Identify Two Theorists Of Consciousness Who Write From Either A 1st, 2nd Or 3rd Person Perspective, Summarize Their Positions And Choose Which One You Feel Is Most Convincing.

1608 words - 6 pages

David Chalmers and Daniel Dennett are both atheists and philosophers (1)(2). However, this is pretty much where the similarities end. David Chalmers is an Australian philosopher and self-proclaimed 'dualist' (3) who firmly believes that "the heart of the science of consciousness is trying to understand the first person perspective" (4). He rejects more materialistic views which he sees as reductionist and argues that when the third person perspective is taken we overlook the important sensations, thoughts and feelings of what it's like to be human. Daniel Dennett on the other hand insists the first person approach can not be trusted (5) and prefers to study consciousness objectively from the third person. He is an American who embraces the materialist approach and rejects dualism (6). This essay will look in more depth at each individual's position as a theorist of consciousness and attempt to understand their contrasting viewpoints.When trying to understand and explain consciousness, philosophers must realise that there is no agreed definition of what 'consciousness' actually is, which naturally creates a problem. There are those for example who would argue that self-awareness is simply an illusion (7) and because this is based entirely on one's own subjective experience it would be difficult to argue or convince them otherwise. As Susan Blackmore puts it, "no wonder philosophers and scientists have struggled for millennia with the concept" (8) The French philosopher René Descartes proposed that the body works like a machine and is constricted to the laws of physics whereas the mind is a separate 'non-material' entity (10), he believed the body and mind to be connected at the pineal gland in the brain, which he referred to as "the seat of the soul" (10). However he does not explain how the pineal gland can interact with the mind. Neither does he explain how qualia (the ineffable traits of how we see the things around us, such as how red a shirt is or how green the grass is) can work.Nikos Logothetis, a Greek biologist experimented with monkeys in the 1980's. He used 'binocular rivalry' by showing a different picture to each eye of the monkey subject and found that the monkeys were unable to press a lever to indicate which picture they were viewing (11). However, after inserting electrodes into different parts of their brains Logothetis found that the activity of the cells in the visual cortex did not change whereas the activity in the central cortex did when the monkey's experiences changed. David Chalmers therefore suggests that consciousness is generated in these areas, and he is supported by the American neuropsychologist Vilayanur S. Ramachandran who suggests that these areas of the brain are "qualia-laden" while others are not (12). Conversely, Daniel Dennett argues that there is no one area of the brain that acts as a 'central headquarters'. Instead, he says, information comes in from the senses and is distributed to different...

Find Another Essay On Identify two theorists of consciousness who write from either a 1st, 2nd or 3rd person perspective, summarize their positions and choose which one you feel is most convincing.

Two of the Strongest Emotions A person can Feel

1605 words - 6 pages Love and hate are two of the strongest emotion a person has for two seemingly very different reasons. These two emotions are classified as total opposites, but I believe that they are closer than one might expect even though they have very different connotations. Love is classified as the stereotypical eccentric and bubbly emotion with a fairly positive connotation. When you feel love, you feel like you are walking on air and you don’t

Choose what you believe to be the three (3) most convincing reasons why appeasement was the diplomatic option of choice in 1938.

1219 words - 5 pages two totalitarian evils as the Holocaust had not yet occurred. Lastly, The Treaty of Versailles imposed many restrictions on Germany's internal affairs, which were widely viewed by the Allied nations as being unfair to Germany. In this essay, the following three reasons as to why appeasement was the diplomatic option of choice in 1938 will be examined and explained in depth for a better understanding as to why appeasement was the diplomatic option

Briefly discuss the stages of the lifespan. Choose one stage and discuss the needs of a person at this stage.

1132 words - 5 pages independence.Childhood spans from two to twelve years of age approximately. In this time a child will overcome a number of developmental tasks including; learning to get along with others in their age group, developing appropriate attitudes towards themselves, achieving personal independence, and developing concepts necessary for everyday living. The development of social skills is important in this age group to aid the development of

POX marketing campaign Which of the two campaign you prefer and why. Who you think you can improve the strategy?

1046 words - 4 pages their desires. On the one hand, after realizing it's a hoax, how many target audiences will truly memorize that is a machination from a game company and will understand POX's novel characteristics? On the other hand, how many kids would truly pay attention to news?To sum up, according to the outstanding features of POX and of the main consumers, namely tweens, Hasbro should go with the traditional campaign to launch this new product.2.This toy-and

The Old Nurse's Story (E. Gaskell) and The Axe (P. Fitzgerald): Of the two stories you have read, which do you think is the most effective ghost story? Which story do you prefer and why?

