This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Inerrancy And The Gospels : A God Centered Approach To The Challenges Of Harmonization

1226 words - 5 pages

Introduction
Inerrancy and the Gospels, authored by Vern Polythress, confronts the challenges of harmonizing the gospels. Polythress is professor of New Testament interpretation at Westminster Theological Seminary. He earned his M.Div. and Th.M. in apologetics from that seminary. He also has an M.Litt in New Testament from the University of Cambridge, as well as a Th.D. in New Testament from the University of Stellenbosch in South Africa. The book is an apologetic that maintains that the gospels are inerrant, in the face of differences found in the gospel accounts of Matthew, Mark, Luke and John. Polythress states that his goal is to, “treat [the gospels] in harmony with the conviction that the Bible is God’s word” (13).
Summary
The book is written in seven parts discussing the challenges, principles and attitudes of harmonization and how they apply to a variety of specific cases. Polythress lays a foundation of an uncompromising belief in inerrancy, and an acknowledgement of the finiteness of the human condition when attempting to harmonize. His initial case study is a fascinating look at the differing accounts in Matthew and Luke of the role of intermediaries in the healing of the centurion’s servant. After rejecting as improbable the possibility of two events, Polythress examines how the differing emphases of the two gospel writers were manifest in the differing details of the account: “In sum, Matthew and Luke have distinctive emphases; Matthew emphasizes the centurion’s Gentile status, and Luke emphasize his humility. Both of these emphases say something significant about the kingdom of God and Jesus’ ministry” (24). Polythress uses this case as a starting point for laying out principles of harmonization including: the assumption of inspiration, benefiting from previous generations of scholarship, the possibility of more than one event, the omitting of details, allowing for differences in environment and theological emphasis. Chapters 4-10 tackle issues that affect harmonization outside of those general principles. For example in chapter four Polythress examines how history, artistry and theology intertwine to affect interpretation and harmonization. Chapter seven discusses the unworkable concept of what Polythress calls, “a mental-picture theory.” He explains, “A mental picture theory of truth expects a true account will produce in readers a mental picture in direct correspondence to the actual events … But this conception is unworkable … it does not respect the nature of verbal communication as sparse” (49-50). Before spending a significant amount of time parsing specific examples of harmonization difficulties, Polythress spends several chapters discussing attitudes that affect harmonization including over-confidence and doubt as well as the limitations of human knowledge. The last three sections of the book apply the principles to various cases of gospel differences, ending with the healing of blind...

Find Another Essay On INERRANCY AND THE GOSPELS : A GOD-CENTERED APPROACH TO THE CHALLENGES OF HARMONIZATION

The Gospels Essay

554 words - 2 pages Christ and His life and teachings, the four Gospels present a living, dynamic, unique personality. God became man to work out man's redemption from sin. These four portraits present Him as Lord and Savior, rather than describing all He did and in the precise order in which He did it. They introduce us to Him, rather than to His life as a whole.The Gospels are designedly incomplete as a story, but marvelously complete and purposeful as a divine

World centered, Reader centered and a Discourse analysis on the book 'Raw'

668 words - 3 pages Reader CenteredThe novel 'raw' was not only a good read, but it also touched on topics that can show relevance to the youth of today. It showed that even in the depths of darkness, there can be a ray of light that can help guide us, whether it is love, friendship or determination. The book shines light on how crime does not pay up for youth, and convinces teenagers to steer clear of heading down any illegal paths in life. I believe the

The Challenges of Non-timber Forest Ecosystem Services Approach

1760 words - 8 pages -making process by providing not only biophysical assessment on forest but also in economics. In addition, the development of the incentive system has reached a mature stage, where creating more respectful among stakeholders and put nature conservation as a common objective. These better responses to the challenges have raised an optimistic thought that this approach would result a better implementation. However, it is not a short-term solution to

The challenges involved in multi-agency approach of safeguarding children

3336 words - 13 pages The challenges involved in multi-agency approach of safeguarding childrenWithin this essay, the several challenges involved in the services protecting and safeguarding children will be explored. Furthermore, a critical analysis of multi-agency collaboration will be explored, highlighting the negative effects.To begin, a definition of what safeguarding is and a brief description of what multi-agencies are and what they aim to achieve, then the

Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of a scientific approach to the study of society

1625 words - 7 pages absence. Thus if heat, an external stimulus, is applied to matter, that matter will react but positivist approach to human behaviour applies a similar approach that people react to external stimuli and their behaviour can be explained in terms of this reaction for example they enter into marriage and produce children in response to the demands of society; society requires such behaviour for its survival and its members simply respond to this

Who wrote the Gospels and Why?

