This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

In What Ways And Why Are The Committees Of The Us Congress So Much More Powerful Than The Committees Of The House Of Commons?

1141 words - 5 pages

One of the first and most obvious differences is that the committees in congress have the ability to stop a proposed bill before it has even reached the floor of the reps or the senate. This shows immense power as effectively the committees in congress have more power than individual senators or representatives themselves.To further emphasize this point one only has to consider that in 1996, 6,808 bills were proposed and only 337 of them were implemented. This is quite a contrast as it is much easier for a bill to be passed in England, even with the oversight of the house of lords due to the massive majority being enjoyed by the Labour party at the moment. However congress can re-introduce a bill if it has been amended, although once again it has to go through the lottery of the committees.This is also quite the opposite of committees in the house of commons as these committees don't even get to be involved if a bill is considered to be of constitutional importance as these sorts of bills are debated on the floor of the commons. The most a standing committee can do is amend a bill after its second reading in the house of commons. Amenments however are limited as the government usually curtails the amount of time given to a standing committee to consider the bill and therefore keep the number of significant changes to a minimum. This is a process known as 'the application of Guillotine.' The committees in congress also have amending powers, particularly when it comes to final stages of bill being passed as a bill has to pass in identical form through the house of Reps and the Senate for it to become law. This means compromise must be reached and this compromise means amendments must be made for compromise to be reached.Another point to consider with the committees is the membership. This is because the committees are made up of MP's from all parties proportionate to the number of MP's each party has in the house. As a result, particularly at the moment, this leads to one party dominating the committees and so the number of changes would be minimal in any case as party members would not seek to change the party line, particularly with pressure from party whips keeping ministers in line. This also leads to a certain amount of predictability from a committee meeting due to party members sticking to their parties ideologies on the matter and this undermines the need for standing committees in the house of commons.An example of the lack of success of british standing committees is shown by the figures for the 1970's whereby only 171 out of 3510 amendments proposed were agreed to.Membership is also in a similar state in congress with somewhat differing effects. The basic rule is similar to the house of commons committees in that the party with the majority will recieve the majority of seats in all of the committees. Membership to committees in the US is controlled by the speaker of the house. This means the speakers powers are huge in that they can...

Find Another Essay On In what ways and why are the Committees of the US Congress so much more Powerful than the Committees of the House of Commons?

Elizabeth Singer Rowe: So Much More Than The Pious Poet

2441 words - 10 pages 18th century. However, to her detriment, she has been classified as a pious poet. This representation is ultimately unfair to her talent, as she was so much more than a pious poet; she was a talented writer who used that talent to write in many different forms as well as subject matters, “Her poetry is both highly experimental and impressively aware of what other writers had done and were doing…” (Backscheider). Rowe started writing at the early

The Role of a Coach: Much More Than Just Sports

1588 words - 7 pages training plan if required” (McKay, 2013). In order to maintain proper discipline on teams there should be a set of rules that players must adhere to on and off the court or field. In conjunction, if these rules are violated than the coach needs to implement reasonable discipline. An effective coach should initially state a code of conduct so when defilements do occur, discipline will follow. There is evidence that supports the theory that in order

What are the assumptions of realism and why has it been so influential in the studies of International relations?

1611 words - 6 pages China.Realism is based upon a series of fundamental assumptions, which when looked at, can explain why indeed realism has been so successful within the sphere of international relations. Its first and key assumption is a pessimistic view of human nature. This sees humans as primarily concerned with their own interests, looking to further themselves in a selfish demeanour, as Morgenthau put it, a 'will to power'. This means human beings everywhere are to

More Powerful than the Government? A Review of the Federal Reserve

2310 words - 9 pages , independence and accountability. Another expansion of power occurred in 2010. The severity of the Great Recession caused the government concern over the future of the financial industry. With the hopes of preventing another crisis, Congress passed the Dodd-Frank Act for reform of the financial industry including banks, mortgage lenders and investors. The Dodd-Frank Act also granted more power and assigned further responsibility to the Fed

This paper talks about the types of glaciers, why glaciers are dangerous, where glaciers exist and much more!

1352 words - 5 pages higher elevations in the mountains form these glaciers, also called expanded-foot glaciers.An ice sheet is a broad glacier of irregular shape that blankets a large land surface. Ice sheets are of considerable thickness and more than 19,300 square miles in area. When they spread outward in all directions and are not confined by the underlying surface, they are called continental glaciers. These ice mantles are now confined to Polar Regions.The valley

Why Was the Roman Legion so Powerful?

