Importance Of Good Precedents For Sustaining Democracies: Case Study On India And Pakistan

1772 words - 8 pages

There are many different reasons why the partition of India occurred. When Britain oppressed India, they had a divide-and-conquer policy that exacerbated the religious and cultural rifts that already existed in the society. The Muslim League, which believed in the ideology of “Pakistan”, actively campaigned to gain more support for the Muslims in India, especially under the guidance of dynamic leaders like Jinnah. Pakistani leader and founder Muhammad Ali Jinnah believed that this partition was inevitable since “‘[a] united India would never have worked’” (Komireddi 2009). He and others thought that a unified state would only lead to the relegation of Muslims to the fringe of society and, ultimately, to violence and civil war. The Indian National Congress also made several small decisions that convinced many members of the Muslim League that a united India was impossible. In the end all three parties, the British, Indian elites, and Muslim elites—played a major role in the partition of India.
As the Hindus in northwest India moved south, the Muslims moved north into Pakistan; millions were displaced, thousands were slaughtered as a result of brutal riots, and the birth of both countries was met with death and destruction. Many believe that the Muslims went along with the partition and moved into Pakistan “not because they viewed it, as official Pakistani narrative suggests, as the land of hope, but because they feared becoming victims of the retributive violence in India that the creation of Pakistan had resulted in” (Komireddi 2009). The disjointed countries used to be a nation of people where, for the most part, the differences in religion, culture, and language did not destroy peace. However, partition turned the entire subcontinent into an abattoir.

After independence, India and Pakistan alike saw civil unrest as well as ethnic and religious discord, all of which threatened the stability of the both countries. India was left in a search for a common identity with its many cultures in the north, south, east, and west. Pakistan, which was primarily a Muslim country, also had its own set of splits and differences. The east and west sides of Pakistan were not divided over religion (they were mostly all Muslim), rather the division was on the basis of culture and language. West Pakistan was Punjabi while East Pakistan was Bengali. In 1971, there was a major war between India and Pakistan and the east side of Pakistan split off into what is today called Bangladesh. For the purposes of this essay, we will be focusing on just Pakistan and India.
The people in both countries have very common and even interlocked backgrounds, so how is it that these countries have very divergent political atmospheres since partition? India, adapting from the legacy of British rule and the Government of India Act 1935 for its constitution, kept the idea of federalism and was also successful in operating its political system within the formal...

Find Another Essay On Importance of Good Precedents for Sustaining Democracies: Case Study on India and Pakistan

Good and Evil on the Rail Case Study

1447 words - 6 pages Good and Evil on the Rail Case Study Sanchez’s love for trains since his early teenage days led him to his career as a Locomotive Engineer in Metrolink commuter rail system. He loved his job, had a few disciplinary issues here and there; absences and failure to follow rules set mostly in the use of his cell phone during operation hours. On September 12, 2008, a day like any other, he was up ready for his daily routine. On this day, Sanchez was

Relations Between India and Pakistan Essay

1506 words - 6 pages -building process. For India, Kashmir poses fundamental questions relating to democracy and federalism. Simply put, does the right to choose your government also extend to secession? (Varshney 1991, 1003). If it doesn’t, the people of Kashmir are unable to elect representative leaders and ipso facto India is subverting its principles. Geo-strategically, Kashmir is an important piece on the imperial chessboard, providing India access to Central Asia

Stability in India and Pakistan

839 words - 3 pages India has been a major advance. Care should be taken to ensure that it is implemented in its true spirit. And lastly, official efforts will need to be supplemented by people to people contacts. On making the first move towards friendship and reinstating its stalled process, India needs to take the initiative to lay at rest the fears of the military in Pakistan as it stands to benefit greatly from a transformed relationship whereas though Pakistan’s need for peace is greater, the weakness of its civilian government and its internal problems make it unlikely that it can take any bold initiative.

Study Questions for Case 2: Apollo Hospitals of India, Report addressing Dr. Reddy.

968 words - 4 pages Executive SummaryDr. Reddy, you have done an incredible service for the people of India. You have started them on an incredible journey toward affordable, quality health care. You have started to reverse the "brain drain", giving bright, entrepreneurial-minded individuals an option to stay at home. You have demonstrated incredible conviction and perseverance. The hospitals that you have been able to establish in India have gained a reputation

Argues in favor of the right to marry for same sex couples or homosexuals based on the fourteenth amendment and precedents set in past supreme court cases.

