In Defense Of Hylas And Support Of Locke

1243 words - 5 pages

In Defense of Hylas and Support of Locke


I wish to defend and support John Locke's "The Causal Theory of Perception" because it is a logical argument with many useful applications. Primarily, this argument allows us to make more objective judgments about the world we perceive - it allows us to more accurately see reality by telling us how to separate the object itself from our own opinions or qualitative value judgments about the object. However, just the fact that a particular theory is useful does not mean that the theory itself is correct, even though that might be the motive for trying to prove its correctness. Therefore, I must also address George Berkeley's argument, put forth by his character Philonous in Three Dialogues Between Hylas and Philonous, that "to exist is to be perceived."


To tackle Berkeley's argument, I will take Hylas and Philonous's Tree Argument. This is a nice variation on the common riddle of "If a tree falls in the middle of a forest, and no one is there to hear it, does it make a sound?" Philonous is trying to prove that everything that exists is perceived, and therefore exists only in the mind. If this is true, then nothing exists without the mind, and it is therefore pointless to distinguish between primary and secondary qualities as Locke does. Philonous challenges Hylas to conceive of any sensible object that exists without the mind. Hylas responds with the idea of a tree existing by itself, independent of, and unperceived by, any mind whatsoever. Philonous then points out that this is a contradiction - conceiving a thing that is unconceived. However, these two riddlers are failing to take into consideration one crucial element - time.


Now, I intend to prove that things can and do exist even though we do not perceive them. My argument rests on this presumption: It is possible for us to conceive things that do not exist and to conceive not to exist things that do exist, and that time allows us to see what really exists and what really does not exist, at the very least for some things. If we truly believe an object (for example, a chair) to exist, we will be able to see it, to touch it, to hear it's sound. We will be able to do all of the above until we have a reason to believe that it does not exist. Notice that I have included several different senses in this example, including the sense of touch. However well we might perceive this particular chair to exist, if it is not real, we will fall to the floor if we try to sit in it. That is because our action of sitting depends on the chair being solid and actually existing.


Now, let us imagine me walking from the patio of a friend's home into the den. I turn and face the house and walk towards the doorway, heading towards the nice comfortable sofa. Suddenly, I am knocked flat on my back. Looking up, I see the sun reflecting off a perfectly cleaned sliding glass door. Up until the moment I hit the glass, I had no idea that...

Find Another Essay On In Defense of Hylas and Support of Locke

Social contract in the view of Rousseau and Locke

1416 words - 6 pages English political theorist, John Locke focuses primarily on the framework of justifiable and workable government, all other issues and ideas as they relate to humanity can be explained and elaborated upon in that relationship. Locke also establishes the issues and viability relating to virtue. Almost the entire key members of the intellectual activity of the eighteenth century in England leads back to Locke. Locke was able to concisely describe

In Defense of Affirmative Action Essay

2658 words - 11 pages and engineering procurementbusiness.)Opposition of affirmative action is the same as defense of discrimination and/or racism. Given that there is no scientific evidence to support the theory of racism, there are no reasonable grounds to oppose affirmative action. Yet, people have tried to find loopholes in the law for as long as laws have existed. Seeing as the present discussion is not based on the criteria of opposing affirmative action, however

In Defense of Permissive Parenting

676 words - 3 pages In Defense of Permissive Parenting In the article “In Defense of Permissive Parenting” Tony Decouple addresses how parenting skills can be a great effect to children. According to a pair of new studies, they state how minor communication style can have an impact to children. A Mexican-American woman by the name of Xenia was in a store with her four years old son named Paulson; she had to battle his son over buying a soft drink. There are

In Defense of Medical Marijuana

920 words - 4 pages medical value and risk” (ProCon). For this reason, medical marijuana should be a considerable option in treating stress in cancer. The most bone chilling testimonies come from cancer survivors. "The chemo and radiation, gave me my life. And marijuana gave my life back to me," is a direct quote from Teresa Boomer of Tennessee in support of medicinal marijuana. Teresa Boomer is now cancer-free and an activist in seeking to reform laws pertaining to