524 words - 2 pages Who wrote the Gospels and Why?The new testament contains four (4) accounts of the story of Jesus' life, death and resurrectionas presented by Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, The 3 accounts are similar, while Johns bible presents Jesusin a unique way.These differences exist because Matthew and Luke got their information from Mark and John gothis information from another source, maybe John did not have access to the other gospels or he chose notto use

Inadequcies of Language in the Gospels

1541 words - 7 pages The word gospel simply means good news. The purpose of the gospels? To give it’s readers reason after reason to believe in it’s words. Faith is not without reason, just as reality cannot exist without language. Historically, the very existence of the gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke and John merely provide historical evidence of a man of importance that walked this Earth known as Jesus of Nazareth; which is little less historically accurate due to

Justice. I defined justice using the synoptic gospels as a means to arrive at a definition

4523 words - 18 pages Jerusalem. He then led them to Bethany where he blessed themand then departed. The disciples returned to Jerusalem in joy and began praying to God inthe temple. Here ends my summary of the synoptic gospels.The definition of justice that I will apply to the synoptic gospels is the following:Justice, which is unprofitable on earth, is a harmony or a light (i.e. God) in whicheveryone gets what they deserve. The gospels inform their readers as Christ and

The Loving and Caring Manager: A Neoclassical Approach to Management

784 words - 4 pages Two opposing armies are geared up and ready to battle each other. The northern army is led by a bureaucratic managing officer. The northern officer leads his army from the front and demands greatness or the team will pay the price of failure. The southern army officer, contrasted from the authoritarian officer of the north, motivated his army, developed their skills and praised the habits achieved by their collaborative work. The southern

The Strengths and Limitations of a Rational, Strategic Approach to Organisational Change

5116 words - 20 pages The Strengths and Limitations of a Rational, Strategic Approach to Organisational Change Introduction Following the brief introduction of a model-ideal conceptualisation of Organisational Goal-Directed-Activity, and the definition within the perspective defined by this model of such terms like 'rational (organisational) action system', 'strategy', and 'organisational change', the first part of this essay presents a

The Synoptic Gospels

1035 words - 4 pages ministry" (Synoptic Gospels). Following these events Jesus gave his sermon on the Mount which he speaks of the law and gives us the Beatitudes and the Lord's Prayer. Jesus' miracles through peoples faith is the second discourse Matthew explains in his gospel. The twelve disciples are also wanted to heal and preach for Jesus. A major part of the third discourse is the objections the Pharisees have of Jesus' teachings and works of miracles. also, the

Similar Essays

“Inspiration,” “Inerrancy,” And “Canon” (As It Pertains To The Bible)

966 words - 4 pages The Catholic Church has many avenues for teaching the word of God. This is a difficult task due to language barriers and variations in interpretations of various church documents. The complications of these interpretations are exampled in such terms as inspiration, inerrancy and canon. This essay will briefly describe these terms and attempt to shed some light on how the Catholic Church uses them in the interpretation of biblical documents

Son Of God Compared With The Four Gospels

1995 words - 8 pages film. Whether they say it is to get more people to enjoy the film to share the life of Jesus Christ or to simply make more money at the box office, The Son of God is a perfect example of how they go about this. In discussing three miracles that happen in the film we can clearly see three examples of taking the more exciting or "Hollywood friendly" details from the gospels of Matthew Mark Luke and John and mixing and matching them to create the most

Limits And Challenges Of The Feminist Critical Approach

3325 words - 13 pages nature; all aspects which are considered undesirable or unneeded are put upon the concept of woman. The second theorist to discuss as a literary critic focusing on feminist aspects is Elaine Showalter. Within her text, which is called “To Feminist Politics”, Showalter identifies and differentiates two distinct styles of criticism which need to be discussed. These are what she refers to as the “woman as reader” approach, and the “woman as writer

Examination Of The Book Of John (And How It Relates To The Synoptic Gospels)

2136 words - 9 pages four possible positions, but was finally put last because it is regarded to have been written last (Thiessen 162).There are many differences between the Gospel of John and the three synoptic gospels. The gospels of Matthew, Mark, and Luke are called synoptic because they are similar. The synoptic gospels referred to Jesus as the Son of God, and put a heavy emphasis on his divinity. John, while certainly not negating the preceding emphasis as being