In Recreating History: Challenges In Balancing Accuracy And Emotiveness

1637 words - 7 pages

When working with early music, modern performers face challenges regarding stylistic and historical accuracy, given limited information on past performances, as well as notable differences in instruments available, technique, and performance practice. Furthermore, they must decide between different approaches that may better reflect the historical sound or intention of past performers, or choose to blend such extremes, creating varied interpretations.
Such challenges manifest explicitly when modern performs attempt to recreate medieval music, such as Gregorian chants. While modern scholars have deciphered most of medieval notations, chant melodies were primarily passed down through oral transmission, while the manuscripts simply served as reminders (HWM 37). Therefore, the exact way in which these chants were sung cannot be recovered. Modern iterations of chants usually preserve the tradition of employing all male voices, and exude appropriate solemnity in execution, even throughout intricate, melismatic passages meant for skilled soloists to heighten the glorification of God.
The limited accessibility to period instruments from the medieval era also contribute to the challenges in modern performances. Clues to historical performance practice, however, can often be found in contemporary art, such as pictures that illustrate the use of vielle, or fiddle and tambourines in instrumental accompaniment to medieval dance (WT 49). Passages accompanying Raimbaut’s works in chansonniers also suggest that troubadour songs such as his Kalenda maya are rooted in dance music, such as the estampie (WT 49). This type of information gives modern performers clues such as appropriate tempo and prominence of the singers. In a live performance by The Ivory Consort, for instance, the singers do not serve as the primary focus throughout the piece. Instead, the piece features more instrumental than sung parts, and keeps a constant beat that recalls its dance origin.
In considering the past context of these songs, modern performers can further inform their interpretation. For instance, in the early thirteenth century, musicians at the Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris developed motets as a brand new genre, which became popular in both sacred and secular compositions (HWM 95). One of its most prominent traits is the added duplum in new text of Latin or French. Combined as a whole, the complex parts and different languages were difficult to comprehend, as the genre was meant for the elite, most educated audience. Secular motets, in particular, were often performed for individual entertainment (HWM 95). In understanding the source of this complexity, modern performers can approach the music knowing its purpose, and interpret it with appropriate effect.
A similar understanding can be applied to later vocal works, such as Machaut’s chansons during the fourteenth century. Rondeaux such as Rose, liz, printemps, verdure were speculated to be “most often performed as...

Find Another Essay On In Recreating History: Challenges in Balancing Accuracy and Emotiveness

Health Achivements and Challenges in Bhutan

1250 words - 5 pages to him. The key aspect of his talk was to give a brief historical background on health and disease in Bhutan. He also highlighted about the modern medicine and its effectiveness. According to Dr. Tshering, (2014) his main aim of delivering the lecture was to give awareness on health progress, health achievements and the challenges and issues while providing free medical services in Bhutan. He further states that the scattered population and

Trends and Challenges in Human Resource Management

2915 words - 12 pages Trends & Challenges in Human Resource PAGE 1 Human resources have been a beneficial aspect to several organizations globally and recently, has been considered one of the most important job functions for many successful corporations. Hiring and retaining qualified employees have previously been a challenging task and with the help of human resource professionals, seeking and maintaining conceptual employees has now become a priority for top

Challenges in the Classroom: ADHD and Autism

1544 words - 6 pages The modern classroom has many challenges that face it. Shrinking budgets, less parental involvement, higher expectations, and growing class sizes, just to name a few. If this list was not daunting enough you also have the special needs students that have an array problems in your classroom that need specialized attention, lessons and seating. There are many forms of diverse learners from students who suffer from ADHD to physical disabilities to

Public Education in America: Challenges and Solutions

1627 words - 7 pages There are numerous issues that plague the public education system. Several of the concerning challenges that it faces today are: The lack of familial support or guidance some students receive, the increase in the population of individuals that seem to undervalue the benefit of an education, and the test-centered curriculum structure that is applied in a majority of schools, within the system. There desperately needs to be an engagement of ideas

The Importance of Accuracy in Journalism

1953 words - 8 pages because newspapers are no longer being purchased in the quantities they used to be, the credibility of the information itself is also put into question. No one would argue that credibility of news sources is unimportant, but there is a discrepancy in what takes precedence; economy and speed or getting the information out correctly at the first publishing by taking the time to make sure all facts are checked. The importance of having a system of

