Identity And Destruction: Asian American In The Namesake

2018 words - 8 pages

In Mira Nair’s film, The Namesake, the disparate cultures of India and America affirms to the binary paradigm of “the one” and “the other”, manifesting the dominance of one from the other and its impact to influence and cause cultural and identity issues. The collision of the two cultures forms a process of trying to construct an identity and a destruction of an ethnic identity, with different factors to consider such as space and other sociocultural codes. This film about the Indian American also shows the concept of model-minority image, standards and expectations imposed to Asian Americans. The Namesake embodies the cultural and identity issues of an Asian American, particularly the Indian Americans, exemplifying the experiences of the intersection of contrasting cultures, marginalization, generation conflicts and identity crisis.
In Heterogeneity, Hybridity, Multiplicity: Making Asian American Differences, Lowe argues that the concept of Asian American is crucial in itself because it emphasizes and intensifies the marginalization of Asian-origin community in the United States. She asserts that Asian American identity becomes “an organizing tool” to formulate Asians in America as homogenous entity, which for her is strongly refutable (511). The film adaptation of The Namesake exhibits this heterogeneity of Asian communities that Lowe argues, narrating the Asian American experience of another ethnicity in the United States—the Indians. The film shows Lowe’s argument of the multiplicity and heterogeneity of Asian American experience, away from the usual stereotyped idea of the Asian American only correspond to Chinese and Japanese Americans. Mira Nair’s The Namesake proves the multiplicity of culture in the context of Asian American, but its general experiences of identity crisis and construction, marginalization, generation and culture conflicts are the common position of heterogeneous communities.
Nair’s film shows the position of Asian American as marginalized, “the other” in a binary paradigm which Americans as “the one”. The American culture as the hegemony is exhibited in the film, how it is the standard for Indians as a better way of living and their perceived idea of its dominance. In first few scenes of the film, the man who befriended Ashoke Ganguli in the train said words that marked in Ashoke’s mind after the dreadful accident. The man asked Ashoke if he ever had the chance to see the world, referring to England and America. He also mentioned his travel in England and pertained to it as dreamlike experience, away from the unclean landscape of India. Then, he advised Ashoke that he must go out of Indian and conquer the world while he’s still young. After his survival from the accident, Ashoke went to America, following the man’s advice. The scene in the train affirms to the binary schema between Indians and Americans, their perception of higher value of “the one” over “the other”.
As Ashoke settled in the United States with his new...

Find Another Essay On Identity and Destruction: Asian American in The Namesake

Asian and American Culture in an American Society

821 words - 4 pages The United States of America is a ‘melting pot’ of diverse cultures. Though primarily Western in nature, due to the large-scale immigration of variant ethnicities from other countries, as well as differing birth and death rates of natives, settlers and immigrants, the ‘white’ American culture has taken on the hues of a rainbow. Within this society, the Asian-Americans, are often perceived to be at the highest stratum due to high income and good

The Overcoat and The Namesake Comparison

765 words - 3 pages In the novel The Namesake by Jhumpa Lahiri mentions a short story named “The Overcoat” written by Nikolai Gogol numerous times. This “mentioning” is also known as an “allusion.” The Namesake is about the Ganguli family and their transformation to an American family. Gogol Ganguli is the character that is closely related to “The Overcoat” which is about the life and also the death of a man by the name Akakiy Akakievitch. Besides the fact that

The Asian American Dream

855 words - 4 pages Did you know that the Asian American race has the highest minority rate worldwide? Asian Americans take up only 5.8 percent of the United States population. They have had a hard time here in the United States trying to achieve and live the “American Dream” but they have had many things get in the way of that. Things that get in their way are factors like Worldwide discrimination. No matter where they go, they get discriminated from things just

Immigrants in The Namesake by Jhumpa Lahiri

1493 words - 6 pages still can’t truly find his identity. This was a milestone in his life, changing his name to try and fit in but it still didn’t work out for Gogol. This develops the theme of identity, having both names to try and find his identity, to find where he belongs. It also reveals his character, his ignorance towards the namesake of his birth name. In conclusion, symbols in The Namesake reveal that symbolism is the most important literary device since it

