Inalienable Rights: A Plea For Open Options

3095 words - 12 pages

Inalienable Rights: A Plea for Open Options

ABSTRACT: Recent analyses of the concept of inalienable rights (i.e., analyses of the inalienable rights to life) transmute these rights into restrictions on the choices of individuals who possess the rights. In this paper I argue that such construals are counter-intuitive, and incompatible with the modern notion of rights as positive benefits to be enjoyed by those who possess them. I offer an alternative (somewhat Lockean) view which proposes that inalienable rights be regarded as entitlements to discretionary options, options the objects of which need not be chosen. To flesh out the theory, such rights (construed as discretionary options) are distinguished from absolute rights, from alienable rights, and from some kinds of indefeasible human rights. I point to several advantages of the open options account of inalienable rights, including the fact that inalienable rights construed as open options are rights that may provide grounds for calling oppressive governments to account, while at the same time protecting areas of freedom which make the possession of the rights worthwhile rather than burdensome. A concluding appeal suggests that the open options view of inalienable rights awaits and encourages the development of theories which bolster modern intuitions concerning the plausibility of affirming individuated, comprehensive, desirable, and universally applicable human rights.

In recent philosophical literature one justification for placing restraints on individuals has been based paradoxically on the notion that those individuals possess basic inalienable rights to liberty and life. It has been argued, for example, that if one has an inalienable right to 0, then there is a duty not to interfere with one's access to 0 (a duty not alleviated by one's preferences alone). It follows that (A) one is not, on grounds of one’s preferences alone, justified in divesting oneself of 0, and that (B) one is not, on grounds of one’s preferences alone, justified in seeking the aid of others in divesting oneself of 0.

It follows that if Sue and Bill have inalienable rights to life, they have a moral obligation to opt for life and, therefore, are not acting in a morally defensible way if they, on grounds of their preferences alone, attempt to persuade others to assist them in comfortably ending their lives. When the notion of the inalienable right to life is construed in the way indicated above, only persons other than the rightholder may make morally permissible decisions concerning the shortening or prolonging of rightholders' lives. And this is held to be the case even if, for example, Bill's and Sue's lives are, from their own points of view, fruitless, torturous, and simply not worth living.

Most views of inalienable rights that entail either (A) or (B) do say that all rights can be overridden, and so recognize situations in which suicide, euthanasia, restriction of liberty, and deprivation of...

Find Another Essay On Inalienable Rights: A Plea for Open Options

Options for Implementing a Leadership Change

2037 words - 8 pages is a common way to enable change and is recognized as a strategy in encouraging employees to make necessary shifts to suit organizational needs and interests". The foundational support structure is what Gene One needs to develop and implement for the Initial Public Offering to be successful. Developing such a structure helps employees build alliances which in turn creates an organization that is open. Implementing this approach will ensure that

A Vote is a Vote: A Plea for Proportional Representation

2852 words - 11 pages auspicious decisions for Canadians every time? The Canadian government is a concentrated power structure out of step with other aspects of society. For our democracy to keep pace with the developing world, Canadian citizens must face these facts, as citizens in other countries have, and restore our political structures to mirror the broad range of political dispositions in today's diverse communities. This goal can only be achieved by abolishing

A Rhetorical Analysis of “A Plea for Caution From Russia”

768 words - 3 pages Henley PAGE 1 Henley PAGE 1 David HenleyJennifer TaylorEnglish 2030September 10, 2014A Rhetorical Analysis of "A Plea for Caution From Russia"On September 11, 2013, Vladimir Putin presented his viewpoint concerning the United States involvement with the country of Syria in the form of an article, respectfully titled, "A Plea for Caution From Russia." The opinion piece, which was submitted to The New York Times, makes an attempt to address the

A Plea For Help!

