This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Idaho Wolves Deserve Conversation Not Eradication

1568 words - 7 pages

The wolves beat the hunters in the recent, and highly contested, wolf and coyote derby in Salmon, ID. Wolves eluded the participants for the entire two-day hunt, but 21 coyotes were not so fortunate. The absence of any wolf kills, however, has not lessened the intensity of the controversy, nor the temperature of the debates. Wolves are a touchy subject, no matter the stance; as with most hotly contested issues, there is an abundance of information, but not all of it is correct.

So are the wolves predators that destroy livestock other wildlife, creating devastating losses for both ranchers and hunters? Or are they prey? Misunderstood, maligned and victimized only for what comes naturally to ...view middle of the document...

They stand upwards of 35" and can weigh as much as 170 lbs, though they average about 145 lbs. These wolves are the big kids.

Aside from the subspecies difference, it is very difficult to find unbiased comparisons between the two. Some will say that the latter is much more aggressive, much more prone to attack livestock, and much more likely to decimate wildlife herds. Wolf advocates say the fault lies with the ranchers and hunters who have forced the wolves out of their natural habitat, and really should expect no different. Searches across the internet reveal the same arguments, with no sign of common ground, and the common ground may be where the answer lies.

Regardless of whether the species is the Northern Rocky Mountain Wolf or the McKenzie Valley Wolf, it is still a wolf. Both subspecies hunt the same food and have the same breeding habits, but one is slightly larger than the other. The reality is what now lives in Idaho's back country is probably a hybrid of the two subspecies, and one which has adopted characteristics of both through genetic combinations. This is a theory, of course, because nothing substantial can be found to back the claim.

As for the aggressiveness; again, the answer most likely is in the center where neither side dares tread. Livestock does take up a lot of ground, and this ground is shared by the wolves, along with cougar, elk, deer, moose, coyote, fox and so on. To get a good feel for this, one only has to visit the open range areas of the South Hills - while nearly at the opposite end of the state, it is not uncommon to come across all of the above (except the wolves), and all standing on the road at one place or another. When domestic livestock encroach on ground usually occupied by wildlife, conflict is going to occur; unfortunately, a newborn calf or lamb is going to make a much easier catch than a full grown elk. This also means that a rancher feels the need to protect his or her herd from a very real threat.

While wolves do pose a threat to livestock, especially if ample wild game is not available, they do not seem to pose as big of a threat to humans. This is not to say that wolves will not attack humans, because they will, especially if threatened or provoked. However, a wolf attack is rarely fatal, and a person's dog faces much more danger from a wolf than the person himself.  In fact, a mountain lion poses more of a threat to a person.

Wolves spread parasites to deer, elk and cattle, and this parasite is dangerous to humans.

The parasite in question is Echinococcus granulosis. This parasitic tapeworm is one requiring two hosts to live. The life cycle of this parasite begins when a wolf, dog, coyote or fox eats an infected animal, such as a cow or an elk. The parasite then lives in the gut of the host animal, where it lays its eggs, which are then expelled through that animal's feces. When the ungulate, such as a cow or an elk, ingests the feces through the normal act of grazing, then the cycle...

Find Another Essay On Idaho Wolves Deserve Conversation Not Eradication

Wolf Population Control Essay

1597 words - 6 pages Idaho, this only costs eleven dollars and seventy-five cents. Native Americans have a very high respect for the wolf; they have a great love for them and are implemented in their everyday life. They as well as many citizens think that Fish and Game should control the population of the wolves humanly instead of the public going out and killing them for sport. In 1996 the government brought back the wolf and there was a lot of controversy about

Wolf and Coyote Derby Turns Tiny Idaho Town Into Battleground

1404 words - 6 pages and hunters were far from keen on the idea, and the hatred of the wolves has steadily risen among these groups. Part of the problem with the wolves now found in the Idaho wilderness is the fact that they are not native to Idaho, as the indigenous populations had all been nearly wiped out. These wolves are from Canada, and are much larger and stronger than those native to the state. Not only that, but the are much more aggressive, run in packs

Big Bad Wolf

2180 words - 9 pages terrifying, because they are as a wild species, and a top predator they deserve that respect. However, not in the way ranchers and the media depicts them. Wolves for one, are social creatures, which one of my images represents. That image is particularly important because it shows that wolves not only depend on their fellow members to survive, but to thrive in a pack, they need to work together as well as look out for one another. A pack

Grey Wolves

2142 words - 9 pages of thelarger red wolves may be bigger than the smaller of the graywolves. They can also be distinguished by identifying a knob,'called cingulum, on the upper carnassials, or shearing teeth ofthe red wolf.' However, this method, also, is not altogetherfull-proof. In some cases a timber wolf will have a cingulum andan occasional red wolf will not have one at all. This method ofusing the cingulum to distinguish the wolves can also bedecieving in