Environmental Challenges in Vietnam

1508 words - 6 pages towards being industrialized and developed. By gaining this title, Vietnam would move forward towards creating sustainability for future generations to come. Sustainable development comes with challenges, and it is these challenges that have prevented Vietnam from fully accomplishing their high set goals. Being burdened with an isolated and closed development policy, Vietnam has found itself lagging in the areas of: economics, politics, science and

Media Bias: Media Research Center Versus Fariness and Accuracy in Reporting

1394 words - 6 pages Introduction I will discuss what I learned from reading Brill’s Content article. Then, I will discuss my findings from visiting Media Research Center (MRC) and Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting (FAIR) websites. I will share my opinion of about the Newsweek. Finally, I will share my thoughts about the role I think the media should play in a democracy. Brill’s Content Before I purchase a big price item I do a lot of research, after reading

Challenges in The Odyssey

1058 words - 4 pages Challenges in The Odyssey There are many challenges throughout the Odyssey the most significant being his arrogance that Odysseus must overcome in order to reach home. In book 9, beginning with line 113 Odysseus and his men begin a journey in the land of the Kyklops. This set of challenges for Odysseus shows the reader the battle between arrogance and wisdom within Odysseus. The choices that Odysseus makes during this portion of his

Professional Challenges in Computing

2073 words - 8 pages PROFESSIONAL CHALLENGES IN COMPUTING Contents 1. Introduction 2 2. Controversy over tax 2 3. Some ethical issues associated by paying no tax 6 4. Bibliography 7 1. Introduction “Google’s slogan “Do no Evil” was suggested either by Google employee “Paul Buchheit or by Google engineer Amit Patel at a meeting about corporate values in early 2000 or in 2001. Google has changed the slogan from “Do no Evil” to “Don’t

Contemporary Challenges in Policing

619 words - 2 pages chains of command flowing to the bottom. The pyramid needs to be inverted, with the community at top, followed by line officers, then managers. Police organizations are "tall, closed, hierarchical, paramilitary bureaucracies," and this combination represents the worst of management science (Reuss-Ianni, 1983).Police managers serve as a citizen's gateway to the criminal justice system. This is reflected in the experience of being told "that's not a

Life Challenges and History of Dylan Thomas

1182 words - 5 pages . Martin’s Church. The death of this young poet destroyed the hearts of many, but his work still lived on. When exploring the life challenges and history of such an amazing British poet one can only imagine what living the life as a poet would be like. “Whatever talents I possess may suddenly diminish or suddenly increase. I can with ease become an ordinary fool. I may be one now. But it doesn't do to upset one's own vanity.” Dylan Thomas poems

Similar Essays

To What Extent Does Modern Technology Pose New Challenges For The Police In Balancing Liberty And Order Concerns.

2835 words - 11 pages and intimidation in firearms crime, binge drinking by people especially the young the increase in ease of access for youngsters to obtain drink and the subsequent increase in alcohol-related disorder. These changing and evolving patterns require new and different wholesale approaches to the old policing method. The use of partners is imperative if the police service want to respond seriously to the challenges facing them.The advancement of

Balancing Democracy And Reality In Hong Kong

3409 words - 14 pages incompetence of the CE reveals to be multi-folded and complicated that is impossible to cure within a short time. Nevertheless, it is equally important to be aware of China’s concerns when looking for solution for democratisation on Hong Kong politics. Hence, after balancing democracy and reality, presidential system with plurality should be promoted in the Hong Kong context that helps build a stable relationship between executive and the legislature

Accuracy In Epic Of Gilgamesh And The Holy Bible

1421 words - 6 pages involved in the story line, and the characters become real. Regardless of the time or place, one's involvement in the work may supersede all history surrounding it. The question of the importance of historicity aside, there can be little harm done in pondering the accuracy of a work. The Hebrew Bible and the Epic of Gilgamesh have come under close scrutiny concerning this topic, most notably for the similar flood stories they contain. One might

James Joyce's Ulysses Balancing Information In Ithaca

3234 words - 13 pages James Joyce's Ulysses - Balancing Information in Ithaca "I hold this book [Ulysses] to be the most important expression which the present age has found; it is a book to which we are all indebted, and from which none of us can escape. " T.S. Elliot In the midst of 'Ithaca,' the climactic second to last episode of Ulysses, James Joyce provides the necessary information for calculating how much excrement, in pounds, is produced annually by