In Search Of Virtue In Honors

1662 words - 7 pages

In Search of Virtue in Honors

Of the three forms of friendship discussed by Aristotle—the useful, the pleasant, and the good—the ideal seminar most resembles the perfectly good friendship between “good men who are alike in excellence or virtue” (Aristotle 1156b). A seminar, the Swarthmore website reads, unites faculty with “small groups of dedicated and accomplished students” committed to “independent learning” and “dialogue with peers, teachers, and examiners.” In light of Aristotelian and neo-Aristotelian thought on friendship, virtue and practical wisdom, this discussion will first examine how an ideal seminar promotes student virtues and then proceed to evaluate an e-mail I wrote in response to an imperfect seminar.

Aristotle contends that friendship is instrumental for acquiring and maintaining moral excellence:

…the friendship of good men is good, and it increases with their meetings. Also, it seems, they become better as they are active together and correct one another: from the mould of the other each takes the imprint of the trait he likes, whence the saying: ‘Noble things from noble people.’ (1172a)

Similarly, a seminar composed of individuals with student virtues—including diligence, intelligence, curiosity, patience, and humility—can best maintain and encourage virtue. Rosemary Volbrecht’s “Mutual Apprenticeship in moral development,” Nancy Sherman’s “Making a Necessity of Virtue,” Laurence Thomas’ Living Morally and Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics outline the means by which friendship encourages moral virtue. An extrapolation from moral virtues to student virtues frames their discussion in the context of an honors seminar at Swarthmore.

Volbrecht highlights the importance of role models in experiential moral development (Volbrecht 309). Abstract behavioral rules fail to impart virtue; the observation of dynamic and contextual behavior of role models, on the other hand, helps cultivate flexible moral judgment. The use of role models allows moral agents to “see the good as good and to see what is the good in a particular situation” (309). At Swarthmore, the honors program makes implicit use of role models. In seminar, seniors initially set the tone for juniors to follow.

Honors seminars also provide a forum for “moral self-examination” (Thomas 140) which encourages deliberation among equals. Seminars allow a degree of academic intimacy and debate which is unavailable in a lecture hall. In Living Morally, Laurence Thomas writes that “Not infrequently…self-examination requires a dialogue” (140). In the Ethics, Aristotle highlights the importance of deliberation in proceeding with practical wisdom: “When great issues are at stake, we distrust our own abilities as insufficient to decide the matter and call in others to join us in our deliberation” (Aristotle 1112b). Successful deliberation, then, often requires the union of various perspectives. In my experience, the wisdom of groups of people outpaces the ability...

Find Another Essay On In Search of Virtue in Honors

Heroic Virtue in Othello Essay

2038 words - 8 pages Heroic Virtue in Othello         William Shakespeare’s tragedy Othello puts on exhibit an obvious hero and other not-so-obvious heroes. Let us examine them all in this essay.   The supreme type of hero in this play did not occur overnight to the playwright. Rather he slowly built upon one hero after another in his plays until his work culminated in the Moor. A. C. Bradley, in his book of literary criticism, Shakespearean Tragedy

The Pursuit of Virtue in Pride and Prejudice

1106 words - 4 pages away from the things that stopped them from achieving positive traits considered to be morally good. Doing so, they managed to find the acquisition of virtue. The importance of virtue here is that, virtues are needed for living well; But in order to obtain them, it is fundamental to search for them , because virtues are voluntary acquired, we are not born with them. We have reasons to acquire them, since they are beneficial for us and for our

Aristotle: His Messages of Virtue and Moderation in Politics

1409 words - 6 pages gadfly, always buzzing in the state's face tomake sure they were doing the just thing. Aristotle also knew theimportance of justice but he approached it slightly differently.Justice, Aristotle's third moral virtue, consisted of two mainaspects. The first was that the laws made citizens just; the statehad to strive to make the people act morally and good (1129a 13-24).Aristotle's second aspect of justice was that people should beawarded justly

John McPhee's In Search of Marvin Gardens

1242 words - 5 pages John McPhee's In Search of Marvin Gardens Im his essay In Search of Marvin Gardens, John McPhee examines Atlantic City, New Jersey, the city upon which the board game of Monopoly was based. In his writing, he touches upon both the board game and the physical city equally which begs the reader to ponder the purpose of McPhee’s essay. Did he write his essay to provide for the reader the physical basis for the game of Monopoly? Or did

In Search of Our Mothers' Gardens: Sainthood

1489 words - 6 pages In Search of Our Mothers' Gardens: Sainthood To use the name of a Saint generally evokes images of holy men and women of the Catholic church, dressed in flowing robes and surrounded by an oil-painted aura. There are patron saints-those with a sort of specialized divinity-of bakers and bellmakers, orphans and pawnbrokers, soldiers and snake bites, soldiers and writers. Each is a Catholic who lived a life deemed particularly holy and was

In Search of the American Cowboy.

