This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Industrial Relations To Human Resource Management: Disparity And Similarity

1002 words - 5 pages

Human resources are the main drivers for today’s organization in managing employees as strategic plan as company’s objective (Haslinda 2009). Variety notion related with theory, perceptivity and understanding of human resource evolution from Industrial Relations (IR) tradition to Human Resource Management (HRM) has transpired to the present day. IR was considerably have two main division: labor management and mutual negotiation including the method of employment management (Kaufman 2001). The terminology from personnel management, or personnel administration and labor relations has been used by most writers represent IR or employment relations era. The evolving terms of both subject fields has initially started in 19th century by the emergence of HRM terminology as modern or an updated version of personnel management (PM) which still linked within the same environment (Ackroyd et al. 2005). Furthermore, HRM content more about employment relations management and contract determination (Ackroyd et al. 2005).
There were many critical views or artificial debate concerns of the role of HRM and its predecessor, PM (Storey 2001). One of article, Legge (1989) was try to prescribe the distinction between them based on its content. Therefore, the point of departure of this report is to provide some overview to specified substantial outline between IR (in case of PM) and HRM, particularly their distinction and commonality.

PM and HRM Overview
As the name suggests, the scope of work of PM has focuses on the employers objectives, training or efforts to strengthen effective working method and emphasizes individuals workers, employers-employee relations (Kaufman 2001). In corporate environment, it conceived as policy of management in organizational performance (Oxford 2007). The conceptualization of the term PM is difference from HRM as recruitment process, performance indicator, payroll system, training and development (Legge 1989). Moreover, HRM can be defined as strategical process in coherent way within organization (Armstrong 2006) which carry on their manpower, commitment to perform as its function (Brewster 1995). As a subject field, HRM encompass PM on diversity aspect of human resource: staffing (workers and IR); shift management (compensation); administration purposes; performance (training and development) including outsource and subcontract network (Brewster 1995). Boxall (1992) defined the scope of work of HRM is more principal and strategic line of duty than IR in terms of PM.
Disparity of both subject area
Guest (1987) pointed out on several difference among both as particular form. First, regarding to time, planning view and contract, PM generally conducted for short-time program in specific case, on the basis of compliance, whereas HRM for long-term period, responsiveness, and strategic management. Within labor relationship, PM can be seen as customary notion (pluralist), simultaneous bargaining, yet low commitment or trust,...

Find Another Essay On Industrial Relations to Human Resource Management: Disparity and Similarity

Performance Management and Industrial Relations Essay

2034 words - 8 pages performance and long-term growth while aligning their contribution with the goals of the organization.[1]Performance Measurement: RationaleIn the latter half of 1980's, Performance management came to the fore with the arrival of Strategic Human Resource Management (SHRM). It served to introduce a unified approach to the management and development of employees and marked a paradigm shift in the decentralization of this responsibility to the line managers

Personnel to Human Resource Management Essay

2323 words - 9 pages Personnel management refers to a set of functions or activities including recruitment, training, pay and industrial relations performed effectively but often in isolation from each other or with overall organisation objectives. In 1991, Hilmer noted that the Australian tradition of many sub-specialities or functions (industrial relations, compensation, training and pay) was out of date. The early 1990s was an are of great speculation on the

Human Resource Management and Traditional Personnel Management

4899 words - 20 pages ., "Banking on HRM to Respond to Change", Personnel Management, 2007, pp. 29-32. Miller, P., "Strategic HRM: What It Is and What It Isn't", Personnel Management, Vol. 21 No. 2, February 1989, pp. 46-51. Keenoy, T., "HRM: A Case of a Sheep in Wolf's Clothing", Personnel Review, Vol. 19 No. 2, 2006, pp. 3-9. Guest, D.E., "Human Resource Management and Industrial Relations", Journal of

Human Resource Management and Traditional Personnel Management

4570 words - 18 pages the NDPM, and their plans for further study. (Drucker, 2000)Various studies found a great many differences between organisations in the ways in which human resource matters were handled. In some organisations personnel management comprised only routine administration or the solution of industrial relations problems. In other companies personnel managers dealt with a very wide range of issues and were engaged in the creation and implementation of a

Strategic Management and Strategic Human Resource Management

3306 words - 13 pages The purpose of this paper is to identify the reasons why strategic management driving strategic human resource management (HRM) and how the strategic human resource management (SHRM) makes benefits for organisation. Besides the introduction and conclusion, the body of this essay has composed by five sections which involve strategic management, strategic human resource management, role of human resource management, a discussion part, and the

