This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Individual Rights Versus Cultural Rights Essay

1860 words - 7 pages

The United States is considered the melting pot of the western world. It boasts many different cultures. People from every part of the world have chosen to live amongst others. They can either assimilate within the cultures; Italian Americans, or maintain their own cultures; Greeks. With such diverse cultures being represented, it is hard to fathom individuals being denied basic human rights. In other areas of the world, humans are being tortured, raped, and killed. These human rights violations are being protected under the muse of tradition, or culture. Cultural rights are being elevated by the notion that only people within that particular society can moderate their own culture. This is called cultural relativism. Although, cultural relativism states cultures cannot be judged by outside societies, individual human rights should outweigh cultural ones.
Cultural relativists promote the rights of cultures to dictate what is morally accepted within one’s own society. Cultural relativism is defined as the view that an action is morally right if one’s culture approves of it (Vaughn). This ideology is formed to prevent ethnocentrism, or the belief that one’s culture is superior to another. Though in theory this sounds plausible, it does little to promote an understanding of different cultures. Since the society makes up the laws that dictates and protects its own people, universal laws of protection may not be applied. Cultural rights are important in that they protect individual cultures against the majority states and communities. (Donnelly 219). If it were not for cultural rights, the smaller cultures would cease existing along with their traditions and beliefs.
Tradition, therefore, may be a front for continued prejudices within a society. In order to protect the traditions of a society one must have a full understanding and defend the piety of its culture. This can be difficult for a person that has been raised in a different society. “Cultural rights protect a communal way of life, which typically has significant value for most members of the community.” (Donnelly 218). Those within the community that are not deemed as the majority can have their rights violated. If the people in charge are responsible for creating all the laws, it is inevitable that the laws will be favorable for them and people who appear to be like them. Being that cultural rights are not universal, it makes it difficult to govern all the laws in place. This ultimately hinders the protection of individuals.
Individual human rights protect the people without a voice. These people include the minorities; non-Anglo Saxons, women, and poor. These people are general not the lawmakers. Therefore, the laws are usually not favorable towards them. They are universal and equal in the distribution. These rights are best described as:
Human rights are equal rights: one either is or is not a human being, and therefore has the same human rights as everyone else. They are also...

Find Another Essay On Individual Rights versus Cultural Rights

Individual Rights and Public Order Essay

1646 words - 7 pages PAGE PAGE 5 Comparison Running Head: INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS AND PUBLIC ORDERIndividual Rights and Public OrderBenjamin CesulkaUniversity Of TexasIndividual Rights and Public OrderIndividual rights are those rights we have that allow us to exercise our freedoms granted by the Bill of Rights. The Bill of Rights, originally drafted in 1789 by James Madison, came into effect in 1791 (Wikipedia 2007). The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain

Individual Rights Vs. National Security Essay

878 words - 4 pages I negate the resolution, "Resolved: When the United States is engaged in military conflict, national security ought to supercede conflicting claims of individual rights. My value for the round is Human Dignity, or what can be defined as a respect for the individual and his or her rights and virtues. John Stuart Mill states that "Everyone who receive the protection of society owes a return for the benefit... but not to the point that it violates

The Purpose of Individual Rights

1666 words - 7 pages segregation in the United States, and were the implied protection that the founding fathers put in the constitution to destroy any oppression attacking these rights of individuals. Individual rights were given to the people so that governmental control and leadership is not up to one person and up to who is worthy of the people. The people’s right to an opinion and the ability to express that opinion has been major in the development of our county today

Police Authority vs Individual Rights

1117 words - 4 pages freedoms and upholding the law, their job (Barkan, 2012). Police officers are allowed to think what they want or say how they feel, a right granted to them in the Bill of Rights. However, under the badge, police officers are required and expected to abide by the laws of the United States. Sometimes, the level of authority police hold in this situation can get them into trouble legally. This is what we call police misconduct (Barkan, 2012

Gun Control versus Gun Rights

1411 words - 6 pages Introduction In America guns have been a part of the country’s society since it’s birth. Throughout history the citizens of the US have used firearms to protect the nation, protect their families, hunt for food and engage in sporting activities. The issue of Guns and gun control is complex. Weighing the rights and liberties of the individual against the welfare and safety of the public has always been a precarious balancing act. In the United

