In What Ways Are Uncle Sam And Columbia Similar And Different In Their Usage And Meaning?

1922 words - 8 pages

Section A
This investigation focuses on the United States national personification "Colombia" and its relationship to another national personification, "Uncle Sam." The period of this investigation is between 1776 and 1850, specifically, the American Revolution and the height of Colombia's popularity, and the period of Colombia's gradual fall from the public eye. I will evaluate the use of both symbols in print, as well as the origins of both, including Columbia's original use as a derogatory term for American and Uncle Sam's origin in the War of 1812.
Primary sources such as political cartoons will be used, as well as scholarly works by historians, found in online databases and in libraries. This primary research question of the investigation is: In what ways are Uncle Sam and Columbia similar and different in their usage and meaning?

Section B
"Columbia" is first used as a name in reference to America in 1697 by Massachusetts Chief Justice Samuel Sewall (Schlereth 938). It was initially used as a synonym for the whole continent, as Amerigo Vespucci, who the continent was named after, was considered a lesser explorer in favor of Christopher Columbus (Schlereth 937). It again appears in publication of the debates of British Parliament in a publication called The Gentlemen's Magazine. (Massachusetts Historical Society)
However, as the American Revolution took hold in the colonies, a Columbia as a nation symbol for the colonists began took gain prominence among the colonists themselves. She appears in the newspapers. She began to accrue items of association, such as "the liberty pole and cap, the American flag, shield, and eagle, the chain of states, the thirteen stars, and the dates of the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution (Schlereth 941)." "Columbian" became synonymous with supporting the ideals and goals of the nation, especially in the 1790s and beyond (Schlereth 938). She was originally depicted as wearing a plain, white gown, but as her visibility increased she appeared wearing the national colors, similar to her counterpoint, the British national personification, Britannia (Schlereth 941). In fact, Columbia developed in many ways as a response to Britannia (Berg).
Colombia then became a prominent symbol of American expansionism and Manifest Destiny. A famous painting circa 1872, entitled American Progress (See Appendix), depicts the personification of America leading settlers west. In her left hand she is laying down telegraph wire, and her gaze is fixed steadily westward. This illustrates her role as the image of manifest destiny, the idea that the American people had a right, a responsibility, and a fate to travel west (Tejani).
Columbia endures into the 19th century, as well. During WWI, she is used in a number of propaganda posters, most conspicuously in the "Be patriotic--sign your country's pledge to save the food" poster (See Appendix), in which she asks viewers to save food to support the war. Other appearances...

Find Another Essay On In What Ways Are Uncle Sam and Columbia Similar and Different in Their Usage and Meaning?

In what ways and why are the constitutions of the UK and the US different?

1022 words - 4 pages the constitutions are only accurate to a certain extent. The origins of both constitutions explain why they are different in structure due to the organic development of the UK constitution, comprised of conventions, acts and authoritative works, and the establishment of the US constitution in 1789 following the "years of weakness and chaos resulting from the pre-existing Articles of Confederation and Perpetual Union which loosely bound the

Different ways the wars in America are portrayed in popular culture specifically films and movies

1130 words - 5 pages the massacre in a different way.Let me first look at the film we watched. It was told as a story by a Native American man/actor. This underscores that the film is based largely on the part of the role of the Indians in the war. The “experts” on the situations at hand were the actual people themselves who wrote letters and were read by actors in the documentary. These first hand accounts let the viewers know exactly what the people were

To what extent and in what ways are people ?fixed? and ?open to change??

1561 words - 6 pages ) developed an “ecological” theory of development. He took into account all variables of a person’s environment: the “microsystem” (“the social, symbolic and physical nature of an immediate environment”), the “mesosystem” (“two or more Microsystems that are inhabited by the same person”), the “exosystem” (which “describes the links between different environmental settings”) and finally the “macrosystem” which views all patterns in light of their social and

O brother where art thou, and the Odyssey Prompt: Creatures encountered in the film and the text- how are they similar/ different?

1519 words - 6 pages KKK was about to lynch his black guitar player. Finally there are the Baptists who portrayed the lotus eaters in the movie O Bother Where Art Thou. They are similar because in O Bother Where Art Thou the Baptists lured Ulysses partners in crime, Pete and Delmar, to be baptized and afterwards they wanted to stay with the Baptists but Ulysses dragged them out of the water, and into the car so that they could continue their journey. This was like

"King Oedipus" and "Things Fall Apart": Talks about how these tragidies are similar in structure in how both demonstrate their belief in heroes who posses a tragic flaw.

1061 words - 4 pages Many ancient societies have a record of tragic tales that observe problems of human life and the nature of the gods. For instance, both Greek and Nigerian tragic tales of King Oedipus and Things Fall Apart prove to be similar in structure. Both civilizations demonstrate their belief in tragic heroes who posses a tragic flaw as well as a belief in the ultimate powers of their gods. In Greek tragedies, the audience was often familiar with the

Discuss some ways in which statistics are used or misused in different Areas of Knowledge to assist and mislead us.