Human Resource Management and Total Quality Management

2793 words - 11 pages perceived as a long-term and comprehensive objective of the entire organization - communicated and integrated across all organizational functions. Nevertheless, he claims that HRM (Human Resource Management) department has sufficient contribution in developing quality through the company. If the HRM department fails to recognize its role and act properly in the TQM implementation, this may hinder the other departments from effectively fulfill their

Human resource management and Personnel management

1970 words - 8 pages PART I: IntroductionThe relationship between human resource management and personnel management has been arguing for many years. The strongest argument among all the advocates is whether human resource management is the same as personnel management only with another name or it is different concept.Some debates are as follow:Approval perspectiveCritical perspectiveGuest: its capacity to satisfy some key propositions such as 'strategy integration

Human Resource Management - Approaches to casual workers

3196 words - 13 pages trap?, Economic & Labour Relations Review, Vol. 9, No. 1, pp. 31-54Burgess, J. and Connell, J. (2002), In search of flexibility: implications for temporary agency workers and human resource management, ABL, Vol. 28, No. 4, pp. 272-283Burgess, J. and Mitchell, W. (2001), The Australian Labour Market, The Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 43, No.2, pp. 124-147Cameron, A. (2000), The hidden organisational costs of using non-standard employment

An Application to Study Human Resource Management

624 words - 3 pages Resource Management to better equip myself with the knowledge on how to manage people, employment policies and practices in the workplace. I believe that me pursuing this mode of studies while on the job will allow me to apply what I am learning in the workplace every single day I am eager to analize the employment relationship and the way people are managed in the workplace. Not only to explores these issues in the context of the individual

Scientific Management And Human Relations Movement

3052 words - 12 pages Scientific Management and Human Relations Movement “Getting things done through people”, according to Mary Parker Follet (1941) is management. Management is said to have no fixed definition, but different authorities on management have different views on it. There are many theories on management. The Classical Theory comprising Scientific Management of Taylor, Administrative Management of Fayol, Bureaucratic Organization of Weber. The Neo

Human Relations Movement and Scientific Management

1678 words - 7 pages MANAGEMENT EASSY ONEThis essay will discuss the application of two schools of management thought which are Human Relations Movement and Scientific Management to improve effectiveness at a clothes store in Hong Kong. In particular, the profitably and work efficiency will be considered. This essay is in 3 sections. The first section will provide a briefly description of the clothes store. The second section will talk about the management thought

Similar Essays

Human Resources Management (Hrm) And Industrial Relations

2453 words - 10 pages all management in the organizations where employees have the right to voice out their opinions or decisions. The level of employee participation and the acceptance of organized labour as an alternative authority structure can measure it.The core objectives of MEF offers quality and professional training courses in the area of Industrial Relations such as labour laws, discipline and collective bargaining, Human Resource Management and Occupational

Human Resource Management And Labor Relations

1743 words - 7 pages Human Resource Management and Labor Relations The role of today’s Human Resource Manager (HRM) is much more involved than in the past. Human Resources (HR) has ordinarily been referred to as Personnel. Formerly, the manager in this field, whether it was referred to Personnel or HR, held a narrow margin of responsibilities. Today’s HRM has the unique role of looking out for the interests of both the employee and employer. Technology

Human Resource And Employee Relations Essay

1729 words - 7 pages Employee Relations is an integral part of human resources. “Employee Relations involves the body of work concerned with maintaining employer- employee relationships that contribute to satisfactory productivity, motivation and morale. Essentially, Employee Relations is concerned with preventing and resolving problems involving individuals which arise out of or affect work situations.” ( The human resource professional

Assess The Changed Role Of Human Resource Practitioners As A Consequence Of The Introduction Of The Work Choices Legislation In Australian Industrial Relations System Of December, 2005

1988 words - 8 pages Work andFamily Scholarship', Work Family and the Law, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 65-87. [Online, retrieved on 1stOctober 2006, from UWS / ProQuest global database].Dessler, G., Griffiths, J. and Lloyd-Walker, B., (2004), Human Resource Management, 2nd edn, PearsonEducation Australia, Australia.Ellem, B., (2006), 'Deregulation and other myths: Re- reading industrial relations policy', IR ChangeReport Card, University of Sydney. [Online, retrieved on 26th