‘In Marina Carr’s Portia Coughlan The Past Is Inextricably Bound Up With The Present.’ Discuss

1160 words - 5 pages

Throughout Marina Carr’s Portia Coughlan it is clear that Portia is a woman who is infatuated by the events and misfortunes of her past. When we first meet her in the opening scene it is clear that she is a distressed and deeply haunted woman “whose legacy is rich only in horror” (Dean, 1997). Her past is haunting her marriage, her relationship with her children and her day to day life. The continuing ghostly presence of her long departed brother immerses her back into the past rendering her present life unimportant and somewhat of a burden. Throughout the play events from the past rear their heads and it is clear that “Portia is fighting blind against a past kept hidden from her” (King, 1997).

Throughout the play the Belmont River plays a central role in connecting Portia to Gabriel and the harrowing events of the past that consume her. The river flows through the characters’ lives and is the location of Gabriel throughout the entire play. Portia regularly seeks solace at the riverside, “land she fiercely claims as her family's own and the scene of Gabriel's suicide fifteen years ago” (Fitzpatrick, 1997). When she meets Damus Halion by the banks of the river she tells him “I come here because I’ve always come here and I reckon I’ll be comin’ here long after I’m gone. I’ll lie here when I’m a ghost and smoke ghost cigarettes and watch ye earthlin’s goin’ about yeer pointless days” (1.3). The river and drowning are regularly talked about by not only Portia but other characters in the play. Portia’s mother, Marianne makes reference to both when she visits Portia “And where’s your children? Playin’ round the Belmont River, I suppose. You be lucky they don’t fall in and drown themselves one of these days” (1.5). It is clear that it is not just Portia whose life is affected by the past. Marianne is a deeply bitter and guilty woman who can’t seem to accept the role she may have played in her son’s death. She and Portia constantly come to blows over Gabriel and the circumstances of his death “I don’t want to hear you talkin’ about him. You sully him on me always” (3.5). Portia, Gabriel and the Belmont River have become “indistinguishably merged” (Maxwell, 2007).

All of Portia’s current relationships are a direct link to Gabriel and the past. Her affair with Damus Halion is a half-hearted one that she believes somehow connects her with Gabriel because “He knew Gabriel” (1.5). She has no interest in him besides this link with the past. Even her marriage to Raphael is a direct link to her past and her strong unwavering connection to Gabriel. She makes it clear that she didn’t marry him for his money or because her parents wanted her to, she tells her mother “the only reason I married Raphael was because of his name, a angel’s name, same as Gabriel’s, and I thought be osmosis or just wishin’ that one’d take on the qualities of the other” (1.5). Her relationship with her own children is deeply affected by her fear and her natural maternal bond with...

Find Another Essay On ‘In Marina Carr’s Portia Coughlan the past is inextricably bound up with the present.’ Discuss

The Great Gatsby: “The Past is Forever in the Present”

1266 words - 5 pages Time remains a universal continuation of the past into the present and bears a strong hold on the future. The destruction of satisfaction in history withholds the contentment of the future with an impeding sense of unalterable guilt. In The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald demonstrates “the past is forever in the present” through numerous literary and narrative techniques, suggesting that memories serve as crucial components in the development

Forgiving is the Past, Present and Future

725 words - 3 pages perpetrator. He remains close to the idea that when someone is seeking forgiveness they become vulnerable to harsh criticism. In seeking forgiveness the perpetrator becomes subject to scrutiny and rejection but if they are willing to expose their wrongdoings they believe there is a future for the relationship. Being true to the past brings acceptance to the present and builds upon that future. He later goes on to state that working towards

"The Past Effects in the Present"

1887 words - 8 pages become unconscious. According to Freud's theory, " Unconscious state- reveals conflicts of protagonist and sometimes creates and/or transferred from the author's own troubled states"(Freud1). Holden is his own problem.He has the opportunity to leave his past behind him, but instead he chooses to let it affect him in his future, that causes trouble for him as he approaches his academics with flunking out, failing his class courses, and having no

when is war worth it; the conflict with iraq present and past

694 words - 3 pages country must b taken into account. Many times in the past, the United States has gone to war with other nations to prevent the spread of communism or to support a group that promotes democracy. This not only helps the other nations, but helps the United States to gain allies for the future. Another major issue concerning the historical beliefs of a nation is human rights. If another country's customs interfere with a person's ability to live a

Discipline In The Classroom: Past And Present

1400 words - 6 pages Discipline in the Classroom: Past and Present Throughout the history of classroom education, many different types of disciplinary systems have been applied by teachers and other authority figures in schools for the sole purpose of controlling student behavior. These systems include corporal punishment, psychological abuse or neglect, and assertive discipline. Although two of these three topics are illegal at this time, they were all

