Indifference To Anxiety In Crane's The Open Boat

2619 words - 10 pages

Indifference to Anxiety in Crane's The Open Boat

   In recent years, critical response to Stephen Crane's The Open Boat has shifted dramatically, focusing less on the tale's philosophical agendas than on its epistemological implications. The story no longer stands as merely a naturalistic depiction of nature's monumental indifference or as simply an existential affirmation of fife's absurdity. Instead, we have slowly come to realize a new level of the text, one that, according to Donna Gerstenberger, explores "man's limited capacities for knowing reality" (557). Gerstenberger's conclusion that the tale "may be best viewed as a story with an epistemological emphasis, one which constantly reminds its reader of the impossibility of man's knowing anything, even that which he experiences" (560), is further developed by Thomas L. Kent:

If we insist that the text be interpreted naturalistically, if we insist, that the text must have some sort of overarching meaning --- even a meaning that shows the universe to be existentially absurd --- we place ourselves in the same boat as the deluded castaways [who "felt that, they could then be interpreters"]. On both the narrative and extra-textual levels, the subject of "The Open Boat" is epistemology, and the text suggests that meaning in the universe is secondary to man's ability to preceive [sic] it. (264)


Building upon the insights of Gerstenberger, Kent and others, l hope to show bow the structure of "The Open Boat" creates an epistemological dilemma, moving the reader from a position of epistemological indifference to a state of epistemological anxiety. Four key moments in the story create this shift from indifference to anxiety: first, in Section 1, the opening sentence and its emphasis on what is not known; second, in Section IV, the narrator's revelation that the crew is miles from a life-saving station; third, also in Section IV, the impenetrable meaning of the man on the beach waving his coat and the unattributed dialogue surrounding this uncertainty; and, finally, in Section VII, the concluding sentence and the revelation that the survivors "could then be interpreters."

Much has been made of the story's opening sentence "None of them knew the color of the sky" (68). For our purposes, what is important is that the story begins by focusing on the crew's lack of knowledge. Certainly the crew "knows" other things: the color, the size, and the frequency of the waves for instance. Yet with this famous first sentence the narrator chooses to foreground the absence of knowledge, thus establishing an epistemological void, a looming unknown. Though the crew's remaining struggle at sea is as much a struggle for knowledge as it is for survival, the members of the crew do not here desire to fill the void created by the opening sentence: not only do they not know the color of the sky, they do not care. In fact, it does not matter whether they know the color of the sky, for "they knew it was...

Find Another Essay On Indifference to Anxiety in Crane's The Open Boat

Symbolism and Devices in Stephen Crane's The Open Boat

1990 words - 8 pages the story is presented at this point when a man is spotted on the shore signaling the boat and there is extensive dialog in the boat as to what the meaning of the signals are.  Crane relates this episode from the point of view of the boat’s occupants without description or exposition to point out the irony.  What was earlier optimism and hope in the first part of the story is now transitioned into the long night “on the sea in an  open boat

Choices and Responsibility in London's To Build a Fire and Crane's The Open Boat

1642 words - 7 pages Choices and Responsibility in London's To Build a Fire and Crane's The Open Boat Naturalism portrays humans' control over their actions and fate as limited and determined by the natural world, including their very humanity. The freedom described by Jean-Paul Sartre results in all individuals having the ability to make present choices independently. Despite the fatalism illustrated in naturalism, the characters in London's 'To Build a Fire

The Open Boat: Crane's View of Naturalism

1134 words - 5 pages To define one's purpose is at the very least human nature and at the very most the meaning of life. Humans seek the significance of existence and try to define it in many ways. There are thousands of religions and countless seminars to help people discover the point of human existence. The idea that we may all be irrelevant in the grand scheme of life or to the universe is not a popular position. In his short story "The Open Boat

Interpreting the Uninterpretable: Unreasoning Nature and Heroic Endurance in Crane's The Open Boat

1847 words - 7 pages nature, and in their silent recognition of its indifference to their struggles. This moment of heroic transcendence is fleeting, however, as the men return to the false security of human society in the end. A triumph of short fiction, Crane's ''The Open Boat'' explores the mysteries of nature and human life on many levels.

