This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Immigration Case Study

2157 words - 9 pages

As illegal immigration from Mexico into the United States continues to increase, state governments are choosing to shift the responsibility of investigating and policing undocumented labor to businesses themselves by requiring employers to utilize E-Verify, an eligibility verification system, and imposing harsh penalties on employers who continue to hire illegals intentionally or unintentionally. This requires both industry and city police departments to work in tandem in an enforcement capacity that used to be solely the role of federal agents. Such enforcement not only raises the cost of doing business, but places business owners in a position to make decisions that reflect ...view middle of the document...

A decade ago, illegal immigrants in the Southwestern states regularly landed jobs in agricultural, construction and hospitality industries simply by presenting bogus social security cards to employers. Social Security took in immigrant contributions knowing full well that accounts were falsified but failed to share information with Homeland Security (McCombs and Stauffer). Since the terrorist events of 2001, American citizens demanded a more secure border by passing statutes featuring harsh punishments to illegal immigrants and all who hire them. Arizona’s SB 1070 is the most famous example of anti-immigrant legislation and has been blamed for institutionalizing racial profiling, chasing 100,000 unauthorized immigrants out of state, and imprisoning 7000 illegals per year in private for-profit prisons (Miller). As part of SB 1070, all businesses are held accountable for checking eligibility of any new hires using E-Verify, a federally funded electronic database, or risk permanent revocation of business licenses, otherwise known as the “business death penalty.” (Nowrasteh, 11).
The E-Verify policy is a “regulatory obstacle” for businesses and therefore many are circumventing the mandate by avoiding E-Verify entirely, according to Alex Nowrasteh, an immigration policy specialist at the Cato Institute’s Center for Global Liberty and Policy. By volunteering information to the federal database, employers may set themselves up for penalties, protracted legal battles and disputes based on what may amount to small administrative errors. This policy has hit Arizona agriculture especially hard. Between 25% and 90% of all farm workers are unauthorized immigrants, and as a result of labor scarcity, labor intense crops such as melons, fruit and vegetables are avoided while less profitable crops are grown that can be harvested by machines. (Nowastay, 6-8) More than 40 percent of Arizona’s construction workers are Latino and 70 percent of those are foreign born, which means illegal laborers make up to 27 percent of Arizona’s home building industry (Costantini). Each investigative query on E-Verify costs $147, so simply doing a complete search on all one’s employees can put a company out of business (Nowrasteh, 3). In addition, there is no guarantee that an employer is home free simply because ineligibility is not ascertained upon the first try. Up to 54 percent of illegal immigrants submitted into the system were not red-flagged (Simon). Later, after an employee has gone through months of training and becomes invested in a business, E-Verify can surprise the employer with an update of ineligibility. Added costs and liabilities to hiring Latinos have thus led to racial discrimination and a preference for hiring native retirees or students. Since many have been employed for years (under falsified identities), terminating unauthorized workers only hurts business by artificially making employees hard to find. As a result,...

Find Another Essay On Immigration Case Study

Immigration and the Media Essay

1704 words - 7 pages . This study was called the "propaganda model of media control," and concluded that the relationship between government elites and the media was actually very influential through an agreed agenda. This assertion made by Herman and Chomsky was again tested in the UK in 2003, concerning the topic of immigration, and the various newspapers which frequently covered the topic. This particular case study was enacted by Matthew Randall, a researcher who

Immigration and Europe Essay

1792 words - 7 pages positive correlation, the dissemination of information to the public. Economic fears are difficult to quell with arguments against immigration on economic grounds being made from quarters such as the right-wing media. The welfare of the native population in strictly economic terms is often the focus of study, but the evidence is not clear(Jean & Jimenez 2011, p244). What seems to be the case is that immigrants do contribute to the economy

Immigration and Immigrants

1434 words - 6 pages New Yorkers moved to suburbs. But it began to rise in 1992, despite a fare increase, with newly settled immigrant sections of the city contributing substantially to the change." At a given moment, migrants are generally net contributors to the public purse: they are disproportionately of working age, and the receiving country has not had to pay for their education. A magisterial study in 1997 of the economic impacts of immigration, by American's

Immigration Reform's Domino Effect

1639 words - 7 pages main question hinting at arguing the more negative effects of these doings within Arizonian politics. All of this is easily relatable back to week 4 of lectures when the pressing issue was migration and the case study discussing the US-Mexico border relations, this paper is just a lens used for analysis of the specifics of one side of this very arguable topic. Overall a very surprising article as its information was diverse in regards to its

Immigration - Who Really Benefits?

