Immigration Who Really Benefits? Essay

1601 words - 6 pages

Immigration – Who Really Benefits?
Why do people move from one country to live in another? In trying to understand this trend, one needs to understand the reason behind a person’s motive to seek economic fulfillment. All countries, in one way or another, are affected by immigration, its policies and agreements. As such, countries must work together in order to address immigration issues, both for the authorized and undocumented immigrants. The two important aspects that people should understand before forming an opinion about immigration are the (negative) impact of policies on immigrants and locals alike, and that immigration drives the US economy, particularly in the areas of wages and employment opportunities for American-born workers.
The creation of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) indirectly generates a negative impact on the Mexican agricultural farmers. According to the article entitled “The North American Free Trade Agreement” taken off the US-Canada-Mexico government website “The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA)”, the “agreement was created in 1994 and considered to be one of the world’s largest free trade zones ….Its purpose is to provide economic growth and rising prosperity for Canada, the United States and Mexico”. However, this was proven not to be the case for Mexico. Prior to NAFTA, small businesses in Mexico relied heavily on their
Aquilina, 2

agricultural produce such as corn plantation and hog farming. These farmers were able to make a living from their agricultural produce and livestock farming. In the article “How US Policies Fueled Mexico’s Great Migration” by David Bacon, Bacon highlights how David Ceja, an immigrant from Veracruz, was able to buy the necessities by just selling the pigs that he reared. However, that all changed once NAFTA came into effect. The free trade agreement allows the U.S., Canada and Mexico to trade goods based on supply and demand. As a result of NAFTA, Mexico imported more pigs from the U.S. due to its low pricing. The low price strongly affects the Mexican farmers and small business owners who rely purely on their agricultural produce and livestock farming. According to the article “Do U.S. Economic Policies Fuel Latin-American Immigration?” by Peter Jesserer Smith, Smith cites that “Mexican farmers are not able to compete with the overall low cost of U.S. imported goods”. The costs of imported U.S. pigs are much lower than locally produced pigs, thereby, making it difficult for Mexican farmers to “compete effectively” (Smith). This lower cost ultimately drives small farmers out of their businesses and, Mexican workers out of their livelihoods.
The subsidies that U.S. farmers receive from the government contribute to the low cost of goods exported to Mexico. “Mexico was flooded with agricultural imports exported at prices below production costs”, said Timothy A. Wise, Director of the Research and Policy Program at the Global Development and...

Find Another Essay On Immigration - Who Really Benefits?

Canada's Demographic Future, Is Immigration The Key?

1666 words - 7 pages "What we're seeing now is demographics which are really driven more and more by immigration."-Dough Norris, director general of Statistics Canada.For the first time in history, Canada is facing a population decline beginning in 2010. Population decline this is happening in a decade where both demographic and economic growth is imperative. From 1996-2001, Canada's population had a 4% (1.2 million) increase in population, making it the lowest 5

This essay 12 pg long, is about the negitive effects immigration has had on the US. this essay talks about multiple reasons why immigration should be cut down in the US.

3456 words - 14 pages states should reduce it's immigration rates. Because immigrants typically earn far less than the average American, they are unable to pay for the necessities, such as insurance and other health care related programs. This causes a burden on taxpayers who are forced to pay out millions of dollars to cover immigrant costs. The study found that immigrants racked up 190 million dollars in unpaid bills at seventy seven border hospitals in 2000


3600 words - 14 pages . Finally, in 1994, California voters approved Proposition 187, which aimed to deny public benefits to illegal immigrants (Huffington 63). Illegal immigration is causing problems to United States citizens. These citizens are forced to pay billions of taxes on people who shouldn't even be here in the first place. Even legal immigrants, who are of large numbers, are also costing a lot for other citizens so that more schools, stores, and other

Persuasive paper

780 words - 3 pages . People see immigration as a strain on our country. They see immigration as overcrowding of border cities, the taking of jobs and the cheating of our nation's benefits system. This paper will cover both meanings people see of this word and come to a conclusion as to how immigration in El Paso should be handled.In El Paso, TX on July 3, 2014 a protest was held in where around 200 people gathered to protest what they believe to be a failed

