This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Influences Of The Rationalist, Structuralist And Culturalist Theoretical Approaches On Comparative Politics

1642 words - 7 pages

What influence have the rationalist, structuralist and culturalist theoretical approaches had on the study of comparative politics?

Comparative politics is the empirical comparative study of political systems. It involves the classification and comparison of institutions - ‘a rule that has been institutionalised’ (Lane and Ersson, 1999: 23) - in order to determine the nature of political regimes. The study of comparative politics has come to be guided by three major research schools: rational choice theory, culturalist analysis and structuralist approaches; each of which spearhead a distinctive notion over what about institutions affects the nature of the political process. Rationalists are methodological individualists who assert that ‘collectivities have no status apart from the individuals who comprise them’ (Lichbach, 1997: 245). Rational choice theory is guided by the principle that individuals ‘act as maximisers of benefits over costs’ (Bara and Pennington, 1997: 17), and whilst there is scope for the acceptance of the role played by culture and institutional structures in conditioning individual action, it is still primarily maintained that an understanding of social structures is fundamentally driven by ‘the incentives and beliefs of individual actors’ (Bara and Pennington, 1997: 33). However, an overlap between the rationalist and culturalist train of thought has been forged by political scientist Herbert Simon with his theory of ‘bounded rationality’ - individuals cannot always ‘assimilate and digest all the information’ (The Economist) required to maximise their benefit from a particular course of action, and instead ‘resort to habits, traditions and rules of thumb’ (Lichbach, 1997: 34); ‘satisficing’. Culturalists are methodical holists who view ‘norms as intersubjective or transindividual’ (Lichbach, 1997: 246). They believe that the prevailing values found in all of society’s institutions reflect the ideas and beliefs widely shared by the community as a whole; in this sense ‘individual perceptions are largely a product of the social environment’ (Bara and Pennington, 1997: 21). Cultural theorists therefore focus their studies on ‘group level processes’ (ibid) when conducting research. However, as highlighted by survey researchers Almond and Verba, by identifying cultural variables, it is almost inevitable that analysts will engage in generalised comparative study. Synthesis can be found between cultural analysis and less rigid forms of structural institutionalism. Political theorist Antonio Gramsci pointed out that coherence between these two schools of thought can be found when considering the fact that whilst, according to Marxist teachings, capitalist societies are based on underlying structural conflict between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie, the manifestation of such conflict is dependent on the cultural circumstances of the country concerned. Similarly to culturalists, structuralists adopt a form of methodological...

Find Another Essay On Influences of the Rationalist, Structuralist and Culturalist Theoretical Approaches on Comparative Politics

The Importance of Studying Comparative Politics

912 words - 4 pages The Importance of Studying Comparative Politics Comparative politics is an important aspect of political science in that instead of studying how this country functions, it studies why other countries around the world are the way they are. There must be some medium for finding the differences and similarities between one county and another in order discover what can effect such aspects as economic strength, military strength, and the

A Comparative Analysis of the Social Media Marketing Approaches of Ryanair and easyJet

7890 words - 32 pages 0 Heidi Mariegaard Poulsen & Alice Høst Fowler Business and Social Sciences, Aarhus University International Virksomhedskommunikation Leila Trapp 3 May 2012 99,003 characters (without spaces) A Comparative Analysis of the Social Media Marketing Approaches of Ryanair and easyJet Abstract Title: A comparative analysis of the social media marketing approaches of Ryanair and easyJet. Year: 2012 Authors: Heidi Mariegaard Poulsen, Alice H

Theoretical Change and Approaches to Therapy

1908 words - 8 pages well-established theoretical background. In addition, the framework of this theoretical background must resonate around your values, work, and interpretations on the processes of creating change. I strongly agree a therapist must be genuine, congruent, and empathetic as symbolized throughout my professional and personal history. I do agree social learning plays a big part but it is not the sole reason for substantiated behaviors. Furthermore

Cold War Influences on American Culture, Politics, and Economics

2251 words - 9 pages Studies Quarterly, Dennis Merrill determined: …the Truman presidency was the first to construct, win public support, and successfully implement a modern foreign policy. Unlike the Monroe Doctrine and its Roosevelt Corollary, which focused on the Western Hemisphere, Truman’s policy was global in scope. Beyond Greece and Turkey, it underpinned an array of Cold War initiatives: the $12 billion Marshall Plan for European reconstruction, the creation

Comparative analysis of the rise of religious extremism in Arab and Indian Politics

