This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

In What Ways Has The Theory Of The Director As The 'author' Of A Film Been Used In Film Studies, And How And Why Has It Been Disputed?

2029 words - 8 pages

Barthes claimed in 1977 that the author was dead and authorial intention had no place in criticism of texts, placing the importance of deciphering meaning fully with the reader (Barthes 1977 142 - 148). However, since 1948, many critics have focused on the director of films as the 'author' placing their own meanings and intentions within a film which was to be interpreted. This essay will look at how much this idea of the 'auteur' is used in studying films and how opposing critics can read films in differing ways, dismissing the auteur as the sole artist.The authorship theory attempted to break down any barriers which existed between art cinema and commercially produced Hollywood cinema, and as such, the idea of the auteur in film originating in the Cahiers du Cinema focused on Hollywood directors. In 1948, Alexandre Astruc saidThe cinema...is gradually becoming a language. By language, I mean a form in which and by which an artist can express his thoughts, however abstract they may be, or translate his obsessions exactly as he does in the contemporary essay or novel. That is why I would like to call this new age of cinema the age of camera-stylo (Astruc 1948: 17-23)This signalled the beginning of the politique des auteurs, which formed the opinion that cinema was a language which an individual artist (the director) could express a personal vision through, making a stand against the serious, social themes of the established French cinema and criticism which gave weight to this 'quality' cinema (Cook & Bernink 1999: 235-240). This politique des auteurs made a clear distinction between directors they deemed worthy of being called auteurs, and those who they named as metteurs-en-scene. This distinction claimed that true auteurs were those directors who showed their world view through their films and who demonstrated in their films an exclusive style which would hint at their personality and meaning. A metteur-en-scene would simply direct without showing any individuality in style or world view. Cahier critics argued that this personal style and meaning could be found in certain themes and motifs which could be discovered in a film's mise-en-scene. The critic's job was to discover this self expression within the film, therefore the subject would be of little consequence to the meaning of the film (Caughie 1981: 9-15). Critics argued that while the 'subject matter and script are...in control of the studio, style is...under control of the director, and it is here that his personality may be most legible' (Caughie 1981: 12).This kind of polemical writing prospered in the 1960s as there appeared to be a political shift which resulted in greater individual freedom in America. Under this climate, Andrew Sarris worked towards supporting Hollywood films and their directors, therefore signalling the rise of the auteur theory in America (Cook & Bernink 1999: 256). Sarris asserted that there were various misunderstandings around the auteur theory...

Find Another Essay On In what ways has the theory of the director as the 'author' of a film been used in film studies, and how and why has it been disputed?

Mildred Pierce Describe the film "Mildred Pierce" as a film noir that has been influenced by both the maternal melodrama and the remarriage comedy

1614 words - 6 pages There are a few themes that seem to be consistently analyzed in film, the two big ones being the nature of family and of sexuality. Dizzy damsels in distress, aging repressed patriarchs, trustworthy buddies, repressed housewives, fumbling villains- these are just some of the archetypes who are used to tell the film’s story. But as universal as these archetypes are, it is in the angle they are shown from and the way their story is told that

How has your perception of "in the wild" been illuminated by "Bladerunner" and "Brave New world"?

1249 words - 5 pages important part of our society but in our search for economic growth we often ignore the environment and it is only afterwards when we can identify what we have done wrong. In Brave New World the environment has been degraded to an item of consumption. No longer is it valued for it's beauty and serenity but is used as a means consuming transport. However in the novel "as a love of nature keeps no factory busy and it was decided to abolish the love of

How and Why Has King John Been Represented in Different Ways?

1748 words - 7 pages How and Why Was King John portrayed in history? King John was born on the 24th of December in the year of 1167 to King Henry II and his wife, Eleanor of Aquitaine. John was the youngest of five sons to his father, and had been nicknamed “Lackland” by Henry as all of his elder brothers had received a certain share of dominion apart from John alone, however, John seemed to be his father’s favourite. In 1173, a marriage proposal was set up by

Discussing the film "Erin Brocovich", examine how this media text has been used to dispaly social class and prejudices within American society

1380 words - 6 pages queens have the reputation of having looks but no brains, but also it emphasises that she is a woman who did not train to be a lawyer when she was in school, so did not have the job as a lawyer afterwards. This is also shown by Erin not acting like a typical lawyer; she has to be told what to do many times before she can grasp the concept, and she isn't respectful to her opposition either- she swears at them and challenges them. She makes jokes on

Why has the Industrialization in the Nineteenth Century Been Described as a 'Revolution?'