1616 words - 6 pages then immediately marched to battle. Later, once Rome had become an empire, there was a much more strict training regiment for all citizens that were called into the army. In fact, before anyone could be fully accepted into the military, they had to serve a brief probationary period that tested their physical and mental fitness. Once a recruit was permitted into the army, they began their first phase of training. Before they were trained in the use

“Some might say that the relationship and characters of Beatrice and Benedick are much more interesting than Hero and Claudio.” Explore your views

739 words - 3 pages My opinion of Much Ado About Nothing is that it is a love story even though it is supposedly a comedy. I thought that all the "funny" bits of the play were hidden and hard to understand and the play seems to centralise greatly on relationships. There are two main relationships in the play, that of Benedick and Beatrice and that of Claudio and Hero. Which of these couple’s relationships is more interesting? Throughout the play Beatrice is shown

Industrial Revolution Essay in 1st person point of view. Speaking as a member of the house of commons, I explain the horrible working conditions, and why child labor was essential for the time

567 words - 2 pages Industrial Revolution EssayI have recently been elected to the House of Commons. I will be serving on the Committee for social well being. The Industrial Revolution has flourished in our great country. As a result, we have become the greatest and most wealthy industrial nation in the world. Unfortunately, many of our citizens are beginning to question our blessed industry as a hidden curse. Many feel that the industry we have so proudly built is

What are the main reasons why women are more likely to be in poverty than men since 1945

455 words - 2 pages Causes of Poverty to WomenThe feminisation of poverty has meant a higher percentage of women than men are likely to experience poverty throughout their lives (TUC). Society views a husbands income as primary to be shared amongst the family and a wife's role as domestic worker and carer (Brown: 1983). The male control of economic power within the family can cause unequal resource access, with acute cases resulting in a wife's poverty when her

"Macbeth" - "The construction of Macbeth in different media for different audiences involves much more than the adaptation of ideas and form."

1323 words - 5 pages were given in their work allowed the construction of Macbeth to flow and have added value. One reason viewers might enjoy Polanski's film on Macbeth much more than any other piece of work on the same Shakespeare production is because he also had a freedom of budget, which enabled him to show and interpret things more dramatically and understandably better in a way. An example of this would be the dreams that MacBeth has about Fleance killing him

Why Half of the US and President Obama are in Favor of Immigration Reform

2537 words - 11 pages what is so characteristic about this labor force. According to the authors, more immigrants are working in lower skilled occupations and in a different set of industries than native workers. There are relatively more immigrant workers who are working in a service or farming industry, or as private household workers. They also tend to work more in agriculture, manufacturing, and wholesale and retail trade. Throughout the article, the authors explored

Similar Essays

Congress, The Committees, And The House V.S. The Senate

1098 words - 4 pages committees. They tend to act as a liaison with the white house if the president is from their party. Whips are important to the Senate. It’s is basically the same as the House; they make sure people show up and talk. Congress is important, especially in passing bills, getting support for them, and making sure they are fair. The House and Senate help to select different members for committees, maintain unity, and much more. These committees themselves have important functions. Many things, most out of our control, influence the congressional elections.

The Types Of Committees Within The U.S. Congress And Their Duties

1016 words - 4 pages turn chooses the members of the committee. Each representative serves on about two full committees and four subcommittees.The Special or Select Committees of the House are frequently created for restricted periods of times. They conduct studies or investigations and they consider other measures. The Select Committees serve for only one congress, which is a period of two years. Their powers are set out in the Order of Reference of the House that

Comparing The Emplementation And Scrutinizing Of Proposed Bills In The House Of Commons And Congress

1910 words - 8 pages constitution, shared Montesquieu's opinion and famously said that "[we] must counter ambition with ambition" . As a result the US constitution contains a system of separation of powers, designed, at least in theory, to ensure democracy through equally powerful branches of government. The term 'gridlock' refers to a situation where legislative decisions are effectively halted because there is so much contention and too many

In What Ways And Why Are The Constitutions Of The Uk And The Us Different?

1022 words - 4 pages the constitutions are only accurate to a certain extent. The origins of both constitutions explain why they are different in structure due to the organic development of the UK constitution, comprised of conventions, acts and authoritative works, and the establishment of the US constitution in 1789 following the "years of weakness and chaos resulting from the pre-existing Articles of Confederation and Perpetual Union which loosely bound the