The actions made in today’s societies across the country not only affect those situations immediately at hand, but also those for generations to come. This paper will be delving into immigration reform in Arizona, and more specifically the negative effects that the border surge has had on the socio-economic status of the Grand Canyon state. The motivation for choosing this topic comes from the time spent personally living in Arizona for 12 years and seeing it as one of the most dynamic states having to solve problems for a multitude of issues that arouse within it. The main drive for this paper is the question that asks, what are the socio-economic impacts of the Arizona immigration legislation? This question focusing more on supporting immigration and analyzing the negative effects that happen as a result.
This article analyzes the domino effect of issues in the hand dealt to Arizona and its citizens following the harsh crackdown on immigration in their state. The big bill passed, SB1070, created a plethora of new problems for the state that continue to harm it even today. As word got out of the bill being passed so did anyone not wishing to associate themselves with the state, that means performers cancel their concerts, conventions for business corporations relocate, and about 12 states with multiple cities and counties boycott any financial contact with Arizona and their business’. This charged the state 141 million dollars, but somehow the economy was not hit as badly as expected. This is the part where the article disagrees with the main stance of the paper, and defends the argument that the economy wasn’t hit “that” bad and the immigration push actually helped tourism having Grand Canyon visits increase by 3% and hotel occupancy by 8%. Still avoiding the real blow to business and relations with the other states financially, this article attempts to bring the brighter side out of the border surge (Ortenzi 2010).
Information taken from this article was the surplus of information that attempted to combat the true negative effects of SB1070 and the immigration reform that continues to plague Arizona to this day. This certainly challenged the overall question brought up in this paper in regards to the main question hinting at arguing the more negative effects of these doings within Arizonian politics. All of this is easily relatable back to week 4 of lectures when the pressing issue was migration and the case study discussing the US-Mexico border relations, this paper is just a lens used for analysis of the specifics of one side of this very arguable topic. Overall a very surprising article as its information was diverse in regards to its unbiased deliverance of both the positive and negative of the immigration law reform and its effects.
Wilson in this article discusses the debate over economic struggles and whether or not immigration is helping or hurting the state. It is said in this article that opinions from all over the state vary,...