2139 words - 9 pages English ghost stories became popular in 1855 when a tax reform brought about the withdrawal of duty on newspapers. This brought about a magazine boom that fed the large literate middle class who were thirsty for sensation. To satisfy their readers, magazines needed stories and promised "fiction of powerful interest". Charles Dickens owned one of the most popular periodicals of the time - All the Year Round, first published in 1859. Dickens

Identify a personal hero and articulate the influence this person has had on you

572 words - 2 pages Identify a personal hero and articulate the influence this person has had on you        I learn Spanish literature from a petite, sophisticated woman who has yet to appear in anything less that pearls, a well-cut suit and carefully scraped-back hair. Nevertheless, not one class has gone by without her eventually sitting cross-legged on her desk, eyes intent behind wire-rimmed glasses, hair slipping from her

A2 milk - Choose an FMCG brand, which you believe has a strong relationship with its consumers – and which you think is placed at the top of the brand equity pyramid.

963 words - 4 pages that is free of the A1 beta casein. Most Australian & New Zealand milk use dominantly A1 producing cows or mix of A1 & A2 cows which linked by some scientific studies to type-1 diabetes, heart disease, schizophrenia and autism, also more seemly a watered down taste due to permeate additive found in most other brands. Consequently consumers have been offered pure 100% A2 produced milk which has no risk of health issues, superior absorbed

Compare the theme of a young person growing up in two or more literary works you have studied

795 words - 3 pages thirties. You can see how the age affects the way the characters view growing up: Rob's view is that growing up is getting married, having children, and leading a happy life until one day you come home and you realise that your wife has cancer. He is afraid to settle down for fear of attaching himself too tight; he doesn't want to be shocked, he doesn't want to cry no matter who dies. Overall, growing up is seen as giving up on something. Alex loses

The Person Who Most Influenced Me

851 words - 3 pages It is easy to say that a parent has had the most influence on your life, they taught you how to walk, talk, drink and among many other things hopefully right from wrong. A good parent is there for you most of your life, quick to lend a hand or offer advice (unless it’s your mother-in-law) when needed, but the trait that impacted my life the most was the integrity my father exhibited with me and the people lucky enough to have met him. My

Choose an Industry with which You Are Familiar. Carry out a Strategic Assessment of it.

3874 words - 15 pages preferred-vendor-list (PVL) helping customers to enhance their operational efficiencies. Fairchild is also required to provide more complete product combination instead of single product recently.Cost-Oriented ManufacturersAs Porter states (cited in University of Leicester, 2009), there are two methods to avoid competitions and gain advantages: to be a cost leader or a differentiator. These years, semiconductor technologies were developed and

Discuss one disagreement or agreement between Plato and Aristotle. Who do you think is more consistent with Greek cultural tradition?

675 words - 3 pages explanation from where forms originate, the explanation of what exactly they are and what is the actual reality. According to Plato’s metaphysics and epistemology, the world consisted of two worlds: the world of becoming and the world of being- which can be referred to as world of forms. He uses an allegory of a cave where prisoners were kept and only exposed to seeing shadows. The shadows represented how people outside of the cave viewed the objects of

Similar Essays

Identify A Patient From Your Clinical Area Who Is Suffering From Cancer And His Actual And Potential Problems Choose And Elaborate On One Of These Problems

2457 words - 10 pages physicians should be carried out for these symptoms throughout the course of the disease, in order to provide adequate symptom control, which sometimes are worse than the disease itself.Case StudyMarco Spiteri is a 17 year old male who has been diagnosed with Acute Myoblastic Leukaemia one year ago. Marco was just three months from finishing four blocks of chemotherapy. He presented at Wonderland a month ago because of hyperthermia and severe

Which One Would You Choose Essay

755 words - 3 pages powers besides strength. In a dark ally being robbed, or a meteor heading toward earth, or the government (which ever kind it is) has gone whack, or any other kind of sticky situation you find yourself in, who are you going to wish was there, Superman or Beowulf. First you have to know what their qualities, strengths, weaknesses, are and what they can provide to help you. One thing that might make things difficult to choose is that they

Choose Three Contrasting Poems That You Feel Show The Difference In The Attitudes And Experiences Of Those People Who Were Part Of World War One.

1938 words - 8 pages Choose three contrasting poems that you feel show the difference in the attitudes and experiences of those people who were part of World War One. Analyse them in relation to how they demonstrate the experiences and feelings towards war at the time.The three poets that I am choosing to write about are, Wilfred Owen, Thomas Hardy, and Rupert Brooke. The reason that the three poems contrast is the tone and content of the poem. Rupert Brooke had

Compare And Contrast Parmenides' And Plato's Different Views Of Reality. Which Theory Do You Find The Most Convincing?

733 words - 3 pages theories. One can question Plato as to how his incorporeal Forms actually relate to the "real" world. What is the mechanism, so to speak? One can also ask, as does Parmenides in Plato's dialogue of the same name, how an attribute can partake of a Form without them being alike in some way, and if they are alike then surely there is another Idea of which these two partake and so on.Parmenides, by making his sphere of "being" corporeal does not render