This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Independence Of Auditors Essay

1979 words - 8 pages

Can auditors remain truly independent when conducting an annual audit of financial statements if their firms provided non audit services (NAS) to audit clients?For many businesses auditing is a useful tool that has been implemented within their business operation to assist decision makings undertaken by the stakeholders. Auditing has also become a compulsory regulatory compliance that needs to be satisfied by public companies listed in the capital market, in which it is imposed for the purpose of protecting investors in a way as to mitigate against the risk of fraudulent activities concealed by the managements of the firm. It is evident from the past that managers tend to deceive investors through the manipulation of financial statements causing substantial economical losses suffered not only by the investors, but also the company itself in terms of bankruptcy. Therefore auditing has always played a vital role in safeguarding investor's interests by enhancing the degree of trustworthiness and objectiveness of the financial statements. Like all other professionals, auditors have long had a legal duty to provide a reasonably level of care while performing work for those they serve, however there are existing deficiencies within the regulatory arena that needs to be rectified in order to promote the effectiveness of the audit system. Those deficiencies were identified through the occurrences of major business failures in the past there were speculated to be caused by false and misleading statement provided by the auditors. Consequently it is critical and urgent to reinforce the audit system through the introduction of new regulations to focus on ensuring that auditors perform their tasks within the legal and professional frameworks, and to enhance the credibility and objectivity of the audit reports. This essay will discuss the question 'can auditors remain truly independent when conducting an annual audit of financial statements if their firms provided non audit services (NAS) to audit clients?'Following the major business collapse around the world attributable to audit failures in terms of undermining audit independence, for example Enron (US), HIH (Australia), WorldCom (US), Ahold (Netherlands). This question has received extensive attention from the auditing profession, commentators and regulators in a multitude of countries. Audit independence means to take an unbiased and objective view when carrying out auditing procedures in terms of audit tests, the evaluation of the results and the issuance of the audit report. This forms a vital and fundamental element of the principles of integrity and objectivity for the auditing profession. Hence it is critical for auditors to maintain independent in order to ensure that users are willing to rely on the information provided by auditors to be the true and fair representation of the financial statements. Apparently there is a widespread belief that auditors undermine their independence when they provide...

Find Another Essay On Independence of auditors

Mind the Gap: Will the auditing expectations gap ever disappear?

2331 words - 9 pages would be unreasonable for auditors to perform to the expectations of the general public and check every transaction and they would instead refer to the objectives of the audit and check a cross section of transactions to ensure everything was up to standard.Grey and Manson (2002) identify two possible reasons for the existence of the performance gap - Lack of competence and Lack of practitioner independence.2.2.1 Lack of CompetenceA lack of

Are Auditors truly independent Essay

1953 words - 8 pages inclined to generate a positive audit report for Enron so that their relationship could continue with regards to both audit and non-audit provision. Law (2008) stated that ‘the majority of the empirical studies have found that the provision of NASs (non-audit services) have had a negative influence on auditors’ perceptions of independence.’ Quite clearly, if non-audit services are being provided, the audit firm is generating income from their client

Ethical Dilemma of a Transaction with United Airlines

1294 words - 5 pages not be free of material misstatement. On the other hand, by refusing to accept Cardillo’s explanation, the auditors could lose Cardillo as a client. Lastly, the auditors have a responsibility to the public, including investors, creditors and competitors who rely on the financial statements to be accurate. The auditors must maintain independence to ensure that the financial information is fair to all parties, and not biased to benefit Cardillo

Business Ethics in Accounting

942 words - 4 pages In the past there [ ] have been several cases in the business environment related to the practices of accountants and auditors who have violated the trust and confidence of public. A number of researches have been conducted to find the potential factors resulting in unethical, biased or inappropriate decision making and judgments by the professionals. The aim of this paper is to review two academic articles and conclude on the reliability of

MANDATORY ROTATION OF AUDITORS

2274 words - 9 pages Abstract In light of a number of high-profile corporate failures during the first half of 2001, a number of studies have been performed to address the impact of mandatory rotation of audit firms to ensure the appropriate level of ‘independence’ of auditors. Majority of studies conclude that the detrimental effects of firm rotation on the quality of the audit work by far outweigh its positive effects as a safeguard against various independence

What are generally thought to be the principal threats to auditor independence?

