Immigrants Are Americans Too Essay

1527 words - 6 pages

The 1996 welfare reform, also known as the Personal Responsibility Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act (PRWORA), was enacted to increase the efficiency of the welfare system but its discriminatory nature has resulted in economic hardship, lack of funds to receive food, and poorer health among new immigrants to the United States.
One of the main provisions of the PRWORA was that it repealed Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) and replaced it with Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF).Before the enactment of TANF and the appeal of the AFDC, legal immigrants were eligible for the assistance under the same guidelines as citizens. This changed after the welfare reform; the PRWORA and TANF made it more difficult for immigrants to receive any form of social assistance by disallowing them to apply until they have been in the United States for 5 years. This was done to increase the effectiveness of welfare programs and prevent welfare dependency which was at its highest peak when the PRWORA was passed. While this regulation may seem just to some, it has led to economic hardships among immigrants.
PRWORA prevents immigrants from participating in welfare-to-work programs, such as CalWORKs, which helps unemployed adults obtain jobs by offering vocational training and adult education. When immigrants enter the United States, they often lack an extensive work history and a good education. Therefore, they tend to have low wage jobs, making them sensitive to the economy as the low earning jobs are the first affected by a receding or booming economy (Kalil and Ziol-Guest 13). Hence, new immigrants to the United States could largely benefit from CalWorks because they would be provided training which would allow them to seek jobs with a higher payroll. But, as stated previously, PRWORA restricts immigrants’ access to this program which in turn forces immigrants to keep their low salary jobs as their only means for survival. Consequently, this leads them to facing economic hardships during difficult times due to their limited income.
Since Ronald Regan’s presidency, funding for welfare programs has been cut significantly due to the government’s and public’s desire to reduce dependency on the federal government. According to Sharon Parrott, former Director of the Welfare Reform and Income Support Division, and Arloc Sherman, Senior Researcher at the Center Budget and Policy Priorities, in their article “TANF’s Results are More Mixed than is Often Understood”, The Food Stamp Program experienced $28 dollars in cuts (3). Also, the block grant given to states through TANF has not been adjusted to today’s economy. Therefore, it has lost 22% of its value due to inflation (Parrot and Sherman 7). This means that the money immigrants do receive is worth less than before due to the declining economy. Combined with the typical lower earnings of immigrants, this has led to the prevalence of a condition known as food insecurity where one’s access to food is...

Find Another Essay On Immigrants Are Americans Too

United States Immigrants Essay

1013 words - 5 pages “American” citizens are; as loyal Americans. Most people in the United States look at immigrants and think they're bad people, immigrants should be able to live here and not be judged badly, immigrants who cross have reasons for crossing whether it’s legal or illegal crossings, immigrants and their families are affected and the economy isn't affected badly by them. Immigrants from different parts of the world come into the U.S, legally and illegally

Illegal Immigration in the United States

930 words - 4 pages . Those with the issues are concerned about illegal immigrants taking Americans jobs and not paying taxes. Those without the issue are mostly business owners who hire them because most immigrants will work for a low wage and owners also do not have to claim them on their taxes. Therefore the American government must control the flow of illegal immigrants in to America by bettering some laws such as punishing employers, raising the number of visas and

Immigrants Should Be Forced to Learn and Speak English

2580 words - 10 pages . Poisl goes on to say, “Most Americans do not realize how difficult it is to learn a language as an adult and do not have much compassion for immigrants who have heavy accents or are too shy to try out their few English words and learn more” (2006). Forcing immigrants to learn and be proficient enough in English in order to complete the paperwork required for citizenship would prevent many from becoming United States citizens (Digh, 1998


1138 words - 5 pages of the U.S. some are superior people and complete everything well. “With a growing economy and more jobs than our own population can readily absorb, the U.S. will continue to need immigrants” (Chavez, 50). There are too many jobs for Americans only to work. Americans need help with all those jobs and immigrants come to make a living help out. The process continues as is. If immigrants are kept out of the U.S., then everything that has been kept


671 words - 3 pages . Realistically, if these jobs were not offered to the illegal immigrants, they would not pay at minimum wage, but since it’s illegal immigrants that are working the shifts, then obviously they would take any job at any offer because they need it badly. But if United States government took back all those illegal immigrants to their homeland the companies who pay the minimum wages would raise their wages and Americans would be getting more jobs to work at

