Industrial Relations Essay

1841 words - 8 pages

There are many different approaches and theories regarding industrial relations today and each one of them have different perspective and approach in resolving the conflict at work place. In order to understand and be able to analyze what are the good industrial relations, there is a need first to understand how the industrial relations are actually defined and what do they refer to. As explained by Barnetson, Lesson note 1, Introduction, “it is the relations between the labour and management”. This relations in Canadian capitalist economy includes labor market offer and demands where the“ workers agrees to provide their time and skills (labour) to the employers in exchange of wages and ...view middle of the document...

As long as this division between those two parties is present, the needs of employees to organize in unions to protect or to speak out their interests will exist and therefore a need for good industrial relations.
In order to find the mutual agreements related to wages issues and other work related potential disagreement between employer and employee, three theories of industrial relations are considered in this essay; unitarism, pluralism, and radicalism. They all have different views of workplace relations’ whether it is related to work related conflict, the role of unions or job regulation. The question that we can ask is do any of these theories can be defined as good industrial relations and why.

“Unitarists theory believes that the work organization is held together by common objectives that unite managers and workers” (Barnetson, 2009, Lesson note 6, Unitarism) which means that there is no division and opposition within the organization since all individual (employer and employee) have the same goal towards the success of the company. The conflict is unnatural and abnormal since they believe that the interests of members of the organization converge. However, if the from the conflict occur in the workplace, it is a result of poor management or bad communication, or caused by troublemakers. Their method of resolving the conflict is often based on authority or paternalism.
There is little room in this theory for union involvement. They are rather considered disruptive and “ don’t understand the realities of the market or have an imperfect understanding of economics” (Barnetson, 2009, Lesson note 6, Unitarism and the “New” Industrial relations)
They consider that the employer and employees are free and equal parties and that the interest and goals of all the members of the organisation are unitary and aligned, which if properly managed, will result in the harmonious functioning of the organization (Barnetson, 2009, Lesson note 6, Unitarism). But if not, then what?
In today’s world, every worker has his own opinion about working conditions. Therefore the interpretation by Barnetson, “unitarist theory believes that industrial relations are good when there is an absence of conflict” (Lesson note 6, Conflict Under Unitarism) does not make sense of good industrial relations since the conflict is a part of today’s society and instead avoiding it, it needs to be dealt in proper manner with proper means. However I would like to mention that the strength, which I would see within the unitarist perspective, is the loyalty to the organization and management.
At the same time, this theory is the good theory of industrial relations but only if we look at it from employer perspective where their right to manage is justified. But from employees perspective they have given up their right to negotiate their wages.
I would criticize this theory as a week theory of industrial relations since in my opinion the unequal distribution of power can only result...

Find Another Essay On Industrial relations

Industrial Relations System: Singapore Essay

3470 words - 14 pages INTRODUCTIONSingapore's industrial relations system is now well known for its remarkable degree of stability and co-operative labour-management relations. The government has played an active part in promoting economic development through changes in the industrial policy. There are four notable transformations of Singapore's industrial relations since its emergence as a Colonial Administration in 1960. The first was a result of Government's

Industrial Relations Framework Essay

1244 words - 5 pages The Industrial relations framework emerged as a response to the Social Question or the ‘Labour Problem’ – which has been defined by some authors as the problem of improving the conditions of employment of the wage-earning classes [1]. To mitigate the problems of the labour class, whose interests were seen as antithetical to the interests of the producers; a variety of flavours and philosophical leanings developed amongst academicians. Thus IR

Performance Management and Industrial Relations

2034 words - 8 pages organizations, workers and formal/informal ways they are organized and government agencies. These actors and their organizations form part of an environment - defined in terms of technology, labor and goods markets and the effects of power's distribution within society [2].Industrial relations in India post independence has largely evolved with the development of trade unions in the organized sector. For the purposes of this paper, the period has

Human resources management (HRM) and industrial relations

2453 words - 10 pages Executive SummaryEmployment Relations encompasses the varied methods and processes of people management, including human resources management (HRM) and industrial relations. The Employment Relations field includes rules, attitudes, customs, practices, policies and behavior in and around the employment relationship. The main 'actors' in the field are employees and the organizations, employers and their associations, and the state and its

