This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

India's Winter Of Discontent Essay

1228 words - 5 pages

India’s winter of discontent: Some feminist dilemmas in the wake of a rape (2013) is an article about the news-making Delhi rape case of December 2012. However, this article looks at the feminist response to rape and sexual assault and the dilemmas that it brings. Even though the authors talk about India, these narratives are very similar to the narratives of women of color universally.
One of the major foci of the authors is to examine how the rape victim Jyoti Pandey’s identity shaped her rape into an international focus-grabbing incident. Further, the authors look at various aspects related to the aftermath of this rape namely the unhealthy relationship between feminism and censorship, demands for corporal punishment, the state as actor, narrow definition of rape, reliance on the law, building transnational sovereignty and the polarized images of the victim and the rapist.
The authors discuss and struggle with the dilemmas mentioned above. Jyoti Pandey was a 23-year-old physiotherapy student who belonged to an upper class, upper-caste urban family. This drew the empathies of the people who have political and media voices: the elite. These urban, upper class, upper caste elites could identify with Jyoti and hence her rape caused an outrage led to widespread protests all over India. Outpour of emotions by the elite caused an exceptionalizing effect on the history of rape. She was made out to be the only woman who has gone through a brutal rape while in reality adivasi (tribal) and lower caste women suffer horrifying rapes almost everyday. Their screams were not heard by the urban elite and their stories did not make it to international news. This incident erased the painful history of rape in India and all the work many feminists did in order to keep the women’s movement going and help out these rural women to recover from the tragic incidents. As the rich urban New Delhi dweller marched with their candles to historical monuments, the authors of the article wondered if it takes an upper class woman’s rape to draw the world attention to violence against women. It is easy to make connections with what we read in our class. Women of color are often seen as violable to the dominant group and their rape is often not seen as legitimate since their bodies are considered to be already polluted.
The authors discuss the intersectionality of the rural lower caste women who face moral judgments from the society because of their lower status. The authors give many examples of such incidents in the article. While the authors do not explicitly mention these concepts but women’s oppression and patriarchal domination is the backbone of rape that is being discussed. In the patriarchal society, women are seen as the property of men to defile and to violate. The author writes about the Hindu radical conservative group that wants to control women’s sexuality. The law furthers this concept of control over women’s sexuality by using the virgin/whore dichotomy. In...

Find Another Essay On India's Winter of discontent

Post First World War Revolutions in Germany and the Former Habsburg Empire

2132 words - 9 pages and the differences begin with the specific reasons for discontent. In Germany, food and resource shortages ravaged the home front causing major loss of support for the war by the winter of 1916-1917, leading to the formulation of the “stab in the back” myth once Germany was defeated; in addition, mutineers, Bolshevized soldiers, and those soldiers that found it impossible to make the transition back into civilian life comprised the core of

Biblical Allegories in Modern Literature Essay

1769 words - 8 pages muse for authors to explain humanity’s fatal flaws. Throughout East of Eden and The Winter of Our Discontent, Steinbeck uses biblical stories and their basic principles to display the hypocrisy of modern Christianity. Criticism of organized religion’s hypocrisy and rigidness is often seen throughout Steinbeck’s writing despite his Episcopalian upbringing and knowledge of the bible. Steinbeck’s mother pounded the bible into his mind which

Geography of India

950 words - 4 pages (January- February), hot weather summer ( march- may), rainy south-western monsoon ( June- September) and post- monsoon, also known as the north-east monsoon in the southern peninsula ( October- December). India's climate is affected by two seasonal winds- the north-east monsoon and south-west monsoon. The north-east monsoon commonly known as winter monsoon blows sea to land after crossing the Indian Ocean, the Arabiab Sea and the Bay of Bengal

Government in India Today

3135 words - 13 pages Government in India Today India's present constitution went into effect on Jan. 26, 1950. At that time, the nation changed its status from a dominion to a federal republic, though it remained within the Commonwealth. A president, chosen by an Electoral College replaced the governor-general, appointed by the British Crown. The president is the official chief of state, but the office is largely ceremonial. In parliamentary government, the

How accurate is it to say that the growth of reformist groups in the years 1881 was the main cause of the 1905 revolution?

