This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Identification Of Gifted And Talented Students

2013 words - 8 pages

Identification of Gifted and Talented Students

When I was in the second grade, all of the students at my elementary school were given a special test one day in class. We were told that it was not for a grade, but that it was to help the school know more about us. None of us really understood what the test was, or what the school would use it for, and it is certain that no one in my class that day understood the implications of what those results would mean for us the rest of our lives.

The topic of gifted and talented education is one that has always sparked debates among parents and teachers, and recent movements towards totally integrating classrooms have added to this debate. For many years now, "average" children, gifted and talented children, and learning disability children have all been separated into different learning environments, for part of, or the entire teaching curriculum. New issues have arisen because of the recent trend of integration, but a few issues have always been in question when it comes to this topic. One of these issues is the identification process of "advanced" students, and specifically, the use of IQ testing to determine placement in these programs.

The test that I took that day over 13 years ago was an IQ test, a test to determine my "Intelligence Quotient." IQ tests have long been used as placement tests, and are used even today by many school systems to determine the levels of the students in their schools. However, a current trend in education is to try to move away from these types of tests. J. S. Renzulli has been widely recognized as an authority on gifted and talented education for a long time. In a 1996 article, Renzulli and J. H. Purcell talk about some of the new trends in the identification methods of Gifted and Talented students, reporting that IQ score is still the predominant feature in identification plans of most school systems (174). However, the authors went on to say that presently, 80% of states use identification definitions that include creativity, approximately 70% use definitions that include artistic abilities, and slightly more than half of states use definitions that include leadership abilities (175). Even with this recent recognition of other abilities, IQ test scores are still being used as a determining factor in most American schools.

Before the 1950s, most educators and school systems tended to follow Louis Terman’s example and based most decisions about gifted individuals on IQ and scholastic achievement scores. Standardized group intelligence tests, such as California Test of Mental Maturity, were often used to determine IQ. In these tests, educators were looking for exceptional ability in verbal or performance IQ, or a combination of the two. For the final identification, individual IQ tests such as the Wechsler scales and the Stanford Binet were used. Most school systems around this time considered an IQ of 130 or above to fall in the "gifted" range. This...

Find Another Essay On Identification of Gifted and Talented Students

How Better to Support Our Gifted and Talented Students in Schools

546 words - 3 pages has been recommended that cultural responsive training, including culturally sensitive definitions and theory of giftedness be developed and aligned with culturally sensitive measures of identification. Because traditional methods tend to identify only half of the brightest students, the identification process must take steps to lead us toward a more diverse population of students in gifted and talented programs. The Office of Educational

Gifted and Talented Program Essay

731 words - 3 pages Implementation of the Gifted and Talented program is headed by Stephanie Cantu. She requires rigorous standards to be met by teachers, students, and parents. If a parent fails to meet a deadline or sign paperwork their student will not qualify for testing that academic year. Testing will be done the following year if the next grade level teacher nominates that student. Students, if accepted into the Gifted and Talented program, will remain in

Critique of the gifted and talented evaluation scales

1019 words - 5 pages . After measuring to see if they are gifted and talented; candidates normally receive a specialized academic education to further develop their individual skills. The identification process used includes a broad-based nomination of students for the gifted and talented education program, multi-dimensional screenings, and identification including placement, committee and review selection. Assessment and interpretation of the Gifted and Talented

struggle of gifted students

853 words - 4 pages A state that undertakes custody of a child is declaring that it can do a better job providing protection. This system is a powerful agent of support, providing positive nurturing environments that enable a child to reach his or her potential. Nonetheless, when children suffer additional abuse in the system, this government intervention should be questioned. In "And Still We Rise," Miles Corwin chronicles the daily struggle of gifted students in

Gifted and Talented Program Admissions: Needed Improvements and Reforms

2200 words - 9 pages Gifted and Talented Program Admissions: Needed Improvements and Reforms Gifted and talented programs are intrinsically valuable to many children’s education as they provide a system in which all students involved are engaged, challenged, and intellectually stimulated. In "How People Learn", Donovan, Bransford, and Pellegrino (1999) stress the importance of each student being given reasonable and appropriate goals based on his or her level

