Improve Affirmative Action By Removing Quotas And Racial Preferences

2821 words - 11 pages

Improve Affirmative Action by Removing Quotas and Racial Preferences

Affirmative action has assisted many members of minority groups in creating equal opportunities in education and employment. Who could object to assisting these minorities, who suffered years of discrimination, in getting the equal opportunity they deserve? The problem is, affirmative action promotes racial preferences and quotas which cause mixed emotions. One time supporters of affirmative action are now calling out “reverse discrimination”. If we want a stronger support for affirmative action we need to get rid of the preferential treatments.
The back bone of affirmative action began with the ratification of the Thirteenth Amendment on December 18, 1865. The amendment abolished slavery and any involuntary labor (“Federal laws,” 1998). This showed there was a calling for equal opportunity for all Americans.
When the Thirteenth Amendment was ratified, there were opponents who were skeptical of the amendment. Because of this they came up with two separate bills of their own: the civil rights bill, and an amendment to the Freedmen’s Bureau Act. The bills covered all citizens, not just blacks. The civil rights bill moved on to become the Civil Rights Act of 1866 (Dorsen, 1994). The Act states that "all persons shall have the same rights...to make and enforce contracts, to sue, be parties, give evidence, and to the full and equal benefit of all laws..." (“Federal laws,” 1998).
The turn of the century saw a minimal amount of legislation regarding discrimination. However, come the mid part of the century, an upheaval of civil disobedience and violent protests would spark what would come to be known as The Civil Rights Movement (Dorsen, 1994). This was an all out effort, made by many, to abolish the segregation and discrimination of black minorities.
In 1961, President Kennedy enacted Executive Order 10925 (Lugg, 1997, p. 11). The order directed employers to take affirmative action to ensure a “color blind” method of hiring and promotion in government contracts. This began a concerted effort to abolish discrimination. With Executive Order of 10925 came the President’s Committee on Equal Employment Opportunity (PCEEO). The Committee was given the authority to enforce affirmative action mandates by being able to cancel or suspend government contractors. Kennedy, mostly endorsing a “race conscious affirmative action,” kept away from racial preferences and quotas (Lugg, 1997, p. 11).
On July 2, 1964, President Johnson signed the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (“Federal laws,” 1998). Title VII of the act prohibits employment discrimination based on race, sex, national origin, or religion. Title VI prohibits public access discrimination, leading to school desegregation. Title VIII is the original "federal fair housing law," later amended in 1988. However, even after this and other legislation, blacks, Hispanics, and Native Americans were still underrepresented in employment and...

Find Another Essay On Improve Affirmative Action by Removing Quotas and Racial Preferences

This is an evaluation of affirmative action. In the essay, I argue that affirmative action is no longer an effective means in achieving racial equality

1399 words - 6 pages majority of Americans feel as though there is still a need for a balancing act to be done by the government.Contrary to popular belief, the non-supporters of Affirmative Action do not entirely consist of conservative republican white males. Many Black and Hispanic groups are against the Affirmative Action policy. They feel as though it is a step back in their equality struggle. "It is patronizing and it causes everyone to pay closer attention to your

The Making of An Army of One In response to our military's racial animosity, the armed forces implemented affirmative action plans during the 1970s

1475 words - 6 pages The Making of An Army of OneIn response to our military's racial animosity, the armed forces implemented affirmativeaction plans during the 1970s. President Clinton's 1999 review of affirmative action confirmedthat these plans have succeeded in expanding representation of minorities and women,especially as officers, while improving race relations, promoting integration, and enhancingoverall combat readiness. The Army has been characterized as

Women and Affirmative Action

1555 words - 6 pages Affirmative action includes the policies and programs, either voluntary or mandated by law, that aim to increase the number of historically disadvantaged people, such as women and minorities, in education or the workforce. Women were initially excluded from affirmative action initiatives, but due to publicity and pressure from some women's groups, women were finally added in April 1973 (Johnson, 1989, p. 114, 116). This literary review will

Minorities and Affirmative Action

1926 words - 8 pages they need. People do have a potential to work hard and many of them are intelligent however they just need a little help to quit the past and abuse that may hold them down. Ultimately, affirmative action is still needed because it supports racial equality, gives minority students a chance for a better life, and helps women to be equally treated. Argument 1 First of all, affirmative action is still needed because students starting at a