1027 words - 4 pages accurate. Reformist groups did play a role in the revolution but other factors like the Russo Japanese War, Industrialisation and the further discontent felt by the civilians in Russia also contributed to the outbreak of the 1905 revolution.The growth of reformist groups was a factor that made an impression towards the outbreak of the 1905 revolution. The assassination of Alexander II had the consequences of creating inspiration for other

Similar Struggles of Apartheid and Segregation

995 words - 4 pages but was luckily stopped by monumental men like Nelson Mandela and Martin Luther King Jr. (MLK) Throughout Apartheid and Segregation in the U.S. there were laws enacted to keep blacks from doing many things. As Merriman and Winter get into the paragraph about laws, the passage says “Many laws were enacted to give effect to total segregation and to regulate the continued presence of blacks in "white" areas” (Merriman/Winter). The whites made the

Government in India

2789 words - 11 pages system that is the basis of India's institutions and culture.Under the Maurya dynasty (325-183 B.C.)-Especially Asoka (323 B.C.), who established Buddhism as the state religion-Indian culture had its first great flowering. A golden age of Hindu culture was achieved under the Gupta dynasty, in the 4th-5th century A.D. considered India's classical period. By the 10th century, Muslim armies from the north were raiding India, and in 1192 the Delhi

kinetic theory

1754 words - 7 pages STUDY TOPICS: AUTOCRACY / OLD SYSTEM IN RUSSIAYour focus should be on events from 1905 onwards, and wherever possible, aim to outline how these events and their consequences weakened autocracy.Account for the growing discontent by 1905 of the following groups:Peasants- a life of poverty, drunkenness and squalor85% of populationLong history of violent rebellion, most famous the Pugachev rebellion of 1973-75In 1900 most common peasant grievance

Modern History - Revolutions and Turmoil - The Russian Revolution

1149 words - 5 pages The fact that the autocracy collapsed in Feb. 1917 is not very surprising at all. One might agree that if for some favourable reason World War I did not take place then neither would the Russian Revolution. Or it may have happened, but later than it did. There was mass discontent spreading throughout Russia at the time of Tsar Nicholas II and the war put too much of a strain upon the nation for it to recover. The 'undeveloped' country had huge

Rani Jhansi

1328 words - 5 pages . Gradually and eventually, the British rule strengthened and in the early 19th century the Christian influence began to grow and Christian missionaries were brought in. English was enforced as the language of government by 1835. (5) The growing discontent with British rule led to the mutiny of 1857, when the sepoys took over Delhi and Kanpur. Subsequently, the British crushed this mutiny very successfully. The Rani of Jhansi, including

Nuclear Deterrence: A case study of the India-Pakistan Conflict

1555 words - 7 pages whether the aversion is primarily due to the concept of nuclear deterrence or are there additional forces in play. In order to understand the nature of the problem, the precise parameters of the issue and how it affects the region of the sub-continent, it is deemed imperative that a historical context should be established. India's atomic program goes over to the late 1950s and was originally initiated for peaceful purposes to be used by civilians

Similar Essays

Major Themes Theory Of Winter Of Our Discontent

1144 words - 5 pages In the novel by John Steinbeck The Winter of our Discontent there are numerous ways one can relate Ethan’s life to the major themes theory. Throughout the novel Ethan is in a moral struggle to decide whether or not he should try and get ahead at any means possible, or remain in his menial grocery clerk job. His compassionate ways are actually holding him back financially, because he is surrounded by ruthless corporate men that will not think

Moral Disintergration Of America Exposed In The Winter Of Our Discontent

1000 words - 4 pages Moral Disintergration of America Exposed in The Winter of Our Discontent      The Winter of Our Discontent    The life of Ethan Allen Hawley, which had for so long held to an irrefutable ethical standard, was about to undergo an unexpected and irreversible change. Likewise he was not alone; progress was descending upon all of New Baytown like the jets which swarmed "with increasing regularity

Short Snippet On The Winter Of Discontent (Great Britain, 1978 1979)

579 words - 2 pages sectors, causing widespread problems in transportation, waste collection, and individual companies. More than one million workers went on strike, even surpassing the numbers in the General Strike in 1926. Although most of the issues were resolved, the Winter of Discontent the strikes had a profound impact on voting intentions when general elections rolled around in 1979, bringing about the Conservative Party’s victory under Margaret

Disillusion, Defiance, And Discontent 1914 1946: Comparison Of Fitzgerald's "Winter Dreams" And Wolfe's "The Far And The Near"

576 words - 2 pages Disillusionment is the act of disenchanting, especially to disappoint or embitter by leaving without illusion. Disillusionment, or the death of a dream, is a prominent them in Fitzgerald's "Winter Dreams," and Wolfe's "The Far and the Near." In both short stories the main character clearly embodies the theme of disillusionment. In "Winter Dreams," Dexter Green experiences disillusionment, and In "The Far and the Near," the engineer experiences