The Best Theory of Industrial Relations

1521 words - 6 pages The Best Theory of Industrial Relations There are many different approaches and theories regarding industrial relations nowadays. In order to mount an opinion on which is the ‘best’ or most appropriate theory of industrial relations, each theory will have to be analyzed. The three most prevalent theories of industrial relations which exist are The Unitarist theory, The Pluralist theory and The Marxist theory. Each offers a particular

INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS IN SINGAPORE: HISTORY, CURRENT DEVELOPMENT AND FUTURE CHALLENGES

2223 words - 9 pages I. Introduction Industrial relations always play an important role in economic development of every country in the world. Singapore’s labor industrial relations have become a solid foundation for the dramatic improvement of Singapore’s economy for the last 50 years. However, just because it was very successful in the past does not necessarily mean that it will continuously bring similar outcomes in the future. The rapid transformation of the

Influences on Irish Industrial Relations Over the Last 30 Years

2643 words - 11 pages 2011 as a result of the recession. Due to this, Ireland earned a negative image which did not encourage any foreign direct investment. LRC (n.d.) explain that due to things such as salary cuts and redundancies as employers try their best in order to cut costs, employees have found their livelihood under threat and therefore the industrial relations have become strained. The Labour Relations Commission has found itself handling increased numbers

Industrial Relations to Human Resource Management: Disparity and Similarity

1002 words - 5 pages Introduction Human resources are the main drivers for today’s organization in managing employees as strategic plan as company’s objective (Haslinda 2009). Variety notion related with theory, perceptivity and understanding of human resource evolution from Industrial Relations (IR) tradition to Human Resource Management (HRM) has transpired to the present day. IR was considerably have two main division: labor management and mutual negotiation

Australian Workplace Political Changes - The Industrial Relations Act in 2006

3105 words - 12 pages The Howard Government's Industrial Relations Changes The proposed changes by the Howard government in 2005 with regard to Industrial Relations have caused extensive controversy. These amendments to Australian Labour Law are the most dramatic for almost a century and are set to entirely re-shape the relations between employer and employee, causing many diverse and strong views on the issue. A key feature of the change is that the Government has

Industrial Relations Between the Union, State, Miners, and Police

2157 words - 9 pages During the 1980s, Trade Unions encountered significant challenges and losses, this occurred against a backdrop of rapid expansion and influence. Before the 1979 conservative election victory it was distinctively voluntarist, with minor legislative intervention. (Gallie et al, 1996).Two strikes in particular, the miners’ strike and the News International industrial dispute changed the face of Industrial Relations in the UK. The conduct and

Industrial Relations - Workplace Satisfaction

2020 words - 9 pages unique and has his/her own needs, wants and desires. For instance, one individual may value having a salary in high regard while another might regard job enrichment in high regard. According to Syptak, Marsland, and Ulmer (1999), there are a number of aspects that will determine an individual’s level of satisfaction with their job, namely: Company Policies, Salary/Benefits, Interpersonal/ Social Relations, Working Conditions, Achievement

Similar Essays

Industrial Relations Essay

2519 words - 10 pages Industrial RelationsOver the past decade, industrial relations in Australia have undergone considerable changes to reflect workplace reforms necessary to meet current and future global economic challenges.Industrial relations involve the relationship between the employers, those who provide work and the employees, those who are paid to do the work as well employer associations and regulatory institutions.As employers do not usually voluntarily

Industrial Relations Essay

2246 words - 9 pages Due to the industrial revolution in countries, there has arisen a need for industrial relations. There are regions that are viewed to posses the biggest economy globally. The largest economy globally being the European economy since they control a big percentage of the global market. Germany is believed to be the Europe’s largest economy. According to Euro found (2009), the largest sector in Germany is the service sector which comprises of about

Industrial Relations Essay

1277 words - 5 pages organizational changes like cost cuttings, structural changes and role/staff reduction can change an employee perception fairly quickly on the processes involved and the fairness of the processes. It is to note that it’s not the fairness in how the changes are implemented but the way the employee’s are treated with the structural changes.  To improve employer – employee relationships i.e. industrial relations. Every relationship starts on trust

What´S Industrial Relations? Essay

2246 words - 9 pages Industrial Relations Industrial relations is a term that inspects the relationship between the employer and employees in the workplace. It also looks at the direct and indirect industrial relations system for governments, institutions and organizations for example. Industrial relations pursue a system that proves to produce minimal workplace disagreements, increase in incomes, environments created from mutual cooperation and goodwill, and the