542 words - 2 pages anyone to support us financially, and we can't get work because women aren't allowed to work. Also, it is very difficult to find someone to support us because single women are looked down upon since they cannot support a family. For all these reasons, we live a very poor life and aren't respected.If women aren't allowed to work, then how do you expect us to get money? I have tired to get some support so I can work but people just take one look at me

A Plea for Love

677 words - 3 pages the help of the love that her teacher provides. The main idea of Hayden’s novel, presented through her use of rhetorical strategies, is that even by offering comfort to an individual for a short amount of time, that person will forever be changed. Torey Hayden develops her theme by playing on the emotions of the reader. At first Hayden used anecdotes that describe the horrible acts that Sheila has committed. Viewers feel the negative tone

Options for Implementing a Leadership Change Organizational Leadership 531 UOP MBA Program

1447 words - 6 pages those who resist change and will not accept anything new. To avoid this from happening, companies can make sure that communication is open, and consistent with their employees; and also asking for ideas and feedback from their workers so that they can feel a sense of ownership in the change. By doing this, it will make the employees feel like they are participating in the change. Having the employees kept informed and involved should lessen

Civil Rights Movement: A Move for Equality

1626 words - 7 pages Civil Rights What was the reason for the civil rights movement? Why was this movement so important to American history? The civil rights movement was a major movement for equality in the United States. The movement broke through a huge pattern of racial segregation using nonviolent protestant actions.”In the late 1950’s a major change took place within the civil rights community, a shift from a representative government and a direct action

Moral Rights: A Cry for Help

1321 words - 5 pages benefits animals, as well. Veterinarians are able to cure animals using the exact analysis tested on certain animals. How can society grow and develop without a few sacrifices? In order for a society to function as a whole, effective measures must be acted upon. However, these actions that need to be acted upon are the same actions that are eliminating life. Why should animal protection rights be overruled? Humans are not placed in a deep fryer, so

Take a Stand For Women's Rights

782 words - 3 pages educated like men, but what of our rights to have a voice in government? Where is our say in legal and government matters of and for the kingdom? Are women not part of the empire? Do we not also contribute to the empire? The answer is yes, we do, but do we have representation within the government? The answer is no. Women live by the laws, rules and codes that were created, established and written into law by none other than the men, leaving

Feminism: A Fight for Human Rights

2767 words - 11 pages Abstract This essay explores the concept of feminism as a human right rather than merely a struggle of American women to achieve equal opportunity and salaries in the corporate world. Without denying the importance of such achievements, the facet of feminism that is explored for the most part is the ability for women around the world to be treated as human. Not only are women denied rights such as the opportunity to be educated or to earn

Animal Rights is a Cause for Vegetarianism

743 words - 3 pages Animal Rights - Cause for Vegetarianism The choice of eating meat or not has been a debated issue for a continued number of years. There have long since been two sides: the proponents and opponents of meat consumption. More and more debates of its value and effect on the world have risen. Many claim it is wrong, while others think of it as a needed pleasure. Today, a greater percentage of the population eats meat. Only a few individuals seek

Similar Essays

A Plea For Applied Science Essay

857 words - 3 pages It is often remarked that spring is the most delightful of seasons, but this is a sore done boon as our appreciation should truly lie under the harvest moon. Just as Mother Nature requires the rest of winter and the ripening of fall for the budding of spring, science requires practical applications on which to build pure theories. Through her application, science more truthfully reveals her mysteries. It is not necessary to look forward to

A Plea For Harmony And Peace

1123 words - 5 pages to the ideals of the Whig party and after giving it Daniel Webster was never fully trusted again by his party(24 Annuls). Historical Background The speech "A Plea for Harmony and Peace" was delivered in 1850. It's content touches on problems that would eventually cause The Civil War. One of the main issues mentioned is what should be done with runaway slaves. The country was divided into three groups on this point. The North wanted to stop all

A Case For Open Borders Essay

1854 words - 7 pages A Case for Open Borders In his address to a joint session of Congress on January 8, 1918, President Woodrow Wilson declared freedom of the seas in times of peace and war. Looking back, it seems ridiculous to think that anyone could challenge the right of individuals to navigate the oceans freely. However, fast-forward to the twenty-first century and we can see an analogous debate over the issue of immigration rights, with territorial

Options For Implementing A Leadership Change Paper

2126 words - 9 pages Running Head: OPTIONS FOR IMPLEMENTING A LEADERSHIP CHANGE PAPER PAGE \* Arabic 1 Running Head: OPTIONS FOR IMPLEMENTING A LEADERSHIP CHANGE PAPER PAGE \* Arabic 8 Options for Implementing a Leadership Change Paper "Don Ruiz was Chief Executive Officer of Gene One. At age 37, Don became a young entrepreneur and started Gene One, a biotechnology company. Don was the CEO and creative force behind Gene One. Don brought his extensive