schools in Australia

1939 words - 8 pages challenged and listened to, will achieve successful relational outcomes for previously poor mathematical students. These principles apply to all realms of mathematics teaching. Herbert & Pierce (2009) stated that ‘research suggests that problems experienced by some calculus students are likely a result of pre-existing limited or incorrect conceptions of rate of change’. They identified eight conceptions held by students regarding rate, which

Cooperative Learning in Mathematics

1194 words - 5 pages Cooperative Learning in Mathematics Low test scores and lack of motivation in mathematics by students in grade school is an issue that has recently been put under the spotlight. According to a study done in 2003, mathematics achievement levels in the United States are much lower than those in other developing countries. The results of this study show that the US is ranked 15th among the 47 participating countries in the 2003 NAEP Mathematics vs

Understanding Mathematics

3971 words - 16 pages Understanding Mathematics This paper is an attempt to explain the structure of the process of understanding mathematical objects such as notions, definitions, theorems, or mathematical theories. Understanding is an indirect process of cognition which consists in grasping the sense of what is to be understood, showing itself in the ability to apply what is understood in other circumstances and situations. Thus understanding should be treated

Women in the Math World

1540 words - 6 pages society compared with the number of men. A person can ramble off names such as Isaac Newton, Albert Einstein, Pythagoras of Samos, and Jean-François Niceron. Where are the women mathematicians? This paper will examine the lives of women that have made an impact on the world of mathematics. There might be more men in the field of mathematics however the women that have made contributions need to be seen as equals

Contrasting Relational Understanding and Instrumental Understanding

2059 words - 8 pages Rhetorical Perspectives p. 12 Healy. & Hoyles, C. (2000). A Study of Proof Conceptions in Algebra Journal for Research in Mathematics Education 2000, Vol. 31, No. 4, 396–428 Jaworski, B. (1989). ‘Mathematics teaching; belief and practice’ in Ernest, P. (Ed), Teaching Mathematics. The State of the Art, New York & London, Falmer Press. Mellin-Olsen, S.: 1981, ‘Instrumentalism as an Educational Concept’, Educational Studies In Mathematics

Gullen Essay

1399 words - 6 pages improve their educational programs. However, while education coverage has increased over time, Bolivia still faces considerable challenges for its education system to improve. Universal coverage remains a challenge especially among disadvantaged groups. We desperately require the help of nonprofit organizations to help with our educational reform. Bolivia’s National Educational System is composed of a formal and a non-formal sector. The non-formal

What Social and Political Meanings did Mathematics Acquire in the Ancient and Medieval Middle East?

1632 words - 7 pages The ancient and medieval Middle East is seen by many as the home of modern mathematics. However this is a dangerous approach because it leans towards mathematical realism, with its emphasis on modern life rather than the period it was created in. Huge advancements were made in the use of Mathematics and this was largely due to the need for more accurate and advanced administrative control over the large, thriving empires present during this

Student Research

7886 words - 32 pages avoidance up to the secondary level with students who have encountered negative experiences during formal education, in addition to a lower self confidence, depending upon these negative experiences. On the other hand, Cates and Rhymer (2003) associate mathematics anxiety with a variety of variables, such as working memory, age, sex, self-efficacy, mathematics attitudes, test anxiety, and general anxiety.White (1959) states that the Theory of


1529 words - 6 pages Psychology is the investigation of the mind and how it processes and directs our thoughts, actions and conceptions. However, in 1879 Wilhelm Wundt opened the first psychology laboratory at the University of Leipzig in Germany. Nevertheless, the origins of psychology go all the way back thousands of years starting with the early Greeks. This foundation is closely connected to biology and philosophy; and especially the subfields of physiology

An Educational Crisis: The Need for Informal Assessment

1544 words - 6 pages discipline of teaching to the test is only harming the quality of education students are receiving. Informal assessment needs to become the primary focus of evaluation rather than formal assessment. Formal assessment tends to narrow a teacher’s instruction often swaying the teacher to focus primarily on what is going to be on the test. Teaching to the test minimizes the amount of comprehension that is expected of students—focusing more on

Similar Essays

Edmund Husserl’s The Crisis Of European Sciences And Transcendental Phenomenology

2295 words - 9 pages . So, objective mathematics (when using methods to get a concrete answer), can have metaphysical features connected to it. Under Husserl’s category of ideal, mathematical ideals would include numbers, sets, and geometrical shapes. All these features cannot be seen; however, the properties of these features can be applied to a mathematical form, like geometry, and thus can be used to discover a concrete and correct answer. If one wants to

My Philosophy Of Mathematics Teaching And Learning

1602 words - 6 pages important one. My personal philosophy of mathematics education – including the optimal learning environment and best practices teaching strategies – motivates my teaching strategies in my personal classroom. Mathematics teachers teach their students a wide range of content strands – geometry, algebra, statistics, and trigonometry – while also teaching their students mathematical skills – logical thinking, formal process, numerical reasoning, and

Formalism Essay

1201 words - 5 pages Formalism In this essay I will show that whilst formalism is an attractive view it does not provide us with an adequate account of mathematics. I will begin with a brief outline of the basic position before going on to discuss it. Finally, I will discuss Hilbert’s programme. In brief, formalism is the view that mathematics is the study of formal systems. This however does not tell the whole story and formalism can be divided into term

Mathematics In The Primary School Essay

1867 words - 7 pages the ways in which I was taught as a child, examining what framework was used for the teaching of mathematics, before continuing to explore if education reforms and learning strategies could have influenced by experiences. Concluding by reflecting on my attitude towards mathematics as an adult and trainee teacher, discussing how they will affect or influence the methods of teaching I will adopt. Entering formal education in 1991 I was taught by