Identify And Evaluate The Roles Of The Prosecution And Defense In A Criminal Trial. Identify & Discuss The Sentencing Powers, Available To A Judge In A Specific Criminal Case

1693 words - 7 pages

The Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE) and The Prosecution of Offences Act 1985 lead to the establishment of the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) in 1986. The CPS is responsible, on behalf of the state, for prosecuting criminal cases investigated by the police in England and Wales. The Legal Aid Act 1988 enables defendants on low incomes and facing court appearances the opportunity to free legal aid. The Access to Justice Act 1999 (s12), directed the Legal Services Commission to establish a Criminal Defence Service (CDS). This means that every person arrested for a crime, regardless of status, is legally entitled to have a free and independent legal representative present before ...view middle of the document...

This has resulted in CPS and police relations improving considerably, but appears to challenge the very reason why the CPS was established in the first instance. Nonetheless, they play a vital role in the pursuit of justice.The key objectives of the defense are to advise defendants on the best course of action for pending prosecutions; assessing the prosecutions case, arguing against it where necessary, and providing their own evidence with the aim of obtaining the best possible outcome for the defendants. They must also seek to ensure that the defendant receives a fair trial. Defense lawyers are often asked 'How can you defend someone that is guilty?' The fact is that their role is to not judge, but to represent the defendant, the judgement is the responsibility of the Magistrates, Judge or Jury. Similarly, the onus of proof of an offence being committed is placed upon the CPS. Defense lawyers can never be sure if a defendant is guilty. There have been a number of cases where an innocent person has admitted guilt. For example - in the 80's Sean Hodgson confessed that he had murdered a barmaid; as a result, he spent nearly thirty years in prison for a crime he did not commit (BBC: 19/03/2009). However, if a defendant admits guilt then the defense's role will be to seek a lenient sentence based on that omission.There are many stages of a criminal trial and at each one the CPS conceivably carries the majority of the burden. During the first pre-trial hearing at Magistrates Court, the CPS must demonstrate that there is a prima facie case to answer; if they fail then the case can be dismissed. However, this does not mean that the accused will not face further prosecution, as the CPS may obtain additional evidence from the police. In complicated cases, there may be a number of pre-trial hearings, particularly in cases listed at Crown Court. These hearings are for both sides to determine preliminary procedural matters. Allegations have been made that defense teams deliberately cause delays in these hearings, reasons given are that it affects witnesses' memories, or sustains their income. In response, the Law Society argued that '…A civilised society demands that criminal convictions should be secured beyond reasonable doubt, and that is not a game, it is a fundamental principle."(Independent: 2002). Moreover, trials may need to adjourn due to CPS waiting for forensic evidence results or other reports.During pre-trial hearings both sides are required under The Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996 to disclose previously undisclosed points known to each other. However, this act states that the CPS must only disclose information that they feel might weaken their case; thus, understandably this exclusive control raises concerns for many defence lawyers. Nonetheless, the CPS are also required to inform the defense in advance of the bad character, or criminal record, of any witness that they plan to call. When a trial begins, the CPS deliver...

Find Another Essay On Identify And Evaluate The Roles Of The Prosecution And Defense In A Criminal Trial. Identify & Discuss The Sentencing Powers, Available To A Judge In A Specific Criminal Case

The Role and Powers of Lay Magistrates in Criminal Cases

1173 words - 5 pages remaining 3% of criminal cases, these involve Early Administrative Hearings, remand hearings, bail applications, sentencing and transfer proceedings. Lay magistrates also deal with commitals, magistrates can commit a defendant charged with a triable either way offence for the sentence to the Crown Court at the end of the case having heard the defendants past record, they feel that their powers of punishment are

Lizzie Borden...Criminal Mastermind or Insanely Innocent? - And article examining the Lizzie Borden Case as a legal prosecution

1253 words - 5 pages Lizzie Borden. Miss Lizzie Borden. Angela Carter has given her defense case and produced what is rather trivial evidence to the jury. I the prosecutor will now provide the evidence which will convince the jury that Miss Borden is not mentally insane, as Carter has shown with her evidential works, but is in fact a cunning criminal who has used her social status to evade the criminal justice which I will finally bring upon her today. Let us

Sentencing Guidelines in the Criminal Justice System

3816 words - 16 pages offense along with his past criminal history, employment, ties to the community, and his charity work before sentencing him. He was then sentenced to three years of probation, alcohol treatment, community service, restitution, and a fine (Richman 2013 p. 58). The judge used two very important legal factors, past criminal history and the seriousness of the offense as well as minor factors in order to deviate from the guidelines and sentence the plumber

Identify, and evaluate the different types of property income taxes?

