In What Circumstances Is It Possible For A Court To Award Exemplary Damages In Tort?

1421 words - 6 pages

I. IntroductionExemplary damages, also known as punitive damages, are granted in some tort cases to "express the court's disapproval of what the defendant has done" . The principles of exemplary damages in tort laws are laid out in the decision of the House of Lord in Rookes v Barnard . In that case, Lord Devlin classified the cases in which the plaintiff is entitled to claim exemplary damages into three categories, namely:(1)"oppressive arbitrary or unconstitutional action by the servants of the government" ,(2)"the defendant's conduct has been calculated by him to make a profit for himself which may well exceed the compensation payable to the plaintiff" ,(3)"where exemplary damages are expressly authorised by statute."Even though Lord Devlin's restriction was rejected in many common law jurisdictions such as Canada and New Zealand , the Hong Kong courts follow strictly with the restriction.II. Category OneFew cases in Hong Kong are brought within this category. Pham Van Ngo & Others v A-G was properly the only case in Hong Kong which exemplary damages are sought under the first category. A group of Vietnamese boat people came to Hong Kong for assistance. Though they expressed they would like to carry on their journey to Japan to seek refugee status, their vessel was destroyed and they were subsequently detained by the Hong Kong government. They sued the government for false imprisonment. The plaintiffs' claim of exemplary damages failed but they were awarded compensation to their destroy vassal. Chan J ruled that the government's conduct was not "deliberate, reckless or monstrous" . Although exemplary damages were not awarded, Patrick Chan J confirmed the Rookes v Barnard principle is applicable in Hong Kong. The government of Hong Kong will be held liable for exemplary damages if governmental department act deliberately, recklessly or monstrously, and these acts are proved to be "oppressive arbitrary or unconstitutional action by the servants of the government" .In England, many Category One cases often concern the wrongful act of the police. For example, in Thompson v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis , exemplary damages were awarded for the police using unnecessary force to the plaintiff. Recently a protester Chan Fong-kwai was awarded legal aid to bring an action against the Hong Kong Police . He alleged that the police used excessive force in a protest dated 26th June 2000. There is still no information of what kind of damages exactly Chan pleaded, but exemplary damages may well be sought. If exemplary damages are awarded, this may lead to a development of Lord Devlin's Category One in Hong Kong to include the misconduct of police.III. Category TwoCategory II exemplary damages are mainly sought in libel cases in Hong Kong. Since Broome v Cassell & Co Ltd it is well established that exemplary damages can be awarded in libel cases.Nevertheless, Broome specified that the mere fact that a libel is committed for business purpose...

Find Another Essay On In what circumstances is it possible for a court to award exemplary damages in tort?

Is It Possible To Be A Verbal Intelligent?

1310 words - 6 pages people don’t have a plan for their future, and don’t know exactly what they want, the revolution would be useless and fruitless. The Egyptian experiment is a vain revolution; “Each party is trying to race against time by implementing its agenda as soon as possible. They don’t appreciate the fact that the interest of the country lies in wisdom and patience and that that things cannot be handled in this manner.”(Al-Qahtani). Usamah thinks that

Testable Question Is it possible to observe diffusion across a

512 words - 2 pages Testable Question Is it possible to observe diffusion across a semi-permeable membrane? Background Research Diffusion is the movement of molecules from an area of higher concentration to that of a lower concentration. Once the particles have reached equilibrium, there is no longer any net movement because a gradient no longer exists. It is the result of the random movement of molecules or Brownian Movement. •1 Dialysis is a separation

Is It Possible To Be A Verbal Intelligent?

1004 words - 5 pages reading disability is not a genetic problem, according to a research done by Robert Plomin, a professor of human development in the center for Developmental and Health Genetics. In his study titled as “ The Role of Inheritance in Behavior”, he explains the influence of society and genes on behavior and shows the minor impact of genes on human behavior. In addition to what is mentioned above, there are many examples of famous and historical

Sharia: Is it Possible to Transcend the Rules in Today’s Secular Society?

1111 words - 4 pages contrast greatly different than the government found in the Islamic nations. (U.S. Const. art. VI, cl. 3.) Essentially, to the United States government, Sharia law, like any law that’s not established nor in accordance with our Constitution, is a foreign law. Foreign laws are used in U.S. courts when appropriate; for matters such as foreign judgments, contracts and incidents that involve foreign governments or when parties involved request it

Torture is Acceptable in Certain Circumstances

849 words - 4 pages data it can guarantee many lives (Messerli 1). A common question when dealing with the topic torture is, “Why would criminals give in to torture?” Well, Criminals, fugitives, terrorists, whatever you decide to call them are also people. All people no matter what your feelings are can although feel, therefore no matter who the person, torture would be painful. Human’s natural instinct is to stop the pain, mental or physical. Therefore, the

Tort law in Canada and what this area of law is all about.