Man and Nature in Stephen Crane's The Blue Hotel and The Open Boat

2883 words - 12 pages essay I asserted that the characters' joyless acceptance of nature in "The Open Boat" leads the men to help and sympathize with one another. The opposite is true in "The Blue Hotel;" in that story, the characters' lies cause dissention and tragedy. Truthfulness in response to nature is everything. What Paul Johnson once wrote about Ernest Hemingway's characters is also true of Crane's: They "stand or fall by whether they are truthful or not

Naturalisn In The Open Boat

1237 words - 5 pages In most traditional happy ending stories, there always appears to be evidence of supernaturalism. However, Stephen Crane leaves out all fairy tale elements and mystical creatures in his “The Open Boat”. Throughout the whole story, there are constant examples of the raw, realistic and indifferent parts of life. In Stephen Crane’s “The Open Boat” naturalism is apparent through the use of language, literary techniques, and thematic elements

Naturalism in Stephen Crane’s “The Open Boat”

988 words - 4 pages in the name of the seven mad gods who rule the sea, was I allowed to come thus far and contemplate sand and trees?” (Crane) Here, Crane repeatedly uses similar hopelessness lines to show how desperate, hopeless and stressful the characters were. Implicitly, “The Open Boat” portrays themes like nature, brotherhood, pessimism, and survival (Hilfer). Crane did emphasis his story in the indifference of nature. Nature had no mercy to anyone, so the

Naturalism Versus Compassion In The Open Boat

631 words - 3 pages Naturalism versus Compassion in The Open Boat         During the late 19th-century, literature makes a distinct shift from the popular realist style of writing to a naturalistic approach in storytelling. Naturalism in literature portrays the guiding of human behavior solely by base instinct and external environmental factors rather than individual choice. One may identify this style of writing by an accounting of details in a story that

The Open Boat

1212 words - 5 pages Tar 1Man vs.Ticha TarENGL 202-D03Prof. Dow10 November 2014OutlineNaturalism from Dreiser's "Truth Art Speaks Plainly." "Truth is what is, and the seeing of what is the realization of truth. To express what we see honestly and without subterfuge: this is morality as well as art"Thesis: In his story, "The Open Boat," Stephen Crane portrays the men as they struggle to endure the harsh weather in what seems like an indifferent universe against them

"The Open Boat" Conflict

640 words - 3 pages Dinghy vs. Nature In his short story, "The Open Boat," Stephen Crane shows how an inanimate object can be very unconcerned with whether you live or die. In this case, it is an ocean, which man has to struggle to survive. The characters in the story come face to face with this natural disaster and nearly overcome by Nature's lack of concern. They survive only through persistence and cooperation. Crane shows the reader how not to give up when

Community-The Open Boat

2052 words - 8 pages Stephen Crane's Theme of CommunityStephen Crane is well known in the literary world for his many underlying themes. In Stephan Crane's "The Open Boat," one of the many themes that can be seen is that of community. He brings to life the importance of the each individual's role in the group setting. Crane uses a dire situation in which men's lives are in the hands of each other to show that without group togetherness no one would make it. He shows

Similar Essays

Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat" Essay

1096 words - 4 pages Stephen Crane: The Open BoatThere are many good short stories in this world, but how many of them can captivate the reader in such a short amount of time like that of Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat." As a reader of this story one may feel as if they too were on the boat with these men. Not just any writer could activate the reader in such a manner as this. Yet we will never know the true extent to how much more of an impact he would have made on

Stephen Crane's " The Open Boat"

1764 words - 7 pages Naturalism and Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat" Naturalism is frequently cited as one of the dominant literary movements of 19th century America. Naturalism aimed at a detached, scientific objective portrayal of a natural self controlled by instincts and ruled by passion. Since a self was not perceived to have free will, naturalism debunked moral judgment. Historically, naturalism is perceived to have been more inclusive but also less selective

Stephen Crane's The Open Boat Essay

776 words - 3 pages Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat"        “None of them knew the color of the sky.” This first sentence in Stephen Crane’s “The Open Boat” implies the overall relationship between the individual and nature. This sentence also implies the limitations of anyone’s perspective. The men in the boat concentrate so much on the danger they are in, that they are oblivious and unaware to everything else; in other words, maybe lacking experience. “The

What Are The Themes Found In Crane's Open Boat?

2413 words - 10 pages In "The Open Boat" Stephen Crane uses repeating themes of character experience, action and imagery to convey feelings of the overbearing vulnerability, and seeming futility, of the successful human race when placed in context and comparison to nature itself. Crane's depiction of four men in a dinghy that "many a man ought to have a bath-tub larger than" guides a reader through alternating themes of hopelessness and hope during a dilemma that