Immigration: An Opinion Regarding Two Conflicting Viewpoints

752 words - 3 pages

Daniel James' "Close the Borders to All Newcomers" and Stephen Moore's "Give Us Your Best, Your Brightest" reflect two very different viewpoints on immigration. James perceives immigration as a strain on our society, economy and environment. In opposition, Moore views immigration as a benefit to the people of America. James fails to present a decent opposing argument in his work. Both authors use only the statistics that work in their favor, conveniently forgetting those that would disprove their point of view. Although Moore fails to present numbers that would work against him, it is implied that he understands the disadvantages of open immigration by his solution.In "Close the Borders to All Newcomers," James portrays immigrants as a burden to the United States of America. To him, it seems that they come here with nothing but ill intentions. They take our jobs, destroy our environment, commit crimes, and abuse our welfare. James fails to consider all of the wonderful things that immigrants have done for our country. He fails to weigh the drawbacks with the contributions.James only presents that immigrants are abusing welfare without considering how many United States natives do exactly the same thing (James, 2005, p. 580). For example, several communities of polygamist Mormons continue to take advantage of welfare. The men will continue to have children with their multiple wives, and then the wives will claim welfare at the will of their husbands. This is possible because many of the marriages are not legal, and therefore are not recognized by the government. The men, though many of them extremely wealthy, are not held financially responsible for neither their wives nor their children. The government shells out millions of dollars each year to support these people who do not need it. Many of the immigrants who come to America are not coming here for our welfare benefits; they come here for better career opportunities. They come here for a better life.James makes mention of the large number of immigrant inmates in California's prisons in 1992. He never mentions the percentage of immigrants in California that year in comparison to American citizens. Chances are that the number of immigrants in prison was proportionate to the number of immigrants in California (James, 2005, p. 580).Though...

Find Another Essay On Immigration: An Opinion Regarding Two Conflicting Viewpoints

Immigration Laws Essay

1546 words - 6 pages in the U.S. came in with “bona fide” visas (Associated Press 34). “The government doesn’t want to fix it, and politicians, as usual, are dodging the issue, even though public-opinion polls show that Americans overwhelmingly favor a crackdown on illegal immigration” (Barlett and Steele 26). Illegal immigration has gotten worse every year and the United States still has yet to find a permanent solution. After weighing the viewpoints, it is clear

Politics, Payoffs, and Illegal Immigration Essay

5521 words - 22 pages migration Reform - Gilkey to Leahy" ( This web site takes the form of an open letter to U.S. Senator Leahy from Mark Gilkey. Mark is expressing his opinions regarding immigration both illegal and legal. The site is purely opinion and there are nor facts stated. In Gilkey's opinion: Business has no incentive to upgrade the skills of workers due to immigration. There is no economic benefit

Bush and Kerry; Chocolate and Vanilla

596 words - 2 pages regarding the presidential candidates, I got a similar response. Basically, everyone had their own opinion and vehemently felt that they were correct. For someone like me, who has a hard time pretending to be interested in politics, I found all the conflicting opinions quite confusing. Let's try to make it simpler and discuss some of the basic differences between Bush and Kerry. The first major difference between the two candidates is their

Immigration: My Solution

897 words - 4 pages services needed for the increase in population brought about by immigration. However, there is much controversy regarding this claim. Others say that the immigrant labor force supports and powers the economy. The cheap labor provided by illegal migrants drives down consumer costs and increase the productivity of the economy. Therefore, the lower costs brought about by immigrant laborers could actually save Americans money. Another argument supporting

Illegal Immigration into America

2263 words - 9 pages would put tougher sanctions on employers and would stop illegal immigrants from coming across (Byrd 1). What happened instead was that the United States sent a message to the world that illegal immigrants could gain legal status in the United States without having to go through the normal process. Consequently, illegal immigration jumped from an estimated five million illegal's in 1986 to an estimate to over 20 million illegal immigrants in the


