Identity Of Indian Emigrants Essay

1499 words - 6 pages

Identity of Indian EmigrantsHugh Tinker's The Banyan Tree is an intensely researched study of the enormous complexities behind the emigration of the citizens of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh. It is a survey of the Indian communities in foreign countries, in a broader scope, mainly relying on the author's knowledge of the Indian diaspora, supported by secondary sources for data. Tinker describes two distinct impressions about the status of Indian emigrants. One is that of exploiters who create Indian colonies in the land where they settle, and the other is of victims of circumstances who need to accept the dominance of the host country. The book evaluates themes like second-class citizenship, minorities, social and economic integration of Indian emigrants in various countries. This essay will investigate the notion of identity and how it defines Indian emigrants and their future generations on foreign soil.Banyan tree, which is the national tree of India, starts its life as an epiphyte (a plant that grows on another plant) when its seeds grow in the cracks of a host tree (and sometimes on structures like buildings). In his book, Tinker uses banyan tree as a metaphor for the Indians who emigrate from their motherland to form new societies abroad. Tinker quotes Rabindranath Tagore's excerpt about banyan trees where he says, "The civilization of India, like the banyan tree, has shed its beneficent shade away from its own birthplace.. India can live and grow by spreading abroad." This quote is a good summary of the theme Tinker uses to portray his arguments in the book. By grouping Indians by communities, Tinker provides a detailed analysis of the composition of the soil where the banyan tree grows, and recognizes each seed, nutrient, mineral, and most importantly, each source of blight of the Indian emigration. [1: Tinker. Pg I]When structuring the chapters of the book, Indians of Srilanka and South Africa are grouped together in one chapter as they are permanent second-class citizens of the respective countries. One of the chapters focuses on the community of sugarcane workers in Fiji, Mauritius, Trinidad and Guyana. The Indians in Malaysia, Kenya and Tanzania come together in another chapter because of their economic power and political influence in the host countries. In this way, Tinker characterizes the Indian communities with a world-wide perspective among different chapters. On the other hand, different scholars, like P. K. Balachandran, criticize the structuring of the book. When looking through the lens of a critic, it is evident that for a reader who is unfamiliar with the subject, the book would seem like a journal of information that lacks a coherent argument. To make the book an easier and a more rewarding read, Tinker could have divided the chapters by first presenting country-wise data, followed by analytical chapters.Tinker says, "The banyan tree has thrust down roots in soil which is stony, sandy, marshy,…its similarity to...

Find Another Essay On Identity of Indian Emigrants

The Reasons Behind Puerto Rican Migration to America

2570 words - 10 pages improve the Puerto Rican situation and community in New York City". When arriving to New York, Vega found all different types of ethnic groups. They were Italians, French, Jews, Cubans, Greeks, etc... All of these groups were all considered as emigrants therefore Vega felt that he could identity with them. These different ethnic groups along with the tabaqueros all formed part of the Socialist group. This became known as Class politics

Migration from the Nation-State of Singapore

573 words - 2 pages citizenship and national identity. This has also raised an old issue of why Singaporeans are leaving Singapore for ‘greener pastures’ overseas (Straits Times, 21 August 2002). Most often, the ones who left are deemed as talents who could have contributed to Singapore if they had not ‘quitted’ Singapore (National Day Rally, 2002). This is widely known as a ‘brain drain’, a problem that most migrant-sending countries in Asia currently face. In Singapore

Love through life and death

2260 words - 9 pages For Time Magazine, by Stephen Lowe You’ve probably heard of the Indian vs. emigrants shootings, the drowning of the Applegate family, and starvation on the Oregon Trail, but do you honestly know to what extent how hard the journey was for the emigrants to make this 2,000 mile journey (McGill; Wagner, 10-15, 109-110; Life and Death on the Oregon Trail). The emigrants had to go through endless hardship, varying from walking the entire journey

Interpreting Maladies: The Necessity of Being Rooted and Being the Root

2394 words - 10 pages accounts for the desperate attempts of the Indian emigrants to hold on to their traditional values, culture and most importantly, their family which ensure them that, in a far distant place, there is a “home” and “homeland” awaiting to accept and guard their sentiments. In her debut work of fiction Interpreter of Maladies, which won the Pulitzer Prize in 2000, Jhumpa Lahiri , the U.K born, Rhode Island raised Indian, vividly captures the

Asian Diaspora by Rumaisa

9452 words - 38 pages the people of Indian origin are numerically significant, the question of their image and identity has been critical. In the colonial phase, the British stereotyped Indian emigrants as "coolies." Even when the upwardly mobile Indians became professionals, the prefix "coolie" was always attached to their professional designation: In South Africa M.K.Gandhi was often called "the Coolie Lawyer." Similarly, the traders of the East African coastline