Conformity in The Lottery, The Ones Who Walked Away from Omelas and The Namesake

1146 words - 5 pages going against their society is considered heroic. However, in The Namesake, Ashima negotiates her beliefs to conform to American society. Even though her actions could be seen as cowardly, being that she has consciously moved to a new country, she must adjust to the new way of living. As humans, we are challenged daily with our understanding of the world and what is considered morally right and wrong. It is up to the individual to decide to conform

The Cultural Identity Within Asian Writing Systems

3052 words - 12 pages Latin letters to represent sounds called pinyin, but this system is hardly used in writing at all. The Japanese and Korean languages had borrowed the Chinese characters from China, so it was almost as if their cultural identity was lost within another culture. This fact was one of the factors that catalyzed the Japanese and Koreans to modify their writing systems. Today, if someone with even the minimal knowledge of one of the three Asian

The Quest for Identity in American Literature

2294 words - 9 pages The Quest for Identity in American LiteratureThe quest for identity depends a lot on the emotional, cultural and social stability of an individual. Stability is the ultimate stage of this quest, this is why I believe there is a strong interdependence between the two. One cannot speak of identity without referring to emotional, social and cultural stability. Apart from these three dimensions of the human being, another important aspect of the

The Extent of American Unity and Identity

1967 words - 8 pages The Extent of American Unity and Identity Since early colonization the English colonies had always felt closer to England than to each other. In fact, it took a British newspaper less time to reach Savannah than a letter from Massachusetts. However, after the French and Indian War a sense of unity began to permeate through the colonies as a result of British acts. For every British action there was an American reaction

An Almost Perfect Match in The Namesake by Jhumpa Latiri

814 words - 4 pages As far as relationships go, people believe there is an ideal match somewhere out there in the world that was made for them. Most of the time this conspiracy becomes a reality, but only for few. In the story The Namesake by Jhumpa Lahiri, the main character, Nikhil and his ex-fiancé, Moushumi seemed as if they were the kind of couple that would have lasted forever. Unfortunately as we continue to read through the story, we realized that they

Compare and Contrast the Way in which Emerson and Thoreau Represents American Identity

1524 words - 6 pages cultures. Although America became an independent nation, European culture was still playing its role. Therefore, American writers namely Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau presented an idea about American Identity. Emerson in The American Scholar and Thoreau in Walden represents the idea of American identity by connecting this concept with nature and individuality but Emerson presents his idea about American identity in an intelligent

compare and contrast the way in which Emerson and Thoreau represent American identity?

955 words - 4 pages , The comparison between Emerson and Thoreau represent American Identity and both of them are consider as best writers during that time because through their books people gets inspired they tried to talk about self reliance, individualism where it connects with the similarities and differences between Emerson and Thoreau which makes people to believe and hope for better in their piece of writing and shows Americans identity In Emerson essays it

Similar Essays

The Components Of Identity In The Namesake By Lahiri

1865 words - 7 pages All around the world people struggle with a sense of self-individualization, which is the internal battle each person has to face in order to discover ones true identity. The quest to find oneself is a difficult and lengthy endevor that can take a lifetime to accomplish. Some if not most people never reach a point where they can truly face who they truly are. In the Novel The Namesake by Lahiri In The Namesake, identity is illustrated by

Gogol's True Identity In The Namesake By Jhumpa Lahiri

836 words - 4 pages Sometimes religion can be a necessity for comfort. Over time, we may already possess our very own identities and then develop different ones after a tragedy. In order to easily move on from a plight, some sort of comfort or security is needed, whether its time, family, friends, a sport, or religion. In the novel, The Namesake by Jhumpa Lahiri, one can clearly see the viewpoint of how Gogol’s life over time has evolved from American to Bengali

Asian American Identity Essay

1566 words - 6 pages Silence as Beauty, Silence as Self: The Asian American Identity The label “American” encompasses many different cultures and races. However, American society is often guilty of assuming there is only one true, certainly white, “American” face, voice, and behavior. Associate Professor of Sociology, Minako Maykovich, states that “the criteria for physical characteristics are generally determined by the dominant group in society,” thus

Identity In The American Revolution Essay

1210 words - 5 pages Essay Question: What factors contributed to the formation of a distinctive sense of identity that was expressed by a significant individual or group in the American revolution?What were the characteristics of this identity, and what actions did this significant individual or group take to express their identity?A distinct patriotic American identity was formed during the American Revolution. A few vital factors were instrumental in forming this