Iago Vs. Moriarty: An Argumentative Comparison

1657 words - 7 pages

In William Shakespeare’s Othello, the antagonist Iago shows evil motivations towards the protagonist Othello that could be considered obsessive. This pattern of behavior can be compared to the BBC television rendition of Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes and its antagonist Moriarty. Iago and Moriarty’s obsessive behavior greatly effect Othello and Sherlock’s lives respectively that provide a solid argumentative comparison between the two. William Shakespeare’s Othello presents and “evil” character, Iago, who can be compared to the Arthur Conan Doyle TV adaption of BBC Sherlock’s Moriarty.
Iago takes on many different persona’s to enact his plan of revenge upon Othello. He plays the friend, a trustworthy and credible source of information for Othello in his feat of drama with his innocent wife, Desdemona. He also plays the wingman for Roderigo who is madly in love with Desdemona, encouraging him to make advances towards her to woo Desdemona away from Othello. Iago even persuades Roderigo to kill Cassio with his lies about Cassio and Desdemona’s affair. “...you may take him at your pleasure: I will be near to second your attempt, and he shall fall between us.” Iago promises to assist Roderigo in the murder of Cassio and he will be rewarded with Desdemona’s love (Navigators.) Iago’s true persona, though, is a heartless, woman-hating villain who would go to great lengths to get revenge against Othello for preferring Cassio over him for the military promotion.
Very much like Iago, Moriarty takes on varying personalities to gain an advantage against his opponent. To Sherlock Holmes, he is Moriarty; the intellectually challenging and dangerous criminal that seeks to eliminate his competition. For Molly Hooper, the trusted pathologist of Sherlock, Jim Moriarty is know by the description “Jim from IT” the flamboyant and awkward boyfriend who uses Molly to meet Sherlock and deceive him. Finally, Moriarty plays the more complicated role of Richard Brook, an average struggling actor that befriends journalist Kitty Riley who poses as a Sherlock-obsessed writer. Moriarty tries to confuse the public into believing that Moriarty isn’t real and all a creation of Sherlock Holmes to make himself look good. ““Of course he's Richard Brook. There is no Moriarty. There never has been. Look him up.” “What are you talking about?” “Rich Brook. An actor Sherlock Holmes hired to be Moriarty.”” (Claire.) The quote provides evidence that Moriarty is hiring individuals to deceive Sherlock as well as his friends into believing Holmes’ intellect is all a ruse.
Early on in Shakespeare’s play, Iago decides he hates Othello because he was not promoted by him. Iago believes that he wasn’t promoted because Othello’s love for Desdemona made him choose Cassio over him. Iago gains this idea because Desdemona and Cassio are friends. “‘tis the curse of service, Preferment goes by letter and affection, And not by old gradation, where each second Stood heir to the first.” (Othello.) In...

Find Another Essay On Iago Vs. Moriarty: an Argumentative Comparison

The Character of Iago in Shakespeare's Othello

1655 words - 7 pages The Character of Iago in Othello      In the play Othello, the character Iago plays a paramount role in the destruction of Othello and all of those around him.  Some critics state that Iago's actions are motiveless and that he is a purely evil character.  However, during the course of this paper, certain motives for Iago's actions will be discussed.             For the first motive to be understood the reader must become knowledgeable...

Othello essay describing the effectiveness and importance of Act Three Scene Three.

5105 words - 20 pages 'Othello'The play 'Othello' was written in the 17th Century by William Shakespeare, at this time blacks were...

Appearance vs Reality in Othello by William Shakespeare

620 words - 2 pages Appearance vs Reality is one of the most fundamental and oldest philosophical themes in human history. All people live their lives relying on their knowledge and perception, and are thus bound to them. These boundaries are what they tend to accept as "reality". However, knowledge and perception are both vague concepts; as a consequence, their reality could be nothing more than a mere mirage shaped by their beliefs. William Shakespeare, one of the...

