This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

In This Paper There Are Five Questions Asked And Answered About The Stanford Experiment Conducted In 1971. The Questions Are About The Ethics Of The Experiment.

2135 words - 9 pages

Discuss the ethics of the Stanford Prison Experiment. In your answer, be sure to touch on the parts of the experiment that may be considered unethical, why the study was conducted the way it was and what was done to protect the subjects, and whether you feel that under the current ethical guidelines this study could be conducted today.Ethics is thought of as a moral principle, or what should be right. The experiment that took place in the summer of 1971 at Stanford University was not ethnical, to any extent... The subjects were not protected to any extent, but the so-called guards had made the 'prisoners' obey them, which in return, the guards had no worries about being violated. They didn't need any type of protection, because what did they have to fear? Nothing, they were the ones who put the fear into the prisoners! The prisoners were frightened of the guards; they humiliated them... They were stripped naked and searched. You know that had to affect the way the prisoners acted. I would obey them, because if I didn't I would be afraid they would humiliate me over and over. They faced the ultimate humiliation when they were arrested in the public's eye. They were stripped of there identity and only to be replaced by a number. The guards had total control over the prisoners from threatening and beating them. They had no choice but to obey. The prisoners knew they would be stripped of some of their privacy and civil rights. They didn't think it would lead as far as it did. The experiment was scheduled to last for two weeks, but it had to be cut short to six days. Why, you ask. It was unethical. As you see there was not one point in this experiment that I find ethical. There would be no way in today's time it would take place again. Today you have to go through boards to get approved and it is a long process. Philip Zimbardo did not have to go through this process. If this experiment were conducted today there would be many, many changes. Training would have to be given to the guards on how to be a 'guard'. Back in 1971, the guards were free to do anything they would like. For example, they used physical force with their nightsticks. They actually hit the prisoners, sending some of them into a state of mild shock. Today, no physical abuse can be used. The guards made up their own set of rules, which included harassing, beating, screaming, and taking their identity away from them. The study was conducted the way it was, because they had no guidelines to follow as we do now. The prisoners and guards were not given any type of training. Zimbardo did not stop the experiment when the guard's ego took over and they began their power trip. He stopped it after it was too late. He sent some of his prisoners to the hospital and home from the experiment because emotions were running wild and they could not control themselves. I think this experiment was way out of line...How are norms/roles a part of this study? Please give specific examples of norms/roles to...

Find Another Essay On In this paper there are five questions asked and answered about the Stanford Experiment conducted in 1971. The questions are about the ethics of the experiment.

A Critique Of the Stanford Experiment

561 words - 2 pages guards that the power would be abused. The experiment tookplace in 1986 and though there had been many years passed since Milgram's experimentwas conducted in 1963, people then and still today try to get to the top of every situation.In this case, the guards were given the power, and it probably took a day or so before theybegan to abuse they power and abuse the inmates. If only they experiment would havebeen conducted a year later, Haney, Banks

The Stanford Prison Experiment: Philip Zimbardo

1937 words - 8 pages suggest major controversy and their methods should be reconsidered. The example above took place in 1971. Philip Zimbardo, the head administrator of Stanford University in Palo Alto, California conducted this experiment with the help of some other professors at the university, and twenty four male college students from the university. The initial purpose of the experiment was to examine the effect of roles. Zimbardo wanted to determine whether the

This paper about the art of PRINTMAKING, and how it is done in other countries. There are specific examples as well

694 words - 3 pages coats the matrix and shortly after being coated, it is covered with a transferring base. This base is usually paper or fabric. The final step is to print it with a roller press, or a hand press. The resemblance from the original to the copy is almost identical. There are several different printmaking techniques.One of these techniques is etching, more specifically, photo etching (used by Edwards Bernstein). In this process, the high contrast

Revisiting the Stanford Prison Experiment: a Lesson in the Power of Situation Critique

893 words - 4 pages ," (Zimbardo, 2007, p. 4). The Stanford Prison Experiment is compared to the Abu Ghraib situation, and also discussed are the implications of this research to the criminal justice system. The problems specified in the article addresses the social power of groups and as to whether a person could be influenced to exert power over someone else. The experiment called for twenty-four student participants to act as either a prisoner or a guard in the "prison

Marxist Ethics This essay explores the idea of whether or not there are 'ethics' in marxism

