Impure Science: Aids, Activism, And The Politics Of Knowledge

905 words - 4 pages

Reading Response
Impure Science: AIDS, Activism, and the Politics of Knowledge
Steven Epstein is a sociologist whose expertise lies in health care inequalities and research on human subjects. Published in 1995, Impure Science: AIDS, Activism, and the Politics of Knowledge is a study of the politicized production of knowledge in the AIDS epidemic in the United States. This work shows Epstein’s interest in how expertise is constructed, the ways in which those who are considered “outsiders” can influence medicine, and how credibility is gained and lost. Epstein focuses on the question of how knowledge is produced through complex interactions among government agencies, pharmaceutical companies, scientists, medical people, and “treatment activists” to discover how knowledge about AIDS emerges out of what he calls "credibility struggles."
Epstein follows the “principle of symmetry”, a methodology for analyzing both mainstream and dissenting views in the same way; this differs from the usual approach which tends to accept a mainstream worldview as true, and then tries to explain other opinions as various kinds of errors. The principle of symmetry reads that the same types of conceptual tools ought to be used to explain both true and false beliefs.
For sources Epstein used medical journal articles, mass media news reports, articles in gay and lesbian press, activist documents, and government documents as well as extensive interviews with more than thirty researchers, activists, and government officials. He also attended many conferences, meetings, forums, demonstration, and other public events. He writes that his “fundamental analytical strategy has been to bring into critical juxtaposition contemporaneous records from different “social worlds”” (page 355). Epstein also explains that he would attend demonstrations and such because he felt that published sources can only tell part of the story and can sometimes conceal parts of the story.
The first part of Impure Science is titled The Politics of Causation and deals with the “consolidation of certainty” surrounding the AIDS hypothesis. Many nonscientists are unaware of and often hold misconceptions about the degree of certainty behind the knowledge that science generates. Through the descriptions of the discourse between the American scientist Robert Gallo and the French Scientist Luc Montagnier, along with the denial by Peter Duesberg of HIV’s role in the disease, we are able to see the social relations, assertions, and assessments that can direct scientific knowledge production.
The second longer section of the book is titled The Politics of Treatment and the primary concern here is the process by which knowledge producers gain credibility, the “credibility struggles”. The scientists in this were deemed the most credible source of knowledge on AIDS due to pre-existing notions and the legitimacy given to them by society. In contrast, the AIDS activists only...

Find Another Essay On Impure Science: AIDS, Activism, and the Politics of Knowledge

Impure Puritans Exposed in The Scarlet Letter and The Crucible

867 words - 3 pages novels has sinned, yet not everyone is punished for it. Among those who suffer the consequences of their actions are the people most proud of them, Hester Prynne and John Proctor. This common trait shows that if these people had not been so proud, they perhaps could have escaped their punishments, as Abigail did. This shows a weakness in the Puritan system of law, where many of the guilty go unpunished. It seems that it would not be difficult to be an impure Puritan.

The Impact of Ethical Decisions on the Discovery of Knowledge in the Natural Science and Art

1261 words - 5 pages “Science cannot stop while ethics catches up… and nobody should expect scientists to do all the thinking for the country” Elvin Charles Stakman ( The quote illustrates how science and ethics are interconnected but ethics is hindering what science can achieve. The knowledge issue I will be addressing is what impact do ethical decisions have on limiting the discovery of knowledge in the natural sciences and arts? One day in

Japanese-American Internment: The Impure Motives of Californians

1935 words - 8 pages American Academy of Political and Social Science 94 (1921): 104-10. Print. Gulick, Sidney Lewis. Hawaii’s American-Japanese Problem: A Description of the Conditions, A Statement of the Problems, and Suggestions for their Solution. Honolulu: Star-Bulletin, 1915. Print. Perl, Lila. Behind Barbed Wire: The Story of Japanese-American Internment during World War II. New York: Benchmark Books, 2003. Print. Roosevelt, Franklin Delano. Executive Order 9066

Frankenstein: The Danger in Knowledge, Science and Playing God

2160 words - 9 pages What is Frankenstein’s monster? Is the Monster a man? Is he a living, breathing demon? What does he represent? Is the Monster a representation of the dangers of playing with science? Is he representative of the dangers of pursuing knowledge? Alternatively, does he reveal to us the dangers of playing God? Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein uses Victor Frankenstein’s creation to expose the dangers of knowledge and playing God. Shelley exposes the

