This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

In Defense Of The Use Of Folk Psychology In Audience Analysis

2953 words - 12 pages

In contrast with the academic preference for objectivity in writing and reading today, emotion and passionate belief were seen as both a prerequisite for and integral part of debate in ancient rhetoric. That is, issues were not worthy of discussion unless they divided people emotionally in Ancient Greece (Crowley and Hawhee 27). Aristotle maintains that emotional states of audiences are crucial in persuasion (31). Indeed, in his accounts of the emotional states of audiences, he never describes how to convince an impartial audience, possibly because such a task is far more difficult. Due to the importance placed on emotions, theories of audience in ancient rhetoric attempted to explain the characteristics of different archetypes of audiences that the rhetor may encounter and how to persuade each type. Despite Aristotle’s affinity for the sciences in his scholarship, he markedly departs from the scientific in his discussion of audience in Ars Rhetorica, relying heavily on folk psychology. In defense of Aristotle’s use of folk psychology, I posit that the practical nature of rhetoric aligns its theories better with intuitive theories of emotional states. To demonstrate this, it is necessary to: first, define folk psychology; second, illustrate that Aristotle indeed relied on folk psychology for his theories of audience; and third, discuss the benefits of folk psychology in a theory of audience.
Folk Psychology/Mindreading
While folk psychology can be defined in many ways, in this essay, I use it in the “mindreading” sense, in which it refers to “that set of cognitive capacities which include (but is not exhausted by) the capacities to predict and explain behavior” (Ravenscroft). Mindreading has long pervaded philosophical, cognitive, and psychological theories because of its prevalence in common thought (Ravenscroft). While the academics of modern cognitive science, psychology, and philosophy have largely departed from the beliefs of mindreading, it is evident that mindreading beliefs are still held by many non-academics due to its intuitive nature. Mindreading posits that the average person can explain and predict the general behaviour and emotional responses of other persons with a surprisingly high success rate (Ravenscroft). That is, many people can recognize another person’s emotional state — explained semantically through emotion-words — and predict how an action will affect another person’s future emotional state. This ability predominantly relies on commonly held beliefs and situational evidence that are acquired throughout a person’s life, and these experiences are used to evaluate behaviour without a specific theoretical framework (Ravenscroft). Mindreading, then, can be described as an intuition because it is a decidedly non-scientific approach.
Aristotle’s Audience and Mindreading
Aristotle certainly relied heavily on commonsense ideas of psychology in Ars Rhetorica, particularly in Book 2 where he argues that rhetors must understand...

Find Another Essay On In Defense of the use of Folk Psychology in Audience Analysis

In Defense Of Abortion Essay

1639 words - 7 pages For hundreds of years women helped each other to abort their pregnancies. Without legal prohibitions, women in Europe and the United States provided abortions and trained each other to perform the procedures. In the past century different states had begun to outlaw any procedure that would terminate or avoid pregnancy. In 1973(?) the United States Supreme Court asserted a woman's constitutional right to abortion in determining Roe v. Wade

In Defense of the Study of Cryonics

1733 words - 7 pages also be disbursed through hospital brochures aimed at those with life threatening, incurable problems. By providing the targeted audience with information about the benefits of cryonics, knowledge of how cryonics helps society will be gained, common myths and disbelieves will be diminished, and support for cryonics will arise, which will help with erasing the negativity revolving around cryonics as well as with advancement in the field

In Defense of the Cynic of Politics

2881 words - 12 pages Despite claims of ideals and words of promise, the decisions of a sovereign entity are fundamentally motivated by self-interest. The decisions of the leaders in Renaissance Italy were done for selfish reasons, as were those of ancient Athens, as have been those of the former Soviet Union and of the United States. When a decision needed to be made between what one’s words or ideals would say to do, and what is found to actually be in one’s best

Folk Psychology in Churchland’s Eliminative Materialism

2140 words - 9 pages suggests that we should abandon all thought of mental states. We understand mental concepts in terms of folk psychological ideas; it is indisputable that we have a folk psychology in the sense of a collection of ideas of mental states. However, we cannot use folk psychology to access the meanings of our mental concepts; we can recognize that we feel happy or sad, but we are unable to determine the meaning or origin of our feelings. For this reason

Critically analyse the use of Clinical Profiling or Criminal Investigative Analysis or Investigative Psychology in police investigation. Illustrat