1601 words - 6 pages Immigration – Who Really Benefits? Why do people move from one country to live in another? In trying to understand this trend, one needs to understand the reason behind a person’s motive to seek economic fulfillment. All countries, in one way or another, are affected by immigration, its policies and agreements. As such, countries must work together in order to address immigration issues, both for the authorized and undocumented immigrants

High skilled immigration

1762 words - 8 pages disproportional contributions to the STEM industry and when they are not allowed to live in the country, they take their talent away with them to other countries with more open immigration laws. It also the case that foreign graduates who do not have an option to reside in the U.S. under perform if they are to reside in a country with low income per capita. (Kahn and MacGarvie) Conclusion The United States has been economically successful in part

Denmark Immigration and Integration

2360 words - 10 pages Denmark in Recent Times." Historiana: Your Portal to the Past. N.p., n.d. Web. 29 Nov. 2013. . Jakobsen, Andreas. "Easier Citizenship Test On Its Way." The Copenhagen Post. The Copenhagen Post, 7 Oct. 2013. Web. 29 Nov. 2013. . Kern, Soeren. "Converting Denmark into a Muslim Country." The Jewish Press. The

Immigration; Reform or Racism

1977 words - 8 pages . "Racism." Merriam-Webster.com. Merriam-Webster, n.d. Web. 9 May 2014. . Romero, Mary. 2008. “Crossing the immigration and race border: A critical race theory approach to immigration studies.” Contemporary Justice Review 11(1):23-37. Smith, Angela. 2006. “Paddington Bear: A Case Study of Immigration and Otherness.” Children’s Literature in Education 37(1). DOI: 10.1007/s10583-005-9453-3.

Economics of Immigration

2560 words - 10 pages goods while not paying income taxes. One major problem of illegal immigration involves the fact that illegal immigrants do not spread out evenly across the nation. They concentrate in certain areas, and the destination states that they choose, like California, pay a heavy toll. U.S. households, in general, end up paying an enormous amount of money because of illegal aliens. A study has found that illegal immigrants drain about 2 billion dollars

Immigration tp Canada

1780 words - 8 pages on immigration; Canada was established by the combined efforts from the indigenous First Nations and the European settlers from various parts of Europe. No single group can claim Canada to be theirs because it was a country built by immigrants and refugees from around the globe. Immigration has greatly influenced Canadian identity; it has become the vehicle which forged the character of Canada, as immigration policy changed so did the Canadian

Illegal Immigration and Slavery

1308 words - 5 pages countries. There is a documentary movie named “The other side of immigration” that captures in-depth study of causes that leads to Mexican emigration. One should not forget that it is very difficult to work in this severe conditions without a family support. Illegal immigrants, who cannot withstand this exploitation either end up being criminals or leads to their own death. We cannot enjoy cheaper goods and services at the cost of inhumanity

Similar Essays

Immigration Essay

1853 words - 8 pages According to the 2010 United States Census, California has the largest Vietnamese population of 581,946 in the United States. Before 1975 there were very few Vietnamese living in the United States. After the Vietnam War and the fall of Saigon in 1975, many Vietnamese refugees fled Vietnam resulting in three major waves of immigration. The first and second waves of immigration played a major role in Vietnamese refugees resettling in California

Illegal Immigration Essay

1403 words - 6 pages United States (Boyle,2013). Furthermore, many studies proved a direct link between the crimes increased rate and illegal immigration(Camarota & Vaughan, 2009). In addition, the flow of migrants from poor to rich countries can also have a negative effect on the developing world. According to a study by the Helsinki-based World Institute for Development Economics Research (WIDER), developing countries that observe their scientists, technology

Illegal Immigration Essay

1941 words - 8 pages explain the high numbers by looking at things from a different point of view. As explained in a study by The National Academies Press, Advisors to the Nation on Science, Engineering, and Research, in a book titled, The Immigration Debate: Studies on the Economic, Demographic, and Fiscal Effects of Immigration,Immigrants are often disproportionately male and at early ages of labor market entry and advancement. Because young males are

Illegal Immigration Essay

1291 words - 6 pages Immigration Harm US Citizens?’” 1) According to a Federation for American Immigration Reform study, illegal aliens cost U.S. taxpayers $113 billion per year. (Nagle Chet, 2), and the CIS finds that in 2002 illegal immigrant on net received $10 billion more in government benefits than they paid in taxes, a value equal to 0.1 percent of U.S. GDP in that year. (“Preface to ‘Does Illegal Immigration Harm US Citizens?’” 4) Illegal immigrations make it