868 words - 3 pages Comparative analysis of the rise of religious extremism in Arab and Indian Politics The cases being discussed by the authors here are more significant than the discussion of any other Muslim or Hindu nation because of the fact that these cases discuss the role of these religions in their respective birthplaces. We can realize the importance of this point by considering, for example that the Islamic countries worldwide look towards the Arabic

A critical evaluation of one of the theoretical approaches used to describe pattern/object recognition

1206 words - 5 pages Pattern/object recognition is concerned with the processes involved in the identification of images and objects. This essentially involves taking information that enters the visual system and comparing this with information stored in memory, and finding a match. There are three approaches within pattern recognition; template and prototype theories, feature comparison theories and structural theories. The focus of this essay is feature comparison

The Civil War in Sudan its Historical Background and its Effects on Comparative Politics and International Relations

1492 words - 6 pages in place in 2005 and this is a serious World matter. Countries will have to decide how they will respond to these accusations. One of the questions is how are China and Sudan economically connected and is China trying to force its government on Sudan, a comparative politics question, by helping them out in Darfur. Publically China has denied all accusations about Sudan and insists it abides by all U.N Arms Embargoes around the world including

The influences and impacts of glolbalisation on Japan

2523 words - 10 pages sign unequal treaties, which benefited the West economically. It was this that spurred on Meiji Japan to become a respected nation of the world by becoming level with, or even superior to, economically and militarily the Western powers. Japan's agrarian economy underwent intensive westernisation as it sought to turn itself into a developed industrial economy. The large associated expenditures led to a financial crisis in the mid 1880's, which

Social and political influences on the theorey of evolution

672 words - 3 pages * The theory had a negative effect on social life because Darwin stating that we had evolved from apes was such a ludicrous idea at the time that he was afraid that the public would denounce his work as heresy.* So he only hinted of the principle of natural selection.* Now he knew he had discovered a great truth. And he felt he had to tell the world. But he withheld the truth, for, it seemed to him, humanity was not ready for this truth.* And


1803 words - 7 pages help secure the rights of an individual. However, even with all of his idealism, Plato’s theories are more real and practical. Plato agreed to give up his idealism, if the ordeal of Syracuse would prove to be successful. Aristotle’s theories, on the other hand, are more theoretical and academic. In Republic, Plato first defines his concept of an ideal state and then traces the path of corruption that such a state would take. So, he moves from

Comparative Paper on the Culture of Philippines and Malaysia

1477 words - 6 pages Comparative Paper on the Culture of Philippines and Malaysiaby: Rose Camille O de AsisThe Philippines and Malaysia have a long history of close economic and political relations. They were founding members of the ASEAN and important trading partners, thus cultural ties between these countries are also evident. The most colorful and celebrated parts of every Malay and Filipino life-the puberty, the courtship, engagement and marriage. These events

Similar Essays

Structuralist And Intentionalist Approaches To Nazi Germany

2544 words - 10 pages Historians are often divided into categories in regard to dealing with Nazi Germany foreign policy and its relation to Hitler: 'intentionalist', and 'structuralist'. The intentionalist interpretation focuses on Hitler's own steerage of Nazi foreign policy in accordance with a clear, concise 'programme' planned long in advance. The 'structuralist' approach puts forth the idea that Hitler seized opportunities as they came, radicalizing the

The Media And Comparative Politics Essay

723 words - 3 pages interest groups do this on a daily basis to persuade others to support their beliefs. Then media is brought up again when discussing comparative politics, playing a crucial role when comparing struggles among State borders. Government has heightened power when using the different forms of media because the dramatic influence the media plays to its viewers. Without the usage of media, we would be unable to obtain important information as fast and we

Comparative Politics Of The French And Mexican Governments

1988 words - 8 pages Comparative Politics of the French and Mexican Governments The political systems of today’s world vary tremendously as you span the world. Each of these systems has gone through an evolution based on mistakes of the past and the needs of a stable and equal government. Most nations throughout the world observe political means through either Unitary or Federal legislation. The Federal government of Mexico and the unitary government of

The Main Models Of Comparative Politics

852 words - 4 pages Currently in the field of comparative politics, there are three main models that researchers tend to adhere to. These three are termed “rationalist”, “structuralist”, and “culturalist.” Each model has a quite distinct approach toward analysis of political phenomena. Simplified, they are as follows: the structuralist model examines the behavior of people based on the groups they belong to; the culturalist model takes careful note of the details