This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

I Never Promised You A Rose Garden By Joanne Greenberg

1196 words - 5 pages

I Never Promised You a Rose Garden by Joanne Greenberg

     The cold tone of this story starts out right in the beginning and her mother and father are quite distraught because of the daughter’s illness and the fact that they must trust the doctors; they seem to not trust anyone. They even told their own family that Deborah is at convalescent school, not a mental institution. Of course the time period of the book is much earlier than now so it is more understandable why they were upset. Hopefully parents now are less ignorant and would try and be proud of their child to willingly get help. It would be too harsh however to say that Deborah’s parents did not do the best that they could, they just did not even realize that their daughter was mentally sick. They didn’t even know that her peeing herself was the result of a tumor. I can say that the way that they treated her for that was wrong. At least they feel bad or that it is their fault. I think that much more of the blame needs to be placed on the parents, contrary of what Dr. Fried stated. It is the responsibility of the parents to protect and nurture their children, not to physically punish what it not right.

     Dr. Fried is a nice women. It is interesting that she was in Nazi Germany. Deborah and her family are Jewish and I feel that this is an important tie. Dr. Fried in able to make progress with Deborah and gain her trust. Dr. Royson has to treat Deborah for awhile when D. Fried is away. He is a much colder person and seems more concerned with proving Deborah wrong than actually getting into her personality and mind frame the way Dr. Fried did. Most of the other people who work in the hospital seem like they are just there to do their job. Dr. Fried, however, seems to be genuinely concerned about her patients. For some reason, there end up being a few folks that inmates or patients constantly torment: Hobbs, who commits suicide, and Ellis, who replaces Hobbs. Deborah tells one of the orderlies that Hobbs and Ellis are just like the patients and that it were all the harassing comes from. MacPherson sets her straight by telling her that some people cannot afford to get help for their problems.

     I found the other patients very intriguing. They were constantly changing, new one coming in, some getting well and leaving only to return later on. Deborah and another girl even escaped but they just walked around and went back. At least they did not receive a punishment or lose privileges. That must be the worst thing with being in a mental hospital, especially in the Disturbed Ward were there are no visitors allowed. It is strange how they interact with each other; they want any human contact, yet they are almost all afraid of it. Miss Coral was a favorite of mine in the story because she is one of the toughest and fierce. She also takes the time to teach Deborah two different languages: Latin and Greek. It is also interesting how the arrival and departure of various patients...

Find Another Essay On I Never Promised You a Rose Garden by Joanne Greenberg

A Rose for Emily: Love Never Leaves

1124 words - 5 pages "And so she died. Fell ill in the house filled with dust and shadows, with only a doddering Negro man to wait on her", crippled by her past and the woman she had become. Miss Emily Grierson lived a life with few loves. She was a woman who loved to be loved, but refused to be abandoned. Miss Emily did anything to avoid the feeling she had when her mother left. Miss Emily is never left alone because the loves she has can never leave. In "A

Incident in a Rose Garden: Theme & Literary Devices

972 words - 4 pages , that the young always outlive the old; and two, that Death’s personified form would be frightening and poorly dressed, his voice scratchy and raw. The use of figurative language elements throughout the poem not only assist in the murder of these common ideas, but enhance the text as well, making it easier for the reader(s) to visualize what is being written. As a whole, I enjoyed Incident in a Rose Garden, and I think the overall theme of it is to be careful, because you never know when Death could beckon you. Works Cited "Incident in a Rose Garden" by Donald Justice, p. 147-148; The Language of Literature

Never Marry a Mexican by Sandra Cisneros

766 words - 3 pages wife, and she wants to be mother. However, Drew never leaves his wife, so she settles sleeping with Drew’s own flesh and blood: his son. Evidentially, Drew’s son comes into being because Clemencia forces Drew to have a child with his pleading wife. The line Clemencia says during her state of apparent delusionary holds truth about Drew’s son: “You’re nothing without me. I created you from spit and dust […]” (Cisneros 132). In a twisted way

"A Rose For Emily" by William Faulkner

1020 words - 4 pages A Rose or A Thorn?In the story "A Rose for Emily" by William Faulkner, readers get an idea of a different time and place. He also portrays to us this old woman who has become a thorn in the townships side. Faulkner describes Emily as "a tradition, duty, and a care; sort of hereditary obligation upon the town" (246), but was this really just an old women unwilling to accept change?He puts you in the scenes by giving great details of her house

A rose for emily by: William Faulkner

1738 words - 7 pages them more knowledge about the story and how it all comes together. For instance, in "A Rose for Emily," dust, decay, and shadows in and of Miss Emily's house are mentioned throughout the story. "Only Miss Emily's house was left, lifting its stubborn and coquettish decay above the cotton wagons and gasoline pumps-an eyesore among eyesores. They were admitted by the old Negro into a dim hall from which a stairway mounted into still more shadow. It

