This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Thoughts On A Possible Rational Reconstruction Of The Method Of

3240 words - 13 pages

Thoughts on a Possible Rational Reconstruction of the Method of "Rational Reconstruction"

ABSTRACT: Rational reconstructions standardly operate so as to transform a given problematic philosophical scientific account-particularly of a terminological, methodological or theoretical entity-into a similar, but more precise, consistent interpretation. This method occupies a central position in the practice of analytic philosophy. Nevertheless, we encounter-even if only in a very few specific publications-a vague image of it. This is due on the one hand to the problem of the intentions of application, i.e., of the normativity of rational reconstruction (descriptive/prescriptive-ambivalence). It is also due on the other hand to the problem of the significance of the method in the field of history of philosophy (systematic/historical-dichotomy). The varied usage within analytic philosophy, as well as the increasingly inflationary and interfering usage outside, contribute to make rational reconstruction somehow appear a Proteus in contemporary philosophical methodology. This paper attempts to administer first aid and to close a bit of the theoretical gap and thus to reach a more exact image for the interests of analytic philosophy. Self-application of the method appears to be the right remedy. A graduating rational reconstruction of a standard concept of rational reconstruction will be suggested, differentiating the concept of rational reconstruction according to normativity, and explicating the method of rational reconstruction into two such variants.

Introduction

The method of rational reconstruction occupies a central position in the practice of Analytical Philosophy. Andreas Kamlah once has dealt with it in an article under the indicative title "Wie arbeitet die analytische Wissenschaftstheorie?" or, in English, "How does Analytical Philosophy of Sciene operate?" (see Kamlah [1980]). Nevertheless, we encounter-even in the specific publications-only a vague image of it. Surprisingly, there are comparatively few specific publications. Historically they concentrate in the phase of Logical Empiricism. On the other hand we record a quite extensive literature on the latest variant of rational reconstruction, the "structuralist reconstruction." Besides Kamlah's article, Poser [1971] is to be mentioned. Further, for Analytical Philosophy directly relevant material includes mainly brief remarks in preliminaries and digressions, particularly in works of Wolfgang Stegmller, who established the method in German postwar philosophy. I want to point out his well-known article on Kant (Stegmller [1967]), which I followed when choosing a title for this paper, as well as his introduction to the fourth volume of his great series on philosophy of science and Analytical Philosophy with its section "Neue Betrachtungen ber die Ziele und Aufgaben der Wissenschaftstheorie" (Stegmller [1973], pp. 1-64). Jrgen Mittelstra has commented for German Constructivism in...

Find Another Essay On Thoughts on a Possible Rational Reconstruction of the Method of

A Historiography of the Reconstruction Era

4644 words - 19 pages Reconstruction up to a certain point. He provided the reader with various excerpts from scholars based on the various issues that came about as a result of Reconstruction. In his introduction, Lynd argued that Reconstruction could be divided into three parts. The first stage was a preparatory period from 1861-1865 in which rehearsals for Reconstruction were enacted in Tennessee, Louisiana, Arkansas, and the sea islands off South Carolina as these fell to the

A Historiography of the Reconstruction Era

4644 words - 19 pages Reconstruction up to a certain point. He provided the reader with various excerpts from scholars based on the various issues that came about as a result of Reconstruction. In his introduction, Lynd argued that Reconstruction could be divided into three parts. The first stage was a preparatory period from 1861-1865 in which rehearsals for Reconstruction were enacted in Tennessee, Louisiana, Arkansas, and the sea islands off South Carolina as these fell to the

The Failure of Reconstruction

770 words - 3 pages The Failure of ReconstructionIn 1863, the Emancipation Proclamation gave freedom to all of the blacks. However, the road to freedom for the blacks was still going to be a long one and would not start until after the end of the Civil War. The Reconstruction definitely failed in bringing social and economic equality to the blacks because of; the failure of the Freedman's Bureau, the blacks were kept from voting, and they were treated unfairly.To

The Failure of Reconstruction

679 words - 3 pages Shannon, The original purpose of Reconstruction was to restore the buildings and the economy of the south the best they could, but without the immoral element of slavery. But, reconstruction under the Johnson Presidency was a failure for a few reasons: 1) Convict Leasing, 2) Sharecropping, 3) the Ku Klux Klan, 4) Segregation in schools, even in the North, 5) Carpetbaggers/Scalawags, 6) misleading statistics, and 7) racism. Convict Leasing