942 words - 4 pages well as the auditors but actually it usually hand over the power to the directors. Thus, the influences from directors of the company become a great threat to the auditor. In audit, the manager's role is just like an examinee, if he has too much influence on the examiner, the result will obviously not reliable. So, keep the auditor's independence far away from the director's influences is a key issue to get a reliable audit result.Except audit

Generally Accepted Accounting Practices

961 words - 4 pages auditors SOX made it illegal to provide certain nonattest services to clients and changed the regulation of the auditing profession. SOX also changed the regulatory environment giving the PCAOB authority to establish auditing standards, quality control standards, and independence standards for auditors of public companies; and to inspect the work of public company auditors. In addition, for non public companies, peer review has become necessary to

The Collapse Of Enron

1092 words - 5 pages play. That is the gap between what society expects from its auditors and what it perceives it receives from them. Though in Anderson's situation it looks as if there could have been a major breakdown of independence within the Houston office, which has lead them to sign off the grossly overstated accounts. This independence has been referred to as "the cornerstone of auditing".This reflects the fact that if auditors could be influenced by other

Legal Regulation of Corporate Governance in the Role of Auditors

2552 words - 10 pages role of auditors, and illustrate some gaps in the regulation with examples. In addition, a few recommendations are given accordingly for changes. 1. Legal Regulation of Corporate Governance in the Role of Auditors 1.1 CLERP 9 reforms CLERP 9 reforms largely employed the law reform recommendations in the Ramsay report to address the audit independence controversy. CLERP 9 has significantly changed the way that audit work is carried out in

Ethics of Accountants and Auditors

1071 words - 4 pages In the past there have been several cases in the business environment related to the practices of accountants and auditors who have violated the trust and confidence of the public. A number of studies have been conducted in order to identify the potential factors resulting in unethical, biased or inappropriate decision making and judgments by the professionals. The aim of this paper is to review two relevant academic articles and evaluate the

Sarbanes Oxley

981 words - 4 pages of the public companies” (SOX-Online). Some other things under tittle one is “investigation and disciplinary actions, funding, registration with the board” (SOX-online) etc. Tittle two named Auditor Independence requires services from auditors to be external, have “audit partner rotation, conforming amendments, conflicts of interest and study of rotation of registered accounting” (SOX-online). Meaning that companies have to have external

Similar Essays

Auditing Reform And Development In Corporation Practise

1396 words - 6 pages auditors did not take a notice on the manipulating in the financial report and lack of independence. Former and current auditors were getting benefit. The HIH Collapse has drawn the attention from regulators of the importance of the independence of auditors and the ethical practise. Audited financial statements are an important part of financial information (Ramsay). Meanwhile, audited financial information could add value to improve reliability

Audit Essay

1293 words - 6 pages Sarbanes- Oxley 2002 Act had enforced audit firms to limit providing non-audit service to clients (the company) which they audit at the same time in order to improve audit quality. We agree that audit firms should develop auditors’ independence, professional skepticism and objectivity to improve the quality of audit reports. The big challenge for PCAOB and each audit firm is how to implement these valuable requirements appropriately. Audit firm

Corporation Internal Auditors Essay

1265 words - 6 pages -reporting relationship. Threats to independence must be managed at the individual auditor, engagement, functional, and organizational levels. (Institute of internal auditors, 2009) Outsourcing Outsourcing internal auditors is an effective cost-saving strategy when used properly. It is more affordable and leverages the business with competencies and skill sets from different functions that existing IA may not have. For example, few in-house IA shops

“Why Is It Important For External Auditors To Be Independent? Relate Your Answer To The Primary Role Of External Auditors. Give Examples Of Specif

1279 words - 6 pages became one the most popular accounting scandal where it is still being talked about even after a decade has passed. Following this scandal, other massive organizations like WorldCom (2002), AIG (2004), and Satyam Computer Services (2009) shared the same fate. Since then, there have been questions being asked on the issue of the independence of auditors being one of the major contributors to these accounting scandals. Firstly, it’ll be good to know