In Defense of Historical Fiction

1372 words - 5 pages The genre of historical fiction novels can be subdivided into many categories and often crosses genres, such as historical mysteries and romances. The traditional definition of the historical fiction genre is “fiction set in the past” where the author is writing from research rather than personal experience. This definition leaves a lot of room for interpretation, controversy, and contradiction. Critics in the media, even when they praise

Locke and Hume on Inequalities of Distribution

1206 words - 5 pages Discuss, compare and contrast the ways in which Locke and Hume defend inequalities of distribution. Does either offer a more convincing defence? Why? This essay seeks to examine the inequalities of distribution of resources and the defences of these inequalities provided by John Locke, in Of Property , and David Hume in Of Justice . Both writings set out the scene in which their theories would evolve. Locke starts with the idea that

Accounts of Miracles and Their Support of Belief in God

841 words - 3 pages Accounts of Miracles and Their Support of Belief in God The definition of a miracle is a violation of the "laws of nature", it is an exception that is beyond all naturalistic explanations, meaning they must be explained supernaturally. So do accounts of miracles support the belief in God? Firstly, one must decided whether there is sufficient evidence to prove the existence of

Defense of the Insanity Defense

2558 words - 10 pages Defense of the Insanity Defense: John Hinckley Jr., Jeffery Dahmer, James Holmes, and Andrea Yates: all are perpetrators of violent crimes, and all claim insanity as the reason. In recent years, it seems that the verdicts of many major violent crimes have come down to whether the defendant is accountable for their actions or if they should be held Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity (NGRI). This verdict more commonly known as the Insanity Defense

In Support of Stem Cells

2254 words - 9 pages Though controversial in nature, the extraction, research, and use of human stem cells has been one of the most significant breakthroughs in modern science. The power within these programmable and adaptable cells promises a brighter future for medical advancement such as freedom for those burdened with diseases and disorders. The evidence and factual support for the use of stem cells conveys the gravity of this prospect. Stem cells come from a

In Support of Parenting Education

1070 words - 4 pages to create effective change. Still other parents are unaware that there is another way, a better way, of parenting. Parent education could help in all of these scenarios. The literature demonstrates that parenting interventions improve the quality of the relationship parents have with the children as well as improving child social behavior (Scott, O’Connor, Furth, Mathias, Price, and Doolan 2010). Programs have been particularly effective when

In Defense of the Study of Cryonics

1733 words - 7 pages also be disbursed through hospital brochures aimed at those with life threatening, incurable problems. By providing the targeted audience with information about the benefits of cryonics, knowledge of how cryonics helps society will be gained, common myths and disbelieves will be diminished, and support for cryonics will arise, which will help with erasing the negativity revolving around cryonics as well as with advancement in the field

Similar Essays

The Support Of Air Defense In Desert Shield And Desert Storm

1744 words - 7 pages could contact troops on the ground and inform them of the predicted impact locations. The 11th Brigade Air Defense Artillery, “The Imperial Brigade,” supplied the majority of the units using the Patriot weapon systems in Desert Shield and Desert Storm. (Kangas) The Brigade (BDE) would play a direct role in the success of Desert Shield and Desert Storm. Their support to the mission made important contributions to the liberation of

In Defense Of Consumerism Essay

696 words - 3 pages We as Americans celebrate the idea of a well educated populace. It is the general thought that a person who has been through the rigors of a formal education has a better understanding of the world around them. These alumni are more able to adapt to new situations and resolve them. They are better suited for the workplace, and are therefore more valuable to society. The authors in the two essays, In Defense of Elitism and On the Uses of a

In Defense Of Food Essay

1254 words - 5 pages about the health consequences of their food choices than we Americans-and no people suffer from as many diet-related problems. We are becoming a nation of orthorexics: people with an unhealthy obsession with healthy eating." (Pollan 8)Works CitedPollan, Michael. In Defense Of Food: An Eater's Manifesto. New York: Penguin, 2008.Print.

In Defense Of Abortion Essay

1639 words - 7 pages For hundreds of years women helped each other to abort their pregnancies. Without legal prohibitions, women in Europe and the United States provided abortions and trained each other to perform the procedures. In the past century different states had begun to outlaw any procedure that would terminate or avoid pregnancy. In 1973(?) the United States Supreme Court asserted a woman's constitutional right to abortion in determining Roe v. Wade