Evolution of Individual Rights and Liberties

685 words - 3 pages The Nevada Constitution has many similarities to the U.S. Constitution and some of the concepts and provisions of the Nevada Constitution have roots that go back to English common law. I will attempt to analyze the evolution of individual rights and liberties in England and in the Colonies and States of the Confederation during the years preceding the Constitutional Convention held in Philadelphia in 1787.The historical and philosophical roots

Protecting Rights Versus Upholding the Law

756 words - 4 pages Discuss the critical value of protecting rights versus upholding the law. Provide examples to support your claims It is very critical in our current Canadian society that individuals rights are being upheld, but at the same time so is the law. My belief is that our current society does an average job with upholding individuals right with comparison to the law in certain cases. Our government’s reputation is one of loyalty, honesty and integrity

How effectively does Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms protect Individual Rights?

1323 words - 5 pages Freedoms is the document that truly separates Canada from all the other powerful nations and is certainly something that Canadians take pride in. The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms brings up many questions, but the biggest and most common question is, how effectively does Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms protect your individual rights? To exactly know how effectively it protects our rights, we can look at situations where it has

The Demands Of National Security Vs. Individual Rights

716 words - 3 pages against loss, attack, or harm to the citizens.Ought to supersede means that there is a duty or obligation to take the place or position of something.Conflicting means not able to be followed or acted on, because each requires different and incompatible actions.Claims of individual rights are demands for entitlements, freedoms, or privileges a person has.Before I begin, I have an observation about the resolution. The demands of national security and

Individual rights are disapearing as the war on terror progresses

879 words - 4 pages All over the world individual rights are slowly vanishing. "The War on Terror" is pressing and another war is taking place. The war is over citizens rights and the government is winning. Over the past five years citizens have lost their right to, true free speech, to take photos of anything public, to play jokes, also the entire constitution is nothing with current laws.The public has become more and more panicked and edgy as well as the police

An Analysis of Cell Phone Technology, Security, and Individual Rights

1056 words - 4 pages An Analysis of Cell Phone Technology, Security, and Individual Rights In this technology driven era, I question what effect cell phones are having on our lives as American citizens? To investigate this, I read two articles. The first reading was “Mobile Phone Tracking Scrutinized” by Nikki Swartz originally published in the Information Management Journal for March/April 2006, and the second reading was “Reach out and Track Someone” by Terry

Similar Essays

Individual Rights Versus Public Order Essay

1713 words - 7 pages Rights are not simply political doctrine, but they are values that structure the connection between individual beliefs and political beliefs. Consequently, expressions of individual rights have on numerous occasions resulted in public disorder and chaos due to opposing beliefs or opinions clashing against one another. America has deliberated the benefits and drawbacks of "free expression," or individual rights, and public order. Can both exist

Individual Rights Vs. State's Rights Essay

1000 words - 4 pages Lance ItoEssay #1February 12, 1997In the reviewing the case of Planck v. Indiana, many complicated issues arise. Included in those, individual rights conflicting with the public good are among the most difficult. According to Mr and Mrs. Planck's attorney, John Price, the Planck's religious beliefs prohibit them from accepting professional medicine practice, as they practice alternative medicine and home school their children. After a complaint

Anthology On Individual Rights Essay

1650 words - 7 pages represent the balancing act of individual rights versus societal rights in America. In “Self-Reliance”, by Ralph Waldo Emerson, the audience can see a theme of a desire for an individualistic society. Ralph Emerson wrote: “Whoso would be a man, must be a nonconformist” (935). This statement is saying that a true man makes his own destiny, by not conforming to the ways of the world, or other men. Also found in “Self-Reliance”, “There is a time in

Community Needs And Individual Rights Essay

977 words - 4 pages personal growth that is present during the course of a person’s life. The stage of love means being around by their love once and being free and save without having any dreaded. The only stage that may affect with the individual rights might be the stage of freedom, meaning that for some individuals their rights of freedom may affect the rights of others. “‘Stand your ground’ law states that a person may use deadly force in self-defense without the