Should The Harris Superquarry Ga Ahead?

2069 words - 8 pages

Not bad A Thourough and thoughtful piece of workRural Economic DevelopmentSHOULD THE HARRIS SUPERQUARRYGO AHEAD ?Kenneth MercerBSc Rural Resources III16th December 1994CONTENTSTABLE OF FIGURES I1 SUMMARY 12 INTRODUCTION 1FIGURE 1 LOCATION OF THE SUPERQUARRY 23 THE ISSUES SURROUNDING THE DEBATE 33.1 History 33.2 The reasons for the selection of Lingerbay 43.3 The need for economic development 43.4 Other incentives 53.5 The environmental concerns 53.6 Making the quarry more palatable 64 CONCLUSIONS 64.1 The case for development 64.2 The case against development 64.3 The probable outcome 64.4 A suitable compromise 6REFERENCES 7TABLE OF FIGURESFIGURE 1 LOCATION OF THE SUPERQUARRY 311 SUMMARYThere is considerable environmental opposition to the development of the Harrissuperquarry. This is unlikely to stop the development on its own, but if the ScottishOffice decides that the project can go ahead environmental restrictions are likely to beimposed on the operation to minimise, as far as possible, the impact. The reasons for thedevelopment centre round the need for economic development to bring jobs andprosperity to this remote area. The life of the quarry is expected to be around 60 yearsand provide an initial 30 jobs, rising to 80 as the quarry reaches peak production. Thequestion is if a superquarry is the best solution to the problems of a remote rural area.What will happen when the jobs come to an end and would another form of investmentnot be more appropriate to their needs? Would the presence of a quarry restrict thechoice for further development? Could an integrated approach be adopted and a 2ndgeneration quarry planned? The decision of whether or not to go ahead cannot bedelayed indefinitely as Norway and Spain are looking at developing their own. If it is togo ahead then an early start will give Harris a stronger position in the market.2 INTRODUCTIONThis report examines the controversy and key issues surrounding the superquarry atRodel, Lingerbay on the southern coast of the Isle of Harris (Figure 1) and attempts tofind an acceptable solution. The quarry will hollow out the heart of the mountain butleave enough of a shell to leave the skyline largely unaffected. The whole question ofwhether or not it should go ahead or not is the subject of the current public enquiry inStornaway. A decision must be made soon. The market for aggregates is limited,Norway and Spain (Section 3.1, 1991) have their own sites and are also looking at thepotential for developing them.FIGURE 1 LOCATION OF THE SUPERQUARRY(Glasgow Herald, 20/10/94)3 THE ISSUES SURROUNDING THE DEBATE3.1 History1927 A detailed geological survey identified the deposit of anorthosite.1965 Planning permission was given in principle to quarry the rock. The remitcovered a larger site than is planned today.1966 Some small scale quarrying took place but found an on site rock crushingplant and a deep harbour were necessary for economic viability.74-76 Outline planning permission was given for...

Find Another Essay On Should the Harris Superquarry ga ahead?

Sam Harris: The End of Faith

841 words - 3 pages As a result of our global society being manipulated by ancient doctrines Sam Harris argues in The End of Faith: Religion, Terror and the Future of Reason the ultimate thesis: religion is the basis for all of human conflict. Because faith bypasses all evidence, Harris feels “we are building a civilization of ignorance” and another direction should be taken lest we desire to meet our doom. It is incredible the amount of detail Harris delves into

Leadership and Event Planning Essay

2200 words - 9 pages every planner is familiar with” (Harris, 2005). While this being the case for some event planners, a smart approach would be to borrow equipment and supplies, make decorations, and ask for donations or sponsors, by allowing them free advertising at the special event; this creates a win-win approach for both parties. Last, event planners should be able to build a budget proposal based on research by estimating costs of each event. “Include, facilities


1012 words - 4 pages acts (pg 277). But he is also capable of accepting punishment for wrong deeds. The story also implies that wrong deeds should be punished regardless of the time and society one lives in. When Hercules grew to manhood, he married and had six sons, and again fell victim to Hera's hatred towards him. As Harris explains, Hera sent a fit of madness upon Hercules who mistook his wife and children for enemies and killed them (pg 278). When his sanity

The Life-Span Developmental Approach to Counseling

982 words - 4 pages affect on the development of their children. The life-span perspective should probably make room for familial environment: family of origin and family of choice. Assuming Harris is correct, a life-span approach to counseling will allow that children and spouses do influence an adult’s development. Environmental factors on a micro level feature the nuclear family; macro-level factors can include social mores, regional cultural norms, and even national

