This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Implications Of Racism In Canadian Society: R.D.S. V. The Queen

1264 words - 5 pages

Implications of Racism in Canadian Society: R.D.S. v. The Queen

"The courtroom is no place to find the truth."

This quotation is taken from a Hollywood film, but has a tendency to ring true in legal disputes in Canada involving minority groups. Racism as a component in the Canadian societal context has prevented the realization of truth and justice throughout history. For instance, Donald Marshall Jr. endured a wrongful conviction as a result of racism in the criminal justice system. While this dilemma has proved to be most difficult for minority groups to overcome, critical race theory, as implemented by defence lawyers in R.D.S. v. The Queen, has allowed for the realization of racism as truth in Canadian society and provides a tool for minority groups in future legal battles.

In October of 1993, R.D.S., a Nova Scotian Black youth, was arrested by a white police officer and charged with assault on a police officer in the execution of duty, assault with intent to prevent the lawful arrest of another, and resisting his own arrest. In a Nova Scotia Youth Court, R.D.S. testified that he did not touch the police officer or assault him in any way. He stated that he spoke only to his cousin, who was being arrested by Constable Steinburg, to ask the nature of his arrest and whether or not to contact his mother. R.D.S. testified that Constable Steinburg told him to either "shut up" or face arrest. The youth argued that the police officer proceeded to place both himself and his cousin in a choke hold. Constable Steinburg maintained that R.D.S. assaulted him and obstructed his cousin's arrest. He made no reference to telling the youth to shut up or to placing either youth in a choke hold. (1)

Judge Corinne Sparks, also a member of the Black community, found in favour of R.D.S. Her decision was reached on the basis of the credibility of the witnesses, as the only witnesses called in the trial were the police officer and the youth. The controversy that eventually brought the case to the Supreme Court of Canada was based in Judge Sparks' comments:

I'm not saying the constable has misled the court, although police officers have been known to do that in the past. And I'm not saying that the officer overreacted, but police officers certainly do overreact, particularly when they're dealing with non-white groups. That, to me, indicates a state of mind right there that is questionable. I believe that probably the situation in this particular case is the case of a young police officer who overreacted. And I do accept the evidence of Mr. S. that he was told to shut up or he would be under arrest. That seems to be in keeping with the prevalent attitude of the day.(2)

In making her decision, Judge Sparks reiterated what every reasonable Canadian knows: racism exists in Canada and permeates the criminal justice system. There was no tangible proof of racism in this particular case, but none was required, as its presence can be taken for granted....

Find Another Essay On Implications of Racism in Canadian Society: R.D.S. v. The Queen

The Canadian Divorce Act: The Practicality of an Age-Old Document in Modern Day Society

1126 words - 5 pages In the past ten years, the Canadian government has created and passed laws and regulations that would not have been predicted by the general public only a couple of decades ago. Gay people can now marry, pot was temporarily decriminalized, and obesity has been declared an epidemic. Despite all of this, the Canadian Divorce Act has remained one of the few documents that is still reflective of modern societal values and continues to be a valuable

Racism in society Essay

1284 words - 5 pages of their basic human rights, dignity and respect Global change has to start small and travel abroad. If children are taught at an early age that it is ok to mock and stereotype others, when they become in the position to change policy concerning the offensive use of other cultures, is it any wonder why they don't see such use as racism and stereotyping? What I propose is that we look for the seeds of racism in dominant society and we destroy them

Racism in Our Society

1524 words - 6 pages in the awareness of how racism is manifest in society (D’Andrea & Daniels, 2007). Beady and Hansell (1981) assert that “the promise of school desegregation for reducing educational inequities has largely gone unfulfilled” (p. 191). The 30 years since this statement was made have done little to change the truth of it. There are three types of racism that are observable in our society: (a) individual, (b) cultural, and (c) institutional

Racism in Society

1854 words - 7 pages American Racism Society In Nathan McCall’s “Makes Me Wanna Holler,” he describes the difficulties he must face as a young black boy experiencing the slow, never-ending process of the integration of blacks and whites. Through this process, his autobiography serves as an excellent example of my theory on the formation and definition of racial identity; a theory which is based upon a combination of the claims which Stuart Hall and George