2028 words - 9 pages of illustrating the actual influence of offender profiling using the investigative psychology method, let us have a look at a case where the use of the method made a consequent impact in the course of investigation, arrest and trial. BENEFITS OF INVESTIGATIVE PSYCHOLOGY IN INVESTIGATION As shown in the above case study, the different approach on a multi-disciplinary basis can provide better guidance and promote adoption and implementation of

Analysis of the Ways the Director Builds Suspense and Scares the Audience in Jaws

3944 words - 16 pages Analysis of the Ways the Director Builds Suspense and Scares the Audience in Jaws We studied the film “JAWS”, which was made by award winning director Steven Spielberg. ==================================================================== “JAWS” was based on Peter Benchley’s number one best-selling novel in 1974. The Plotline for the film is about a police officer, a scientist, and a grizzled sailor who set out

How Does Miller Use The Ending Of Each Act To Make The Audience Feel The Madness In Salem?

1523 words - 7 pages How does Miller use the ending of each act to make the audience feel the madness in Salem?Miller is able to portray the madness of Salem in a variety of ways, throughout the whole of the play however the ending of each act allows the audience to fully feel the hysteria. By incorporating changes of key themes and ideas as well as using links throughout the text and a variety of dramatic techniques towards the end of each act, Miller is able to

In Defense of Affirmative Action

2658 words - 11 pages and engineering procurementbusiness.)Opposition of affirmative action is the same as defense of discrimination and/or racism. Given that there is no scientific evidence to support the theory of racism, there are no reasonable grounds to oppose affirmative action. Yet, people have tried to find loopholes in the law for as long as laws have existed. Seeing as the present discussion is not based on the criteria of opposing affirmative action, however

In defense of abortion review

1042 words - 5 pages groups. The population, theoretically, would decrease so much so that it would become an annihilation of that population which would probably be concentrated in one ethnicity or demographic—ultimately eugenics. Therefore regarding the legality of abortions, there needs to be some requirements in place to limit the amount of abortions that occur to prevent possible yielding of these negative effects such as eugenics. In the article A Defense of

In Defense of Medical Marijuana

920 words - 4 pages Marijuana can serve a very profound medical purpose. In fact, many doctors have praised the use of marijuana or “cannabis” (for medicinal purposes) because it has proven effective in alleviating stress. Lester Grinspoon, MD stated in a Boston Globe article that "Doctors and nurses have seen that for many patients, cannabis is more useful, less toxic, and less expensive than the conventional medicines prescribed” (ProCon). Specifically, marijuana

In Defense of Permissive Parenting

676 words - 3 pages In Defense of Permissive Parenting In the article “In Defense of Permissive Parenting” Tony Decouple addresses how parenting skills can be a great effect to children. According to a pair of new studies, they state how minor communication style can have an impact to children. A Mexican-American woman by the name of Xenia was in a store with her four years old son named Paulson; she had to battle his son over buying a soft drink. There are

Similar Essays

Use Of The Battered Woman Defense In Canada

1776 words - 7 pages unprotected and extreme measures to deal with a situation are ok? Did courts in Canada give a way that women who deliberately plan to kill their husbands on false allegations can use the battered woman defense and get away with it as in the Nicole case. Should the battered woman defense be a legal defense? In Angelina Napolitano case she was psychologically damaged and deemed it the only way out of her situation. In the Nicole Doucet case she

In Defense Of Literacy Essay

1020 words - 5 pages In “In Defense of Literacy,” Berry explains, that we live in a country that everyone has the privilege to have an education, that it is ridiculous to have to defend literacy yet he still has to do so. Literacy, is the ability to read and write. As well as the ability to think critically. If we didn't have the ability to think critically, reading and writing would just be skills, to move words around. Anyone that’s ever read and written  knows

In Defense Of Consumerism Essay

696 words - 3 pages We as Americans celebrate the idea of a well educated populace. It is the general thought that a person who has been through the rigors of a formal education has a better understanding of the world around them. These alumni are more able to adapt to new situations and resolve them. They are better suited for the workplace, and are therefore more valuable to society. The authors in the two essays, In Defense of Elitism and On the Uses of a

In Defense Of Food Essay

1254 words - 5 pages about the health consequences of their food choices than we Americans-and no people suffer from as many diet-related problems. We are becoming a nation of orthorexics: people with an unhealthy obsession with healthy eating." (Pollan 8)Works CitedPollan, Michael. In Defense Of Food: An Eater's Manifesto. New York: Penguin, 2008.Print.