In Praise Of Big Brother: Why We Should Learn To Stop Worrying And Love Government Surveillance

1897 words - 8 pages

Part I:
James Stacey Taylor's article, "In Praise of Big Brother: Why We Should Learn to Stop Worrying and Love Government Surveillance" begins reviewing the concept of "Big Brother" as it was originally presented in George Orwell's 1984. The Big Brother started off as a fictional character in 1984-- a dictator of Oceania within a totalitarian state. Set within a society in which everyone is under complete surveillance by the authorities, mainly by telescreens, the people are constantly reminded of this by the phrase “Big Brother is watching you” (Wikipedia) . Taylor goes on to explain some examples of recent surveillance technology and how it is applied in lives today. An interesting note and comparison between today’s technology and that of the telescreens in 1984, is that people could be sure that they could not be watched by Big Brother’s telescreens by going out of the cities into the country, where they only had to take care that their conversations were not monitored by hidden microphones (Taylor 227). He contrasts the two, highlighting the fact that “Such an escape is not impossible, for spy satellites can be used to monitor people wherever they go” (277). From there, Taylor perpetuates the framework for his position on the Big Brother notion. Taylor argues that, "rather than opposing such an expansion of surveillance technology, its use should be encouraged -- and not only in the public realm" (227). Taylor’s argument presented in a more formal construction is as follows:

i. If is ever morally permissible for the State to secure information about past events, then it is morally permissible for it to do so through the use of surveillance devices.
ii. It is morally permissible for the State to secure information about past events.
:. Therefore, the State is morally permitted to use surveillance devices.

Consequently, Taylor concludes with that, given this, the State is in principle morally permitted to place its citizens under constant surveillance (228). This only reaffirms his thesis that the “State should place all of its citizens under surveillance at all times and in all places, including their offices, classrooms, shops – and even their bedrooms” (227). To support his conclusion and to quell alarms at the notion of constant surveillance, Taylor reiterates the point that, “in certain circumstances, it is morally permissible for the Stat to secure information about past events” (228). He gives a few criminal trial examples to saturate this claim, such as the State being morally permitted to compel witnesses to testify about past events; however, if the State can only use hindsight to decide what information it is morally permitted to have access to, becoming clear only after the fact what is relevant to solve a crime or judging mitigating circumstances. This brings his argument full circle, showing a situation in which the State could use preemptively gathered information through surveillance retroactively, making it...

Find Another Essay On In Praise of Big Brother: Why We Should Learn to Stop Worrying and Love Government Surveillance

Should "Big Brother" be cancelled? Essay

1590 words - 6 pages Many people think that Big Brother is a waste of time and that it is "entertainment for animals". A TV critic wrote into a newspaper and said horrific things about it. An example of a comment he used was, "This show is doing nothing but attracting weirdo's and odd people. Has the world gone mad and if so, how do we stop such sheer disgrace?" My reply to this terrible statement is that it is not a disgrace. OK! It might be attracting a few

why do we need to learn english

631 words - 3 pages . As technology advances, keeping track of modern devices is necessary, since the language used in the devices is English. During my university hunt I have enlightened myself that, all the universities around the world require the knowledge of English at least the fundamental level, far more they ask to pass English test such as ‘IELTS TOEFL’ Why do we need to learn English? The answer is simple, path! I love to read wisdom quotes and one I would

"Why wasn't the Provisional Government able to stop Lenin and the Bolsheviks in 1917?"

1209 words - 5 pages The Provisional Government wasn't able to stop Lenin and the Bolsheviks in 1917 because of its inability to gain support from all sections of the population. Many factors contributed to the Provisional Governments downfall. Most importantly was their decision to continue the war, their failure to act upon the urgent social and economic problems, the fact that they were weakened by the actions and authority of the Petrograd Soviet, and the rising

Why we Should Love the Non Lover

993 words - 4 pages Why we Should Love the Non Lover Loving happens as natural as the rising of the sun. At some point in our lives, we all profess to love someone or something. For as long as the word and notion of love has existed, there have been innumerable attempts to explain just what love is and whom we should or should not love. Even the Bible, commands its believers to love their neighbors, family, friends, and enemies as they love themselves. The

Smoking: Life Or Stupidity? What does smoking do to you and others? Why should we stop smoking? What does smoking lead to?