A Rose For Emily, by William Faulkner

1136 words - 5 pages never really know the reasons that Emily decided to preserve the body of her deceased forlorn lover in her bedroom. This was obviously an act of a mentally unstable woman, which makes the story twisted and harder to discern the reason for her actions. These stories represent the horror motif and do a brilliant job of engaging the reader in their perverse and abnormal elements. While reading "A Rose for Emily" and Frankenstein one can see how

"A Rose for Emily" by William Faulkner

1087 words - 4 pages The Past Is the Present After World War One, there were many changes occurring in the world. Man's inherent need to follow tradition was now being challenged by a continually changing, modern world. The past and the present often conflicted. William Faulkner, a southern born writer, based much of his novels and short stories on this conflict. He aptly reflects the turmoil of the past and the present in, " A Rose for Emily". The conflict between

A Rose for Emily by Charles Faulkner

1269 words - 5 pages Miss Emily, crazed with years of being an old maid and an outsider from society, stayed in bed next to her beloved, as if he had never left her? If it had not been for the foreshadowing so well placed in the story we would have no clues as to who lie in the bed. No indication as to what might have led to his murder and for him to be left in the upstairs bedroom. Although Faulkner did not answer such questions for the reader, he gives enough information in the foreshadowing for conclusions to be drawn. Works Cited "A Rose for Emily" by Charles Faulkner

A Rose for Emily by William Faulkner

1598 words - 6 pages Running Head: A Rose for Emily by William FaulknerA Rose for Emily by William FaulknerA Rose for Emily by William FaulknerPart I. General Writing and AnalysisWilliam Faulkner is a writer of "A Rose for Emily". On September 25, 1897, he was born in New Albany, Mississippi. His grandfather was a writer, and he benefit from poetry at a very initial age. He was lived near the University of Mississippi at Oxford, where he ultimately studied Spanish

A Rose for Emily, by William Faulkner

1804 words - 7 pages 2011 Everybody Would Hand a Rose In his short story, “A Rose for Emily” William Faulkner gives us a picture of female identity from a male point of view, showing compassion and forgiveness for his central character. Intriguingly, the writer uses the word “rose” in the title even though a rose does not exist in any part of his story; it has highly symbolic implications. Usually, the rose

"A rose for Emily" by William Faulkner

1301 words - 5 pages In "A Rose for Emily" by William Faulkner, we see how past events effect the main character Miss Emily, especially her mental state. She seems to live in a sort of fantasy world where death has no real meaning. Miss Emily refuses to accept or even recognize, the death of her father or that of Colonel Satoris. She does not want to acknowledge the fact that the world around her was changing therefore Miss Emily surrounds herself with death. What

Similar Essays

I Never Promised You A Rose Garden By Joanne Greenberg

1443 words - 6 pages "I Never Promised You a Rose Garden" by Joanne Greenberg Schizophrenia has long been a devastating mental illness and only recently have we begun to see an improvement in our capabilities to treat this disorder. The development of neuroleptics such as, Haldol, Risperidal, and Zyprexa have given psychiatrists, psychologists and their patients great hope in the battle against this mental disease. However, during the 1960s, drugs were not

Book Report: I Never Promised You A Rose Garden

1527 words - 6 pages In the novel I Never Promised You a Rose Garden by Joanne Greenberg, sixteen year old Deborah Blau is in a tough three year battle with schizophrenia. On top of this illness, at the age of five Deborah had a tumor removed from her urethra, this awful surgery that was performed by mostly male surgeons, made Deborah feel violated. However this schizophrenia is unlike others; it takes a rough toll on her family leading through many ups and downs

I Never Promised You A Rose

1771 words - 7 pages I Never Promised You a Rose GardenNovember 15, 2013I read the novel I Never Promised You A Rose Garden by Joanne Greenberg, I chose this book because the title seemed interesting. Also, the cover of the book made me think more of what the book would be about and so I checked it out and began reading the first chapter. At first it wasn't as interesting, but as I began reading one of the middle chapters and noticed the activities that occur, I

Characters, Language And Physical Characteristics In I Never Promised You A Rose Garden

1456 words - 6 pages of Yr's reality within the reader. The secret world of Yr, which was introduced in the book I Never Promised You a Rose Garden (1964) by Hannah Green, deserves much consideration and attention. Its sophisticated structure makes even the most sane of human beings question their own perception of reality. The author brought the reality of Yr to life through three distinguished elements: characters, language and physical characteristics. Keep