Nietzsche on Knowledge and Truth: Excerpt from the Gay Science

581 words - 2 pages Nietzsche's explanation of the origin of knowledge is one that deduces most attempts to error and misdirection. Nietzsche begins his account by attacking all past endeavours of intellect by asserting that, "over immense periods of time the intellect produced nothing but errors"(169). He continues by characterizing the progression of theories as "erroneous articles of faith, which were continually inherited"(169). He also systematically denies

The Way the Learning of Science Aids in the Structure of Society

1353 words - 5 pages .” .These two quotes outline what I have learned about individuals and society through the study of science and literature. Through studying different sciences, from biology to physics to chemistry, I have found that science is governed by theories and laws and work with limited theoretical possibilities. However, from literature I have found that it helps us understand what we know by clarification. In this essay I will present my knowledge issue by

AIDS and the Women of Africa

785 words - 4 pages . Her children will then be forced to drop out of school to start farming for their family. Dropping out of school reduces the amount of AIDS prevention education those children receive and can lead to those same children eventually contracting AIDS and dieing. With no one left with the knowledge of how to farm, their family can stave. It is an incredibly vicious cycle. The good news is that if we act with urgency, we have a great chance to

Origin and Evolution of the AIDS Virus

1328 words - 5 pages and the origin of AIDS”, Philosophical Transactions of The Royal Society, Paul M. Sharp and Beatrice H. Hahn, 2010 “The Challenge of Finding a Cure for HIV Infection”, Science Magazine, Douglas D. Richman, David M. Margolis, Martin Delaney, Warner C. Greene, Daria Hazuda, Roger J. Pomerantz, 2009

HIV and the Condition of AIDS

1559 words - 6 pages Introduction HIV has been a major global issue for over 100 years. It is estimated that 1.6 million people died as a result of this virus in 2012 (“Fact sheet”, 2012). Due to statistics such as the one I just cited, I decided to write this review essay on HIV and the condition of AIDS. As an up and coming scientist, I feel it is imperative that we strive to grow in our understanding of diseases, such as AIDS, so that we can do our part in

Conservation of Marine Biodiversity within the Framework of Impure Public Goods

1089 words - 5 pages good that is both rivalrous and excludable. It may seem that marine biodiversity is a type of public good, since they are in the vast ocean and everyone is entitled to their ownership. However, many marine biodiversity have tremendous economic values, and one person using it may constitute as another person not being able to use it. Thus, it is best described by the term “impure public goods”. Impure public goods, also known as “mixed public goods

Investigating the Attitudes and Behaviors of Generation Y Towards Environmental Activism in Australia

2070 words - 8 pages drastic and immediate action is imperative; this is a sentiment increasingly pervasive on a global scale. The movement to preserve and protect our planet’s natural environment and ecosystems has accordingly gained momentum, attributable to greater levels of awareness and knowledge on environmental issues. This can be credited to the progressive politicisation and routinisation of environmental issues, and ongoing media coverage (Tranter 2010

Similar Essays

The New Science Of Politics Essay

1039 words - 4 pages The New Science of Politics When discussing the new science of politics laid out in the Federalist papers, it is imperative to understand that proponents of the Constitution had various reasons for writing these papers, not the least of which was convincing critics that a strong central government that would not oppress but actually protect individual freedoms as well as encouraging the state of New York to agree to ratify the Constitution

The Life And Activism Of Angela Davis

1906 words - 8 pages The Life and Activism of Angela Davis I chose to do this research paper on Angela Davis because of her numerous contributions to the advancements of civil rights as well as to the women’s rights movement. I have passionate beliefs regarding the oppression of women and people of racial minorities. I sought to learn from Davis’ ideology and proposed solutions to these conflicts that pervade our society. As well, I hoped to gain historical

Knowledge From The Viewpoint Of Natural Science And Art

1551 words - 7 pages Introduction According to my understanding, knowledge is completely subjective, only existing in the mind of the beholder. Not only is the acquisition of knowledge limited by the tight lenses through which we view this world, to compound this, it is also limited by the conceptions created through the individual experiences of people and how these created ethical decisions limit the acceptability of certain pursuits. In the natural sciences

Is Science The Supreme Form Of Knowledge?

1459 words - 6 pages For some people science is the supreme form of all knowledge. Is this view reasonable or does it involve a misunderstanding of science or of knowledge?Science can be defined as the process of evaluating empirical knowledge (scientific method) and a global community of scholars where an organized body of knowledge is gained by the process and is carried by the community. Science today is considered one of the most reliable, accepted and trusted