671 words - 3 pages immigrants and illegal immigrants are two distinct things. But contrary to popular belief, legal immigrants are also an economic burden, more so than illegal immigrants in some cases (Cozic, 70). Immigration can become a serious problem to this country if the United States government does not produce stricter laws. Many hope that soon they will not have to worry about the amount of immigrants coming into this country. Immigration keeps the population and

Influences of Immigration on U.S. Provinces

1106 words - 4 pages labor and housing markets, and diversity. Many people disagree in allowing more immigrants to enter the U.S. due to economic downturns regarding limited housing and resources, willingness to integrate in host societies, and crime rates. Immigration creates a demand in housings which causes the prices to rise (Saiz, 2003). Homeowners and landlords raise prices because housing is limited. These price changes seem to not benefit natives who migrate

The U.S. Needs Comprehensive Immigration Reform

2942 words - 12 pages for the past three decades. The faces of this broken immigration system are the estimated eleven million of undocumented families, including two million children, who are living an American lifestyle as they work, live and study in American soil (Garcia, 2013). Although undocumented individuals have adopted American values as their own, they are forced to remain under the shadows. In hiding, immigrants are not capable of benefitting neither the

Social Issues Paper

1720 words - 7 pages normally have those jobs. Clearly there is disagreement and it is dificult to come to any consensus without truly understanding both viewpoints. On one hand we have many people in support of illegal immigrants, but on the other hand there are still many who feel that immigration will only cause harm in the long term. Many people in the United States feel that immigration only causes an oversaturation of workers and that those who are legally

Illegal Immigration and Its Effects on the United States

1488 words - 6 pages Many presidents have promised to increase government regulation on the ongoing cycle of illegal immigration. However, none of them have succeeded in doing so. It does seem to be an impossible task with thousands crossing every day and many of them fooling the U.S. by getting a working visa then never returning back home. Although this task of illegal immigration seems overwhelming the government needs to be more involved by continuing to build

The Effect of Illegal Immigration on the US Economy

963 words - 4 pages away from mostly African American citizens and cause a decrease in the amount of pay received to perform certain jobs because they are offering to do it for less. The Minutemen is an anti-illegal immigrants group who aims to help the citizen in protecting the border from the entry of illegal immigrants coming from Mexico. The American Immigration Control Foundation is committed to preserving the common heritage of Americans by educating citizens

Similar Essays

Immigration Helps America Essay

1386 words - 6 pages ethnical perspective of these people is nearly incompatible. This incompatibility leads to exchange of the aspects of the two cultures hence enrichment of the untied states culture. This is a positive impact to of immigration. If the new people were just visiting and going back to where they came from, then such exchange could not have happened, therefore, after all immigration is not only a negative aspect in United States, but a positive one too

The Impact Of Illegal Immigration On The United States

1956 words - 8 pages ways, and many other negative opinions. Citizens are not willing to take the time to become educated regarding immigrants. If citizens would take their time to become educated and put themselves in the immigrant’s shoes then the world might be a little bit better place. A negative aspect of legal or illegal immigration is definitely the language barrier. When an immigrant and their family come to live in our country by the third, maybe even the

Immigration And Europe Essay

1792 words - 7 pages Immigration within and into Europe has increased in recent years, with local populations' anxieties raised(Pilcher 2010, p445). I will look at the socio-cultural challenges which immigration introduces. These include the real and perceived impacts on native populations, and the policy responses which stem from the issues. Next, economic well-being is an aspect of the immigration question that will be examined. I will consider soem of the

The Economic Effects (Positive And Negataive) Of Immigration In Australia.

1672 words - 7 pages other countries, does not have an official population level or population policy. There are many theories and relative predictions regarding what Australia's population should be for the future. There are two sides to the argument.Many argue that Australia needs to reduce its population by creating an immigration policy which would only allow very few migrants to Australia. Such people argue that "this would be in Australia's favour as there