1111 words - 4 pages be a detriment to society.Tort law is used in society as an advantage by helping the victim receive damages from the person who caused the injury or damage. Tort law is great when it is used properly. If you get injured due to the negligence of another person it is not right. Tort law is a benefit because the victim will receive compensation for the mistakes of the person who was negligent. As an example of a real case; John Doe is suing Thomas

Public Art in Greece: To what extent and in what ways does the Parthenon perform the function of a gigantic billboard for the late fifth century Athens? For whom is it intended?

1808 words - 7 pages , where the Persians were defeated, served as role models for young Athenian men to aspire to. (This is not unlike our own war monuments) It thus honored their courage and sacrifice and elevated them from being mere mortals to worthy heroes, ascending and joining the realms of gods. These young warriors "must evoke a generation that is to come - or a generation that has already been" ."Just as the young men in the frieze are presented in their

Is it Possible to Harmonise International Trade?

2546 words - 10 pages viewpoints in two different sets of global trade law already in place, it would be difficult to harmonise international trade law because nations will have conflicting opinions on appropriate judgement for violations. The Vienna Convention, also known as the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG), is a provision which was enacted to attempt the harmonisation of international sale of goods contracts. While the

Is it possible to define ‘art’?

2136 words - 9 pages The expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form such as painting or sculpture, producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional power. The above quotation is the Oxford Dictionary’s definition of art. It is one of the many definitions and theories written in answer to the question “what is art?” However, that very question implies an inhibited and essentialist answer

Camaraderie in "This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix"

743 words - 3 pages Thesis: In, This is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona, Victor's father's death leads to the many stories about their childhood that makes them reconsider their friendship. I. Mother Theresa once said, "Kind words can be short and easy to speak but there are truly endless." A. As Victor and Thomas approached the door to the trailer Victor says, "I never told you I was sorry for beating you up that one time." B. He does not

To What Extent Is Eddie Responsible For His Own Death In 'A View From A Bridge'?

2620 words - 10 pages could see exactly what was going to happen to him.P.65: 'He could see every step coming.'- AlfieriThis is like a prophecy which is fulfilled to its full extent. However we can't blame everything on fate because of free will. Eddie and all other Italians followed the Italian code. It was Eddie who chose to break this unwritten law and no one else could have made the decision for him. In Eddie's neighbourhood, you define your identity by following

Similar Essays

Is It Possible For God To Be All Good And All Powerful While There Is Evil In The World?

1235 words - 5 pages evil: Moral evils were discussed by Augustine and later adopted by Aquinas.(Stumpf , 1983). Evil, by Aquinas is not a thing, it is the absence of a the good. The same as for the blind the absence of sight. In this context the question is, why does God allows the evil to exist whether it exist per se or by the absence of good? Aquinas replies that the perfection of the universe required the existence of various kinds of beings, including bad as

What It Is To Be A Hero In American Literature.

743 words - 3 pages What exactly does it mean to be an American? This question has thousands of possible answers, all depending on the person. It is difficult to answer though, according to separate pieces of literature when one's own opinion might differ. However, according to many novels and plays, to be an American, especially an American Hero, is to work an entire lifetime to reach the American Dream, then fall just short, all the wasted tears and effort in

To What Extent Is It Possible To Discredit The 'black Legend Of Childhood' (Keith Wrightson) In 16th And 17th Century England?

2384 words - 10 pages neglectful and possibly abusive by historians in support of the ‘black legend’, it can also be argued that, during the early modern period, parents carried out these traditions because of a general belief that they were doing what was best for their children.It is clear that many of the issues put forward as evidence of the ‘black legend of childhood’ are open to interpretation. Sixteenth and seventeenth century parents lived by a

Expert Witness Describe What An Expert Witness Is. What Do They Add To The Court Room? Why Are They Important? This Is A Very Good Essay For Psychology And Law Classes. It Is Detailed And Well...

1461 words - 6 pages determine whether they will receive custody because they must be able to support themselves and their child. Lastly, an expert witness will take a look at past childcare from both sides to see which parent is most capable of caring for the child. Once a complete evaluation is done, the judge may accept the recommendation of the mental health professional, or it is possible that the judge is in difference and does not believe that it is in best