Secondary Talented and Gifted Programming: Challenges and Successes

1755 words - 7 pages their focus on low or underachieving students (Beisser, 2008). As long as TAG students remain proficient, districts see little incentive to invest in these students. More and more, gifted and talented coordinators serve larger numbers of students. For example, in one Iowa district, one TAG coordinator serves grades 6-12; however those same grade levels are served by nine special education teachers (Carlisle Community Schools, 2010). Beisser also

Gifted Students and Social Stigma

5938 words - 24 pages gifted students, so those students know how to treat others in the future. And above all else, we must remember that gifted students are children first and gifted second. Works Cited Benbow, Camilla Persson, and Susan L. Dauber. "Aspects of Personality and Peers Relations of Extremely Talented Adolescents." Gifted Child Quarterly. 34.1. (1990): 10-5. Clark, Jennifer J., and David N. Dixon. "The Impact of Social Skills Training on the

Varying Types of Gifted Students

821 words - 4 pages , the use of interpreters or translators would be crucial to the students learning and identification process because without them, educators would not have a means for identifying accurately if their ESL students are also gifted or need extra support in their learning.

Gifted and Talented Children; How do Parents influence Children and Children influence Parents?

1060 words - 5 pages Over the course of their life a child’s development will be impacted by a variety of different factors. These factors often include but are not limited to; education, family environment, society and even popular culture. However over the years it has been recognised that none of these factors surpass this influence of parents on their children and children on their parents. In regards to gifted and talented students, there are a variety of

The Pros and Cons of Ethnic Identification

832 words - 3 pages enriches societies and makes them multi-racial. Therefore, every ethnic group is essential to complete the mosaic. Although they are sometimes threatened, minorities must fight to preserve their principles. Why must they fight? Because racial identification has many positive impacts on the members. But it’s undeniable that this way is invaded by dangers. After evoking the positive and negative aspects of ethnic identification, we will suggest some

Identification and Characterizaation of Three GS Isoforms

1144 words - 5 pages 3. Results 3.1. Identification and characterization of three GS isoforms Three different GS sequences (GS01, GS02 and GS03) have been identified through the sequencing and blastx searching. All the sequences contain a complete coding sequence (CDS) region and 5′ and 3′-UTRs. In this study we have attempted the characterization of the multiple GS cDNAs present. The characteristics details of the full-length cDNAs of GS01 (Accession No. JQ740737

Similar Essays

Classification Of Gifted And Talented Students

3785 words - 15 pages Classification of Gifted and Talented Students Many people have varying views on what classifies a student as gifted and talented. According to the Office of Gifted and Talented, six qualities determine giftedness. These qualities are intellectual ability as well as talent, scoring in the 97th percentile and above on aptitude tests, creative thinking, leadership ability, talents in the fine arts, and psychomotor abilities. Using the

Teaching Gifted And Talented Students Essay

2088 words - 8 pages preceding statements are all myths about gifted and talented students. In reality, gifted and talented students need just as much – if not, more – resources and assistance than their average-by-comparison peers. Yet there exists a reluctance to grant this extra help to a set of students who are, by definition, “gifted” with higher abilities than average students. Thus, challenging and nurturing their abilities becomes less of a priority and these

Adressing The Needs Of The Gifted And Talented Students

1497 words - 6 pages of assessment (Gearheart, 1995, p 430). However, according to a study by Tyler-Wood and Carrie in 1991, a single test does not accurately portray the population of gifted and talented students (Gearheart, 1995 p 430). Gearheart suggests a five step process to more accurately gauge the screening process for gifted and talented students. This process allows for several assessments during screening and identification. These steps include initial

Effective Curriculum Models For Gifted And Talented Students

1923 words - 8 pages levels. The third dimension of the Integrated Curriculum Model centers gifted and talented students learning around major issues and themes. To connect the themes and issues to real world applications is creating a deeper understanding of the material. The Research Model was created at the William and Mary Center for Gifted Education. This model was created to strengthen the student’s critical thinking skills. The Research Model provides the