This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Imitation; Truthful Or Deceptive? The Concept Of Art To Plato And Aristotle

1810 words - 7 pages

As literary critics, Plato and Aristotle disagree profoundly about the value of art in human society. Plato attempts to strip artists of the power and prominence they enjoy in his society, while Aristotle tries to develop a method of inquiry to determine the merits of an individual work of art. It is interesting to note that these two disparate notions of art are based upon the same fundamental assumption: that art is a form of mimesis, of imitation. Both philosophers are concerned with the artist?s ability to have significant impact on others. It is the imitative function of art which promotes disdain in Plato and curiosity in Aristotle. Examining distinctions between the two arguments by their different conceptions of the reality that art professes to imitate, the process of imitation, and the inherent strengths and weaknesses of imitation as a form of artistic expression may lead to understanding how these conflicting views of art could develop from a seemingly similar premise.Both philosophers hold radically different notions of reality. The assumptions each man makes about truth, knowledge, and goodness directly affect their specific ideas about art. For Plato, art imitates a world that is already far removed from authentic reality, from Truth. Truth exists only in intellectual abstraction, that is, paradoxically, more real than concrete objects. The universal essence, the Form of a thing, is more real and thus more important than its physical substance. The physical world, the world of appearances experienced through the senses, does not harbor reality. This tangible world is an imperfect reflection of the universal world of Forms. Human observations based on these reflections are, therefore, highly suspect. At best, the tangible fruit of any human labor is "an indistinct expression of truth" (Republic X, 22). Because knowledge of truth and knowledge of good are virtually inseparable to Plato, he counsels rejection of the physical in favor of embracing reason in an abstract, intellectual, and ultimately more human, existence. Art is removed from any notion of real truth, an inherently flawed copy of an already imperfect world. Art as an imitation is irrelevant to what is real.Aristotle approaches reality from a completely different premise. While his ideas do stand in sharp contrast to Plato's, they are not simply a refutation of his former mentor's views. To Aristotle, the world exists in an infinitely diverse series of parts. These various parts are open to human observation and scrutiny. Rather than an eternally regressing truth beyond the scope of human apprehension, knowledge of truth and good are rooted firmly in the observable universe; truth, or at least gestures toward it, lies in existence rather than essence. Aristotle encourages embracing the particular in order to possibly gain a sense of the universal. There is, however, no universal system of inquiry to investigate each part of the whole. Different parts require different...

Find Another Essay On Imitation; Truthful or Deceptive? The concept of art to Plato and Aristotle

Examining the Ethics of Plato and Aristotle

1051 words - 4 pages how I perceive the theories of Plato and Aristotle. In my view, the better solution to the problem of the ‘good life’ is Aristotle’s belief rather than Plato’s belief of the good life. Firstly, Plato’s argument about the ‘good life’ is flawed under a few conditions. The first condition I will analyse is whether his inference ‘if a person can discover what is right and knows what the good life is, he or she will not act immorally’ is justified

The Soul According to Plato, Aristotle, and Augustine

1187 words - 5 pages taken away from us, this very thing is truth. So in short, for the soul to be happy, it must desire and obtain or attain truth. This truth Augustine recognizes as being God. Like Aristotle, Augustine believes that the soul is a unitary being, but like Plato, he also distinguishes it from the body and accepts its immateriality. The thing that stands in the way of happiness-which is of the soul, is when the soul does not rule the body. It is also

Plato and Aristotle: Their Contributions to the Development of Western Philosophy

604 words - 2 pages The philosophies of Plato and Aristotle and their contributions to the development of western philosophy. Plato was a classical Greek philosopher and one of the top 5 contributors to Western philosophy, educator after his mentor, Socrates and teacher of Aristotle. His sophistication as a writer started while under the tutelage of Socrates, continued through his establishing of his own academy, (The Academy of Athens which has been labeled as

My notes to review for final. The brief overview of Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, and Epicurus

847 words - 3 pages or false because it is 2) based on appearances - may change; 3) rely on things that are many and changing. Good is like a sun: 1) allows sight; 2) creator & sustainer of life in visible world; 3) purpose to life. Soul exists in particular part of our body 2. Aristotle A. believes that happiness is the end and "most people say that happiness includes pleasure that may be good or bad. So, if pleasures are bad then they can not be our goal