1007 words - 4 pages and 12-ounce coca-cola in the 1950s delivered 590 calories. But in now day, a 'extra value meal' including super size fries and 42-ounce coke packs 1,550 calories. The super size fries contain 610 calories, 29 grams of fat, 390 milligrams of sodium and 77 grams of carbohydrates. Those numbers show what are the factors make Americans getting fat and killed 300,000 Americans each year. When people saw this statistic data, many of them might have

To What Degree Might Different Languages Shape In Their Speakers Different Concepts Of Themselves And The World

1109 words - 4 pages To What Degree Might Different Languages Shape In Their Speakers Different Concepts Of Themselves And The World? What Are The Implications Of Such Differences For Knowledge?      The difference in languages can cause different perceptions of various cultures leading to distinctions or possible clashes. When I lived in France I faced some of the problems a language barrier can cause. The most common and at the same

Spiders and Arachnids: Similar Yet Different

1254 words - 5 pages organisms. The order, Araneae, is comprised of spiders. How do spiders and arachnids compare? While spiders and arachnids have many mutual traits, spiders differ in some key categories. All arachnids have similar anatomies, one of the most common traits being the number of appendages. Arachnids develop with eight legs. However, some species of arachnids appear to have only six legs because they are sometimes converted for use in their senses

Similar Poems and their use of Imagery

731 words - 3 pages reader is able to interpret the poem in as many different ways as possible. It is sort of like a different way of sharing what one may be thinking but using things to substitute exactly what is meant. This way will open up a series of ideas to the reader, and therefore the author's thoughts could be a combination of anything.

Louis XIV and Henry III Lived very simmilar lives. What were the main differences in their lives and what caused their kingdoms to be so different?

806 words - 3 pages similar and yet so different was their need to have complete control. Louis was one of the first kings to become his own minister. Louis transformed France into the dominant nation in Europe, expanded its boundaries, and left his heirs secure in their possessions. Henry was "selfish and willful, and his hand on the rudder of state was uncertain, unskilled and unpredictable." Henry tried to rule effectively, he was just not able to. His entire

Abolitionism and Inactivity in Uncle Tom's Cabin

3060 words - 12 pages Abolitionism is predicated on the belief that women are naturally unsuited for public activities and that their place is in the domestic sphere. While Beecher also uses Christian rhetoric to support her analysis of woman's sphere and role, she manipulates it in a different manner than Grimké does, arguing that "It is Christianity that has given to woman her true place in society. And it is the peculiar trait of Christianity alone that can sustain

Similar Essays

In Which Ways Are Religion And Magic Similar, In Which Ways Are They Different?

1270 words - 5 pages desperation. Magic is used to achieve a goal, to come closer to ones personal satisfaction. These two ideas are more related than appears.Religion gives many people a purpose in life; it helps them through "rough times" and gives them something to believe in. They want their lives to have meaning; they want something to live for in order to be happy. Using magic focuses more on short term goals of content, but nevertheless it also aims at creating a

Emily Dickinson And Walt Whitman Contrast In The Ways Of Their Different Writing Structure, Subject Tone, And Topics Discussed In The Majority Of Their Published Works.

787 words - 3 pages different. But they both wrote some of the best poetry this country had ever seen. Emily Dickinson and Walt Whitman contrast in the ways of their different writing structure, subject tone, and topics discussed in the majority of their published works.First, the most forthcoming evidence of their differences would be the structure that the poets use to express themselves through. Whitman uses free verse in his poems. A clear representation of

Outline Three Different Ways Christians Can Practice Personal Devotion In Their Tradition And Analyze How These Practices Relate To The Principal Teachings And Beliefs Of Christianity.

1252 words - 5 pages Practicing devotion is the central core of establishing a certain faith. In Christianity, adherents partake in personal devotions in order to strengthen their faith as well as to spiritually bond with the inner soul and Jesus.There are many forms of devotion that can be expressed in the Christian faith including scripture reading, praying the rosary and the personal devotion of using icons.The Scripture is quite a significant aspect in the

Violent Or Threatening Behaviour Can Be Presented To An Audience In Different Ways. Compare The Ways In Which At Least Two Playwrights You Have Studied Have Presented Violence, And/Or Threats And...

1127 words - 5 pages Violent or threatening behaviour can be presented to an audience in different ways. Compare the ways in which at least two playwrights you have studied have presented violence, and/or threats and comment on their success or otherwise of their methods. "The Glass Menagerie" and "The Crucible certainly laid emphasis on violent and threatening behaviour. Throughout Arthur Miller's Crucible we discover how a small pagan community cause superstition