626 words - 3 pages people are not ready to be heavily taxed in order to support the army. Napoleon keeps the ideals of the French Revolution which allows him to keep his power. However, eventually Napoleon must tax the French people because the French Empire has spread across most of Europe and there are not any countries left to plunder. Napoleon Bonaparte uses the Continental System and a self-sufficient army as attempts to keep himself in power. Napoleon uses

Mildred Pierce. An essay on the film nuor Mild Pierce. It has been written in review format

603 words - 2 pages back after World War II was based on ethics and the economy. This movie reenacts the lives many women led during this time as a result of the war. Woman would take on the independent roles of their husbands, while they were away defending their country. Many would have to find ways to earn a living on their own. The film makers do an exceptional job of portraying the emotional, social, and economic demolition. Joan Crawford plays the amazing

"Mary Shelley's Frankenstein has been adapted to a film about the dangers inherent in the quest for personal glory at the expense of all else". Discuss

1361 words - 5 pages to an icy, gloomy place where the ship under control of a man called Walton is stuck in the middle of this ice world. He is that determined to get to the North Pole that he is willing to put his crew, himself and anybody else that gets in his way. Walton and Frankenstein are very much alike as we both see there overwhelming ambition for self glory, regardless who it affects or how. We see Victors over ambition from the death of his mother as she

In the film Rabbit Proof Fence, We, as the viewer, are positioned to see Mr Neville as a mostly unsympathetic character. How has the director, Phillip Noyce used various techniques to achieve this?

1266 words - 5 pages In the film "Rabbit Proof Fence", the character A.O. Neville is portrayed as a mostly unsympathetic character. The director, Phillip Noyce used the technique of camera angles to develop Neville's character as very authoritative and controlling of the other characters in the movie. The soundtrack, particularly the sound effects, are also used to develop Neville's character. He is shown to be very isolated from the suffering of Aborigines and only

It has been suggested the “stress is in the eyes of the beholder?”. What does this mean? Do you agree?

1750 words - 7 pages I strongly agree with the statement, as stress is a fact of daily life. It is been feel when one’s thought of any adjustment in life. In workplace, stresses are the one of the importance as the excessive of it could give an upside down impact in physical and emotional of the workers. Not everything perfect as in workplace, we can’t control everything to be as we wish for, but that doesn’t mean useless. It is better to find a way to managing

It has been suggested that “stress is in the eyes of the beholder?”. What does this mean? Do you agree?

2262 words - 10 pages stresses within a poem is the foundation of poetic rhythm. The process of working out which syllables in a poem are stressed is known as scansion; once a metrical poem has been scanned, it should be possible to see the matter. In psychology, stress is a feeling of strain and pressure. Stress in general is something that is always taken as a bad, negative or deadly issue. Just the word may be enough to set your nerves on edge. Stress is recognized

It has been said that Tennessee Williams' plays are 'full of hate, anger and envy'. How far is this true in scene three of 'The Glass Menagerie'?

2492 words - 10 pages For a play to be full of anger, hate and envy implies that there is no room for other emotions such as happiness, sympathy and sadness. It implies that the play revolves around hateful, angry and envious characters and that the audience feels no other emotions reflected from the characters other than hate anger and envy. This is true to some extent. In scene three of 'The Glass Menagerie' (set during a blazing row), these emotions are expressed

Similar Essays

Choose An Extract From The Film You Have Been Studying And Write An Analytical Essay Exploring How The Director Has Used A Range Of Cinematic Tech

1529 words - 7 pages sound and gives a positive outlook towards what may happen in the film. The first frame in the film is a panoramic shot of outer space. The camera pans down to allow give a clear view of the three planets and has a still image for a few seconds. By having this at the start of the film, it gives the audience a brief idea of the size of space and it also shows us where the story is set. Then, spaceships enter the frame firing lasers at one

What Are The Assumptions Of Realism And Why Has It Been So Influential In The Studies Of International Relations?

1611 words - 6 pages Originating from the German word 'Realpolitik' , realism is often used as a term which fits a more realistic and unpretentious political theory, as opposed to an unrealistic ideological theory. It is this theory which has been one of the leading and most prominent ways of thinking in terms of international relations in modern times, with its stark view of nation states and people appealing greatly to the Western leading political institutions

A. What Has Been The Most Important Event In Your Life, And How Has It Changed You?

683 words - 3 pages how important teamwork is and ways to get my home council to work together better. If it wasn’t for that week at camp, I probably wouldn’t have had the courage to run for Secretary that upcoming school year. I also attended camp in 2013 as a Level 2 camper. My second year at camp didn’t focus so much on teamwork, but more on my own potential, not only in Student Council, but in all aspects of my life. I learned that I alone have the power to make a

Explain What Is Meant By The Term 'social Construction' And Consider How It Has Been Used To Further Our Understanding Of The Concept Of Identity

1162 words - 5 pages According to social construction it is through social interactions that people "act and react in relation to others, through these social interactions we learn what is acceptable and what is not. Over time these rules become internalized within us, and eventually become an unconscious part of our lives and our identity. It is the aim of this essay to explain what is meant by the term 'social construction' and how social construction has