3206 words - 13 pages Tax is a 'charge against a citizen's person or property or activity for the support of government' ( Tax payments were established many years ago to bring balance in society. It was not to provide help for individuals or groups of people but for community as a whole. Taxes can be traced back to the Ancient Egyptian ages and have developed significantly in many ways over time. Taxes are raised by the Government to pay services and

Identify the underlying theme in a Shakespearian play you have studied. Discuss the relevance of these themes in the context to the period and why they are still relevant today

1448 words - 6 pages contextualisation, quotes and scenes from the text as well as examples from today's society will prove that the social order are still undergoing the same religious and racial issues as we once were in the context of the playwright.The merchant of Venice was written during the highly pious Elizabethan period, a time of religious controversy and due to certain prejudicial restrictions Shakespeare could not write against his own country for he would be persecuted

Regardless of the nature of the disease, 'palliative care' should be available for all dying people. Identify and briefly evaluate some arguments for and against this assertion

1860 words - 7 pages In this essay I shall firstly give a description of what palliative care is. I will discuss the modern hospice and the history of care provided in early hospices. Secondly I shall review the care that people with incurable diseases receive. In order to do this, I will gather evidence from course materials and other literature to examine the expanding hospice movement, and look at the arguments for and against the expansion of palliative care

Age as a Criminal Defense

1881 words - 8 pages this challenge.ConclusionThere is a definite need to attach a minimum age to criminal responsibility. Juvenile offenders need to be held accountable and culpable for their criminal actions. If a juvenile is committing crimes then they should be held responsible and given the proper sentencing regardless of their age. Having a minimum age, whether it is state legislated or federally legislated, would allow for the prosecution of offenders in either

Roles and Challenges in the Canadian Criminal Justice System

862 words - 4 pages , Ramcharan, Dowler, & de Lint, 2007, p. 4). When in reality, only a few people may possess those traits which are socially constructed. The book: The Canadian Criminal Justice System (2007, p.4) proves that it’s essential to have an open mind in regards to this issue. Another difficulty that the criminal justice system is trying to overcome and bring more awareness to is the needs of specific groups who have some type of regular contact within the

'Consider what you think are the key aims of a criminal trial and explain, with reasons, the extent to which you think the Crown Court or magistrates’

1689 words - 7 pages Within criminal court proceedings, there are two key aims that need to be upheld. Firstly, the trial should be fair, most importantly with respect to the consistency of judgments that are given for comparable offences; additionally, judges and juries must fully consider each case individually. Secondly, a judgment ought to come from a body that is representative of the local population; those making judgments should be without any prejudices

A) Explain how lay magistrates and district judges (magistrate's court) are selected and appointed. b) Identify and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the use of lay magistrates

2315 words - 9 pages committee, or in respect of urban areas. In this case, it is on recommendation of the advisory committee only.These committees were kept secret, until 1992, but have since been re-published so that all names are noted.The Lord Chancellor has to take into account that the panel has a wide-cross section. This means that there should be a variety of different people from different racial and social backgrounds. This is to make sure that the panel of JP's

In this essay I identify and discuss the assessment methods that I use within my training

1450 words - 6 pages CONTENTSINTRODUCTION1ASSESSMENT2PRE ASSESSMENT FORMS2ASSIGNMENTS3OBSERVATION3PRINCIPLES OF ASSESSMENT4INTERNET RESEARCH5REFLECTION6BIBLIOGRAPHY6In this essay I identify and discuss the assessment methods that I use within my training.ASSESSMENTIs finding out formally or informally how students are progressing throughout the course? Students are assessed to ensure that they have understood what they been taught and to ensure that the course was

Similar Essays

The Basic Procedures Of A Standard American Criminal Trial...Covers Everything Between Indictment And Sentencing

2633 words - 11 pages during this crucial point of the trial. The argument is often emotional and poetry or verse is sometimes used. The prosecution, however, is only likely to use one emotion: outrage at the defendant. The situation during summations is favorable to the prosecution, who, in the vast majority of instances, opens the argument. After a rebuttal by the defense, the prosecution then has an opportunity for counter-rebuttal. In any case, the prosecution is

The Selection And Role Of A Jury In A Criminal Trial

946 words - 4 pages The Selection and Role of a Jury in a Criminal Trial This assignment focuses on how a jury is selected and its role in a criminal trial. The advantages and disadvantages of using a jury to decide the outcome of a criminal case will also be considered. A Jury is chosen at random, by a computer using names on the electoral

Budgets Fulfill A Number Of Roles In The Management Of Organizations. Identify The Principal Such Roles And Comment On The Compatibility Of These Differing Roles

1035 words - 4 pages IntroductionThe main responsibility of manager is planning for the future by deciding what should be done and how it will be achieved. Budget is such a formalized system of planning, forecasting, monitoring and controlling the use of resources which help the managers to achieve organization's objectives both in public sector and private sector. Budgets fulfill a number of roles in the management of organizations and different roles may cause

The Roles Of The Main Players In A Canadian Criminal Law Case

1146 words - 5 pages . Judges must exercise their roles at three stages throughout the judicial process; the pre-trial, trial, and during sentencing. During the judicial pre-trial, it is the role of the judge to discuss matters of disclosure with both the prosecutor and defense council, to hear evidence in order to ensure there is sufficient evidence for a trial, and (if necessary) to discuss possible sentences for a guilty plea. During the trial, the role of the