Racism in the American Society in the 1920s

1489 words - 6 pages Racism in the American Society in the 1920s Black people have always been a part of America's history. They were brought to America in the seventeenth century as slaves by white settlers. Slavery ended by the nineteenth century, and by this time there were more black Americans than white Americans in the southern states. However, Blacks always had a tough time, this is due to the stereotypical view that the people had

The Myriad Dynamics of State Policies Shaping Canadian Aboriginal Society

1769 words - 8 pages State policies have shaped Canadians’ lives in a myriad of ways. Policies and social construction have both played an important role in how policies have influenced the construction of race, class, gender and disability in the age of neoliberalism. The modern ideals have been shaped largely by historical happenings that have both challenged and advanced Canadian society, specifically in relation to the country’s Indigenous context. This essay

The Implications of Expressed Emotion in Schizophrenia

1936 words - 8 pages illness of the dependent (Whittick, 1993). When a Schizophrenic patient goes into convalescence, they are required to be in a stable environment which is low in expressed emotion, otherwise implications, including relapse, are more likely to occur (Vaughn and Leff, 1976). Schizophrenia is a complex psychological disorder in which the sufferer experiences severe disturbances is cognitive ability, speech, perception, emotion and behaviour (Herz and

The Implications of Quasi-Democracy in China

933 words - 4 pages representatives” (Muhlberger 27). In this essay, I argue that there have been quasi-democratic elements even within the Chinese Communist tradition. These elements at the local level signal the potential for China to fully transition into a democracy in the future. Muhlberger notes the historical tradition of quasi-democracy within Chinese political development. Under most emperors, village administration was the responsibility of the villagers

Implications of Catcher in the Rye

695 words - 3 pages The Catcher in the Rye has been prevalent in some of the most traumatic and earth-shattering moments in contemporary history, and may have even contributed to them. Before the police arrived and after the gun was fired, Mark David Chapman (John Lennon’s assassin) started reading lines from Salinger’s work. He recited the passage: “ I keep picturing all these little kids...I’d just be the catcher in the rye and all” (Salinger 224-25). Author

The Queen of Spades

1228 words - 5 pages In 2014, American Hustle topped the box office charts and was celebrated by critics alike. The film praised con artists and even portrayed them as light-hearted, “comedic figures” (Surowiecki). Americans condemn rapists and murders, yet we idolize con artists and often strive to achieve the most out of life with the least amount of work. People are constantly looking for shortcuts and quick solutions, making us bait to the cons of our society

Queen of the Damned

868 words - 4 pages played out the vampires disband and eventually go their separate ways. The vampire is one of the oldest and ideal models in today’s society. The Queen of the Damned is not only a good read it deals with the origins of vampires too. It began with Queen Akasha the mother of all vampires and her king Enkil. It tells of how a blood thirsty spirit gave them eternal life if they drank blood, but tanned them in the presence of the sun. “It’s an awful

Similar Essays

Implications Of Living In A Gendered Society

2691 words - 11 pages Implications of Living in a Gendered Society Analysis from a gender perspective Throughout history women have engaged in 'burning their bra's', battling for prerogative and constructing what we now recognise as a feminist perspective. Being a woman is now defined in various manners: the career woman, the sports woman, the mother and the liberated, candid feminist. These are all valid and valued roles within

The Problem Of Racism And Discrimination In American Society

1040 words - 4 pages stronger and longer imprisonment. Racism and discrimination of all sorts is a huge problem in American society of the past present and will be of the future. It seems to be the left over residue of the slavery, lynching, and slave patrols. Just as time goes on, traditions and customs alter, racism and discrimination to began to change and take different forms. Actions and demonstrations may not be seen so vividly or clear as before in strappingly

The Canadian Borderland And Racism Essay

934 words - 4 pages This essay will focus on racial borders within Canadian literature looking at the effects of a border on a member of a minority group. “The border is in fact also the symbol of the exclusionary practice inherent in the discourse of the nation.” Canada is a country made up largely of immigrants and their descendants, an interesting question is, what caused a country, with a diverse population to be so deeply racist?. Two novels which will

Racism In American Society Essay

548 words - 2 pages In American society racism is still alive today. The racial conflict that still exists is a reflection of the racist attitudes of the people in American society. To help eliminate or reduce racism people must have an understanding of its root cause. Racism was first institutionalized in society to exploit African labor to preserve the power, privilege and wealth of the European Americans. To this day, racism survives because people still believe