Asthma Case Study

1960 words - 8 pages risk of impaired skin integrity for Mrs. Harris as it provides a barrier to infection. The skin has to be kept clean and free of any faces and urine, and skin protection products, which can be cream, wipe or liquid, can be used to keep Mrs. Harris skin moisture ( Phillips 2012, pp.1021-1023). Mrs. Harris has an operation wound and it should be managed properly in order to decrease the risk of pressure ulcer because wounds can impaired the skin

Negotiations Strategy Article Analysis

1038 words - 4 pages , Negotiation Strategy: Planning is Critical puts enormous emphasis on the essential aspect of planning ahead before going into a negotiation situation. Cathy Cronin-Harris refers to five strategies with which a negotiator should remember. Those strategies are as follows:1.Decide on priority interests and plan them2.Assess the other side’s priorities3.Money represents other needs4.Plan factual inquiries carefully5.Plan money moves based on objective

The Fall of Slavery

834 words - 4 pages an old man expressing that God should be thanked for the end of slavery and that all celebrations should be directed towards him. The song the old man sings provides insight into John Harris’ personal beliefs of spirituality and freedom, how they should be obtainable. John Harris uses the song in “The Fall of Slavery” to focus readers’ attention onto his principles of freedom and happiness. The poem begins with the narrator, presumably John

The Debate Over Standardized Testing

1307 words - 5 pages on this subject appeared in At Issue (2012), a book which was published by Greenhaven Press. In “Standardized Tests Effectively Measure Student Achievement,” an article within this book, Herbert Walberg, who has taught at Harvard University as well as the University of Illinois at Chicago for a total of thirty-five years, argues that standardized tests adequately measure student achievement. In contrast, Phillip Harris, Bruce Smith, and Joan

Looking to the Past

738 words - 3 pages their life. In two of Cather’s short-stories, “Neighbour Rosicky” and “Old Mrs. Harris”, the characters, Mr. Rosicky and Mrs. Harris, have a great deal of wisdom to share with younger generations, but they are often overlooked, misunderstood, or ignored by those they wish to help. In the short-story “Neighbour Rosicky,” Mr. Rosicky was a simple, hardworking man who had lived through many difficulties and seeks to share the things he has learned

organisation and behaviour

3434 words - 14 pages MICHAEL KWAMISTU26482 MODULE 3 ORGANISATION AND BEHAVIOURNAME: MICHAEL KWAMISTUDENT NUMBER: STU 26482MODULE TITLE: ORGANISATION AND BEHAVIOURDATE OF COMPLETION: 13 FEB 2012INTRODUCTIONMy choice organization for this report is the Ghana Army (GA) which is my current employer. The Ghana Army (GA) is part of the Ghana Armed Forces (GAF) tasked with the role of maintaining the territorial sovereignty of Ghana as well as internal security.Tarmac

Religion vs. Morality

2552 words - 10 pages where Harris’ true ignorance shines. This new groups of “Christians”, should not even be considered Christians at all. A simple definition of Christian is one who follows Christ wholly, trying their best to live in the image of their savior, therefore with this new definition, it is difficult to see where these so called “Christians” would fit in to the same genre of Christ. Anyone would has read the New Testament would clearly see past the

Similar Essays

The Effect Of Gibberellic Acid On A Plant's Growth

633 words - 3 pages accurate, and that could effect the average result. It is also very hard to precisely measure the plant, because of the small height of the plant. To avoid such a mistake in a future, the plants should be measured and re-measured with assistance of the lab partner. In conclusion, the plants treated with GA increase the elongation of stem; this experiment did not clearly demonstrate that relationship.Reference: Gibberellic acid. Wilipedia, 2006.Purves

Mitoxantrone And Glatiramer Acetate Essay

1040 words - 5 pages There are a few disease-modifying agents demonstrated to treat MS, two of which are MX and Glatiramer Acetate (GA), which is also known in the market as Copaxone . In general, disease-modifying agents reduce the aggravation of the disease, lessen the number of new lesions detected on MRI scanning, and some of them might slow the progression of the disease. Aside from that MX and GA are nearly different in every other. While MX is an

The Effects Of Hormones On Plant Growth

1894 words - 8 pages compare them with the heights in one week's time.         A distinct difference in size between the growth of the "control" dwarf pea plants and the "experimental" dwarfs is expected. The dwarfs lack the gene that produces a sufficient amount of growth hormone, thus resulting in their miniature size. Therefore the addition of the hormone GA should trigger immediate growth in the plants. If the lack of a growth hormone is the only thing

Research Essay

1848 words - 8 pages operations impose and reasons why there should be stronger security measures implemented by the government to help mitigate these risks. General Aviation encompasses about 54 % of all civil aviation within the United States.5 There are a variety of different aircraft types, but also may different reasons for each aircraft to be flying. The number of registered GA aircraft in the U.S. is around 220,000, which has a very significant impact (Elias, 2010