3941 words - 16 pages that he did not intend for the races to mix." The couple repealed the case to the Supreme Court in 1967. The Supreme Court overturned the case and declared anti-miscegenation laws violated the 14th amendment's equal protection clause, and was therefore, unconstitutional. The judge noted that "Marriage is one of the "basic civil rights of man," fundamental to our very existence and survival.... To deny this fundamental freedom on so unsupportable

Study on Bicycle Market of India

5976 words - 24 pages European partner for catering to the European market. It has also chalked out a restructuring plan for increasing the profit margin through backward integration.5.5.3.Avon Cycles:Avon Cycles is founded by Pahwa Brothers. Their dream was to give the common man of India an affordable means of mobility in the early days of our country's independence. Starting up a bicycle saddles and brakes manufacturing unit in 1948, the Pahwas set out on a long and

India and Pakistan: a modern history of the antagonistic relationship between nuclear neighbors and what it could mean for the future of the free world.

3218 words - 13 pages The conflict between India and Pakistan has been going on since their partition in 1947. With the recent developments in both countries' nuclear arsenals as well as the increase in insurgent movements in the disputed territory of Kashmir, it has now escalated to a point where the security of not only South Asia but also the entire world is threatened. The United States' lack of credibility in the region has seriously infringed upon their ability

India and Pakistan: The First Fifty Years

2526 words - 10 pages India and Pakistan: The First Fifty Years Part I: Political Development India: Democratic progress and problems One of the strengths of India politically over Pakistan is said to be the fact that it has elected to take on a democratic system of government. There are several issues, however, with India as a democracy due to several factors including numerous cases of malpractice and corruption in electoral

Cultural Differences Between India and Pakistan

1032 words - 4 pages . Governance is a big contributor to tensions because democracy and Sharia law are very opposed to each other (Mohmand, 2009). Sharia Laws blames democracy for the prevalence of morality in the world. On the other hand, democracy frowns on the primitive nature of Sharia laws that still do not recognize the need for human rights. The border crisis between India and Pakistan government is a cultural issue that looks to become more deadly. After the

Impact of an Educator on Sustaining and Enhancing a Child’s Learning and Development

2941 words - 12 pages ’ (Woodrow & Press 2007; Van Hoorn et al 2011). Once again, although there is a large emphasis on play and its crucial importance for learning and development in the Early Years Framework (DEEWR 2009), all notions of child-initiated, play-based learning disappear when children ‘come of age’ and attend primary school (ACARA 2013; Lingard 2010). Consequently, this curriculum can encourage teachers to standardise their pedagogy in the hope of ensuring

"Religious Wars of India" looks at the wars in Kashmir and Ayodhya between India, Pakistan, and Afghanistan. It is written in an argumentative style with an emphasis on new compromises.

2336 words - 9 pages Religious Wars of IndiaThe beginning of the new millennium has been a heart wrecking one for the peace loving people of the world. The year 2001 saw dispute, destruction, and death, all in the name of religion.As we usher in a new year with high hopes of peace, India and Pakistan are again on the brink of a war! Why are these two siblings always at loggerheads with each other? Is it because Pakistan is an Islamic nation and India predominantly a

Similar Essays

Nuclear Deterrence: A Case Study Of The India Pakistan Conflict

1555 words - 7 pages . The Origin and Prevention of Major Wars. Cambridge [England: Cambridge UP, 1989. 48. Print. Salik, Naeem. "Minimum Deterrence and India Pakistan Nuclear Dialogue: Case Study on Pakistan." LNCV Publications (2006): n. pag. Web. . Waltz, Kenneth. "The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More May

Case Study On India

604 words - 3 pages The Islamic Republic of Afghanistan would like to seize this unique opportunity to work on a case study pertaining to the medical conditions and the health situation in the Republic of India (8°4' and 37°6' north latitude and 68°7' and 97°25' east longitude). Afghanistan is merely interested in studying this nation due to its close vicinity to Afghanistan and the omnipresence of this problem in the country. In India, since the pre-independence

India And Pakistan Dispute Essay

2871 words - 11 pages the State was a Hindu, while the population was overwhelmingly Muslim and wanted to join Pakistan. In this case, India consistently pressurized the Hindu Ruler to accede to India. Apprehending that the Hindu ruler was likely to succumb to Indian pressure, the people of Jammu and Kashmir rose against him, forcing him to flee from Srinagar, the capital of the State. They formed their own government on 24th October, 1947. On

Forum Selection Clauses An Argument For Their Use Case Precedents And Arguments On Why Forum Selection Clauses Included In Contracts Should Be Legal And Binding.

1850 words - 7 pages Network, L.L.C., 323 N.J. Super. 118 (App. Div.), certif denied, 162 N.J. 199 (1999).] The Microsoft case is of critical importance in that it affirmed the Superior Court's decision in a class action suit covering several states on the grounds of lack of jurisdiction and improper venue by reason of the forum selection which clearly establishes the "...exclusive jurisdiction and venue of courts in King County, Washington, USA, in all disputes