In Political, Cultural And Social Terms The May Fourth Movement Was Far More Important Than The 1911 Revolution. Discuss.

2899 words - 12 pages

The 1911 Revolution led by Dr. Sun Yat Sen is one of the most significant events in the history of China. It marked an end to the world's most remarkable span of imperial history, dating back 2133 years when Shi Huangdi first unified China (Gascoigne, 2003: 204). However, the change from autocratic monarchy to republic did not bring about the sort of fundamental political, social or cultural changes that one would normally expect from a revolution that smashed a 2000 year old feudal monarchy. Many scholars argue that the 1911 Revolution was not in fact a revolution at all. This statement is very much debatable, but conventional wisdoms asserts that the 1911 Revolution did not fulfil its potential.Given these circumstances how true is the deeply held view that the political, cultural and social impacts of the May Fourth Movement were far more important than the 1911 Revolution? Mao Zedong was certainly amongst those who championed the role of the May Fourth Movement in the development of China, he wrote in January 1940: "Its outstanding historical significance is to be seen in a feature which was absent from the Revolution of 1911, namely its thorough and uncompromising opposition to imperialism as well as to feudalism" (Mao Ze Dong, 1940: x, quoted in Mackerras, 2006: 28-29).In order to answer this question I will examine the significance of the 1911 Revolution and explain that these merely planted the seeds for a series of events of much greater historical significance, namely the May Fourth Movement, whose political, social and cultural influences had far greater immediate and long-term consequences.However before examining the significance of the 1911 Revolution it is important to understand the political climate on which it was founded, by examining the collapse of the Qing dynasty. (Spence, 1996: 48-53) provides an account of the previous few years before the 1911 Revolution where many revolutionary groups within China became allied with the republican movement of Sun Yat-Sen. Dr. Sun Yat-Sen called for the overthrow of the Qing dynasty and the establishment of a democratic republic. The anti-Qing movement developed with increasing momentum and brought about a succession of uprisings in Sichuan (over the government's railway policy), followed by a rebellion of the soldiers of Wu Chang in Hupei, leading to revolutionaries seizing important centres all over the country in October 1911. In rapid succession province after province declared themselves independent of the Manchu Court, and on February of 1912 it was announced from the palace that the child emperor Puyi was abdicating. The development of a Constitutional Republic in China had begun.(Sheng, 1983 and Yu, 1962) argue that despite these developments the new republican government never really got off the ground and that the 1911 Revolution was a failure. It is certainly easy to accept this point of view given the immediate consequences of the Revolution; namely the collapse of the Qing...

Find Another Essay On In political, cultural and social terms the May Fourth Movement was far more important than the 1911 Revolution. Discuss.

Was any one of these reasons more important than the others in Hitler's rise to power?

1178 words - 5 pages Question 3. Was any one of these reasons more important than the others in Hitler's rise to power?The Treaty of Versailles was important to Hitler's rise to power because, it was the cause of Germany's downfall. Hitler felt very strongly about the Treaty of Versailles and thought the terms were unfair towards Germany. Many German people also despised the treaty, and wanted something done about it. Hitler was there to turn to. He wanted to

Spring Moon by Bette Bao Lord and the May Fourth Movement

909 words - 4 pages externally, get rid of the national traitors at home", "Do away with the 'Twenty-One Demands'" and "Don't sign the Versailles Treaty"(May Fourth Movement). They demanded for the traitors Tsao Rulin, Zhang Zongziang and Lu Zongyu, who held important posts as diplomats, to be punished. Tsao managed to flee in the midst of confusion, but the Japanese minister, Chang, was not so lucky and was ruthlessly beaten. Parts of Tsao's house were burned and

?Revolutions Occur When Governments are Weak.? Discuss in Terms of the Russian Revolution and One Other

1852 words - 7 pages with which the corrupt and weak government cannot cope. However this is rarely the case as, ?the simple fact of oppression does not lead to revolution.? In fact the reality is quite the opposite. As Alexis de Tocquevile pointed out, ?revolutions seldom start when things are bad, rather when they are getting better.? This may seem contradictory but if one considers Aristotle?s principle, ?that the distribution of political power tends to approximate

Was force more important than persuasion in Mussolini's consolidation of power between 1924 and 1929? (In which I argue the other side)

1942 words - 8 pages . Therefore, although Mussolini used both force and persuasion, in the consolidation of power force was the more important factor. The type of force most associated with the Fascist regime is squadristi violence, but force is also synonymous with the removal of choice; for example, through censorship and the banning of political parties of the opposition.The most immediately threatening institutions over which Mussolini needed to assert his control

