This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Icwa And The Social Welfare Of Native Americans

1867 words - 8 pages

The abuse of children of any kind is unacceptable, regardless of one’s culture. When looking at the Native American culture, the indigenous people of this land we have come to call America, there has been a debate spanning decades in terms of what should be done to keep an abused child who has to be taken away from the birth parents, within their own culture (the Native American culture). In 1978, the United States Congress and the President of the United States at the time, Jimmy Carter, enacted a law known as the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) in attempts to avoid the separation of Native children from their family, let alone, their own culture (Fletcher, 2009). How exactly does the Indian Child Welfare Act, ICWA, keep Native children taken away from their birth parents within either their family or the Native culture itself?
When considering the Indian Child Welfare Act, a social worker, or other official can ultimately terminate parental rights. To do this, they must make their argument for termination by presenting a burden of proof. The Indian Child Welfare Act states that children cannot simply be removed because someone else is able to raise the child or because the parents have been deemed “unfit to parent.” Rather, evidence must be provided that the child is put in a dangerous situation if they remain in the home given the present issues being investigated by said officials. According to the Department of Health and Human Services Screening and Assessment for Family Engagement, Retention, and Recovery, if a social worker or the agency in charge of the investigation wants to terminate parental rights, there are two ways of doing so: clear and convincing, or proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
Through clear and convincing, the plaintiff(s) must provide a strong argument that supports and persuades their reasoning for placement in foster care in comparison to the arguments from the defendants as to why placement is not necessary. With making a case via beyond a reasonable doubt, the plaintiff(s) must now have such a strong argument and strong enough evidence to support their argument for placement in foster care that there is no room for a judge to doubt the need for the child’s removal from the home and placement into foster care. Regardless, if the court finds the child is not in a dangerous situation if he/she remains in the home, the Indian Child Welfare Act requires the court to deny parental termination of rights (Young, Nakashian, Yeh, &Amatetti, 2006). With all of this said, what exactly does the situation look like on the reservations in terms of child welfare as a whole?
According to the National Indian Child Welfare Association (n.d.), there are currently 5.2 million American Indian and Alaska Natives that live within the United States-- this making up around 1.7 percent of the United States total population. The NICWA further states that some of the following problems are present among American Indian children and...

Find Another Essay On ICWA and the social welfare of native americans

The Worth of Native Americans Essay

730 words - 3 pages with no other option but to take their own lives. When the Native Americans were promised the health facilities and they were taken away, it hurt them mentally and physically. The mental aspect of it, is that they couldn’t get any help, and were probably too ashamed to tell their families. The physical aspect, is that it hurt their population; the Native Americans that die, the less the culture lives. When you get dependent on something like the

The Genocide of Native Americans Essay

1359 words - 5 pages famous memoirs have come from these genocides, and many have come from events that do not exactly classify as genocides. Many sites such as,, and have created lists of the most horrific genocides in history, there are 8 that come up time and time again they are the Genocide of North Korean Prison Camps, the Genocide of Native Americans, the Bosnian Genocide, Stalin’s Genocides, The Chinese Cultural Revolution, the

Native Americans, Bradbury and the Scorn of the FBI

1869 words - 8 pages In the twenty-first century, schools all over the country teach that Native Americans were here before what are now considered “Americans.” These new Americans arrived by boats, bringing with them disease and manifest destiny, conquering the land that was once called home by thousands of tribes. Nevertheless, through extortionist deals, mass murder and small pox, the land was evetually vacated, leaving the new Americans to take their place and

The Settlement of America and Attitudes Toward Native Americans

1015 words - 4 pages The Settlement of America and Attitudes Toward Native Americans Indians were first introduced to Europeans in the late fifteenth century. The Native Americans were referred to as the "noble redman" at the time. The Native Americans were very helpful to the Europeans and they guided them around what is now America. The Europeans became very curious of this "new land" and they began to settle it. The settlement of America brought conflict and

Cruel and Inhuman Treatment of Native Americans by the Colonists

1745 words - 7 pages The process of assimilation, as it regards to the Native Americans, into European American society took a dreaded and long nearly 300 years. Initially, when the European’s came to the hopeful and promising land of the “New World”, they had no desire or reason anything but minimal contact with the Indians. However, starting in the 1700s the European colonists population skyrocketed. The need for more resources became evident and the colonists