Race and Affirmative Action

3216 words - 13 pages Race and Affirmative Action Race is an issue that is embedded in the nation’s history and continues to spur discussions on how the different minorities and ethnic groups must be treated fairly. Affirmative action is a recent attempt to solve the discriminations produced by racial inequality. However, affirmative action is also being scrutinized as scholars and the public debate the benefits and harms of affirmative action

Discrimination and Affirmative Action

3024 words - 12 pages Action Programs that are accompanied by negative perceptions such as quotas, the idea of hand-outs and lower or preferential hiring and performance standards is Diversity Management which uses voluntary goals in an attempt include a qualified, diverse and representative work force in both the formal and informal aspects of an organization (Gilbert, Stead & Ivancevich, 1999).In this paper we will discuss the Disabled Veterans Affirmative Action

Animosity and Affirmative Action

622 words - 2 pages score a 72 percent on the exam versus white male applicants who score 100 percent. The result of hiring someone who scores low on this exam versus high could mean the difference between life and death.Another example of why Affirmative Action should be re-considered or dismissed is racial animosity. Society sees racism as a social issue in need of a solution. Society is always trying to solve racism; however, Affirmative Action is increasing racism

America and Affirmative Action

1060 words - 4 pages issues thataffirmative action raises while forgetting to scrutinize the system that has created theneed for them. Too often, affirmative action is looked upon as the panacea for a nationonce ill with, but now cured of, the virulent disease of racial discrimination. Affirmativeaction is, and should be seen as, a temporary, partial, and perhaps even flawed remedyfor past and continuing discrimination against historically marginalized

ADA and Affirmative Action Paper

1204 words - 5 pages University of Phoenix/BSHS 422This paper will Critique of American's with Disabilities Act (ADA) and Affirmative Action and the effects on people in America today, by providing the definition of ADA and Affirmative Action, reasons for their enactment and populations they seek to protect, effectiveness of the ADA and Affirmative Action, concerns and criticisms of the ADA and Affirmative Action, and the future of the ADA and Affirmative Action.The

Affirmative Action and Collective Responsibility

2529 words - 10 pages exploit. There is, however, very little serious discussion about affirmative action underway; more often it is supplanted by buzzwords such as "quotas," "set-asides," and "reverse discrimination." A serious discussion of affirmative action must begin by addressing the question of collective responsibility. Affirmative action opponents firmly reject the notion of collective responsibility, claiming that it is unfair to punish those alive

Affirmative Action and Capital Punishment

1369 words - 6 pages narrowed the gap, but unfortunately the problem still persists. Affirmative action attempts to make up for this unfairness by prioritizing certain racial minorities along with giving women a bit of an advantage. Affirmative Action compensates the fact that racial minorities and women are more likely to be undervalued by employers by providing a greater opportunity for a higher education. I believe that we owe our racial minorities after all

Similar Essays

Affirmative Action And Racial Equality Essay

1709 words - 7 pages opposite. (3) Position Statement Moreover, affirmative action does advance racial equality evident by several aspects. Affirmative action has been effective in its pursuit to promote racial equality. During the past few decades, the U.S. Department of labor has reported a significant increase in the number of high-level management positions occupied by individuals of a minority group and females of equal merit! Today, five million

Why The Us Should Implement Bans On Racial Preferences Or Affirmative Action For Universities

3229 words - 13 pages before, change to racial preference policies proves to be difficult in terms of political costs. Both parties, historically, avoid the subject of reform for fear of being seen as racially insensitive. Even if racial preferences are unpopular amongst the majority of the population the tactics used by proponents are extreme. Many advocates of affirmative action such as the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) have resorted to demagoguery and say

Affirmative Action Is Racial Discrimination Essay

2776 words - 11 pages "affirmative action" was first used in a racial discrimination context in Executive Order No. 10,925 issued by President John F. Kennedy in 1961 (Brown). This executive order indicated that federal contractors should take affirmative action to ensure that job applicants and employees are treated "without regard to their race, creed, color, or national origin"(Brown). Kennedy's executive order implied equal opportunity and nothing else. The system

Affirmative Action: Michigan´S Law That Bans Use Of Racial Criteria In Admissions To Public Universities

1374 words - 6 pages affirmative action was originally created to instill racial equality and to correct centuries long discrimination against minorities, today its policies are obsolete and actually create a different form of discrimination by showing preference based on race/ethnicity rather than according to academic success. There is also concern that such preferential treatment might cause resentment and unfair treatment towards minority students by other fellow students