Theme of the Nineteenth Century: Revolution and Political Movement

1029 words - 4 pages The main theme of the nineteenth century is definitely political movement and revolution (seeing that one leads to the other). Huge steps forward were made during the nineteenth century. One of the events that started this century off on the right foot was the French Revolution. It took a lot of brutal killing, but in the end it had far-reaching results. The bourgeois and landowning classes came to be the dominant power. Another was the Women's

Discuss how social and cultural contexts influence children's learning and use of more than one language or variety

2540 words - 10 pages As English becomes more and more of an international language with the establishment of local varieties in different countries, bilingualism and multilingualism has an emergent social and cultural role in children being increasingly expected to master the art of having to speak and converse in more than one language.In this essay, I will begin by discussing how Julian Roux has acquired two languages under the cultural influence of his mother and

The Fourth Revolution (An Analysis of the more radical idea between Jane Austen and Mary Wollstonecraft)

1075 words - 5 pages the reasons that Wollstonecraft’s essay is much more radical and rebellious than Jane Austen’s essay. Nowhere in Jane Austen’s story does she go out and state this. Meanwhile, Wollstonecraft states, “And this desire making mere animals of them, when they marry they act as such children may be expected to act, they dress, they paint, and nickname God’s creatures… Can they be expected to govern a family with judgment, or take care of the poor

The Zionist Movement in the Land of Israel: Political and Cultural

895 words - 4 pages Before taking this course, I was under the impression that Zionism was a unified social movement; however, YPS’ lecture and the course readings highlighted that there were actually several factions within the Zionist movement, the main ones being political Zionism and cultural Zionism. Both political and cultural Zionism sought to return the Jewish people to the Land of Israel, and viewed the formation of a Jewish state as a solution to improve

"UN activity in the Korean War was nothing more than a cover for US anti-communism." Discuss

1106 words - 4 pages through MacArthur. However, there is still substantial evidence to show either than UN activity was divorced from US influence and/or motivations to a certain degree, or that the UN can be excused from its dependence on the US.The fact cannot be ignored that the US constituted more than half of the UNC, and was moreover in the hands of a US officer accountable only to the US. However, in light of another fact that the UN's political career was

"The French Revolution was a radical political revolution with conservative social consequences". Do you agree? Why?

1721 words - 7 pages revolution would suggest that although the political aspect of the revolution was quite radical, it failed to make any lasting or meaningful changes, leaving more people not only worse off than they were in the old regime but also failing to change any aspect of the social structure. The clergy would perhaps be the most obvious group of persons who suffered throughout the revolution. From the beginning they lost their income and wealth from

Do you think the actions and skills of Hitler and the Nazi Movement were more important in winning support than factors outside their control such as the economic depression?

1232 words - 5 pages The gradual incline of the support for Nazism and Hitler, during the 1930's in particular, can be said to be the result of several factors - those within the control of Hitler and the ones outside of his power, although he was often able to manipulate these to his advantage. I believe that such external issues played a great role in propelling Hitler to the forefront of German politics, a process which may have been otherwise drawn out or

Similar Essays

May Fourth Movement And Beyond Essay

1058 words - 4 pages Mao Zedong, the prominent leader of the Cultural Revolution and one of the innovators of the People’s Republic of China, once declared, “Classes struggle, some classes triumph, others are eliminated. Such is history; such is the history of civilization for thousands of years.” By the time the Qing Dynasty met its inevitable downfall in 1919, a new set of radicals started protesting of a new form of government on May Fourth. This movement, known

The American Revolution Was More Sucessful Than The British And French Revolution

558 words - 2 pages result of the operation. Another would be the long term result of that operation. In the American Revolution, the colonists were fighting Britain, which at the time was one of the most powerful nations in the world. It had the best navy in the world, along with one of the largest and most professional army in the world. In comparison, the American colonists had small militias that was not professionally trained, not organized in a national way

"The Roaring Twenties" Was More Superficial Than Substantial. Discuss

868 words - 3 pages not share in the prosperity as they could not afford it with their low wages.Massive immigration, occurring in the war years, was the breeding ground for even more discrimination. Immigrants had to be content with the worst paid jobs and thus these new "Americans" did not share in the boom either.The poor in general were discriminated because of the Republican attitude of "rugged individualism". Republican mindset such as this was common in this

Discuss How The Six Macro Environments (Demographic, Economic, Natural, Technological, Political, And Social/Cultural) Forces May Affect The Marketing Of A Drink Or Food Company

1409 words - 6 pages Discuss how the six macro-environments (demographic, economic, natural, technological, political, and social/cultural) forces may affect the marketing of a drink or food company.Companies and their suppliers, marketing intermediaries, customers, competitors, and publics all operate in a macro-environment of forces and trends that shape opportunities and pose threats. Within the rapidly changing global picture, the firm must monitor six major