Conservation Biology

2432 words - 10 pages predator by introducing wolves to Yellowstone National Park (Ripple and Beschta, 2012). Many other scientists, even prior to Weaver’s conclusion, also felt the same way. The gray wolf was one of the first species to be listed as endangered under the Endangered Species Preservation Act of 1966 (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 2013). However, this listing did not provide a legal basis for the reintroduction of the gray wolf to the Yellowstone

Irretrievable Interlopers

810 words - 4 pages between the two feuding families, the two men are clearly not in such a bad position that they should be slowly devoured by wolves. Thus, the two men did not deserve the end of their lives coming in such a fashion. So, because of this agreement, there is yet another reason why the two men did not deserve their fate. A final reason that should bring a person to believe that the two men did not deserve their fate would be the utter horror of their


846 words - 4 pages fate that concludes the story, whether or not they deserve it is a negotiable subject. As a reader, one could decide that they did deserve their fate of which they both die the same way, wolves. In “The Interlopers” the two men, Ulrich and Georg deserve their fate at the end of the story because; they were originally there hunting each other, they bickered quite a bit after the tree had fallen and showed their hate, once one had realized that there

Housing Restrictions: A Necessary Evil

2249 words - 9 pages ). By having students live under the watchful eye of managers and each other, BYU-Idaho can ensure that the formation of a culture that fosters disregard for the rules does not arise. However, the school does not wish to promote distrust among the students. David A. Bender, while president of Rick’s college states that students should not act as “self-appointed, judgmental, and self-righteous spiritual vigilantes”, but rather as “concerned

Commentary and analysis of "Dances with Wolves"

781 words - 3 pages , yet at the end it is apparent that the Lakota tribe indirectly assisted Dunbar in becoming a spiritually mature individual.At the beginning of Dances With Wolves, John Dunbar was not a complex or spiritually developed person. He was a soldier sent to an abandoned post without any knowledge of the surrounding environment or cultures. John Dunbar was insensitive to the beliefs and culture of the Lakota. Originally, he believed that they were savages

Personal Dialect Analysis

772 words - 4 pages Idaho can have differences in how they pronounce certain words. The word “ketchup”, for instance, is pronounced regularly with a short “e” sound here in Idaho. But down in Utah, which is where I am from, we pronounce is with a short “a” sound. This pronunciation sounds more like “catch-up” than “ketchup.” Because I am used to it being said both ways, I am not able to pick out the change in everyday conversation. Most people I associate with, here

An analysis on whether two characters from a story deserved their fate

813 words - 4 pages . Humans need to realize it is ok to forgive and forget. In The Interlopers, the two men at least tried to make amends. Even if it wasn’t legitimate, it still shows a lot that they tried as they had been enemies for so long. In the short story of The Interlopers, the two men did not deserve the fate that happened to them as they made an effort to become friends, everyone should get a second chance, and no one deserves to die that way. To start, the two

Similar Essays

Reintroducing Wolves To Yellowstone And Idaho

1209 words - 5 pages with the wolves around."The majority of what hunters are seeing are behavioral changes rather than population changes," said Steve Nadeau, Idaho Fish and Game large carnivore biologist (Casper Star, 2004). The elk are not out in the open but staying in concealed places and moving constantly. The lower number of elk sighting could also mean a loss of revenue for outfitters as well as ranchers. While outfitters may have to find another way to offset

Debate Over Weither The Yellowstone Wolves Should Be Removed. Side With Either The Ranchers Or The Conservationalists

1201 words - 5 pages , but further damaged.Even though the ranchers and many other skeptics believe that the wolves should be removed from the National Park the conversationalists' beliefs are the opposite. The conversationalists believe that the Yellowstone wolves should defiantly not be removed from the National Park. The Yellowstone wolves hold an essential spot in the ecosystem of the Idaho region. They encourage evolution to occur in their prey. The reason why

The Effects Of Wolves On Game Populations

1327 words - 6 pages environmental problems, they succeeded in doing the opposite, by bringing back the wrong kind of wolves they started, depleting elk populations, and wild game. In 1995 the environmentalists started to repopulate the wolves. The wolves started spreading like rabbits, across many states including Idaho, Wyoming, Utah, and Washington. The main area in the spot light would be Yellowstone because of the national park there it instantly hit the News

The Yellowstone Wolf Controversy Essay

1463 words - 6 pages long as they were off National Forest or National Park property and on private property. Many environmentalists did not want this to come to be since they felt this was the reason all the wolves had been lost in the first place. The Montana and Idaho plans were a little bit different than Wyoming's. They were planning on putting a trophy hunting season out on the wolf. The thing about all of these plans in the first place is that they were all