The Pursuit of the American Dream by African Americans, Native Americans, and the Working Class

1672 words - 7 pages groups of people living in America as they pursued comfort in social and economic aspects. The “American Dream” has long been a part of American society and culture. In particular, Native Americans, the working class, and African Americans have all experienced the struggle and accomplishment that comes with the “American dream”. Native Americans faced many struggles in their efforts of achieving the “American Dream.” Shortly after the West became

The Slaughter of Native Americans and The Enslavement of African Americans

1130 words - 5 pages invasion were secure in their status in the realm.” As the years progressed, race and racism worsened and have led to the slaughter of Native Americans and the enslavement of Africans. More recently, it was seen as the basis for the Holocaust and Apartheid. The torture and cruelty humans have inflicted upon other humans have led many people to question if there are different species of humans, with some being inferior to others. It also brings up

The Relationship Between Oklahomans and Native Americans

4507 words - 18 pages The Relationship Between Oklahomans and Native Americans I. Introduction When the name Oklahoma is mentioned, there are certain things that come to the minds of many people and one of those things are Native Americans. Native Americans and Oklahoma share a special bond that neither one of them ever thought would come into fruition. This special bond between Native Americans and Oklahoma is something that started with great

History and Relocation of Native Americans

2671 words - 11 pages Indians were forced onto the reservations or were killed for their defiance. Once they were forced to reservations Congress passed a law that stripped the Bands of their rights, and forfeited the Black Hills to the U.S.’9(p. 348-349). Similar events were common re occurrences10 throughout the 19th century. The idea of living on a reservation for Native Americans was the equivalent of living in a hell on earth. Many feared going to them so much

The Southeast Native Americans: Cherokees and Creeks

934 words - 4 pages also developed large towns and highly centralized social and political structures.” In the first half of the 1600s Europeans encountered these native peoples. Both cultures encountered new plants, animals, and diseases. However, the Indians received more diseases compared to the few new diseases to the Europeans. The new diseases resulted in a massive loss of Native Americans, including the Southeast Indians which had never encountered the new

Native Americans And Treaties with the Government

3983 words - 16 pages their livestock of the bison. Jones justifies the military grade of the natives, "they were armed with the latest and most approved repeating rifles, and their tactics and strategy equal to the enemy" and with the superior knowledge of the land, during the 1860s and into the 1870s, the Plain Native Americans were victorious of almost every major battle that they fought. The Fetterman fight in 1866 was one of the biggest military disasters in

Similar Essays

Examination Of The Indian Child Welfare Act (Icwa) Of 1978

3154 words - 13 pages federal law, and the contemporary debates that relate to the implementation of this law. The history of Indian Child Welfare Act derived from the need to address the problems with the removal of Indian children from their communities. Native American tribes identified the problem of Native American children being raised by non-native families when there were alarming numbers of children being removed from their homes by state social welfare agencies

Social And Economic Problems Facing Native Americans

1828 words - 7 pages In the late 1870’s, while the American-Indian war was still being fought, another war began against Native American culture. It began when the American government took Native American children away from the families and placed them into boarding schools that were far from their homes and taught them the ways of the white man. Native Americans have since struggled to survive on the lands where they were placed many years ago, a place of

The History Of Native Americans Essay

894 words - 4 pages tell each tribe by looking at their clothes, headdresses and ornamentation. The Native Americans was very religious, and were inspired by nature. Most Native American tribes recognize that all things in the universe have a deeper meaning. Symbols were used to recognize these beliefs.For example Indian symbols include images of the sun, moon, animals, or ancestral tribe members. For example the sun symbolized the cardinal directions

The History Of Native Americans Essay

1081 words - 4 pages Indian threat to the peaceful westward expansion, and try to destroy its cultures, spiritual, economic, and political traditions by assimilating Native American into American life. The signing of these treaties and the adoption of policies and laws gradually declined sovereignty of indigenous nations. In the 1830’s, Five Indians Nations lived in territories that many Americans thought it might be more profitable for breeding, however