Mythic Heros. A personal essay on the thoughts of Sinbad the sailor

558 words - 2 pages crew met up with: a fish so large, many mistook it for an island, an island where rocs (enormous birds (their eggs were often mistaken for buildings)) still lived, cannibals, giants, and even herds of angry elephants. On each and everyone one of his famed voyages, he was shipwrecked, alone, and faced with some hideous danger. On each and everyone, he overcame the odds, destroyed his foes, and returned home with riches beyond the imagination

The Perspective of Rational Choice

1722 words - 7 pages The rational choice perspective is a great way of understanding society and larger systems. When I read in our book how human behavior is based on self-interest and rational choices about effective ways to accomplish goals (Hutchison, 2008, p. 46), my past interactions made so much more sense. This is because human interaction involves trade of social resources, such as love, approval, information, money, and physical labor (Hutchison, 2008, p

The Power of Rational Beings

1916 words - 8 pages Imagine yourself going to the shopping mall and picking out a floral dress at your favorite store, only to have the worker telling you that you cannot have it, that you must have the polka dot dress instead. How would you feel? How does it trigger your emotion? As humans, we despise having the people around us thrusting us to do or choose something that is out of our league. We insist on making the choice ourselves because we have the competence

The Development of a New Spectrophotometric Method

714 words - 3 pages A new spectrophotometric method based on the oxidation reaction between iodide and iodate in the presence of carboxylic acid form of losartan potassium (LP) has been developed for the estimation of LP in pharmaceutical products. HPLC/MS method, kinetic studies and central composite design method was used for formation reactions, equilibration and determination of stability duration and experimental conditions, respectively. Developed

a) Explain the term decision making using the rational method - education class - presentaion

2475 words - 10 pages a) Explain the term decision making using the rational method A decision is a choice made from two or more alternatives. The decision-making process is defined as a set of different steps that begins with identifying a problem and decision criteria and allocating weights to those criteria; moves to developing, analysing, and selecting an alternative that can resolve the problem, implements the alternative, and concludes with evaluating the

Thoughts Of A Serene Domicile

768 words - 3 pages I have warm thoughts of my neighborhood and a home. The neighborhood is filled with families, children's laughter, and beautiful homes surrounded by Martha Stewart Garden's. Yellow tulips, red roses, orange daises, and some gardens would have fountains with water coming out of a cupid or angels' mouth. There would be a car in every driveway, maybe two if the individuals residing in the home were married. Each child has a bike and/or scooter

Thoughts of a Troubled Mind

1429 words - 6 pages love with Holly and wants to know about her well being (Capote, Breakfast 104). Capote seemed like to toy with people's love since he had never truly experienced it. In the above scene fro Breakfast at Tiffany's, Capote portrayed love as something unreachable by letting the narrator's love for Holly to be in vain and he also reflect on Holly's indifferent to love as a reflection of his mother. Although Capote's works are mostly influenced by his

Similar Essays

The Thoughts Of A Writer Essay

877 words - 4 pages Ernest Hemingway portrays many of his views through the characters in his stories. Hemingway has found a way to deliver many different themes in his writing. He includes personal experiences, thoughts and opinions to convey his way of thinking to the reader. Hemingway's writing can be interpreted in many ways, but as countless readers have observed, Ernest Hemingway is a sexist. Hemingway is viewed as a sexist because of the way he writes about

A Summary Of "Discourse On The Method" By Rene Descartes

758 words - 3 pages Discourse on the Method is Descartes' attempt to explain his method of reasoning through even the most difficult of problems. He illustrates the development of this method through brief autobiographical sketches interspersed with philosophical arguments. Part 1 contains "various considerations concerning the sciences." First, all people possess "good sense," the ability to distinguish truth from fiction. Therefore, it is not a lack of ability

Vonnegut's Thoughts On The Atrocities Of War

2053 words - 9 pages details the life of Billy Pilgrim, a goofy, awkward, and incompetent guy whose life never seems to turn out the way he anticipates. When Billy was a young man, against his wish, he was drafted to fight against the Germans in World War II. As most men do in war, Billy experiences horrific sights on and off the battlefield. As a result he greatly traumatized for the rest of his life because of it. Then, in his middle years, he becomes kidnapped

Thoughts On The Defintion Of Integrity

570 words - 2 pages The definition of integrity according to Webster's Dictionary is, 'a rigid adherence to a code of behavior.' There are though many ways to look at a persons integrity. A person with integrity possesses many qualities. Three of these qualities are honesty, the ability to follow a moral code, and loyalty to yourself and your beliefs.In The Crucible, a prime example of a person with integrity is Elizabeth Proctor. Elizabeth shows her personal