2199 words - 9 pages , Paul et al. The Enduring Vision: A History of the American People, Volume 2: From 1865. 5th ed. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2004.Rausch, Jane M. "Frontiers, Cowboys and Popular Culture." Studies in Latin American Popular Culture 13, (1994). Available from the University of Alberta Library Databases, Academic Search Premier, item no. 07309139.Steiner, Stan. "Riders of the Range." Natural History 93, no. 2 (1984): 84-92. Available from the University of

Hamlet: In Search of His Own Identity

2053 words - 8 pages O' Brother, Where Art Hamlet's Mind In life, one goes through different experiences which makes and shapes us into the person who we become. Whether something as little as a "hello" by a crush or a death in a family, they contribute to the difference, as they are all equal in importance. In the play Hamlet by William Shakespeare, the protagonist Hamlet struggles throughout his life as he is in search of his true identity. The Webster's

In Search of the Good Family

1256 words - 6 pages A family is a group of people who love, respect, and help one another no matter the circumstances. Family members are not confined to people you are related to or have married; they can include friends, acquaintances, etc. In this second paragraph on page 283, Howard states, “If our relatives are not, do not wish to be, or for whatever reason cannot be our friends, then by some complex alchemy we must try to transform our friends into our

Honors in Action Project: Many Forms of Incivility

2414 words - 10 pages who was unreliable, unresponsive, and disrespectful. Fortunately, something good came from the experience. From that exercise came the development of one driven member then serving as Fellowship Chair the opportunity to lead the Honors in Action project. This also created an opening for another member to take a leadership role as Fellowship chair to keep our chapter united. At first, there was some animosity between the impeached officer and our

In Search of Light and Finding Darkness         In his short

1014 words - 4 pages In Search of Light and Finding Darkness In his short story "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place" Ernest Hemingway creates the stages of his life and portrays himself as the character of the older waiter viewing a customer, the old man, slipping away into the shadows, sheltered from the light of life. Hemingway was a creative but tormented artist and if the reader spends the time with an open mind it is easy to get into, and enjoy his stories. In order

Penelope: In Search of the Feminist in James Joyce's Ulysses

5673 words - 23 pages Penelope: In Search of the Feminist in James Joyce Ulysses is an oeuvre in rebellion against society’s standards of race, class, and religion, against traditional images of sexuality and gender. Its final book, “Penelope,” is a reflection of this rebellion, however its true feminist character has been an issue of contention among critics. A more grounded vision of Joyce’s feminism can be found through an understanding of the two

Similar Essays

In Search Of Perfection Essay

2128 words - 9 pages Keywords: genetic engineering, moral issues, genetic changes, genetic technologiesIn Search of PerfectionThere is no doubt that any other field is as closely connected with human life as medicine. Yet medicine has been so greatly affected by technological advances that it has gone beyond therapy and towards the limits of our imagination. Unlike a few years ago, when conceiving a baby girl or a baby boy was a matter of chance, today's prospective

In Search Of Excellence Essay

1860 words - 7 pages By: Anonymous In Search of Excellence was the 1982 best-selling look at excellent companies and an attempt to identify the attributes they had in common that helped to make them successful. Thomas Peters and Robert Waterman studied dozens of American companies and deemed these companies to be excellent: Bechtel, Boeing, Caterpillar, Dana, Johnson & Johnson, Hewlett-Packard, Delta, Fluor, IBM, Procter and Gamble, McDonalds, 3M, Digital

In Search Of A Dream Essay

1869 words - 8 pages Currently, it is estimated that there are between 11.5 and 12 million undocumented immigrants living in the United States, some of which are really committed to this country, but many workers aren’t given the chance to show their loyalty to the country. Getting into the U.S. brings many new challenges to the immigrants, language being one of the most important and basic ones since most of the immigrants who come to the U.S. illegally couldn’t

Virtue In Telemachus’ Life Essay

1236 words - 5 pages adult man capable of making virtuous decisions and acting with the honor that is required of a virtuous man of the Greek world and Christian world. Virtue in the Greek world was determined mainly by how one is viewed by others. This was an important notion for the Greeks, since their society was very aggressive. The world of the Odyssey was fiercely competitive, as each hero strove to outdo the other (Finley 118). This competitive attitude stems from