Digital Media in the Past and Present

1159 words - 5 pages Digital Media in the Past and Present In today’s world digital media are everywhere, TV, newspapers, advertisements, and magazines. Almost everywhere you look you will find some sort of digital technology. Digital technology has come along way since the beginning of its time in. Although computers were invented long before; digital technology didn’t start to shine its light until the early 80’s. Originally, NASA developed digital imaging for

Television Censorship in the Past and Present

1988 words - 8 pages Television Censorship in the Past and Present Typing in the web address "http://www.censorship.com", I begin my search for information regarding the controversial subject. After a few seconds of waiting for the site to load, a black background comes up, with black font displaying the message: "This site is not accessible because it is categorized as: Sex, Violence, Language." I immediately highlight the web address and annoyingly thrash at

the past and present in five years

765 words - 4 pages The Present and Past Five Years of my Life Throughout a young adult’s life there are many things that can drastically change in five year time period. In fact, I believed to be the age of twenty-three years old waiting to see what the world is about. Like many young adults planning for the future perhaps I can characterize my myself at twenty three irresponsible individual with any goals set for my future . As for my present age of twenty

Segregation in the Past and Present

1149 words - 5 pages the Rosa Parks incident and the start of the Civil Rights Movement. Before this, whites in the south would separate themselves from the colored folks. Giving themselves separate diners, bathrooms, stores, etc. African Americans have the liberty to move around freely today with nothing to separate then from the whites as there was before. Of course there is still segregation going on today in the world of not only the African Americans, but Latinos

Martial Law in the Past and Present

788 words - 4 pages almost secretly under the controversy with “Duck Dynasty” star Phil Robertson, as “it is a huge and egregious assault against our democracy. It overturns over 200 years of law, which has kept the military out of domestic policing.” Like in “Pasambang Bayan,” the government is instituting a state of martial law (or at the very least a policy similar to it) in response largely to large-scale threats from uncivil forces. Where in “Pasambang Bayan

Walter Benjamin and the past disassociating with present

2521 words - 10 pages In Walter Benjamin’s Berlin Childhood Around 1900, he applies a variety of concepts with respect to time: past, present, and future. The concepts are highlighted in his vignettes: “Victory Column”, “The Telephone”, and “Butterfly Hunt”. Benjamin attempts to imbue his writing with a different structure of time from what was conventional. He perceives history as a section of moments, and each moment is an integral whole in its own right, making

Similar Essays

Car In The Rain In What Way Are Desire And Identity Inextricably Bound Up With Time? Essay

5854 words - 24 pages sees. Hemingway knows that identity is a problem bound up with our imagination. It is an image, a mental fiction which we construct and into which we project ourselves. In the mirror, the girl/wife sees herself the way she would like to look in the future, that is to say with long hair. That image remains, however, extremely tenuous, as if she knew that she is paralysed by her present situation and that she will never be able to reach that state

Discuss The Status Of Women In Africa, Past And Present. Is It Getting Better Or Worse

511 words - 2 pages all ready working there, or be willing to give up part of their salary to the person that is hiring her. It is reasons like this why you see so many women in Africa turn to prostitution in order to make money to survive.I believe that over time and the more women the step forward and take a stand against gender inequality will the situation in Africa begin to improve. The number of women going on to college has increased and you are starting to see more women in positions of power through out the countries of Africa. Over time and with more and more women getting involved and becoming educated the less you will see of gender inequality in Africa.

Discuss Law, The Youth Criminal Justice System Past And Present

3441 words - 14 pages Youth System of Justice, Past and PresentYouth crime happens to be one of the highest controversial issues in the Canadian politics. The fact that youth crime is quite common in Canada is appalling, there are disagreements concerning how to treat youths in the situation of the criminal system. (Brennan and Dauvergne, 2010) Although we all know the best approach that can be used to address youth offenders deals with strictness and sternness of

Discuss The Impact Of The Past Upon The Present In Both "Persuasion" By Jane Austen And "The Magic Toyshop" By Angela Carter, From The Point Of View Of Both Characterisation And Plot

2579 words - 10 pages . Restoring her past, her love for Wentworth means she gains her youth, and also her character back. While the past keeps Melanie back, it is a renewal of a past love that moves Anne forward.In terms of the past impacting the present in the plots of each novel, it certainly opens up new perspectives for Austen to play with in terms of style, thus directly influencing the perspectives in her plot. A renewal of a love past makes a more interesting and