United States Immigration Policy

2873 words - 11 pages California. Currently, California spends billions of dollars to incarcerate enough illegal aliens to fill eight state prisons. Further, California taxpayers pay $3.6 billion a year to provide benefits to illegal immigrants. In order to reduce illegal immigration, Wilson believes the federal government should stop forcing state governments to provide education, health care, and other benefits to illegal immigrants, assure that government benefits are

Moving Forward: Immigration Reform

1374 words - 5 pages accepted across the board. Issues with equality, safety and economics have hindered reform into becoming a unanimous vote. Equality and fairness have always been an issue with immigration. People get very enraged when they think of how simple illegal immigrants get to the U.S; just jump a border and you now have the world of opportunity in your hands. Should those people be given the same rights as someone who immigrated legally and spent months

Immigration In The 21st Century: Pros And Cons

3282 words - 13 pages improvements for blacks.IMMIGRATION AND WELFARE Another argument used in favor of immigration controls concerns the American welfare system and its potential abuse by immigrants who migrate into America merely to feed at the public trough of social services. The claim is made that the welfare system, not potential economic freedom, is the lure which draws immigrants into the American economy. Immigrants -unproductive, slothful, and indigent


1747 words - 7 pages . economy and provides more of a positive impact than negative on the country. Immigrants working for cheap labor and getting jobs helps the U.S. economy financially. Immigrants bring in a positive influence and benefits not only to the economy, but to the country as a whole. A Bipartisan Policy Center study showed how a major overhaul of immigrants could boost the economic recovery of the U.S. The study showed within the next 20 years, immigration

The Impacts of Changing Immigration Patterns of the Post-War Period

1310 words - 6 pages European skilled workers. This Immigration Act defined independent immigrants consisting of British (including Commonwealth) and French immigrants who could support themselves and find employment. Western Europeans were also allowed if they had already arranged for employment. This allowed for more skilled workers to make their way to Canada and help build infrastructure. As a result, Canadians enjoy the benefits of the post-war boom today. After this

America as a Nation of Immigrants

2394 words - 10 pages benefits then they deserve. The reality of illegal immigration is that it has been an increasingly difficult problem to solve. For three decades now our government has been trying to find ways to alleviate the number of illegal immigrants in the nation. One attempt was the Amnesty program in the mid-90's for those who had been in the country since 1992 (Suro 40). However, this covered only about 60% of the illegal population and drew much

Immigration to the U.S

808 words - 4 pages oppression. There are many immigration laws in the United States (U.S.) such as the green card, the immigration bill, and the Gentlemen’s agreement. These helps protect citizens’ benefits from the immigrants that come to U.S. Even though many of those citizens abuse these benefits in a prideful way; “Compassion and fairness ‐‐” (Leppala), these two ideas have been competing against each other over the debate with the U.S. immigrants. The

Similar Essays

Who Really Benefits? Essay

1911 words - 8 pages Who Really Benefits? Unlike many other professions, individuals in the teaching profession have as many opportunities to acquire and enhance skills while on the job, even when exhibiting poor performance (Seldin, 2005). Doctors, for example, are not allowed to practice if they have not acquired the necessary skills or with several malpractice complaints on their record. Allowing teachers to practice when their mediocre performance is documented

The Debate In The United States Over Immigration

1300 words - 5 pages immigrants is the whole job and population situation, which really is not that big of a deal to most people who do not want low paying jobs, but yet the still seem to argue that if they had to they would take a low paying job with bad health benefits and hard labor, that is a answer you are most likely to get, but in all reality no American is really willing to take. Immigration definitely has disadvantages but also had many plus sides as well

The Cost Of Illegal Imigration Essay

1984 words - 8 pages own. Illegal immigration has even impacted the economy. Over 500 thousand illegal immigrants arrive to our country yearly which has damaged our economy severely. Our economy cannot withstand 500 thousand undocumented workers who have limited skills and steal from the government with all the free benefits they are given. 95% of all illegal immigrants are part of the lower class and have minimal skills (Illegal immigration Cost, Crimes and

Debating Immigration Essay

1364 words - 5 pages take a moment to really absorb what Brad said. At first I was like whatever guy. Then I sat down and wrote what he had just said to me and it really does mean a lot to the way all people, of all races, immigrated or born citizen look at the USA. The motivation behind immigration to the USA over the last four hundred years was mainly done for two reasons. They need to leave their prior environment to survive and the attraction