3770 words - 15 pages Karl Marx and Frederick Engels wrote a lot of books. So many, in fact, that International Publishers offers a 50 volume collection of their complete works. Be this as it may, as a couple of philosophers they wrote very little on the subject of ethics. There is no direct explanation or definition of a "Marxist ethics", and the brief references to morals and ethics are limited. Many critics take this to mean that ethics in Marxism are non-existent

The Important Questions about Hemphilia

974 words - 4 pages joints and bones, so all you can really do is be careful and try not to cooperate with dangerous activities. Kinds of treatment are there:  On demand - giving treatment to stop prolonged bleeding when it occurs. This is more common in the management of patients with mild hemophilia.  Preventative treatment (prophylaxis) - medication to prevent bleeding episodes, and subsequent complications, such as joint and/or muscle damage. More commonly

Questions and Answers About the Enron Scandal

863 words - 4 pages in prison. Andrew S. Fastow the Chief financial officer was found guilty of conspiracy and was convicted for a period of 6 years behind bars. Question 2: Regulations that arouse as a result of Enron’s scandal Reforms The US Congress reacted hastily to the Enron disaster and other indignities by assuming an extensive set of reforms. Most of the improvements are contained in the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002. This act applies only to those companies

Questions Answered by The War of the Worlds

878 words - 4 pages The War of the Worlds broadcast happened quite a while ago. But even today people think about whether it was real or not. I know that I thought it was real in the beginning, but near the end I found out that it was just a dramatization. After we listened to it, we got some questions that we had to answer. The answers to the questions are below. People everywhere were freaking out. They were in a state of panic. People loaded blankets and

The Stanford Prison Experiment: Taking a Deeper Look

1023 words - 5 pages heard about the Stanford Prison Experiment, but may not have been aware of the scars that it left upon the participants. Taking a deeper look into the study and the impacted outcomes on individuals will be elaborated on (Stanford Prison Experiment). On August 14, 1971, the Stanford Prison Experiment had begun. The volunteers who had replied to the ad in the newspaper just weeks before were arrested for the claims of Armed Robbery and Burglary

Three Answered Questions About War, State and Humanitarian Crises

1277 words - 6 pages problems of open information and credibility of threats. Democracies tend to have a more public political system, so other countries can get more information about a democracy’s capabilities. This is connected to the democratic peace theory, which states that democratic states are less war prone with each other. Almost every interstate war involving a democratic country in history has been between a non-democratic state, or states. This can be

The Stanford Prison Experiment - Choosing to Remain A Prisoner

1015 words - 5 pages comments. In the Stanford Prison Experiment a comparable situation took place with the inmate participants; they may not have necessarily been shy, but they were in a position where they wanted to say something, but they didn’t because of the influence of the guard participants and other inmate participants. Finally, as I mentioned before, there are some people with power and some that are helpless. I would not classify myself as helpless, nor

Similar Essays

The Ethics Of The Stanford Prison Experiment

941 words - 4 pages priest that was called in and the prisoners parents that came for a visitation day didn’t protest the treatment of their sons after hearing stories of the mock prison. There is something about these symbols of authority that I think led to this happening, and I feel that Zimbardo’s ethics are questionable for even conducting the experiment. I think that the reason why this experiment turned out how it did because of the symbols of authority shown

Frequently Asked Questions About "Gryphon" Answered!

708 words - 3 pages Charles Baxter is often asked questions about his short story "Gryphon". In order to help students everywhere better understand his story Charles answered some of the most common questions for this site.Question: What does the title of the story mean? The gryphon doesn't seem very important-- what does the idea of a gryphon bring to the story?Baxter: Ms. Ferenczi mentions the gryphon as an animal she's actually seen in Egypt. A gryphon, however

The Stanford Prision Experiment Essay

768 words - 3 pages Philip Zimbardo, a world-renowned psychologist at Sanford University, conducted the landmark psychological study known as ?The Stanford Prison Experiment?. Performed in the summer of 1973, the experiment set out to study the human response to captivity, in particular, to the real world circumstances of prison life. Volunteers played the roles of guards and prisoners, and lived in a mock prison. However, the quickly took a turn in the wrong

The Implications Of The Stanford Prison Experiment

1115 words - 4 pages . What would be interesting is experimenting if the change can be reversed by putting evil people in a good place will they change for the better? There is a connection between the Stanford prison experiment and the novel The Lord of the Flies as the both discuss "man's essential illness". In both the experiment and the novel the subjects are male, perhaps this could mean the essential illness belongs to man (I