The Cheyenne Tribe Being Expelled From Their Lands

716 words - 3 pages America was to flourish economically that they needed to encourage the settlement of the west. The west promised vast resources, in lumber, gold and farmland. As people began migrating west they began to encroach on Indian country. As the Indians were pushed from their land and the emigrants depleted their resources, many tribes began to rebel and resort to violence. The Cheyenne is a Great Plains tribe that settled in Minnesota and then

The Superiority Complex

631 words - 3 pages success among different countries. This article turned out to be very helpful in understanding the hardships faced by immigrants in New York City and America at large. Though Mehta is Indian and a victim of discrimination, the article is quite unbiased and clear in presenting the stories of the immigrants. The article clearly makes a connection between the historical America and the modern America by pointing out how racism has not been

Colonial Jamestown

1165 words - 5 pages and part of the Canadian province of Ontario.” (Gale group) At first, the men believed they had found paradise. The climate appeared mild, and the natives had reacted friendly. John Smith wrote, “Heaven and earth never agreed better to frame a place for man’s habitations.” (Colonial History) Then, the beautiful new world turned to blistering heat, swarms of insects, unfit water, starvation, fierce winters, Indian attacks, and shiploads of

Building international relationships for a better economy

1877 words - 8 pages is revolved around Chinese and Indian emigrants, I can still use this source as a way of demonstrating the benefits of immigration. By showing the benefits, I’ll be able to create a better argument of why the United States should accept emigrants because hopefully emigrants won’t be seen as a threat but rather partners. Therefore, establishing a greater sense of community. However, communities need to be prepared for immigration in order to

Canada's Identity

1292 words - 5 pages Head Tax” law was passed in order to filter the overwhelming number of Chinese immigrants into Canada (1). Chinese immigrants were required to pay a fee in order to come into the country. The amount, person, rose from fifty dollars in 1885, to an astounding five-hundred dollars in 1904. Ten years later, another unjust act was expressed, this time focusing on Indian immigrants. All 376 emigrants possessed valid British passports, yet were still

THE TRAIL OF TEARS

1880 words - 8 pages that this place of death was where his beloved people were being taken after years of persecution and injustice at the hands of white Americans, the proud Indian people were being forced to vacate their lands, leaving behind their homes, businesses and almost everything they owned while traveling to an unknown place and an uncertain future. The Cherokee Indians suffered terrible indignities, sickness and death while being removed to the Indian

Similar Essays

Emigrants Of The Russian Empire: Integrity And Identity

690 words - 3 pages TThe October Revolution of 1917 has forced the first wave of emigrants to leave Russian Empire. Russian history knows several such waves during its different periods: World War II, time of Great Repression, Cold War and Iron Curtain. The last wave of the emigrants fell within the time known by some as "Putin decade exodus", a roller coaster of economical insecurity in Russian Federation. Students, workers, intellectuals and aristocrats headed

Gandhian Politics: The Role Of Khadi In Shaping Indian National Identity

3040 words - 12 pages “Swadeshi was the soul of Swaraj and Khadi was the essence of Swadeshi.” Gandhi’s favorite obsession, khadi, played a key role in the fostering of an Indian national identity. As such, the study of khadi is integral in understanding Gandhian politics and Indian nationalism from the years 1919- 1947. However, the symbolic manifestations represented by khadi and put forth by Gandhi are not without their critics. Many historians

The Partition Of Indian Subcontinent: Crisis Of Identity And Uprooted Nationalities Resulting In Double Disaster For Pakistan

2127 words - 9 pages culture, language, music, all sorts of things. So that this is a case where the Geo-political reality is sought to be transcended by an emphasis on a narrower identity. Students in Pakistan are taught Arabic at an early age and indoctrinated to despise everything Indian. Unlike entire world they even do not respect Mahatma Gandhi, who was gunned down by a Hindu for he was blindly favouring Muslims. Chaudhari Muhammad Ali, Prime Minister of Pakistan

Desh And Videsh: Be/Longingness In Bharati Mukherjee's Jasmine

1556 words - 7 pages context, Kingsley Davis (1968) remarks, "...pressure to emigrate has always been great enough to provide a stream of emigrants much larger than the actual given opportunities." And Tinker puts it, " there is a combination of push and pull: the push of inadequate opportunity in South Asia and the pull of the better prospects in the West."(1977:10) Indian history provides umpteen examples of mobility of people that undoubtedly was motivated by