Inaccurate View Of The Legal System

1638 words - 7 pages

Although often interpreted differently by individuals, legal rights, human rights and the
jury system are essential features of the legal system. Nielsen believes that the main purpose of
rights is to protect individuals, while Hajjar portrays the objective of the legal system as
recognizing and respecting certain inherent human rights. Further, Dooley understands the jury
system as essential for ensuring a democratic and fair trial procedure. As rights and the jury
system are viewed according to these varying objectives, it seems there is a general assumption
that the legal system is intended to protect individuals from the power of the government.
However, individuals’ abstract idea of how the law works can be contrary to the actual workings
of the legal system. Rights and the jury system create the expectation in people that they will be
protected from the power of the government, and yet these expectations often remain unfulfilled,
creating a disconnect between the idea of protection and the reality of the legal system.
In her article “The Work of Rights and the Work Rights Do,” Laura Beth Nielsen asserts
that “legal rights are important for protecting individual autonomy and resisting the arbitrary or
tyrannical imposition of state power” (Nielsen 63). In the case of traditionally disadvantaged
groups, rights have provided a sense of power as a direct result of their nature. Nielsen explains,
“’Rights’ are said to apply equally to everyone, they are ‘neutral,’ and are backed by the
legitimate authority of law and the state,” and that “Rights are often thought of as naturally
inhering in persons” (66, 68). Because many minority groups view rights as inalienable,
absolute, and supported by the government, they believe these legal rights will act as a form of
protection from “the illegitimate exercise of state authority” (63). Nielsen claims that although
rights may be a significant tool for weaker individuals or groups to guard against the more
powerful government, the less powerful are actually less likely to know what rights they have
and when these rights have been violated (69). Nielsen also notes that it is their perpetual
position of disadvantage that makes these individuals less likely to exercise their rights, as they
feel their rights will not be recognized or that their claims will not be addressed (75). The very
nature of legal rights generally leads these individuals to perceive them as instruments for
challenging the power of the government. However, the inability of the less powerful to
understand or execute their rights demonstrates the divide that exists between the expectations
these individuals have of their legal rights and their lived experiences with the legal system.
The Supreme Court case Korematsu v. United States is a clear example of the divide
between individuals’ expectation of their rights and the reality of the legal system. After the
bombing of Pearl Harbor by Japan, the United...

Find Another Essay On Inaccurate View of the Legal System

The English Legal System Essay

1443 words - 6 pages The English Legal System The English legal system comprises of two different branches, barristers and solicitors. In the UK at the moment there are around 9,000 barristers and they are known collectively as the 'Bar'. The governing body for barristers is the Bar Council, which acts as a kind of trade union, safe guarding the interests of barristers and regulating barristers training and activities. All barristers

Law Essay: The Judiciary of the English Legal system

861 words - 3 pages are no judges from ethnic minorities in the judiciary. Furthermore, this under presentation for people from ethnic minorities is further evident where statistics at the beginning of 2002 entailed that only 1 percent of all circuit judges were from ethnic minorities; this further raised the question of whether the English legal system has taken like to having judges from ethnic minorities. However, despite this, there are slow, gradual

Inequality in the Legal System of the United States

1970 words - 8 pages In the United States, true equality has never existed. From the Declaration of Independence to modern times, the U.S. legal system has failed in any attempt at equality. The ideology of "all [men] are equal but some [men] are more equal than others" has been present throughout the history of the U.S. (Orwell). Inequality has always existed in the United States legal system and continues to exist today; however, the inequality presently in the

The Purpose of Tort Law in the Irish Legal System

3219 words - 13 pages In this essay I will endeavour to outline what the intended purpose of tort law is in the Irish legal system and how it has come about over centuries. I will include a brief outline of the meaning of tort law and the different kinds of Tort, I will also include a brief summary of the sister laws of tort, that being criminal and contract law. The word tort is the equivalent of the French word that means ‘wrong’. This word ‘tort’ was derived

The Ineffectiveness of the Death Penalty in our Legal System

1140 words - 5 pages that people are willing to fight capital punishment because they see it as a failure in any legal system. In addition, one of the most important developments has been the adoption of treaties that protest the death penalty as an infringement on civil and human rights and freedoms. Amnesty International has listed 4 in existance today, they are: the Second Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Human Rights, the Protocol to