1803 words - 7 pages . Both Plato and Aristotle believed that the rule of the poor or the democratic system would bring chaos and violence. Such a system would be solely based on commercial association and would not be bound by moral or ethical rules. Aristotle and Plato promote the concept of an ideal state in their theories. Of course, Aristotle’s ideal state is more pedestrian and pales in comparison to Plato’s concept of the ideal state. Both Plato and Aristotle

Arguments of Plato in The Republic and Aristotle in Poetics

1195 words - 5 pages What does imitation (mimesis) involve for Plato and Aristotle? Explain its different features. Mimesis, the ‘imitative representation of the real world in art and literature’ , is a form that was particularly evident within the governance of art in Ancient Greece. Although its exact interpretation does vary, it is most commonly used to describe artistic creation as a whole. The value and need for mimesis has been argued by a number of

The Views Of Reality Of Plato and Aristotle

1015 words - 4 pages The Views of Reality of Aristotle and PlatoIntroductionThe purpose of this essay is to compare and contrast the views of reality of both Aristotle and Plato. Plato and Aristotle, two of some of the greatest philosophers of Ancient Greece, were connected in studies. Plato was taught by Socrates, then Aristotle studied at Plato's Academy. Plato was the first of the two to study, and Aristotle then studied there. And, upon learning this, one would

A Comparison of Plato and Aristotle

1892 words - 8 pages concept of what politics and government should be is a direct result of his belief in the theory of forms. The theory of forms basically states that there is a higher 'form' for everything that exists in the world. Each material thing is simply a representation of the real thing which is the form. According to Plato, most people cannot see the forms, they only see their representation or their shadows, as in the simile of the cave. Only those who love

Historical Views of Leadership: Plato and Aristotle

1780 words - 7 pages leisure, things useful and necessary for the sake of things honourable” (as cited in Wren, 1995, p. 66). For Aristotle leisure is not a form of relaxation or rest, but is an activity of learning, activity, and engagement with how one ought to live (Edel, 1967, p. 166). All things considered, there are many similarities in how Plato and Aristotle approach leadership. Perhaps the biggest difference between them though – in this particular

The Beliefs of Plato vs Aristotle

3784 words - 15 pages consequences, little as Aristotle cared to trouble himself with these, to the same exaltation of the universal over the particular which we find in Plato. For if it is once conceded that the essence of the individual lies in the species, the most essential part of the species must again lie on a still higher plane, or, in other words, the ground of the species must lie in the genus, and so on." (I, 88.) Thus, as one of Aristotle's translators has

Arroyo Administration: The Plato and Aristotle Views

2842 words - 11 pages eventually be changed. Another condition Plato said is that, a parent with a gold stone can have a child with an iron stone, meaning the child does not necessarily inherits the stone that his parents possess. This can be seen in or society today. Poor people may give birth to a future president of a country. Similarly, rich parents could have a child that is destined to become poor.Since I am to discuss the Arroyo administration using Aristotle and

Similar Essays

Comparing Plato And Aristotle On Government And The Concept Of Good

1645 words - 7 pages concept of knowing the good, but instead advocates doing good. In Aristotle's city, people should do the best they can at their craft so they can flourish and be good. This concept carries over to the politics of the city, as political scientists should do good by making just laws that allow the citizens to do good through just habituation. Because Plato is primarily concerned with knowing the good, while Aristotle is primarily concerned with being

The Perspective Of Plato And Aristotle On The Value Of Art

1389 words - 6 pages same fundamental assumption: that art is a form of mimesis, imitation. Both philosophers are concerned with the artist's ability to have significant impact on others. It is the imitative function of art which promotes disdain in Plato and curiosity in Aristotle. Examining the reality that art professes to imitate, the process of imitation, and the inherent strengths and weaknesses of imitation as a form of artistic expression may lead to

Plato Vs. Aristotle On Art Essay

1979 words - 8 pages during 420-348 B.C. in Athens, and Aristotle, Plato’s student who argued against his beliefs, have no exceptions to the steps they had to take in order to understand the purpose of art and artists. Though these two philosophers made marvelous discoveries about the existence of art, artists, and aesthetic experience, Plato has made his works more controversial than Aristotle. During the ancient times in Greece, Plato was the first human to document

Plato & Aristotle Differences In Art

629 words - 3 pages term, Art. Today, as we study the philosophical ideas of how and why things are, as they seem, we are reminded of the ideas and believes of both Plato and his mentee Aristotle. What they have had deem as art and its representation are of so much value though the differences are subjected to its matter. However amongst all these, it came from the same agreement in its form of mimesis, in other words, imitation. Art today has been classified as a