Immigration in the United States

1104 words - 4 pages among immigrants is very minimal and limited to the unskilled labor. Therefore, these immigrants are only competing with natives who have insignificant education and occupy jobs in fields such as construction, manufacturing, landscaping, agriculture, etc. As the education level of Americans continues to increase and older workers retire, these jobs are becoming increasingly vacant. Immigrants will fill these essential jobs in the labor market, such

Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants in the United States - CSULB/ ENGL301B - Essay

1651 words - 7 pages they have or do not have proper documentation to work. In fact, not too many native Americans are willing to perform the dirty and burdensome jobs, but the illegal immigrants are. Those taxpaying people have a positive impact on the economy and communities in the United States. Plenty of people who come to America, especially illegal immigrants, work for a full-time job but receive a little pay. Although having a lot of illegal immigrants may be

Left Out: Illegal Immigrants and Health Care

1176 words - 5 pages Left Out: Illegal Immigrants and Health Care Leah Karol Clemson University   With the implementation of the Affordable Care Act, most Americans are concerned with their private insurance or the benefits with Medicaid or CHIP. However, there is another population that was left out of the new bill almost entirely: undocumented immigrants. There is an ongoing debate as to whether illegal immigrants should be eligible for public

The Social-Political Ramifications of Immigration

2429 words - 10 pages For many years, America has had a misconception of immigrants. Most Americans think them to be taking up space, money, and jobs, but that’s not the case. U.S. native-born citizens have a trace of immigration in their family history leaving them with no room to judge others because after all immigration is down the line somewhere and, “[a]ll Americans are immigrants” (Granquist). Americans have common misconceptions of a lot of things such as

Immigrantion, Good or Bad?

1248 words - 5 pages problem to the government or to the people? Stern too shows us how the STEM program poses new moral questions for us. The immigrants who are coming to the United States are doing the jobs Americans should be doing, even if they take away the jobs of Americans. Are Americans becoming too lazy to keep achieving the American Dream that they are letting immigrants replace them? John and Stern have me see how important these questions are. Reading the

Immigration Needs to be Restricted in America

1020 words - 4 pages of illegal immigrants from Cuba. When the Cuban Government saw that nothing was going to be done about these immigrants, they seized the opportunity. As many as 40,000 of Cuba's hardcore criminals, murderers, rapists and armed robbers were turned lose in Florida (Stacy). If the Government had taken action when it should off this would have never happened. Americans are robbing illegal immigrants, as they cross into the United States. Very few

Similar Essays

When Are Immigrants Americans Too? Essay

866 words - 3 pages what Americans are really meaning to say is "We aren't giving the children a chance to live" and "Let them die, and the children too" (Baca, 775). Most Americans believe that Immigrants who come to America are looking for a way out and a free ride. Some times this is true, but most of the time it is not. It is the false pretences and the hopes of many, such as Hugo Ortega, that get them to migrate here. I believe that many Americans are scared

Americans Are Immigrants! Essay

989 words - 4 pages Americans are Immigrants!      “Everywhere immigrants have enriched and strengthened the fabric of American life,” was the words of former American president, John F. Kennedy (American Immigration: Quotes about Immigration). Immigrants have been in America for many years now. Today many people have different opinions about whether immigrants should be allowed into America freely, or if there should be more harsh

Are Immigrants Really Changing America’s Economy? Or Is America Becoming Too Racial? English 101 Essay

1989 words - 8 pages English 101 Are immigrants really changing America’s economy? Or is America becoming too racial? In 1942 King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella agreed to fund Christopher Columbus’s voyage to sail across the Atlantic Ocean. It was at this time Columbus had discovered a new world. He discovered this land containing only settlements from Native American people, who were living off the land. America was introduced to the world, and when the announcement

Immigrants And Immigration Blessing Or Burden?

1069 words - 4 pages immigrants that enters the United States. Many people argue that immigrants steal jobs from the loyal Americans. Overcrowds schools, ruin health care system and abuse health and public and federal services. Michael Huffington, a former member of the U.S House of Representatives from California, explains: ?Spending on illegal immigrants is out of control.? On the other hand, many argue that immigrants are actually good for America?s present and future