Failure of the Australian Legal System to Provide True Justice

2711 words - 11 pages Failure of the Australian Legal System to Provide True Justice The Australian legal system uses the adversary system in solving legal disputes. The adversary system is a judicial process where an independent and impartial judge administers justice in courts and two opposing parties present allegations and counter allegations regarding a legal dispute placed before the court by one or both parties. (B.Bash, 2001, Legal

Analysis of the Austrlian Legal system for Domestic Violence

1263 words - 5 pages Domestic ViolenceDomestic violence has long been a serious issue in our modern society, there has been many attempts to settle domestic violence through many different organization. The legal system has been effectively addressing domestic violence, however there are limitations to the legal system and mechanism that may prevent it from successfully stopping domestic violence. The lack of funding in many services causes an ineffective mechanism

Justice in the Legal System

668 words - 3 pages Justice in the Legal System Justice, as defined by Webster’s Dictionary is the quality of being fair or just. This implies that justice would have something to do with being fair. I thought that if one of the things the law and legal system are about is maintaining and promoting justice and a sense of fairness, they might not be doing such a great job. An eye for an eye is fair? No, that would be too easy, too black and white. I could

The Marxist View on the Role of the Education System

1075 words - 4 pages The Marxist View on the Role of the Education System In this essay I am going to examine the Marxist view that the role of the education system is to reproduce and justify the existing class structure. Marxists see the educational system as a mechanism for maintaining class inequalities, for example the reproduction of the capitalist system. The capitalist system is one where by the rich (the bourgeoisie) stay rich and

A View of the Graduated Licensing System in Canada

576 words - 2 pages One of the biggest legislative trends is the passage of graduated licensing systems. These statutes introduce new drivers to driving privileges slowly. That way, teens get practice under lower risk conditions before being allowed full driving privileges. Graduated Licensing was passed by the government on April 1, 1994. This new system of acquiring your license has three levels and gradually introduces drivers to the dangerous roadways. This

The United State Legal System and Legal Practitioner

1360 words - 5 pages accused individuals, guilty criminals, and corruptive organizations. Legal practitioners play pivotal roles within the criminal justice system and although laws are meant to provide types of behavioral conformities within social norms, it too must be protected from being abused by government officials practicing law enforcement, hence, legal practitioner ensure lawful judicial balance in the pursuit of justice. Although lawyers and attorneys provide

Similar Essays

The Consequences Of Inaccurate Nursing Assessments

1989 words - 8 pages Inaccurate nursing assessments and recording of client data can detrimentally affect a patient’s well-being. Nurses are ethically, legally and morally responsible for assessing their patients appropriately. Nurses are also expected to document this data accurately in order to ensure safe and effective care for patients. In this case study, a nurse fails to assess the patient’s weight and instead estimates it. In this situation, it is key to

The Australian Legal System Essay

1297 words - 5 pages The Australian Legal System The Australian Legal System has a rich and detailed history dating from 1066. Law is made in Parliament. We have four sources of law and three courts with different jurisdictions that interpret the law when giving out justice. Important doctrines act as the corner-stones of our legal system. There is a procedure in the courts for making appeals. Separation of powers exists between officials in the courts, the

The Australian Legal System Essay

1293 words - 5 pages The Australian Legal System has a rich and detailed history dating from 1066. Law is made in Parliament. We have four sources of law and three courts with different jurisdictions that interpret the law when giving out justice. Important doctrines act as the corner-stones of our legal system. There is a procedure in the courts for making appeals. Separation of powers exists between officials in the courts, the parliament and the Executive

The Legal System Essay

2254 words - 9 pages Legal System PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 4 Legal System Identification, Comparison, and AnalysisTeam DLori Costa, Sharon Distance, Michael HansonBrandie Little, Yvette PowellAugust 25, 2008University of PhoenixLegal System Identification, Comparison, and AnalysisOur firm is committed to providing Mr. Al Jones with legal support in the matter. Our objective is to identify and analyze the legal situation in which Mr. Al Jones's company is involved. In