Appearnce Vs. Reality Othello

618 words - 2 pages “ I am not what I am.” What is Iago? Iago’s actual personality is quite distant from what he pretends to be. In Shakespeare’s Othello, the reader is presented the classic battle between good and evil. It is these forces of evil that ultimately lead to the breakdown of Othello. Othello's breakdown results in the murder of his wife Desdemona. Desdemona is representative of the good in nature. Good can be defined as forgiving, honest, innocent and...

Bestial Theme In Othello

1193 words - 5 pages Since the existence of mankind, humanity is what distinguishes us from all other living creatures. It is by humanity that we perceive ourselves to be the dominant species. Although humans believe they are above all, it is the natural instinct that humanity shares with all other living creatures. The only characteristic that classifies us as humans is our ability to reason. However, our capability to rationalize can be easily suppressed by our...

Iago Essay

1337 words - 5 pages Explain your interpretation of Iago's character and role in the play so far Iago, the most villainous character in the play. He has very remarkable powers both of intellect and wit and is totally devoted to himself. It is quite ironic as Iago displays himself as honest towards the other characters in the play, but he is treacherous, deceitful and manipulative.Iago, is presented in many different ways, he can be described as an evil...

Iago Essay

1337 words - 5 pages Explain your interpretation of Iago's character and role in the play so far Iago, the most villainous character in the play. He has very remarkable powers both of intellect and wit and is totally devoted to himself. It is quite ironic as Iago displays himself as honest towards the other characters in the play, but he is treacherous, deceitful and manipulative.Iago, is presented in many different ways, he can be described as an evil...

Analysis of Jafar and Iago Characters with Evil Trials

1778 words - 7 pages The word “evil” can be interpreted in many ways. However, most people use the term evil to describe deliberate wrong doing that causes harm to others. Within the foundation of any compelling story there is always the struggle of good vs evil. The person who possesses the evil characteristics in the story is often labeled the villain. In the play Othello by William Shakespeare, the character Iago possesses evil characteristics leading to...

Othello:Character Analysis of Iago.

916 words - 4 pages Character Analysis: IagoAn antagonist, who opposes and contends against the other characters, is an important element in any tragic play. This idea is certainly well portrayed in William Shakespeare's infamous play

"Othello" by Shakespeare: Iago by end of Act I

1173 words - 5 pages "Othello" by William Shakespeare is a tragedy that constructs the play's antagonist

Othello: Characters Bring About Their Own Demise.

1138 words - 5 pages As in almost all tragedies, especially those of William Shakespeare, the tragic hero always runs into misfortune. The play Othello is no exception. In this play, every character acquainted with the tragic hero appears to be unfortunate. While these misfortunes are oddly related to Othello, are they his fault or did each character attract them out of their own actions? To answer this daunting question, one must consider the three most unfortunate...

Similar Essays

An Effective Argumentative Style vs. A Poor Argumentative Style

988 words - 4 pages When you first think about the movie Fight Club, great argumentative skills is not something that comes to mind as an essential part of the characters. After more thought and a deeper analysis of this movie though,

Abortion: Choice Vs. Murder, an argumentative paper

703 words - 3 pages Abortion: Choice Vs. MurderIs it a right to have children or is it a privilege? Does every women have the right to chose to have a child or to have an abortion?Having an abortion can only be decide by women, due to the fact, that the abortion has a lifelong changing effect that is irreversible. No other person has the right to choose for her. She is the individual, who will under go all the transformations that pregnancy has in...

Australia vs. China: An Economic Comparison

1472 words - 6 pages Australia and China adopt very different economic systems in order to cater the best for their society. However, Australia's economic system is more successful than China's and, due to the writer's right-wing value system, will be measured in terms of environmental efficiency, labour and entrepreneurial resource efficiency and the standard of living.The

Impact of Relationships Upon the Themes of Shakespeare's Othello

1361 words - 5 pages The Impact of the Relationship between Othello, Iago and Cassio Upon the Themes of Othello           The major themes present in Othello are Jealously, Betrayal and Appearance vs. Reality. Each one of these themes are reinforced throughout the play in Iago's evil plot. They are represented or seen by Othello, Iago and Cassio and the relationship between them; dictating the motion of the...