557 words - 2 pages should quit smoking is that many people are dying of cancer. For example, the stats say that in the United States six out of ten people are dying everyday of lung cancer. This disease is killing people if it is not detected right away. Another reason to quit smoking is heart disease and its costs. For example, many people suffer from heart failure, but even though they know about smoking and its dangers, they do not stop until they become ill. In

Why do We Need to Learn About History

1603 words - 7 pages to have an impact on the way in which the community we live in behaves? While looking at history, psychology, reason, sense perception and emotion, we will see that history isn’t necessarily the study of the past and that human scientists are not necessarily looking to change the future. In order to determine the purpose of human scientists, we should analyze whether the purpose of history is linked to the purpose of science or not. Despite the

Torture: Why It Should Stop

932 words - 4 pages Torture: Why It Should Stop Torture, the most extreme form of human violence, resulting in both physical and psychological consequences. A technique of interrogation that has been proven time and time again to not only be ineffective but also a waste of time. Studies have shown that not only does torture psychologically damage the mind of the victim, but also can hurt the inflictor. If there is proof that torture is useless, why do we still use

The lessons we should learn from the battle of Uhud

736 words - 3 pages The lessons we should learn from the battle of Uhud The battle of Uhud has great significance in the history of Muslims. This war was fought in the guidance of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) where Meccans attacked the forces of Muslims in Madinah. This battle was fought on 3rd Shawwal 3 AH according to Islamic calendar. The Quraish’s perspective to fight this war was to take revenge from Muslims for the defeat of battle of Badr which they thought they

Live and Learn: Why we have college by Louis Menand

1217 words - 5 pages global economy by our nation is the force behind the purpose of higher education in our culture. References Hutcheson, P. (2011). Goals for United States higher education: from democracy to globalisation. History Of Education, 40(1), 45-57. Lindsey, T. (2013). The Likelihood of Higher-Education Reform. Society , 236-244. doi:10.1007/s12115-013-9649-x Menand, L. (2011). Live and Learn: Why we have college. Retrieved March 10, 2014, from http://www.newyorker.com/arts/critics/atlarge/2011/06/06/110606crat_atlarge_menand?printable=true&currentPage=all#ixzz2wLtYDJ49

This essays is in regard to the comparitive psychology career (study/comparison of animal behavior to humans) Should we really study animal behavior to learn more on humans???

649 words - 3 pages of the century that comparative psychology would develop and become more recognized. Here a key issue was raised in which the author refers to the question of whether the investigation of the animal mentality should be studied for just that reason or to help us learn more of human behavior. Furthermore, many of the studies have been focused clearly on animal instinct and nothing of its relation to human activity. (Dewsbury, 2000) Programs such as

Misundertanding of Algebra: Why We Should Continue to Have It in Our Math Programs

2745 words - 11 pages , students and parents arguing if they should even learn algebra. One of the reasons is that many U.S. students are failing algebra in high school and college. Algebra is the minimum requirement for all students in high school and a basic requirement in college and universities. To ask to change the requirement would mean a big reform to be made and has to be accepted nationwide. As we look at the misunderstandings of algebra, we should look at why it

Similar Essays

Lost In The Funhouse: Or How I Learned To Stop Worrying And Love The Lack

1919 words - 8 pages novel begins within the self-consciousness of Ambrose Mensche, who is looking to order the discrepancies of his life and cope with his own self-awareness through the act of writing his autobiography. In “Ambrose, His Mark”, we learn that Ambrose was not named for a long time, and that the name he eventually received was little more than arbitrary. It is not known whether his mark is a diabolic or fortuitous sign, he is marked by ambiguity rather

Stanley Kubrick’s Dr. Strangelove Or: How I Learned To Stop Worrying And Love The Bomb

2201 words - 9 pages Stanley Kubrick’s 1964 film Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb presents a satire of the Cold War and nuclear warfare. The film stars comedian Peter Sellers in three different roles, including the president, a Royal Air Force officer, and the title character of Dr. Strangelove—a character who does not play a major role in the action until the final scene of the film. The film itself was adapted by Stanley Kubrick

Dr. Strangelove Or: How I Learned To Stop Worrying And Love The Bomb

767 words - 3 pages the world by the U.S and the Soviet Union could have occurred in a real nuclear all out wars, which brings frightening thoughts to mind. Are we in control of our weapons? And why might a doomsday device be a logical step in the mind of the Soviet?Why the atomic weapon was even made in the first place and how do you justify the use of it? The movie explores some of the questions which people must have faced everyday in the 1960's. The American and

Why We Should Stop Extinction Essay

2262 words - 9 pages . During the winter of 2006-2007 a quarter of U.S. beekeepers lost between 30 percent and 90 percent of their hives. Most people don’t think twice about the extinction of random animals they have only ever seen in zoos if at all. Some might ask “why should we care”? We should care because if the extinction of animals continues at its current rate our entire ecosystem is in jeopardy. As evidenced above even one species is extremely important to the